Best tactical engine?
Moderator: Ras
-
Jouni
- Posts: 3977
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:15 pm
- Full name: Jouni Uski
Best tactical engine?
Leptir and Rems are superior because of internal MV mode. So I tested Stockfish 19, Reckless dev and PlentyChess 8 in MV = 3 mode. You can do this in Banksia GUI. Result: all 3 engines were very similar after 500 puzzles and equal to Leptir/Rems in solving!
Jouni
-
Dann Corbit
- Posts: 12897
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:57 pm
- Location: Redmond, WA USA
Re: Best tactical engine?
Possibly useful for general chess play, if an engine is stuck in a draw line or falling behind, to widen the search with mpv=3.
In those cases, I doubt if it would hurt anything and it might even find a win.
I think Mike did something like that many years ago.
In those cases, I doubt if it would hurt anything and it might even find a win.
I think Mike did something like that many years ago.
Taking ideas is not a vice, it is a virtue. We have another word for this. It is called learning.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
But sharing ideas is an even greater virtue. We have another word for this. It is called teaching.
-
NathanDrake
- Posts: 40
- Joined: Mon Jun 01, 2026 4:57 pm
- Full name: Francesco Torsello
Re: Best tactical engine?
I recommend checking out Triumviratus 8.0 position solver. I couldn't compare it with Leptire because I didn't have the executable.
https://github.com/Tors3/Triumviratus/r ... -possolver
https://github.com/Tors3/Triumviratus/r ... -possolver
Francesco 
-
peter
- Posts: 3699
- Joined: Sat Feb 16, 2008 7:38 am
- Full name: Peter Martan
Re: Best tactical engine?
Here I had some of the actual at game playing- rating lists leading engine- versions together with some for problem solving specialised ones, most of them as well with MultiPV=1 as with MultiPV=4- setting. The four best ones ran with MultiPV=2 and with MultiPV=3also, see name- extensions, as for Triumviratus 8.0 Problem Solver "pure" name (default setting with AnShadow true) stands for MultiPV=2, as for Leptir MultiPV=3 (which is the default setting of Random Open MultiPV value 3), both have one more run with extenson MPV1 and one with MPV4 too.
Evaluation was done by a tool, that Claude built for me following the role model of the fine EloStatTS by Dr. Frank Schubert with his permission to do so. The positions are the 325 to be downloaded at ShashChess- site (practically the same ones, only 2-3 have changed since then), Hardware- TC was single thread of 4.3GHz CPU and 90"/pos., ShashChess42C is a pre release candidate, Andrea Manzo sent me to test it about 2 weeks ago, there will be newer candidates already now.
Code: Select all
# Engine Elo +/- Matches Score% Av.Opp Solved MST1 MST2
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 ShashChess42C-MPV3 3565 7 9715 59.3% 3499 269/325 8.9s 22.9s
2 Crystal260930MPV3 3563 8 9855 58.9% 3499 269/325 8.8s 22.8s
3 Crystal260930MPV4 3555 9 9820 57.7% 3499 269/325 8.8s 22.8s
4 ShashChess42C-MPV2 3554 8 9483 57.6% 3499 260/325 9.3s 25.4s
5 Crystal260930MPV2 3550 9 9559 57.0% 3500 253/325 8.2s 26.3s
6 ShashChess42C-MPV4 3543 8 9537 56.1% 3500 259/325 9.1s 25.5s
7 CorChess260924MPV3 3542 7 9626 55.9% 3500 265/325 11.5s 26.0s
8 ShashChess41.2GDMPV4 3540 8 9677 55.6% 3500 262/325 9.0s 24.7s
9 CorChess260924MPV4 3539 7 9680 55.5% 3500 267/325 12.2s 26.1s
10 Crystal260930 3539 9 9607 55.4% 3500 252/325 10.0s 28.0s
11 CorChess260924MPV2 3537 7 9470 55.1% 3500 258/325 11.5s 27.7s
12 LeptirM260122 3531 8 9590 54.4% 3500 262/325 11.2s 26.5s
13 Stockfish261013MPV4 3530 9 9420 54.0% 3501 250/325 11.3s 29.5s
14 LeptirM260122MPV2 3528 7 9479 53.9% 3500 254/325 11.1s 28.3s
15 LeptirM260122MPV4 3524 8 9543 53.3% 3500 258/325 10.9s 27.2s
16 ShashChess42C 3513 9 9101 51.5% 3502 227/325 10.6s 34.6s
17 Triumviratus8.0PosMPV3 3510 8 9043 51.1% 3502 229/325 10.4s 33.9s
18 Reckless260903MPV4 3505 9 9366 50.4% 3502 243/325 9.7s 30.0s
19 Triumviratus8PS 3505 8 8910 50.3% 3502 223/325 10.5s 35.5s
20 Triumviratus8.0PosMPV4 3495 8 9106 48.9% 3502 232/325 12.9s 35.0s
21 CorChess260924 3493 8 8972 48.6% 3503 223/325 11.2s 35.9s
22 Stockfish261010 3492 8 8893 48.2% 3504 213/325 11.5s 38.6s
23 Stockfish260913 3491 9 8890 48.1% 3504 207/325 12.1s 40.4s
24 ShashChess41.2 3490 9 8889 48.1% 3503 214/325 9.0s 36.7s
25 LeptirM260122MPV1 3484 8 8921 47.2% 3503 218/325 12.5s 38.0s
26 Crystal9 3482 10 9216 47.0% 3503 223/325 10.1s 35.2s
27 Stockfish19 3473 10 8683 45.4% 3504 195/325 11.1s 42.6s
28 Triumviratus8.0 3471 9 8530 45.1% 3505 191/325 9.2s 42.5s
29 Triumviratus8.0PosMPV1 3469 10 8569 45.0% 3505 194/325 10.4s 42.5s
30 Reckless260903 3459 8 8962 43.6% 3505 212/325 12.3s 39.3s
31 PlentyChess8.0 3454 11 8736 42.6% 3506 185/325 9.9s 44.4s
32 Pawnocchio260828 3447 10 8960 41.9% 3505 204/325 14.4s 42.6s
33 Integral260925 3405 10 8699 35.9% 3507 175/325 15.0s 49.6s
34 Cinder0.6.1 3386 11 8354 33.3% 3508 150/325 13.0s 54.4s
35 Coda0.9.4.1 3336 14 8213 27.2% 3509 117/325 10.6s 61.4s
Code: Select all
Kreuztabelle (Zeile gegen Spalte, Elo-Differenz; Spalten = Ranglistennummer):
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35
1 ShashChess42C-MPV3 — -0.3 +8.9 +12 +16 +22 +30 +29 +29 +25 +31 +40 +39 +40 +47 +57 +63 +62 +65 +76 +75 +73 +76 +74 +82 +81 +90 +90 +95 +105 +103 +116 +152 +163 +204
2 Crystal260930MPV3 +0.3 — +12 +10.0 +19 +20 +22 +24 +26 +35 +28 +40 +34 +36 +46 +49 +49 +58 +55 +65 +72 +67 +67 +75 +84 +95 +82 +85 +84 +100 +103 +116 +160 +155 +205
3 Crystal260930MPV4 -8.9 -12 — +0.5 +8.5 +12 +16 +17 +18 +27 +23 +31 +31 +31 +34 +39 +43 +52 +49 +60 +61 +57 +63 +69 +78 +83 +72 +79 +82 +93 +94 +109 +148 +145 +199
4 ShashChess42C-MPV2 -12 -10.0 -0.5 — +2.2 +11 +15 +14 +19 +15 +20 +27 +27 +26 +30 +47 +48 +52 +53 +63 +63 +62 +65 +63 +67 +68 +86 +80 +85 +94 +93 +108 +143 +162 +202
5 Crystal260930MPV2 -16 -19 -8.5 -2.2 — +9.0 +9.3 +9.1 +13 +17 +16 +23 +22 +23 +31 +36 +34 +46 +43 +51 +59 +58 +60 +61 +71 +80 +76 +76 +80 +94 +96 +107 +149 +145 +195
6 ShashChess42C-MPV4 -22 -20 -12 -11 -9.0 — +3.7 +6.4 +9.0 +0.9 +9.0 +17 +18 +19 +26 +34 +40 +44 +42 +57 +51 +48 +50 +55 +59 +64 +65 +71 +73 +78 +83 +91 +130 +146 +193
7 CorChess260924MPV3 -30 -22 -16 -15 -9.3 -3.7 — +1.6 +4.2 +2.1 +6.6 +12 +14 +17 +17 +31 +37 +44 +43 +55 +54 +49 +55 +50 +59 +60 +71 +71 +71 +82 +85 +91 +132 +149 +190
8 ShashChess41.2GDMPV4 -29 -24 -17 -14 -9.1 -6.4 -1.6 — -0.8 +3.0 +3.7 +15 +7.5 +12 +20 +32 +37 +37 +41 +51 +46 +46 +50 +57 +60 +59 +61 +73 +72 +83 +79 +90 +130 +147 +191
9 CorChess260924MPV4 -29 -26 -18 -19 -13 -9.0 -4.2 +0.8 — -2.8 +1.9 +8.8 +11 +11 +14 +28 +38 +38 +41 +52 +53 +51 +54 +51 +60 +55 +66 +72 +71 +82 +81 +90 +129 +147 +189
10 Crystal260930 -25 -35 -27 -15 -17 -0.9 -2.1 -3.0 +2.8 — +4.2 +9.9 +8.1 +15 +20 +29 +21 +29 +31 +42 +50 +47 +49 +54 +63 +68 +65 +70 +71 +84 +86 +97 +139 +142 +194
11 CorChess260924MPV2 -31 -28 -23 -20 -16 -9.0 -6.6 -3.7 -1.9 -4.2 — +3.5 +7.6 +7.1 +8.7 +21 +30 +38 +36 +48 +52 +50 +55 +45 +52 +49 +72 +63 +68 +82 +85 +94 +129 +153 +190
12 LeptirM260122 -40 -40 -31 -27 -23 -17 -12 -15 -8.8 -9.9 -3.5 — +0.0 +3.8 +7.5 +22 +26 +22 +30 +42 +42 +40 +44 +49 +60 +49 +61 +68 +68 +74 +79 +84 +126 +140 +191
13 Stockfish261013MPV4 -39 -34 -31 -27 -22 -18 -14 -7.5 -11 -8.1 -7.6 -0.0 — +3.9 +7.9 +18 +22 +26 +27 +42 +37 +40 +42 +45 +46 +45 +56 +63 +63 +68 +76 +79 +119 +142 +196
14 LeptirM260122MPV2 -40 -36 -31 -26 -23 -19 -17 -12 -11 -15 -7.1 -3.8 -3.9 — +4.8 +14 +20 +23 +30 +35 +38 +35 +40 +42 +52 +48 +59 +61 +64 +74 +76 +81 +123 +141 +179
15 LeptirM260122MPV4 -47 -46 -34 -30 -31 -26 -17 -20 -14 -20 -8.7 -7.5 -7.9 -4.8 — +13 +19 +19 +26 +33 +34 +31 +37 +41 +46 +41 +54 +61 +63 +66 +69 +80 +118 +134 +179
16 ShashChess42C -57 -49 -39 -47 -36 -34 -31 -32 -28 -29 -21 -22 -18 -14 -13 — +1.9 +6.7 +6.8 +17 +20 +27 +23 +25 +32 +28 +49 +47 +49 +54 +58 +68 +107 +127 +183
17 Triumviratus8.0PosMPV3 -63 -49 -43 -48 -34 -40 -37 -37 -38 -21 -30 -26 -22 -20 -19 -1.9 — +5.3 +6.7 +18 +18 +21 +18 +22 +27 +31 +40 +46 +47 +53 +58 +58 +109 +134 +183
18 Reckless260903MPV4 -62 -58 -52 -52 -46 -44 -44 -37 -38 -29 -38 -22 -26 -23 -19 -6.7 -5.3 — +3.8 +7.5 +7.6 +13 +12 +15 +23 +25 +33 +37 +38 +52 +55 +61 +104 +118 +172
19 Triumviratus8PS -65 -55 -49 -53 -43 -42 -43 -41 -41 -31 -36 -30 -27 -30 -26 -6.8 -6.7 -3.8 — +13 +17 +13 +13 +14 +19 +20 +41 +43 +48 +45 +58 +58 +102 +126 +180
20 Triumviratus8.0PosMPV4 -76 -65 -60 -63 -51 -57 -55 -51 -52 -42 -48 -42 -42 -35 -33 -17 -18 -7.5 -13 — +2.1 +7.8 +1.2 +6.3 +11 +16 +26 +33 +33 +37 +45 +53 +95 +114 +169
21 CorChess260924 -75 -72 -61 -63 -59 -51 -54 -46 -53 -50 -52 -42 -37 -38 -34 -20 -18 -7.6 -17 -2.1 — +7.5 +7.4 +2.3 +8.6 +11 +28 +24 +26 +39 +44 +51 +89 +124 +165
22 Stockfish261010 -73 -67 -57 -62 -58 -48 -49 -46 -51 -47 -50 -40 -40 -35 -31 -27 -21 -13 -13 -7.8 -7.5 — -1.3 -1.1 +1.8 +8.7 +20 +20 +22 +25 +41 +38 +87 +126 +170
23 Stockfish260913 -76 -67 -63 -65 -60 -50 -55 -50 -54 -49 -55 -44 -42 -40 -37 -23 -18 -12 -13 -1.2 -7.4 +1.3 — +1.7 +7.0 +5.2 +24 +19 +21 +32 +43 +39 +86 +117 +163
24 ShashChess41.2 -74 -75 -69 -63 -61 -55 -50 -57 -51 -54 -45 -49 -45 -42 -41 -25 -22 -15 -14 -6.3 -2.3 +1.1 -1.7 — +1.9 +4.8 +22 +28 +19 +37 +37 +49 +91 +115 +163
25 LeptirM260122MPV1 -82 -84 -78 -67 -71 -59 -59 -60 -60 -63 -52 -60 -46 -52 -46 -32 -27 -23 -19 -11 -8.6 -1.8 -7.0 -1.9 — +0.3 +15 +20 +21 +27 +35 +42 +86 +109 +158
26 Crystal9 -81 -95 -83 -68 -80 -64 -60 -59 -55 -68 -49 -49 -45 -48 -41 -28 -31 -25 -20 -16 -11 -8.7 -5.2 -4.8 -0.3 — +11 +12 +13 +29 +30 +41 +84 +98 +140
27 Stockfish19 -90 -82 -72 -86 -76 -65 -71 -61 -66 -65 -72 -61 -56 -59 -54 -49 -40 -33 -41 -26 -28 -20 -24 -22 -15 -11 — -4.1 +2.5 +12 +23 +25 +70 +108 +151
28 Triumviratus8.0 -90 -85 -79 -80 -76 -71 -71 -73 -72 -70 -63 -68 -63 -61 -61 -47 -46 -37 -43 -33 -24 -20 -19 -28 -20 -12 +4.1 — +0.1 +11 +22 +22 +70 +100 +161
29 Triumviratus8.0PosMPV1 -95 -84 -82 -85 -80 -73 -71 -72 -71 -71 -68 -68 -63 -64 -63 -49 -47 -38 -48 -33 -26 -22 -21 -19 -21 -13 -2.5 -0.1 — +7.7 +25 +24 +68 +100 +163
30 Reckless260903 -105 -100 -93 -94 -94 -78 -82 -83 -82 -84 -82 -74 -68 -74 -66 -54 -53 -52 -45 -37 -39 -25 -32 -37 -27 -29 -12 -11 -7.7 — +14 +13 +63 +74 +131
31 PlentyChess8.0 -103 -103 -94 -93 -96 -83 -85 -79 -81 -86 -85 -79 -76 -76 -69 -58 -58 -55 -58 -45 -44 -41 -43 -37 -35 -30 -23 -22 -25 -14 — +6.4 +54 +74 +124
32 Pawnocchio260828 -116 -116 -109 -108 -107 -91 -91 -90 -90 -97 -94 -84 -79 -81 -80 -68 -58 -61 -58 -53 -51 -38 -39 -49 -42 -41 -25 -22 -24 -13 -6.4 — +52 +66 +123
33 Integral260925 -152 -160 -148 -143 -149 -130 -132 -130 -129 -139 -129 -126 -119 -123 -118 -107 -109 -104 -102 -95 -89 -87 -86 -91 -86 -84 -70 -70 -68 -63 -54 -52 — +22 +81
34 Cinder0.6.1 -163 -155 -145 -162 -145 -146 -149 -147 -147 -142 -153 -140 -142 -141 -134 -127 -134 -118 -126 -114 -124 -126 -117 -115 -109 -98 -108 -100 -100 -74 -74 -66 -22 — +69
35 Coda0.9.4.1 -204 -205 -199 -202 -195 -193 -190 -191 -189 -194 -190 -191 -196 -179 -179 -183 -183 -172 -180 -169 -165 -170 -163 -163 -158 -140 -151 -161 -163 -131 -124 -123 -81 -69
Peter.
-
Jouni
- Posts: 3977
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:15 pm
- Full name: Jouni Uski
Re: Best tactical engine?
I did extensive test with SF19. MV3 was better than MV4. It is also default in Leptir.
Jouni
-
peter
- Posts: 3699
- Joined: Sat Feb 16, 2008 7:38 am
- Full name: Peter Martan
Re: Best tactical engine?
Which number of MultiPV- lines scores best compared to which other one(s) engine(s) depends strictly on positions, sample of engines and hardware- TC. For most of the engines listed above (that were run with MultiPV=1, =2; =3 and =4, MultiPV=3 scored best, so that might probably be the reason for Random Open MultiPV value 3 in Leptir, regards
Peter.
-
peter
- Posts: 3699
- Joined: Sat Feb 16, 2008 7:38 am
- Full name: Peter Martan
Re: Best tactical engine?
BTW, here are two more suites I like to use for quick tests.
506 for about 5"/pos. single thread:
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/8wf6ci0f ... 41hk3&dl=0
One example of a little list made with this one suite by 15 runs of MultiPV=1- settings:
And 4096 quiet positions (not tactically deep and not of single best moves, so in old tradition of "strategic" tests) for 1"/pos.:
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/uy8gnzhc ... v3n2q&dl=0
With this one also all runs in MultiPV=1- setting:
506 for about 5"/pos. single thread:
https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/8wf6ci0f ... 41hk3&dl=0
One example of a little list made with this one suite by 15 runs of MultiPV=1- settings:
Code: Select all
# Engine Punkte +/- Pkt% eElo +/- Matches Score% volle Pkt no points Ø Zeit
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Crystal260930 8184/13970 294 58.6% 3643 28 1232 70.9% 400/506 91/506 0.6s
2 Corchess260924 7435/13970 276 53.2% 3582 26 1168 63.2% 386/506 105/506 0.6s
3 ShashChess42C 7484/13970 252 53.6% 3580 25 1076 63.6% 386/506 105/506 0.5s
4 Stockfish261013 7409/13970 252 53.0% 3576 25 1082 62.2% 384/506 106/506 0.6s
5 Stockfish19 7378/13970 260 52.8% 3560 27 1094 60.5% 382/506 108/506 0.6s
6 LeptirM260122MPV1 7238/13970 279 51.8% 3550 27 1207 58.7% 379/506 107/506 0.5s
7 Triumviratus8.0PosSolMPV1 6914/13970 245 49.5% 3532 24 1065 56.2% 374/506 117/506 0.5s
8 ShashChess41.2GD 6874/13970 286 49.2% 3512 27 1189 53.5% 372/506 115/506 0.5s
9 PlentyChess8.0 6653/13970 283 47.6% 3483 25 1260 47.9% 362/506 126/506 0.7s
10 Reckless260903 6119/13970 264 43.8% 3453 25 1169 43.7% 355/506 138/506 0.6s
11 Pawnocchio3.0 6794/13970 287 48.6% 3446 24 1348 41.9% 352/506 135/506 0.6s
12 Viridithas20.0 6546/13970 266 46.9% 3437 27 1294 40.5% 350/506 138/506 0.6s
13 Integral260925 6458/13970 282 46.2% 3420 24 1398 38.5% 344/506 146/506 0.6s
14 Cinder0.6.1 5825/13970 279 41.7% 3386 24 1276 33.8% 339/506 150/506 0.6s
15 Coda0.9.4.1 5661/13970 271 40.5% 3340 25 1428 27.7% 324/506 169/506 0.7s
Kreuztabelle (Zeile gegen Spalte, Elo-Differenz; Spalten = Ranglistennummer):
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
1 Crystal260930 — +57 +75 +76 +90 +84 +128 +123 +156 +222 +165 +208 +246 +252 +281
2 Corchess260924 -57 — +12 +16 +32 +31 +61 +69 +88 +145 +120 +128 +149 +199 +269
3 ShashChess42C -75 -12 — +12 +29 +32 +70 +77 +96 +134 +132 +137 +150 +204 +227
4 Stockfish261013 -76 -16 -12 — +18 +17 +47 +60 +95 +127 +129 +145 +148 +196 +271
5 Stockfish19 -90 -32 -29 -18 — +8.7 +35 +45 +70 +111 +123 +123 +134 +194 +230
6 LeptirM260122MPV1 -84 -31 -32 -17 -8.7 — +36 +52 +70 +102 +97 +103 +125 +157 +197
7 Triumviratus8.0PosSolMPV1 -128 -61 -70 -47 -35 -36 — +16 +56 +82 +95 +106 +105 +176 +216
8 ShashChess41.2GD -123 -69 -77 -60 -45 -52 -16 — +34 +61 +68 +81 +88 +126 +156
9 PlentyChess8.0 -156 -88 -96 -95 -70 -70 -56 -34 — +30 +43 +52 +63 +95 +130
10 Reckless260903 -222 -145 -134 -127 -111 -102 -82 -61 -30 — +19 +22 +50 +67 +129
11 Pawnocchio3.0 -165 -120 -132 -129 -123 -97 -95 -68 -43 -19 — +9.4 +23 +52 +94
12 Viridithas20.0 -208 -128 -137 -145 -123 -103 -106 -81 -52 -22 -9.4 — +19 +51 +92
13 Integral260925 -246 -149 -150 -148 -134 -125 -105 -88 -63 -50 -23 -19 — +20 +72
14 Cinder0.6.1 -252 -199 -204 -196 -194 -157 -176 -126 -95 -67 -52 -51 -20 — +59
15 Coda0.9.4.1 -281 -269 -227 -271 -230 -197 -216 -156 -130 -129 -94 -92 -72 -59 —https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/uy8gnzhc ... v3n2q&dl=0
With this one also all runs in MultiPV=1- setting:
Code: Select all
# Engine Punkte +/- Pkt% eElo +/- Matches Score% volle Pkt no points Ø Zeit
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1 Stockfish261013 36317/40876 127 88.8% 3550 6 17405 58.1% 2843/4096 258/4096 0.2s
2 Stockfish19 36346/40876 130 88.9% 3547 7 17795 57.6% 2851/4096 255/4096 0.2s
3 ShashChess42C 36154/40876 128 88.4% 3545 6 17450 57.2% 2820/4096 274/4096 0.2s
4 Corchess260924 36068/40876 130 88.2% 3538 7 17592 56.3% 2810/4096 275/4096 0.2s
5 Triumviratus8.0PosSolMPV1 35943/40876 130 87.9% 3529 7 17646 54.9% 2788/4096 296/4096 0.2s
6 ShashChess41.2GD 35425/40876 139 86.7% 3502 6 18566 50.7% 2693/4096 316/4096 0.2s
7 Reckless260903 35043/40876 145 85.7% 3493 6 19228 49.1% 2654/4096 358/4096 0.2s
8 Viridithas20.0 34919/40876 150 85.4% 3490 6 19075 48.6% 2654/4096 368/4096 0.2s
9 Crystal260930 35015/40876 151 85.7% 3489 6 19279 48.6% 2663/4096 364/4096 0.3s
10 PlentyChess8.0 35045/40876 150 85.7% 3488 6 19461 48.3% 2635/4096 356/4096 0.2s
11 Coda0.9.4.1 34827/40876 150 85.2% 3488 6 18852 48.4% 2646/4096 384/4096 0.2s
12 Pawnocchio3.0 34243/40876 162 83.8% 3464 6 20159 44.5% 2549/4096 413/4096 0.3s
13 Obsidian16.0 34267/40876 163 83.8% 3463 6 20423 44.5% 2554/4096 418/4096 0.2s
14 Integral260925 34271/40876 155 83.8% 3462 6 19509 44.2% 2547/4096 413/4096 0.3s
15 Cinder0.6.1 34061/40876 156 83.3% 3452 6 19746 42.9% 2508/4096 429/4096 0.3s
Kreuztabelle (Zeile gegen Spalte, Elo-Differenz; Spalten = Ranglistennummer):
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
1 Stockfish261013 — +2.3 +7.9 +12 +21 +50 +54 +59 +62 +61 +66 +84 +88 +87 +100
2 Stockfish19 -2.3 — +3.5 +13 +20 +47 +54 +53 +61 +59 +63 +78 +81 +85 +95
3 ShashChess42C -7.9 -3.5 — +3.5 +18 +44 +53 +54 +55 +53 +60 +80 +82 +82 +96
4 Corchess260924 -12 -13 -3.5 — +11 +37 +46 +47 +53 +49 +51 +72 +73 +80 +87
5 Triumviratus8.0PosSolMPV1 -21 -20 -18 -11 — +28 +35 +37 +42 +42 +42 +65 +66 +68 +82
6 ShashChess41.2GD -50 -47 -44 -37 -28 — +12 +12 +14 +15 +15 +41 +40 +44 +49
7 Reckless260903 -54 -54 -53 -46 -35 -12 — +3.6 +1.7 +6.3 +3.0 +30 +32 +32 +41
8 Viridithas20.0 -59 -53 -54 -47 -37 -12 -3.6 — -0.2 -0.5 +0.8 +29 +25 +27 +38
9 Crystal260930 -62 -61 -55 -53 -42 -14 -1.7 +0.2 — +1.2 +1.7 +27 +28 +27 +36
10 PlentyChess8.0 -61 -59 -53 -49 -42 -15 -6.3 +0.5 -1.2 — -0.3 +24 +23 +25 +33
11 Coda0.9.4.1 -66 -63 -60 -51 -42 -15 -3.0 -0.8 -1.7 +0.3 — +23 +25 +29 +40
12 Pawnocchio3.0 -84 -78 -80 -72 -65 -41 -30 -29 -27 -24 -23 — -0.7 -2.5 +9.6
13 Obsidian16.0 -88 -81 -82 -73 -66 -40 -32 -25 -28 -23 -25 +0.7 — -1.4 +9.0
14 Integral260925 -87 -85 -82 -80 -68 -44 -32 -27 -27 -25 -29 +2.5 +1.4 — +6.2
15 Cinder0.6.1 -100 -95 -96 -87 -82 -49 -41 -38 -36 -33 -40 -9.6 -9.0 -6.2 —Peter.
-
Stephen Ham
- Posts: 2517
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:40 pm
- Location: Eden Prairie, Minnesota
- Full name: Stephen Ham
Best tactical engine?
Hallo Peter,
Some of your engines seem available only for android format, such as Crystal 260930. Do you have versions for PC use?
Thanks in advance.
-Steve-
Some of your engines seem available only for android format, such as Crystal 260930. Do you have versions for PC use?
Thanks in advance.
-Steve-
-
peter
- Posts: 3699
- Joined: Sat Feb 16, 2008 7:38 am
- Full name: Peter Martan
Re: Best tactical engine?
Hello Stephen!Stephen Ham wrote: ↑Tue Oct 20, 2026 6:12 pm Some of your engines seem available only for android format, such as Crystal 260930. Do you have versions for PC use?
All the engines listed ran on the same PC of course, single thread with 4.3GHz- CPU and Windows11. Some are simply compiled from github- sources on my own PC too, such als Crystal 260930, meaning compiled from sources of that (20260930) date, regards
Peter.