CEGT - rating lists from 28th October 2007

[Werner]

Hi all ,

our new 40/4, 40/20 and 40/120 rating lists are online and can be found under the attached links.

40 / 20:
"Yes", we managed to make more than 400 games with the new DeepShredder 11 x64 2CPU - so you will have a relatively precise rating. The other surprise this week was the result of the bug-fix version of Deep Fritz 10.1 4CPU. We also made more games with Fruit 2.2.1, Scorpio Beta and DJ10.1 4CPU. See more in our list "Games of the week".

In total our 40/20 list is based on 191.732 games!

New engines:

Stefan promised +100 Elos for his new engine. Perhaps he had a look into our list, as the new Deep Shredder 11 x64 2CPU has 2961 elos - which are exactly 100 points more than for the previous version . We think +100 elos at this level is a huge effort. Congrats Stefan!! - this is the 2nd place just in front of Zappa.
Another surprise was the result we got with Deep Fritz 10.1 4CPU. We found the patch here: http://f23.parsimony.net/forum50826/messages/173809.htm
As in our list DeepFritz 10 4CPU had a rating under the 2CPU-version we tested this update with 4CPUs. The reslult was 2949 elos - 88 points more than the version 10.0 on 4CPUs and 59 more than the 2CPU-version.

updated engines:

Scorpio 2.0 beta lost some more points and is now very close to the version 1.91.

40 / 120:
Our 40/120 list was updated too. As we now make matches with 4 CPUs the number of new games is not so high . In the meantime 16324 games are played.
The Fruit2.2.3f rating did not change after now 614 games.
Next new engine will be DeepShredder 11 2CPU. Results in our next update in 2 weeks.
For next week we plan a new 4CPU-list with 150 matches for Rybka 2.3.2a x64 4CPU, Zappa Mexcio x64 4 CPU, Naum 2.2 x64 4CPU and Deep Shredder 11 x64 4CPU. Interim results (DeepShredder 11 4CPUs included) we publish in our forum:
http://husvankempen.de/nunn/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=864

40 / 4:
Our blitz list was updated too with new results for Spike Turin 2CPU, Delfi 5.2, ProDeo 1.6....Altogether we added 6000 games to the list. Next week we will add results for the new Shredder engine too.

A big „Thank you“ to all testers as usual!

40/20: http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/rating.htm
Blitz: http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/blitz.htm
40/120: http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/rating120.htm
Tester: http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/testers/testers.htm
Games of the week: http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/40_40%2 ... on/gow.JPG
Elo-comparison: http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/Replay/ ... arison.htm

Werner
CEGT Team

[ThatsIt]

..now some (Deep) Shredder 11 Games integrated.

Remark:
the games are not included in the games-database so far.

Standings until now:
http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/blitz.htm

Code: Select all

   Program                        Elo    +   - Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws
17 Deep Shredder 11 x64 2CPU     2958   32  32   280   49.3 %   2963   37.1 %
19 Deep Shredder 11 w32 2CPU     2950   40  40   200   60.5 %   2876   34.0 %
43 Deep Shredder 10 w32 2CPU     2858   16  16  1199   43.1 %   2907   31.9 %
47 Deep Shredder 10 x64 2CPU     2856   13  13  2050   48.1 %   2869   30.5 %


26 Deep Shredder 11 x64 1CPU     2915   23  23   565   57.7 %   2861   35.8 %
41 Deep Shredder 11 w32 1CPU     2865   33  33   300   56.8 %   2817   30.3 %
74 Shredder 10 w32 1CPU          2809    9   9  4162   47.5 %   2827   30.0 %
79 Deep Shredder 10 x64 1CPU     2804   19  19   840   41.7 %   2863   34.8 %

The matches (some are intermediate results):

Code: Select all

17 Deep Shredder 11 x64 2CPU : 2958  280 (+ 86,=104,- 90), 49.3 %
Hiarcs 11.2 2CPU                      94 (+ 41,= 33,- 20), 61.2 %
Rybka 2.3.2a x64 2CPU                 93 (+ 16,= 34,- 43), 35.5 %
Zappa Mexico x64 2CPU                 93 (+ 29,= 37,- 27), 51.1 %

19 Deep Shredder 11 w32 2CPU : 2950  200 (+ 87,= 68,- 45), 60.5 %
Loop-MP 12.32 2CPU                   100 (+ 48,= 32,- 20), 64.0 %
Naum 2.2 w32 2CPU                    100 (+ 39,= 36,- 25), 57.0 %

26 Deep Shredder 11 x64 1CPU : 2915  565 (+225,=202,-138), 57.7 %
Fruit 051103                          49 (+ 23,= 15,- 11), 62.2 %
Deep Sjeng 2.7 1CPU                   48 (+ 25,= 16,-  7), 68.8 %
Spike 1.2 Turin 1CPU                  48 (+ 26,= 15,-  7), 69.8 %
Rybka 2.2 x64 1CPU                   140 (+ 35,= 43,- 62), 40.4 %
Naum 2.2 x64 1CPU                    140 (+ 62,= 55,- 23), 63.9 %
Loop 13.6 x64 1CPU                   140 (+ 54,= 58,- 28), 59.3 %

41 Deep Shredder 11 w32 1CPU : 2865  300 (+125,= 91,- 84), 56.8 %
Rybka 1.2f w32 1CPU                  100 (+ 33,= 28,- 39), 47.0 %
Deep Fritz 7 1CPU                    100 (+ 55,= 28,- 17), 69.0 %
Naum 2.2 w32 1CPU                    100 (+ 37,= 35,- 28), 54.5 %

http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/

Best, G.S.

[Wolfgang]

....
40 / 4:
Our blitz list was updated too with new results for Spike Turin 2CPU, Delfi 5.2, ProDeo 1.6....Altogether we added 6000 games to the list. Next week we will add results for the new Shredder engine too.

there were even about 10.000 games added

[ArmyBridge]

Hi , nice job But I can´t see the link to download the las update of 40/20, the page only have the 10/21/2007, where I can get it?, thanks!!

[Werner]

Hi,
it´s here
http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/downloa ... 071028.zip
please refresh your browser

[ArmyBridge]

Thank´s a lot Werner I refresh my browser, now a see the link, but is strange.. the link download the file UP20070128.zip then I serch in my database and seems that is a old download.... and I dont see any game of shredder 11

[Kirill Kryukov]

Thanks for update! In CEGT 40/4 "Best Single Versions" list the first 10 places are occupied by Rybka, is it normal?

[Uri Blass]

Thanks for update! In CEGT 40/4 "Best Single Versions" list the first 10 places are occupied by Rybka, is it normal?

In the CCRL the first 29 places are occupied by rybka

The best non rybka is only place 30:

http://computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/404/cg ... ons_only=1

1 Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit 3084 +22 −22 77.1% −192.4 32.3% 812
100.0%
2 Rybka 2.2 64-bit 3028 +21 −21 74.7% −177.0 29.8% 882
54.6%
3 Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit 3026 +24 −23 75.7% −188.2 28.7% 719
51.3%
4 Rybka 2.3.2a 32-bit 3025 +20 −20 73.4% −158.0 34.5% 892
58.0%
5 Rybka 2.1o 64-bit 3022 +26 −25 75.4% −183.8 28.4% 595
77.8%
6 Rybka 2.1c 64-bit 3007 +28 −27 74.7% −178.3 27.5% 512
76.9%
7 Rybka 2.3 LK 32-bit 2994 +21 −21 75.3% −188.2 24.8% 908
52.9%
8 Rybka 2.3.1 32-bit 2993 +15 −15 74.7% −182.0 26.4% 1878
55.0%
9 Rybka 2.2 32-bit 2992 +13 −13 73.8% −174.0 29.0% 2435
64.6%
10 Rybka 1.1 64-bit 2983 +41 −39 79.5% −225.3 22.7% 273
63.9%
11 Rybka 2.3 32-bit 2974 +27 −26 74.9% −182.4 26.7% 570
64.6%
12 Rybka 1.2n 32-bit 2967 +27 −26 67.3% −124.0 28.1% 524
61.0%
13 Rybka 1.2f 32-bit 2963 +13 −13 66.5% −116.3 35.2% 2328
47.6%
14 Rybka 2.1o 32-bit 2963 +13 −13 68.4% −131.9 31.4% 2117
55.7%
15 Rybka 1.2f 32-bit (Contempt +1) 2961 +28 −27 73.0% −167.1 28.0% 510
62.0%
16 Rybka 1.2f 32-bit (Outlook SO) 2953 +45 −43 73.9% −176.5 25.4% 209
51.7%
17 Rybka 2.1c 32-bit 2952 +14 −14 67.1% −123.2 31.4% 1852
50.6%
18 Rybka 2.1c 32-bit (C+1_OSO_RS) 2952 +28 −27 71.4% −158.3 28.1% 509
50.3%
19 Rybka 2.1c 32-bit (Outlook SO) 2952 +28 −27 71.3% −158.4 24.4% 508
54.1%
20 Rybka 1.1 32-bit 2950 +18 −18 65.6% −107.0 38.0% 1073
52.6%
21 Rybka 2.1c 32-bit (C+1 OSO) 2949 +27 −26 70.9% −154.9 25.6% 540
50.9%
22 Rybka 1.2i 32-bit 2948 +24 −23 68.4% −133.8 28.7% 675
57.8%
23 Rybka 1.0 Beta 64-bit 2946 +17 −17 74.4% −179.0 29.7% 1364
71.8%
24 Rybka 2.1c 32-bit (Contempt +1) 2936 +28 −27 69.4% −142.1 26.3% 510
54.6%
25 Rybka 2.1o 32-bit (Outlook SO) 2934 +28 −27 69.1% −140.1 26.9% 510
54.0%
26 Rybka 2.1c 32-bit (Rate Slow) 2931 +34 −33 71.5% −154.5 29.1% 330
57.3%
27 Rybka 2.1c 32-bit (Outlook VO) 2927 +33 −32 69.4% −142.9 25.1% 359
54.3%
28 Rybka 2.1c 32-bit (ETB Small) 2924 +34 −33 70.3% −147.2 27.1% 328
62.5%
29 Rybka 1.01 Beta 13d 2917 +30 −29 67.6% −125.4 31.3% 418
61.2%
30 Hiarcs 11.1 2912 +12 −12 60.5% −72.5 33.1% 2407
60.0%

I the CEGT 40/20 list there are also many rybkas single cpu
They did not calculate the best single version correctly but the top 12 single are rybka and I still see no single processor machine that is above rybka 64 bit.

Maybe Shredder11 can do it but unfortunately they did not test shredder single version or did not test it with enough games to be in the list

13 Rybka 2.3.2a w32 1CPU 2970 12 12 1985 68.4% 2836 36.9%
14 Rybka 1.1 x64 2964 17 17 1768 83.1% 2687 20.4%
16 Rybka 2.3.1 w32 1CPU 2957 24 24 605 72.2% 2791 32.4%
17 Rybka 1.2f x64 2955 18 18 1306 76.5% 2750 27.6%
21 Rybka 2.2 w32 1CPU 2937 17 17 1184 69.0% 2798 34.4%
22 Rybka 1.2f w32 2934 25 25 605 73.1% 2761 27.4%
24 Rybka 2.3 LK w32 1CPU 2920 48 48 154 66.9% 2798 31.2%
25 Rybka 1.01 Beta 13-13d x64 2919 25 25 713 78.6% 2693 24.8%
28 Rybka 2.1c w32 1CPU 2907 23 23 658 68.3% 2773 33.3%
30 Rybka 1.1 w32 2901 16 16 1641 77.1% 2690 25.4%
33 Rybka 1.01 Beta 9 x64 opti 2890 37 37 315 77.0% 2680 24.4%
44 Rybka 1.0 Beta x64 2863 16 16 1238 63.2% 2769 36.6%
52 Fruit 2.3.3f Beta 2839 17 17 981 48.3% 2851 36.7%

[ThatsIt]

Thanks for update! In CEGT 40/4 "Best Single Versions" list the first 10 places are occupied by Rybka, is it normal?

Hi Kirill !

Thats right. We will fix it with the next update.

Best to you !
G.S.

[Kirill Kryukov]

Thanks for update! In CEGT 40/4 "Best Single Versions" list the first 10 places are occupied by Rybka, is it normal?

Hi Kirill !

Thats right. We will fix it with the next update.

Best to you !
G.S.

Cool, thanks!