Nelson Hernandez wrote:Lyudmil,
Thank you for your kind words and analysis at the start of this thread. I did have to laugh when I read further on that, after all the analysis and verbiage, you had not yet read my opening notes! You're probably in the majority so don't be embarrassed.
To answer your questions...
Combining stages 1, 3, 4 and the SuperFinal 'A' ECOs are seen 24%, B 24%, C 14%, D 17% and E 22%. Note that in rare instances the ECO I thought I was delivering subsequently transposes to another line, so my numbers may not correspond exactly to what you might see by downloading the games and counting.
Your observation that A+E dominate is not quite accurate but you would be correct if you said they were overrepresented compared to human and especially computer databases. When selecting a position (methodology described in my notes) I'm looking for one that meets a set of criteria. Some openings meet the requirements easier than others. For example, you will rarely (if ever) see a Berlin or a Petroff played in TCEC because I actively steer away from draw-prone openings.
As for your third question, my main database is a consolidation of human/correspondence/engine games, where engine games represent a significant majority. ECO B openings are clearly the leaders numerically, so relative to the database B is quite underrepresented. Reason: if I reflected what was in the database we'd be seeing many Sicilian Najdorf openings, which is not a good idea for competition purposes.
Thanks again for your questions and comments.
Hi Nelson.
Thanks for the explanations.
You have really done a great job!
I must admit that I follow all the games with interest, that was not quite the same last season. One of the reasons is the high level of artistic satisfaction from the game contents. When everything develops according to strict rules, you have that feeling. Any big eval deviations certainly would spoil that. I am certain the engines are also happy they are threated in a fair manner.
I did not read the book rules until yesterday, but I have replayed all major TCEC games twice...
By now there is no doubt whatsoever you possess the highest-quality and most even book in the world with such length. Only problem I see with it is the uneven spread of A,B,C,D,E openings, but maybe it is time for engines to learn to play closed positions better. If you could also include some Berlin/Petrov positions in the future, as well as some sharper ones, and a bit bigger portion of QGD/QGA, just for a higher sample representativeness, that would be gorgeous.
Kind regards to Reston.