Mate in 10 test for Amateurs < 2700 (and humans!)

Discussion of chess software programming and technical issues.

Moderator: Ras

JVMerlino
Posts: 1396
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 10:15 pm
Location: San Francisco, California

Mate in 10 test for Amateurs < 2700 (and humans!)

Post by JVMerlino »

In recent CCRL D8 match between Myrddin and Luna: [d] 2b2k1r/bp1p2p1/r1pP1pB1/7P/4NP2/3R3R/1p2P3/1K6 w - - 0 28 One surprising move leads to Mate in 10, and Myrddin finds it in 1.6 seconds.

Enjoy!
User avatar
Steve Maughan
Posts: 1272
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:28 pm
Location: Florida, USA

Re: Mate in 10 test for Amateurs < 2700 (and humans!)

Post by Steve Maughan »

Interestingly Stockfish development version need 3 min 30 secs to find this, running on one core. Maverick finds it in 1.8 seconds, The King 3.5 finds it in less than one second. (i9 laptop)

— Steve
http://www.chessprogramming.net - Juggernaut & Maverick Chess Engine
User avatar
Ajedrecista
Posts: 2097
Joined: Wed Jul 13, 2011 9:04 pm
Location: Madrid, Spain.

Re: Mate in 10 test for amateurs < 2700 (and humans!).

Post by Ajedrecista »

Hello:

Summary:

Code: Select all

=============================
ENGINE             → M:SS.sss
=============================
Rybka 2.2 64-bit   → 0:00.947
Ruffian 1.0.5      → 0:01.310
Hermann 2.4 64-bit → 0:01.728
Nejmet 3.07        → 0:15.000
SOS 5.1 for Arena  → 0:34.794
Chest 5.2          → 3:42.403 // Rhe3 found as #10
Chest 5.2          → 6:03.961 // Only Rhe3 is #10
-----------------------

Chest 5.2 needed almost four minutes on my desktop (hash = 256 MB) to find the checkmate in ten moves and more than six minutes to find that this move was the only move to checkmate in ten moves:

Code: Select all

FEN: 2b2k1r/bp1p2p1/r1pP1pB1/7P/4NP2/3R3R/1p2P3/1K6 w - - 0 28

ChestUCI:
FEN: 2b2k1r/bp1p2p1/r1pP1pB1/7P/4NP2/3R3R/1p2P3/1K6 w - -   (9+11)
Stellungs-Analyse:  C0/R0/K2/P7/X22   W:8/32
Suche nach Matt in 10 ...  (Hash=256MB)
  10	03:43	 148.672.221	668.481	+M10	Rh3e3
Suche abgeschlossen ...  (Zeit=363.96s)
Matt in 10 gefunden !  (1 Lösung in 06:03)
 10/10	06:04	 239.522.010	658.098	+M10	Rh3e3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 f6f5 Re3e8+
------------------------

Hermann 2.4 64-bit did an excellent job:

Code: Select all

FEN: 2b2k1r/bp1p2p1/r1pP1pB1/7P/4NP2/3R3R/1p2P3/1K6 w - - 0 28

Hermann 2.4 64 bit:
  1/6	00:00	          56	56.000	-0,94	Kb1xb2 Ra6b6+
 10/29	00:00	     575.030	1.089.072	+3,11	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c3 Ra5e5 f4xe5 b7b5 e5xf6 g7xf6 Re3e8+ Kf8g7
 11/29	00:01	     830.260	1.074.075	+3,49	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2
 12/32	00:01	   1.833.893	1.061.281	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a3 Rb5a5+ Ka3b4 Ra5b5+ Kb4a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 Rh8xh5
 13/32	00:02	   2.139.220	1.047.610	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 Rh8h6
 14/32	00:02	   2.641.998	1.041.797	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 Rh8xh5
------------------------

Nejmet 3.07 was a little slower than Hermann, but finally succeed:

Code: Select all

FEN: 2b2k1r/bp1p2p1/r1pP1pB1/7P/4NP2/3R3R/1p2P3/1K6 w - - 0 28

Nejmet 3.07:
  1/2	00:00	           2	2	-2,00	Kb1xb2
  1/2	00:00	           3	3	-1,44	Kb1xb2
  1/2	00:00	          34	34	-1,44	Kb1xb2
  2/4	00:00	          41	41	-1,44	Kb1xb2
  2/4	00:00	          68	68	-1,87	Kb1xb2 b7b5
  2/4	00:00	         331	331	-1,87	Kb1xb2 b7b5
  3/6	00:00	         427	427	-1,87	Kb1xb2
  3/6	00:00	         596	596	-1,52	Kb1xb2 b7b5 Rd3a3
  3/6	00:00	       1.296	1.296	-1,52	Kb1xb2 b7b5 Rd3a3
  4/8	00:00	       2.108	2.108	-1,55	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 Rd3a3 Ba7d4+ Kb2c2
  4/8	00:00	       5.741	5.741	-1,55	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 Rd3a3 Ba7d4+ Kb2c2
  5/10	00:00	       8.116	8.116	-1,37	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 Rh3g3 b7b5 Rd3a3
  5/10	00:00	      10.544	10.544	-1,37	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 Rh3g3 b7b5 Rd3a3
  6/12	00:00	      25.103	25.103	-1,36	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 e2e3 b7b5 Rd3a3 b5b4
  6/12	00:00	      32.155	32.155	-1,36	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 e2e3 b7b5 Rd3a3 b5b4
  7/14	00:00	      56.815	56.815	-1,36	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 e2e3 b7b5 Rd3a3 b5b4 Ra3xa6
  7/14	00:00	      92.797	92.797	-1,36	h5h6
  7/14	00:00	     115.975	115.975	-1,31	h5h6 Rh8xh6 Rh3xh6 g7xh6 Kb1xb2 Ra6a4 Rd3g3
  7/14	00:00	     133.606	133.606	-1,31	h5h6 Rh8xh6 Rh3xh6 g7xh6 Kb1xb2 Ra6a4 Rd3g3
  8/16	00:00	     143.335	143.335	-1,31	h5h6
  8/16	00:00	     197.120	197.120	-1,64	h5h6 Rh8xh6 Rh3xh6 g7xh6 Kb1xb2 Kf8g7 Rd3g3 b7b5
  8/16	00:00	     217.607	217.607	-1,64	Kb1xb2
  8/16	00:00	     278.934	278.934	-1,37	Kb1xb2 b7b5 h5h6 Rh8xh6 Rh3xh6 g7xh6 Ne4xf6 Ba7c5
  8/16	00:00	     299.456	299.456	-1,37	Rd3a3
  8/16	00:00	     339.966	339.966	-0,88	Rd3a3 Rh8h6 Ra3xa6 b7xa6 Kb1xb2 a6a5 Rh3b3 a5a4
  8/16	00:00	     350.077	350.077	-0,88	Rd3a3 Rh8h6 Ra3xa6 b7xa6 Kb1xb2 a6a5 Rh3b3 a5a4
  9/18	00:00	     399.452	399.452	-0,78	Rd3a3 Rh8h6 Ra3xa6 b7xa6 e2e3 c6c5 Kb1xb2 Bc8b7 Kb2c3
  9/18	00:00	     505.250	505.250	-0,78	Ne4c5
  9/18	00:00	     572.109	572.109	-0,52	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xa7 Rh3h2
  9/18	00:00	     596.159	596.159	-0,52	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xa7 Rh3h2
 10/20	00:00	     659.719	659.719	-0,52	Ne4c5
 10/20	00:01	     994.287	994.287	+1,90	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xh3 Kf8g8 Nc5e4
 10/20	00:01	   1.255.573	1.255.573	+1,90	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xh3 Kf8g8 Nc5e4
 11/22	00:01	   1.283.332	1.283.332	+1,90	Ne4c5
 11/22	00:01	   1.496.762	1.496.762	+1,45	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xh3 Kf8g8 Nc5e4 b7b5
 11/22	00:01	   1.905.714	1.905.714	+1,45	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xh3 Kf8g8 Nc5e4 b7b5
 12/24	00:02	   2.405.273	1.202.636	+1,53	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xh3 Kf8g8 Rh3e3 Kg8f8 Re3c3
 12/24	00:03	   3.822.708	1.274.236	+1,53	Rd3e3
 12/24	00:04	   4.508.867	1.127.216	+1,92	Rd3e3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Ne4g5 Ba7d4+ Kb2c2 Bd4e5 Ng5f7 Be5xf4 Nf7xh8 Bf4xe3 Rh3xe3 Rg1a1
 12/24	00:05	   6.031.634	1.206.326	+1,92	Rh3e3
 12/24	00:07	   8.486.470	1.212.352	+4,65	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 Kf8g8
 12/24	00:07	   8.583.014	1.226.144	+4,65	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 Kf8g8
 13/26	00:09	  10.057.341	1.117.482	+4,65	Rh3e3
 13/26	00:15	  18.192.008	1.212.800	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5
 13/26	00:18	  22.085.783	1.226.987	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5
------------------------

Ruffian 1.0.5 also did an excellent job, like Hermann:

Code: Select all

FEN: 2b2k1r/bp1p2p1/r1pP1pB1/7P/4NP2/3R3R/1p2P3/1K6 w - - 0 28

Ruffian 1.0.5:
  1/1	00:00	           2	0	-1,39	Kb1xb2
  2/5	00:00	         114	0	-1,86	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6
  2/6	00:00	         723	0	-1,81	Rd3d2 Rh8h6 Rd2xb2
  3/7	00:00	       1.538	0	-1,81	Rd3d2 Rh8h6 Rd2xb2
  3/9	00:00	       1.861	0	-1,52	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 Rh3g3
  4/9	00:00	       3.303	0	-1,89	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 Rh3g3 Ba7b6
  5/11	00:00	       9.653	0	-1,51	Kb1xb2 Rh8h6 Rh3g3 Ba7b6 Kb2c3
  6/13	00:00	      27.858	2.785.800	-1,86	Kb1xb2 b7b5 Rh3g3 Rh8h6 Kb2c3 Ra6a2
  7/15	00:00	      67.413	2.247.100	-1,70	Kb1xb2 b7b5 Rh3g3 Rh8h6 e2e3 Ba7b6 Kb2c3
  7/15	00:00	     108.300	2.707.500	-1,60	Rd3a3 Ba7d4 Ra3xa6 b7xa6 e2e3 Bd4b6 Kb1xb2 a6a5
  8/16	00:00	     198.506	2.835.800	-1,42	Rd3a3 Ba7b6 Ra3xa6 b7xa6 Rh3b3 Bb6a7 Kb1xb2 Ba7d4+ Kb2c2 a6a5
  8/19	00:00	     382.985	3.191.541	+0,96	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3e3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Re3xh3 Kf8g8 Rh3h5 b7b5
  9/21	00:00	     461.396	3.075.973	+0,99	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3e3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8g8 Rh3h5 Ba7b8 Re3d3 Kf8e8
 10/23	00:00	     658.477	3.135.604	+0,96	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3e3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8h6 Re3c3 Ba7b8 Rh3xh6 g7xh6 Rc3d3 Kf8g7
 11/24	00:00	   1.099.488	3.435.900	+0,75	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3e3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Re3xh3 Kf8g8 Rh3h5 b7b6 Nc5e4 b6b5 Ne4c5 Ba7b6
 11/26	00:00	   2.990.657	3.437.536	+4,77	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 Rh8h6
 12/26+	00:01	   3.826.614	3.416.619	+5,12	Rh3e3
 12/26	00:01	   4.704.971	3.591.580	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 Rh8h6 Re3e8+
 13/26	00:01	   5.569.568	3.640.240	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 Rh8h6 Re3e8+
 14/26	00:01	   7.400.048	3.775.534	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+ Kb3a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5xb6 Rh8h6 Re3e8+
------------------------

Rybka 2.2 64-bit was even faster (less than a second!):

Code: Select all

FEN: 2b2k1r/bp1p2p1/r1pP1pB1/7P/4NP2/3R3R/1p2P3/1K6 w - - 0 28

Rybka 2.2 64 bit:
   2	00:00	       1.210	72.884	-0,41	Kb1xb2
   3	00:00	       3.664	117.248	-0,46	Kb1xb2
   4	00:00	       7.932	253.824	-0,54	Kb1xb2
   5	00:00	      16.086	343.168	-0,59	Kb1xb2 Ra6a5
   6	00:00	      67.863	489.378	-0,60	Kb1xb2 b7b5 e2e3
   7	00:00	      79.273	469.222	-0,59	Kb1xb2 b7b5 e2e3 Bc8b7
   8	00:00	     102.496	477.072	-0,61	Kb1xb2 b7b5 e2e3 Bc8b7 Rd3c3
   8	00:00	     117.247	478.330	-0,56	Ne4c3 Rh8h6 Kb1xb2 b7b5 Rd3e3
   8	00:00	     140.804	483.836	+1,08	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3e3 Rg1xg6
   9	00:00	     143.416	469.194	+0,98	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3e3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3
  10	00:00	     146.880	457.158	+1,03	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3e3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Re3xh3 Kf8g8
  11	00:00	     151.442	449.497	+0,91	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3e3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Re3xh3 Kf8g8 Rh3e3
  11	00:00	     260.828	448.887	+2,80	Rd3e3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Ne4g5 Ba7d4+ Kb2c2 Bd4e5 Ng5f7 Rh8g8
  11	00:00	     264.593	444.169	+3,31	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Nc5b3 Rb5e5 f4xe5
  12	00:00	     275.190	438.932	+3,38	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Nc5b3 Rb5e5 f4xe5 f6f5
  13	00:01	     492.000	519.389	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+
  14	00:01	     503.640	531.677	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a2 Rb5a5+ Ka2b3 Ra5b5+
  15	00:01	     521.523	533.506	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+
  16	00:01	     552.242	547.961	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+
  17	00:01	     604.568	582.387	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+
  18	00:01	     687.429	616.398	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+
  19	00:01	     828.155	677.882	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+
  20	00:01	   1.071.154	770.809	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+
  21	00:01	   1.435.914	871.075	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+
Although the complete checkmate is not shown.

------------------------

SOS 5.1 for Arena also found the checkmate in ten moves. It was the slowest engine on my desktop (Chest aside):

Code: Select all

FEN: 2b2k1r/bp1p2p1/r1pP1pB1/7P/4NP2/3R3R/1p2P3/1K6 w - - 0 28

SOS 5.1 for Arena:
  1/4	00:00	           6	0	-1,70	Kb1xb2
  2/5	00:00	          76	0	-1,68	Kb1xb2
  3/10	00:00	         230	0	-1,68	Kb1xb2 Ra6a4 Rd3a3
  4/10	00:00	         613	0	-1,68	Kb1xb2 Ra6a4 Rd3a3
  5/14	00:00	       9.324	0	-1,82	Kb1xb2 b7b5 e2e3
  6/14	00:00	      10.234	0	-1,82	Kb1xb2 b7b5 e2e3
  7/16	00:00	      73.499	0	-1,91	Kb1xb2 b7b5 Kb2c2 Rh8h6 Rd3a3 Ba7d4 Ra3xa6 Bc8xa6
  8/16	00:00	      78.565	0	-1,91	Kb1xb2 b7b5 Kb2c2 Rh8h6 Rd3a3 Ba7d4 Ra3xa6 Bc8xa6
  8/17	00:00	      89.906	0	-1,80	Kb1xb2 b7b5 Rd3a3 Ba7d4+ Kb2b3 Ra6xa3+ Kb3xa3 Bc8b7 e2e3
  8/18	00:00	      99.834	0	-1,69	Kb1xb2 b7b5 Rd3a3 Ba7d4+ Kb2b3 Ra6xa3+ Kb3xa3 Bc8b7 e2e3
  9/18	00:00	     138.192	0	-1,63	Rd3a3 Rh8h6 Ra3xa6 b7xa6 Kb1xb2 Ba7d4+ Kb2b3 Bc8b7 Kb3c4
 10/19	00:00	     166.506	0	-1,57	Rd3a3 Ba7d4 Ra3xa6 b7xa6 e2e3 Bd4b6 Kb1xb2 Bc8b7 Rh3g3
 10/19	00:00	     199.776	0	-1,46	Rd3a3 Ba7d4 Ra3xa6 b7xa6 e2e3 Bd4b6 Kb1xb2 Bc8b7 Rh3g3
 11/21	00:00	     389.386	1.067.133	-1,39	Ne4c5 Ba7xc5 Rh3e3 Bc5xe3 Rd3xe3
 12/21	00:00	     400.620	1.067.133	-1,39	Ne4c5 Ba7xc5 Rh3e3 Bc5xe3 Rd3xe3
 12/21	00:00	     421.460	1.067.133	-1,28	Ne4c5 Ba7xc5 Rh3e3 Bc5xe3 Rd3xe3
 12/23	00:00	     949.574	1.149.408	+0,82	Ne4c5 Ba7xc5 Rh3e3 Bc5xe3 Rd3xe3
 13/23	00:00	   1.083.926	1.216.346	+0,83	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xh3 Kf8g8 Rh3h5 b7b5 e2e4
 14/25	00:01	   1.516.401	1.298.749	+0,81	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xh3 Kf8g8 Rh3e3 Kg8f8 Re3c3 b7b5 e2e4
 15/26	00:01	   1.699.264	1.298.749	+0,81	Ne4c5 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1g1 Rd3a3 Rg1xg6 h5xg6 Rh8xh3 Ra3xh3 Kf8g8 Rh3e3 Kg8f8 Re3c3 b7b5 e2e4
 15/29	00:02	   3.130.423	1.351.514	+0,83	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Rh8h6 Ne4g5 Rh6xg6 Ng5h7+ Kf8f7 Re3e7+ Kf7g8 h5xg6
 15/39	00:12	  20.783.769	1.600.373	+5,78	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Rh8h6 Ne4g5 Rh6xg6 Ng5h7+ Kf8f7 Re3e7+ Kf7g8 h5xg6
 16/39	00:13	  21.891.051	1.587.583	+5,88	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Rh8h6 Ne4g5 Rh6xg6 Ng5h7+ Kf8f7 Re3e7+ Kf7g8 h5xg6 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a2+ Kb2xa2 b7b5 Re7e8+
 16/39	00:14	  22.542.152	1.579.283	+5,99	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Rh8h6 Ne4g5 Rh6xg6 Ng5h7+ Kf8f7 Re3e7+ Kf7g8 h5xg6 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a2+ Kb2xa2 b7b5 Re7e8+
 16/39	00:34	  55.216.684	1.602.539	+M13	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Rh8h6 Ne4g5 Rh6xg6 Ng5h7+ Kf8f7 Re3e7+ Kf7g8 h5xg6 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a2+ Kb2xa2 b7b5 Re7e8+
 17/39	00:34	  55.759.163	1.602.539	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a3 Rb5a5+ Ka3b4 Ra5b5+ Kb4a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5a4 f6f5 Re3e8+
 18/39	00:35	  56.908.273	1.609.569	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a3 Rb5a5+ Ka3b4 Ra5b5+ Kb4a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5a4 f6f5 Re3e8+
 19/39	00:36	  58.706.104	1.618.307	+M10	Rh3e3 Ba7xe3 Rd3xe3 Ra6a1+ Kb1xb2 Ra1a5 Ne4c5 Ra5b5+ Kb2a3 Rb5a5+ Ka3b4 Ra5b5+ Kb4a4 Rb5a5+ Ka4xa5 b7b6+ Ka5a4 f6f5 Re3e8+
------------------------

Finally, AnMon 5.60 and Dragon 4.6 found the best move in few seconds with winning scores, though evals raised slowly. ProDeo 1.5 showed a similar search pattern, although switching between 28.- Rde3 and 28.- Rhe3.

Regards from Spain.

Ajedrecista.
Jouni
Posts: 3621
Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:15 pm
Full name: Jouni Uski

Re: Mate in 10 test for Amateurs < 2700 (and humans!)

Post by Jouni »

Analysis by Stockfish 16:

1. +- (#10): 28.Rhe3 Ra1+ 29.Kxb2 Bxe3 30.Rxe3 Ra5 31.Nc5 Rb5+ 32.Ka2 Ra5+ 33.Kb3 Rb5+ 34.Ka4 Ra5+ 35.Kxa5 b6+ 36.Kxb6 f5 37.Re8#
2. +- (#14): 28.Ng5 Ra1+ 29.Kxb2 Ra5 30.Rhe3 Rb5+ 31.Kc2 Rc5+ 32.Kd2 Re5 33.fxe5 Rxh5 34.Bxh5 g6 35.exf6 gxh5 36.Re7 Bf2 37.Nh7+ Kg8 38.f7+ Kxh7 39.f8Q+ Kg6 40.Qg7+ Kf5 41.Rf3#
3. +- (#16): 28.Rde3 Bd4 29.Nc3 Be5 30.fxe5 Ra5 31.Rhf3 Kg8 32.exf6 gxf6 33.Rxf6 Rhxh5 34.Bxh5 Rxh5 35.Rg3+ Kh7 36.Ne4 Rh1+ 37.Kxb2 Rh2 38.Rf7+ Kh6 39.Nf6 Rxe2+ 40.Kc1 Re1+ 41.Kd2 Re2+ 42.Kxe2 c5 43.Rh7#
Jouni