4101 games played
PGN file:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_603563
9/7/2013 8:02:14 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3051 16 16 983 58.2 % 2993 46.0 %
2 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3025 15 15 933 54.0 % 2997 55.1 %
3 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3016 15 14 984 52.5 % 2998 55.5 %
4 Komodo51-64bit : 3011 14 14 985 51.7 % 2999 56.3 %
5 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 15 15 987 51.3 % 2999 53.5 %
6 Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 3003 23 23 387 50.9 % 2997 56.3 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2985 15 15 973 47.4 % 3003 51.7 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 15 15 984 46.4 % 3003 50.6 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2927 16 16 986 38.2 % 3010 48.1 %
Komodo: My humble tournament
Moderator: Ras
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Komodo: My humble tournament
9/8/2013 4:41:12 PM :
Individual statistics
(for 4138 games)
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3052 992 (+351,=455,-186), 58.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 33,= 76,- 27), 52.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 48,= 59,- 24), 59.2 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 132 (+ 56,= 62,- 14), 65.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 69,= 51,- 16), 69.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 67,- 24), 57.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 51,= 56,- 27), 59.0 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 15,= 25,- 14), 50.9 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 36,= 59,- 40), 48.5 %
2 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3025 942 (+250,=520,-172), 54.1 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 38,= 67,- 29), 53.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 135 (+ 40,= 59,- 36), 51.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 135 (+ 27,= 93,- 15), 54.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 76,- 15), 60.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 49,= 72,- 14), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 132 (+ 30,= 76,- 26), 51.5 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 76,- 37), 44.9 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 1 (+ 0,= 1,- 0), 50.0 %
3 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3016 994 (+246,=553,-195), 52.6 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 19,= 98,- 16), 51.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 24,= 67,- 43), 42.9 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 40,= 69,- 25), 55.6 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 37,= 68,- 30), 52.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 134 (+ 58,= 56,- 20), 64.2 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 24,= 89,- 23), 50.4 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 56 (+ 18,= 30,- 8), 58.9 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 132 (+ 26,= 76,- 30), 48.5 %
4 Komodo51-64bit : 3010 994 (+234,=559,-201), 51.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 27,= 76,- 33), 47.8 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 132 (+ 36,= 69,- 27), 53.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 37,= 64,- 33), 51.5 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 56,= 58,- 21), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 133 (+ 16,= 98,- 19), 48.9 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 17,= 98,- 19), 49.3 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 56 (+ 16,= 29,- 11), 54.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 29,= 67,- 38), 46.6 %
5 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 997 (+245,=532,-220), 51.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 19,= 98,- 17), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 27,= 56,- 51), 41.0 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 45,= 54,- 35), 53.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 36,= 64,- 35), 50.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 133 (+ 47,= 59,- 27), 57.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 89,- 24), 49.6 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 55 (+ 11,= 36,- 8), 52.7 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 136 (+ 37,= 76,- 23), 55.1 %
6 Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42: 3003 387 (+ 88,=218,- 81), 50.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 56 (+ 11,= 29,- 16), 45.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 54 (+ 14,= 25,- 15), 49.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 54 (+ 11,= 35,- 8), 52.8 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 56 (+ 17,= 29,- 10), 56.2 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 55 (+ 19,= 33,- 3), 64.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 56 (+ 8,= 30,- 18), 41.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 55 (+ 8,= 36,- 11), 47.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 1 (+ 0,= 1,- 0), 50.0 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2984 982 (+210,=509,-263), 47.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 132 (+ 27,= 69,- 36), 46.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 131 (+ 24,= 59,- 48), 40.8 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 131 (+ 38,= 61,- 32), 52.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 131 (+ 38,= 69,- 24), 55.3 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 25,= 69,- 40), 44.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 35,= 54,- 45), 46.3 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 8,= 35,- 11), 47.2 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 93,- 27), 45.6 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 993 (+210,=503,-280), 46.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 33,= 64,- 37), 48.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 14,= 62,- 56), 34.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 32,= 61,- 38), 47.7 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 41,= 79,- 16), 59.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 30,= 68,- 37), 47.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 135 (+ 35,= 64,- 36), 49.6 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 56 (+ 10,= 29,- 17), 43.8 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 15,= 76,- 43), 39.6 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2926 995 (+141,=477,-377), 38.1 %
Komodo51-64bit : 135 (+ 21,= 58,- 56), 37.0 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 16,= 51,- 69), 30.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 24,= 69,- 38), 44.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 16,= 79,- 41), 40.8 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 20,= 56,- 58), 35.8 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 59,- 47), 42.5 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 55 (+ 3,= 33,- 19), 35.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 14,= 72,- 49), 37.0 %
Individual statistics
(for 4138 games)
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3052 992 (+351,=455,-186), 58.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 33,= 76,- 27), 52.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 48,= 59,- 24), 59.2 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 132 (+ 56,= 62,- 14), 65.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 69,= 51,- 16), 69.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 67,- 24), 57.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 51,= 56,- 27), 59.0 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 15,= 25,- 14), 50.9 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 36,= 59,- 40), 48.5 %
2 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3025 942 (+250,=520,-172), 54.1 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 38,= 67,- 29), 53.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 135 (+ 40,= 59,- 36), 51.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 135 (+ 27,= 93,- 15), 54.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 76,- 15), 60.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 49,= 72,- 14), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 132 (+ 30,= 76,- 26), 51.5 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 76,- 37), 44.9 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 1 (+ 0,= 1,- 0), 50.0 %
3 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3016 994 (+246,=553,-195), 52.6 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 19,= 98,- 16), 51.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 24,= 67,- 43), 42.9 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 40,= 69,- 25), 55.6 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 37,= 68,- 30), 52.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 134 (+ 58,= 56,- 20), 64.2 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 24,= 89,- 23), 50.4 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 56 (+ 18,= 30,- 8), 58.9 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 132 (+ 26,= 76,- 30), 48.5 %
4 Komodo51-64bit : 3010 994 (+234,=559,-201), 51.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 27,= 76,- 33), 47.8 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 132 (+ 36,= 69,- 27), 53.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 37,= 64,- 33), 51.5 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 56,= 58,- 21), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 133 (+ 16,= 98,- 19), 48.9 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 17,= 98,- 19), 49.3 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 56 (+ 16,= 29,- 11), 54.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 29,= 67,- 38), 46.6 %
5 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 997 (+245,=532,-220), 51.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 19,= 98,- 17), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 27,= 56,- 51), 41.0 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 45,= 54,- 35), 53.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 36,= 64,- 35), 50.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 133 (+ 47,= 59,- 27), 57.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 89,- 24), 49.6 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 55 (+ 11,= 36,- 8), 52.7 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 136 (+ 37,= 76,- 23), 55.1 %
6 Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42: 3003 387 (+ 88,=218,- 81), 50.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 56 (+ 11,= 29,- 16), 45.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 54 (+ 14,= 25,- 15), 49.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 54 (+ 11,= 35,- 8), 52.8 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 56 (+ 17,= 29,- 10), 56.2 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 55 (+ 19,= 33,- 3), 64.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 56 (+ 8,= 30,- 18), 41.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 55 (+ 8,= 36,- 11), 47.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 1 (+ 0,= 1,- 0), 50.0 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2984 982 (+210,=509,-263), 47.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 132 (+ 27,= 69,- 36), 46.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 131 (+ 24,= 59,- 48), 40.8 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 131 (+ 38,= 61,- 32), 52.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 131 (+ 38,= 69,- 24), 55.3 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 25,= 69,- 40), 44.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 35,= 54,- 45), 46.3 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 8,= 35,- 11), 47.2 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 93,- 27), 45.6 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 993 (+210,=503,-280), 46.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 33,= 64,- 37), 48.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 14,= 62,- 56), 34.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 32,= 61,- 38), 47.7 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 41,= 79,- 16), 59.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 30,= 68,- 37), 47.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 135 (+ 35,= 64,- 36), 49.6 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 56 (+ 10,= 29,- 17), 43.8 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 15,= 76,- 43), 39.6 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2926 995 (+141,=477,-377), 38.1 %
Komodo51-64bit : 135 (+ 21,= 58,- 56), 37.0 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 16,= 51,- 69), 30.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 24,= 69,- 38), 44.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 16,= 79,- 41), 40.8 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 20,= 56,- 58), 35.8 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 59,- 47), 42.5 %
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 : 55 (+ 3,= 33,- 19), 35.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 14,= 72,- 49), 37.0 %
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Komodo: My humble tournament
Tournament UPDATE
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 has been added
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 has been removed, with its 387 games now stripped from the PGN file. It is no longer used to determine ratings in the tournament.
3884 games played
PGN file download:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_635591
9/11/2013 5:58:44 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3053 16 16 955 58.5 % 2993 46.1 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3043 37 36 127 56.3 % 2999 63.8 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 15 15 957 54.0 % 2996 55.6 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3012 15 15 955 51.9 % 2998 55.7 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3010 15 14 957 51.6 % 2999 56.6 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3006 15 15 959 51.0 % 2999 53.1 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2984 15 15 946 47.3 % 3003 51.5 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2979 16 16 954 46.5 % 3003 50.5 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2927 16 16 958 38.2 % 3010 47.1 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3053 955 (+339,=440,-176), 58.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 33,= 76,- 27), 52.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 132 (+ 49,= 59,- 24), 59.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 132 (+ 56,= 62,- 14), 65.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 69,= 51,- 16), 69.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 67,- 24), 57.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 51,= 56,- 27), 59.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 36,= 59,- 40), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 2,= 10,- 4), 43.8 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42: 3043 127 (+ 31,= 81,- 15), 56.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 17 (+ 2,= 11,- 4), 44.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 16 (+ 4,= 10,- 2), 56.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 16 (+ 2,= 12,- 2), 50.0 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 15 (+ 6,= 7,- 2), 63.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 16 (+ 8,= 7,- 1), 71.9 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 16 (+ 5,= 9,- 2), 59.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 16 (+ 2,= 13,- 1), 53.1 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 15 (+ 2,= 12,- 1), 53.3 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 957 (+251,=532,-174), 54.0 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 38,= 67,- 29), 53.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 135 (+ 40,= 59,- 36), 51.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 135 (+ 27,= 93,- 15), 54.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 43,= 77,- 15), 60.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 49,= 72,- 14), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 132 (+ 30,= 76,- 26), 51.5 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 76,- 37), 44.9 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 15 (+ 1,= 12,- 2), 46.7 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3012 955 (+230,=532,-193), 51.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 19,= 98,- 16), 51.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 24,= 67,- 43), 42.9 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 40,= 69,- 25), 55.6 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 37,= 68,- 30), 52.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 58,= 56,- 21), 63.7 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 24,= 89,- 23), 50.4 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 132 (+ 26,= 76,- 30), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 2,= 9,- 5), 40.6 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3010 957 (+223,=542,-192), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 27,= 76,- 33), 47.8 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 133 (+ 36,= 70,- 27), 53.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 37,= 64,- 33), 51.5 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 57,= 58,- 21), 63.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 133 (+ 16,= 98,- 19), 48.9 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 17,= 98,- 19), 49.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 29,= 67,- 38), 46.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 17 (+ 4,= 11,- 2), 55.9 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3006 959 (+235,=509,-215), 51.0 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 19,= 98,- 17), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 27,= 56,- 51), 41.0 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 45,= 54,- 35), 53.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 133 (+ 47,= 59,- 27), 57.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 89,- 24), 49.6 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 136 (+ 37,= 76,- 23), 55.1 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 1,= 13,- 2), 46.9 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2984 946 (+204,=487,-255), 47.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 70,- 36), 46.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 24,= 59,- 49), 40.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 131 (+ 38,= 61,- 32), 52.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 131 (+ 38,= 69,- 24), 55.3 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 25,= 69,- 40), 44.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 35,= 54,- 45), 46.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 93,- 27), 45.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 2,= 12,- 2), 50.0 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2979 954 (+203,=482,-269), 46.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 33,= 64,- 37), 48.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 14,= 62,- 56), 34.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 32,= 61,- 38), 47.7 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 41,= 79,- 16), 59.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 30,= 68,- 37), 47.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 77,- 43), 39.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 15 (+ 2,= 7,- 6), 36.7 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2927 958 (+140,=451,-367), 38.2 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 21,= 58,- 57), 36.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 16,= 51,- 69), 30.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 24,= 69,- 38), 44.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 16,= 79,- 41), 40.8 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 21,= 56,- 58), 36.3 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 59,- 47), 42.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 14,= 72,- 49), 37.0 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 1,= 7,- 8), 28.1 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 has been added
Stockfish_13081307_x64_sse42 has been removed, with its 387 games now stripped from the PGN file. It is no longer used to determine ratings in the tournament.
3884 games played
PGN file download:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_635591
9/11/2013 5:58:44 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3053 16 16 955 58.5 % 2993 46.1 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3043 37 36 127 56.3 % 2999 63.8 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 15 15 957 54.0 % 2996 55.6 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3012 15 15 955 51.9 % 2998 55.7 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3010 15 14 957 51.6 % 2999 56.6 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3006 15 15 959 51.0 % 2999 53.1 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2984 15 15 946 47.3 % 3003 51.5 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2979 16 16 954 46.5 % 3003 50.5 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2927 16 16 958 38.2 % 3010 47.1 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3053 955 (+339,=440,-176), 58.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 33,= 76,- 27), 52.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 132 (+ 49,= 59,- 24), 59.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 132 (+ 56,= 62,- 14), 65.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 69,= 51,- 16), 69.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 67,- 24), 57.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 51,= 56,- 27), 59.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 36,= 59,- 40), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 2,= 10,- 4), 43.8 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42: 3043 127 (+ 31,= 81,- 15), 56.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 17 (+ 2,= 11,- 4), 44.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 16 (+ 4,= 10,- 2), 56.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 16 (+ 2,= 12,- 2), 50.0 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 15 (+ 6,= 7,- 2), 63.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 16 (+ 8,= 7,- 1), 71.9 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 16 (+ 5,= 9,- 2), 59.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 16 (+ 2,= 13,- 1), 53.1 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 15 (+ 2,= 12,- 1), 53.3 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 957 (+251,=532,-174), 54.0 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 38,= 67,- 29), 53.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 135 (+ 40,= 59,- 36), 51.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 135 (+ 27,= 93,- 15), 54.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 43,= 77,- 15), 60.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 49,= 72,- 14), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 132 (+ 30,= 76,- 26), 51.5 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 76,- 37), 44.9 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 15 (+ 1,= 12,- 2), 46.7 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3012 955 (+230,=532,-193), 51.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 19,= 98,- 16), 51.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 24,= 67,- 43), 42.9 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 40,= 69,- 25), 55.6 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 37,= 68,- 30), 52.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 58,= 56,- 21), 63.7 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 24,= 89,- 23), 50.4 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 132 (+ 26,= 76,- 30), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 2,= 9,- 5), 40.6 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3010 957 (+223,=542,-192), 51.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 27,= 76,- 33), 47.8 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 133 (+ 36,= 70,- 27), 53.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 37,= 64,- 33), 51.5 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 57,= 58,- 21), 63.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 133 (+ 16,= 98,- 19), 48.9 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 17,= 98,- 19), 49.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 29,= 67,- 38), 46.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 17 (+ 4,= 11,- 2), 55.9 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3006 959 (+235,=509,-215), 51.0 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 19,= 98,- 17), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 27,= 56,- 51), 41.0 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 45,= 54,- 35), 53.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 133 (+ 47,= 59,- 27), 57.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 89,- 24), 49.6 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 136 (+ 37,= 76,- 23), 55.1 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 1,= 13,- 2), 46.9 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2984 946 (+204,=487,-255), 47.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 70,- 36), 46.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 24,= 59,- 49), 40.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 131 (+ 38,= 61,- 32), 52.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 131 (+ 38,= 69,- 24), 55.3 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 25,= 69,- 40), 44.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 35,= 54,- 45), 46.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 93,- 27), 45.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 2,= 12,- 2), 50.0 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2979 954 (+203,=482,-269), 46.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 33,= 64,- 37), 48.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 14,= 62,- 56), 34.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 32,= 61,- 38), 47.7 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 41,= 79,- 16), 59.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 30,= 68,- 37), 47.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 77,- 43), 39.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 15 (+ 2,= 7,- 6), 36.7 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2927 958 (+140,=451,-367), 38.2 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 21,= 58,- 57), 36.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 16,= 51,- 69), 30.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 24,= 69,- 38), 44.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 16,= 79,- 41), 40.8 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 21,= 56,- 58), 36.3 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 59,- 47), 42.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 14,= 72,- 49), 37.0 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 16 (+ 1,= 7,- 8), 28.1 %
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Komodo: My humble tournament
4055 games played
Note: Stockfish_13090815 is the "b version". From what I understand there were two releases with the same label, since they were released during the same hour.
PGN file download:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_648767
9/13/2013 10:45:58 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3050 16 16 977 58.2 % 2993 46.2 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3036 25 25 298 55.4 % 2999 60.4 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 14 14 979 53.9 % 2997 56.4 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3011 14 14 976 51.9 % 2998 56.0 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3009 14 14 978 51.4 % 2999 56.4 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 15 15 981 51.3 % 2999 52.7 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2983 15 15 967 47.2 % 3003 52.1 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2979 15 15 974 46.7 % 3003 50.4 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2924 16 16 980 37.8 % 3011 46.9 %
Note: Stockfish_13090815 is the "b version". From what I understand there were two releases with the same label, since they were released during the same hour.
PGN file download:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_648767
9/13/2013 10:45:58 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3050 16 16 977 58.2 % 2993 46.2 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3036 25 25 298 55.4 % 2999 60.4 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 14 14 979 53.9 % 2997 56.4 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3011 14 14 976 51.9 % 2998 56.0 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3009 14 14 978 51.4 % 2999 56.4 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 15 15 981 51.3 % 2999 52.7 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2983 15 15 967 47.2 % 3003 52.1 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2979 15 15 974 46.7 % 3003 50.4 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2924 16 16 980 37.8 % 3011 46.9 %
-
beram
- Posts: 1187
- Joined: Wed Jan 06, 2010 3:11 pm
Re: Komodo: My humble tournament
Thx Nicolas,
The three Komodo releases are now with more games played very close. With 3008 3009 and 3011 in your list, the differences between them are almost negligable
Stockfish 4 and later SF4 versions for sure, are closing in on Houdini 3
grts Bram
The three Komodo releases are now with more games played very close. With 3008 3009 and 3011 in your list, the differences between them are almost negligable
Stockfish 4 and later SF4 versions for sure, are closing in on Houdini 3
grts Bram
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Komodo: My humble tournament
Things get interesting: 1 point behind Houdini
4112 games played
PGN file download:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_644575
9/14/2013 8:44:34 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3049 16 16 984 57.9 % 2993 46.0 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3048 23 23 355 57.2 % 2998 58.6 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 14 14 985 54.0 % 2997 56.5 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3011 14 14 983 51.8 % 2998 56.2 %
5 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 15 15 988 51.3 % 2999 52.8 %
6 Komodo51-64bit : 3008 14 14 985 51.3 % 2999 56.4 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2982 15 15 975 47.0 % 3003 52.0 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 15 15 981 46.5 % 3003 50.2 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2923 16 16 988 37.7 % 3011 46.9 %
4112 games played
PGN file download:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_644575
9/14/2013 8:44:34 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3049 16 16 984 57.9 % 2993 46.0 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3048 23 23 355 57.2 % 2998 58.6 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 14 14 985 54.0 % 2997 56.5 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3011 14 14 983 51.8 % 2998 56.2 %
5 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 15 15 988 51.3 % 2999 52.8 %
6 Komodo51-64bit : 3008 14 14 985 51.3 % 2999 56.4 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2982 15 15 975 47.0 % 3003 52.0 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 15 15 981 46.5 % 3003 50.2 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2923 16 16 988 37.7 % 3011 46.9 %
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Komodo: My humble tournament
4185 games played.
SF takes the ELO lead, but Komodo51r2 has a better record against SF!
More games still needed in this battle of Titans, now going on almost 3 months (some engines were added later, of course).
PGN file download:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_753563
9/16/2013 2:23:32 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3048 21 21 428 57.2 % 2997 58.9 %
2 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 16 16 993 57.7 % 2994 45.9 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 14 14 994 53.9 % 2997 56.8 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3010 14 14 993 51.6 % 2999 56.1 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3009 14 14 994 51.4 % 2999 56.5 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 15 15 997 51.3 % 2999 53.1 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2981 15 15 984 46.9 % 3003 52.1 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 15 15 990 46.5 % 3003 50.2 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2922 16 16 997 37.6 % 3011 46.8 %
Individual statistics:
1 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42: 3048 428 (+119,=252,- 57), 57.2 %
Komodo51-64bit : 54 (+ 12,= 31,- 11), 50.9 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 54 (+ 20,= 26,- 8), 61.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 54 (+ 13,= 38,- 3), 59.3 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 51 (+ 18,= 22,- 11), 56.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 55 (+ 30,= 23,- 2), 75.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 54 (+ 14,= 34,- 6), 57.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 54 (+ 8,= 33,- 13), 45.4 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 52 (+ 4,= 45,- 3), 51.0 %
2 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 993 (+345,=456,-192), 57.7 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 33,= 76,- 27), 52.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 132 (+ 49,= 59,- 24), 59.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 132 (+ 56,= 62,- 14), 65.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 69,= 51,- 16), 69.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 67,- 24), 57.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 51,= 56,- 27), 59.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 36,= 59,- 40), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 8,= 26,- 20), 38.9 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 994 (+253,=565,-176), 53.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 38,= 67,- 29), 53.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 135 (+ 40,= 59,- 36), 51.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 135 (+ 27,= 93,- 15), 54.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 43,= 77,- 15), 60.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 49,= 72,- 14), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 132 (+ 30,= 76,- 26), 51.5 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 76,- 37), 44.9 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 52 (+ 3,= 45,- 4), 49.0 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3010 993 (+234,=557,-202), 51.6 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 19,= 98,- 16), 51.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 24,= 67,- 43), 42.9 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 40,= 69,- 25), 55.6 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 37,= 68,- 30), 52.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 58,= 56,- 21), 63.7 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 24,= 89,- 23), 50.4 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 132 (+ 26,= 76,- 30), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 6,= 34,- 14), 42.6 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3009 994 (+230,=562,-202), 51.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 27,= 76,- 33), 47.8 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 133 (+ 36,= 70,- 27), 53.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 37,= 64,- 33), 51.5 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 57,= 58,- 21), 63.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 133 (+ 16,= 98,- 19), 48.9 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 17,= 98,- 19), 49.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 29,= 67,- 38), 46.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 11,= 31,- 12), 49.1 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 997 (+247,=529,-221), 51.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 19,= 98,- 17), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 27,= 56,- 51), 41.0 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 45,= 54,- 35), 53.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 133 (+ 47,= 59,- 27), 57.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 89,- 24), 49.6 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 136 (+ 37,= 76,- 23), 55.1 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 13,= 33,- 8), 54.6 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2981 984 (+205,=513,-266), 46.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 70,- 36), 46.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 24,= 59,- 49), 40.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 131 (+ 38,= 61,- 32), 52.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 131 (+ 38,= 69,- 24), 55.3 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 25,= 69,- 40), 44.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 35,= 54,- 45), 46.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 93,- 27), 45.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 3,= 38,- 13), 40.7 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 990 (+212,=497,-281), 46.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 33,= 64,- 37), 48.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 14,= 62,- 56), 34.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 32,= 61,- 38), 47.7 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 41,= 79,- 16), 59.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 30,= 68,- 37), 47.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 77,- 43), 39.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 51 (+ 11,= 22,- 18), 43.1 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2922 997 (+141,=467,-389), 37.6 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 21,= 58,- 57), 36.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 16,= 51,- 69), 30.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 24,= 69,- 38), 44.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 16,= 79,- 41), 40.8 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 21,= 56,- 58), 36.3 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 59,- 47), 42.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 14,= 72,- 49), 37.0 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 55 (+ 2,= 23,- 30), 24.5 %
SF takes the ELO lead, but Komodo51r2 has a better record against SF!
More games still needed in this battle of Titans, now going on almost 3 months (some engines were added later, of course).
PGN file download:
https://www.sugarsync.com/pf/D0094094_75971673_753563
9/16/2013 2:23:32 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3048 21 21 428 57.2 % 2997 58.9 %
2 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 16 16 993 57.7 % 2994 45.9 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 14 14 994 53.9 % 2997 56.8 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3010 14 14 993 51.6 % 2999 56.1 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3009 14 14 994 51.4 % 2999 56.5 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 15 15 997 51.3 % 2999 53.1 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2981 15 15 984 46.9 % 3003 52.1 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 15 15 990 46.5 % 3003 50.2 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2922 16 16 997 37.6 % 3011 46.8 %
Individual statistics:
1 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42: 3048 428 (+119,=252,- 57), 57.2 %
Komodo51-64bit : 54 (+ 12,= 31,- 11), 50.9 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 54 (+ 20,= 26,- 8), 61.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 54 (+ 13,= 38,- 3), 59.3 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 51 (+ 18,= 22,- 11), 56.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 55 (+ 30,= 23,- 2), 75.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 54 (+ 14,= 34,- 6), 57.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 54 (+ 8,= 33,- 13), 45.4 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 52 (+ 4,= 45,- 3), 51.0 %
2 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 993 (+345,=456,-192), 57.7 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 33,= 76,- 27), 52.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 132 (+ 49,= 59,- 24), 59.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 132 (+ 56,= 62,- 14), 65.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 69,= 51,- 16), 69.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 67,- 24), 57.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 51,= 56,- 27), 59.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 36,= 59,- 40), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 8,= 26,- 20), 38.9 %
3 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3024 994 (+253,=565,-176), 53.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 38,= 67,- 29), 53.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 135 (+ 40,= 59,- 36), 51.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 135 (+ 27,= 93,- 15), 54.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 43,= 77,- 15), 60.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 49,= 72,- 14), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 132 (+ 30,= 76,- 26), 51.5 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 76,- 37), 44.9 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 52 (+ 3,= 45,- 4), 49.0 %
4 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3010 993 (+234,=557,-202), 51.6 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 19,= 98,- 16), 51.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 24,= 67,- 43), 42.9 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 40,= 69,- 25), 55.6 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 37,= 68,- 30), 52.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 58,= 56,- 21), 63.7 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 24,= 89,- 23), 50.4 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 132 (+ 26,= 76,- 30), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 6,= 34,- 14), 42.6 %
5 Komodo51-64bit : 3009 994 (+230,=562,-202), 51.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 27,= 76,- 33), 47.8 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 133 (+ 36,= 70,- 27), 53.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 37,= 64,- 33), 51.5 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 57,= 58,- 21), 63.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 133 (+ 16,= 98,- 19), 48.9 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 17,= 98,- 19), 49.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 29,= 67,- 38), 46.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 11,= 31,- 12), 49.1 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 997 (+247,=529,-221), 51.3 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 19,= 98,- 17), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 27,= 56,- 51), 41.0 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 45,= 54,- 35), 53.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 133 (+ 47,= 59,- 27), 57.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 89,- 24), 49.6 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 136 (+ 37,= 76,- 23), 55.1 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 13,= 33,- 8), 54.6 %
7 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2981 984 (+205,=513,-266), 46.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 70,- 36), 46.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 24,= 59,- 49), 40.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 131 (+ 38,= 61,- 32), 52.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 131 (+ 38,= 69,- 24), 55.3 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 25,= 69,- 40), 44.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 35,= 54,- 45), 46.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 93,- 27), 45.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 54 (+ 3,= 38,- 13), 40.7 %
8 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 990 (+212,=497,-281), 46.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 33,= 64,- 37), 48.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 14,= 62,- 56), 34.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 32,= 61,- 38), 47.7 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 41,= 79,- 16), 59.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 30,= 68,- 37), 47.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 77,- 43), 39.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 51 (+ 11,= 22,- 18), 43.1 %
9 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2922 997 (+141,=467,-389), 37.6 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 21,= 58,- 57), 36.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 16,= 51,- 69), 30.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 24,= 69,- 38), 44.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 16,= 79,- 41), 40.8 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 21,= 56,- 58), 36.3 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 59,- 47), 42.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 14,= 72,- 49), 37.0 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 55 (+ 2,= 23,- 30), 24.5 %
-
beram
- Posts: 1187
- Joined: Wed Jan 06, 2010 3:11 pm
Re: Komodo: My humble tournament
Hi Rob,
Now that the competition is so close and we even have a current Stockfish dev. as leader in your tournament, it would be interesting to see whether it is possible to improve the performance of Houdini 3 by setting its default contempt= 1 setting to contempt= 0
Besides myself I think a lot of other people want to see the result by doing so.
So I hope that you will add a Houdini 3 (contempt= 0) as a new competitor in your great 'humble' tournament
My bet based on some test observations against Komodo and Stockfish, is that Houdini 3 (contempt = 0) will perform better by 10- 20 ELO within this field of engines
thx Bram
Now that the competition is so close and we even have a current Stockfish dev. as leader in your tournament, it would be interesting to see whether it is possible to improve the performance of Houdini 3 by setting its default contempt= 1 setting to contempt= 0
Besides myself I think a lot of other people want to see the result by doing so.
So I hope that you will add a Houdini 3 (contempt= 0) as a new competitor in your great 'humble' tournament
My bet based on some test observations against Komodo and Stockfish, is that Houdini 3 (contempt = 0) will perform better by 10- 20 ELO within this field of engines
thx Bram
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Komodo: My humble tournament
UPDATE: Houdini 3 with Contempt 0 has been added:
(since I have 3 SFs, and 3 Komodos, I guess it's fair to add a Houdini, for now at least)
4320 games played
9/18/2013 9:21:42 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 3065 43 41 95 58.9 % 3002 63.2 %
2 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 16 16 1010 57.6 % 2994 46.0 %
3 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3047 20 20 479 56.9 % 2998 58.7 %
4 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3022 14 14 1009 53.7 % 2997 57.1 %
5 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3009 14 14 1009 51.4 % 2999 56.3 %
6 Komodo51-64bit : 3007 14 14 1008 51.2 % 2999 56.7 %
7 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3007 15 15 1014 51.1 % 2999 53.4 %
8 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2981 15 15 998 46.9 % 3002 52.5 %
9 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 15 15 1007 46.4 % 3003 50.3 %
10 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2921 16 16 1011 37.5 % 3010 46.9 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 3065 95 (+ 26,= 60,- 9), 58.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 10 (+ 3,= 7,- 0), 65.0 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 11 (+ 2,= 8,- 1), 54.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 9 (+ 0,= 8,- 1), 44.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 11 (+ 3,= 8,- 0), 63.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 11 (+ 5,= 5,- 1), 68.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 11 (+ 3,= 7,- 1), 59.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 11 (+ 3,= 7,- 1), 59.1 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 10 (+ 3,= 6,- 1), 60.0 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 11 (+ 4,= 4,- 3), 54.5 %
2 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 1010 (+349,=465,-196), 57.6 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 33,= 76,- 27), 52.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 132 (+ 49,= 59,- 24), 59.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 132 (+ 56,= 62,- 14), 65.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 69,= 51,- 16), 69.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 67,- 24), 57.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 51,= 56,- 27), 59.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 36,= 59,- 40), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 60 (+ 11,= 27,- 22), 40.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 1,= 8,- 2), 45.5 %
3 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42: 3047 479 (+132,=281,- 66), 56.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 58 (+ 13,= 34,- 11), 51.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 60 (+ 22,= 27,- 11), 59.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 59 (+ 15,= 41,- 3), 60.2 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 57 (+ 20,= 24,- 13), 56.1 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 58 (+ 31,= 25,- 2), 75.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 59 (+ 15,= 38,- 6), 57.6 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 60 (+ 9,= 38,- 13), 46.7 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 57 (+ 4,= 50,- 3), 50.9 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 3,= 4,- 4), 45.5 %
4 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3022 1009 (+254,=576,-179), 53.7 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 38,= 67,- 29), 53.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 135 (+ 40,= 59,- 36), 51.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 135 (+ 27,= 93,- 15), 54.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 43,= 77,- 15), 60.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 49,= 72,- 14), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 132 (+ 30,= 76,- 26), 51.5 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 76,- 37), 44.9 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 57 (+ 3,= 50,- 4), 49.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 10 (+ 1,= 6,- 3), 40.0 %
5 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3009 1009 (+235,=568,-206), 51.4 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 19,= 98,- 16), 51.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 24,= 67,- 43), 42.9 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 40,= 69,- 25), 55.6 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 37,= 68,- 30), 52.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 58,= 56,- 21), 63.7 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 24,= 89,- 23), 50.4 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 132 (+ 26,= 76,- 30), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 59 (+ 6,= 38,- 15), 42.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 1,= 7,- 3), 40.9 %
6 Komodo51-64bit : 3007 1008 (+230,=572,-206), 51.2 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 27,= 76,- 33), 47.8 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 133 (+ 36,= 70,- 27), 53.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 37,= 64,- 33), 51.5 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 57,= 58,- 21), 63.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 133 (+ 16,= 98,- 19), 48.9 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 17,= 98,- 19), 49.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 29,= 67,- 38), 46.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 58 (+ 11,= 34,- 13), 48.3 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 10 (+ 0,= 7,- 3), 35.0 %
7 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3007 1014 (+248,=541,-225), 51.1 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 19,= 98,- 17), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 27,= 56,- 51), 41.0 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 45,= 54,- 35), 53.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 133 (+ 47,= 59,- 27), 57.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 89,- 24), 49.6 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 136 (+ 37,= 76,- 23), 55.1 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 60 (+ 13,= 38,- 9), 53.3 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 1,= 7,- 3), 40.9 %
8 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2981 998 (+206,=524,-268), 46.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 70,- 36), 46.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 24,= 59,- 49), 40.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 131 (+ 38,= 61,- 32), 52.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 131 (+ 38,= 69,- 24), 55.3 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 25,= 69,- 40), 44.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 35,= 54,- 45), 46.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 93,- 27), 45.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 59 (+ 3,= 41,- 15), 39.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 9 (+ 1,= 8,- 0), 55.6 %
9 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 1007 (+214,=507,-286), 46.4 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 33,= 64,- 37), 48.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 14,= 62,- 56), 34.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 32,= 61,- 38), 47.7 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 41,= 79,- 16), 59.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 30,= 68,- 37), 47.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 77,- 43), 39.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 57 (+ 13,= 24,- 20), 43.9 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 0,= 8,- 3), 36.4 %
10 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2921 1011 (+142,=474,-395), 37.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 21,= 58,- 57), 36.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 16,= 51,- 69), 30.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 24,= 69,- 38), 44.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 16,= 79,- 41), 40.8 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 21,= 56,- 58), 36.3 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 59,- 47), 42.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 14,= 72,- 49), 37.0 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 58 (+ 2,= 25,- 31), 25.0 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 1,= 5,- 5), 31.8 %
(since I have 3 SFs, and 3 Komodos, I guess it's fair to add a Houdini, for now at least)
4320 games played
9/18/2013 9:21:42 AM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 3065 43 41 95 58.9 % 3002 63.2 %
2 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 16 16 1010 57.6 % 2994 46.0 %
3 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3047 20 20 479 56.9 % 2998 58.7 %
4 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3022 14 14 1009 53.7 % 2997 57.1 %
5 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3009 14 14 1009 51.4 % 2999 56.3 %
6 Komodo51-64bit : 3007 14 14 1008 51.2 % 2999 56.7 %
7 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3007 15 15 1014 51.1 % 2999 53.4 %
8 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2981 15 15 998 46.9 % 3002 52.5 %
9 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 15 15 1007 46.4 % 3003 50.3 %
10 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2921 16 16 1011 37.5 % 3010 46.9 %
Individual statistics:
1 Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 3065 95 (+ 26,= 60,- 9), 58.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 10 (+ 3,= 7,- 0), 65.0 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 11 (+ 2,= 8,- 1), 54.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 9 (+ 0,= 8,- 1), 44.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 11 (+ 3,= 8,- 0), 63.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 11 (+ 5,= 5,- 1), 68.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 11 (+ 3,= 7,- 1), 59.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 11 (+ 3,= 7,- 1), 59.1 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 10 (+ 3,= 6,- 1), 60.0 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 11 (+ 4,= 4,- 3), 54.5 %
2 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 1010 (+349,=465,-196), 57.6 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 33,= 76,- 27), 52.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 132 (+ 49,= 59,- 24), 59.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 132 (+ 56,= 62,- 14), 65.9 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 69,= 51,- 16), 69.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 43,= 67,- 24), 57.1 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 51,= 56,- 27), 59.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 36,= 59,- 40), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 60 (+ 11,= 27,- 22), 40.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 1,= 8,- 2), 45.5 %
3 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42: 3047 479 (+132,=281,- 66), 56.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 58 (+ 13,= 34,- 11), 51.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 60 (+ 22,= 27,- 11), 59.2 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 59 (+ 15,= 41,- 3), 60.2 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 57 (+ 20,= 24,- 13), 56.1 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 58 (+ 31,= 25,- 2), 75.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 59 (+ 15,= 38,- 6), 57.6 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 60 (+ 9,= 38,- 13), 46.7 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 57 (+ 4,= 50,- 3), 50.9 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 3,= 4,- 4), 45.5 %
4 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3022 1009 (+254,=576,-179), 53.7 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 38,= 67,- 29), 53.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 135 (+ 40,= 59,- 36), 51.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 135 (+ 27,= 93,- 15), 54.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 43,= 77,- 15), 60.4 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 49,= 72,- 14), 63.0 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 132 (+ 30,= 76,- 26), 51.5 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 76,- 37), 44.9 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 57 (+ 3,= 50,- 4), 49.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 10 (+ 1,= 6,- 3), 40.0 %
5 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3009 1009 (+235,=568,-206), 51.4 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 19,= 98,- 16), 51.1 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 24,= 67,- 43), 42.9 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 40,= 69,- 25), 55.6 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 135 (+ 37,= 68,- 30), 52.6 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 135 (+ 58,= 56,- 21), 63.7 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 24,= 89,- 23), 50.4 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 132 (+ 26,= 76,- 30), 48.5 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 59 (+ 6,= 38,- 15), 42.4 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 1,= 7,- 3), 40.9 %
6 Komodo51-64bit : 3007 1008 (+230,=572,-206), 51.2 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 27,= 76,- 33), 47.8 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 133 (+ 36,= 70,- 27), 53.4 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 134 (+ 37,= 64,- 33), 51.5 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 57,= 58,- 21), 63.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 133 (+ 16,= 98,- 19), 48.9 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 17,= 98,- 19), 49.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 134 (+ 29,= 67,- 38), 46.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 58 (+ 11,= 34,- 13), 48.3 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 10 (+ 0,= 7,- 3), 35.0 %
7 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3007 1014 (+248,=541,-225), 51.1 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 19,= 98,- 17), 50.7 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 134 (+ 27,= 56,- 51), 41.0 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 134 (+ 45,= 54,- 35), 53.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 133 (+ 47,= 59,- 27), 57.5 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 136 (+ 23,= 89,- 24), 49.6 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 136 (+ 37,= 76,- 23), 55.1 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 60 (+ 13,= 38,- 9), 53.3 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 1,= 7,- 3), 40.9 %
8 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2981 998 (+206,=524,-268), 46.9 %
Komodo51-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 70,- 36), 46.6 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 24,= 59,- 49), 40.5 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 131 (+ 38,= 61,- 32), 52.3 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 131 (+ 38,= 69,- 24), 55.3 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 134 (+ 25,= 69,- 40), 44.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 134 (+ 35,= 54,- 45), 46.3 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 93,- 27), 45.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 59 (+ 3,= 41,- 15), 39.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 9 (+ 1,= 8,- 0), 55.6 %
9 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2978 1007 (+214,=507,-286), 46.4 %
Komodo51-64bit : 134 (+ 33,= 64,- 37), 48.5 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 132 (+ 14,= 62,- 56), 34.1 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 32,= 61,- 38), 47.7 %
Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 136 (+ 41,= 79,- 16), 59.2 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 30,= 68,- 37), 47.4 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 136 (+ 36,= 64,- 36), 50.0 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 15,= 77,- 43), 39.6 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 57 (+ 13,= 24,- 20), 43.9 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 0,= 8,- 3), 36.4 %
10 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2921 1011 (+142,=474,-395), 37.5 %
Komodo51-64bit : 136 (+ 21,= 58,- 57), 36.8 %
Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 136 (+ 16,= 51,- 69), 30.5 %
Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 131 (+ 24,= 69,- 38), 44.7 %
Critter_1.6a_64bit : 136 (+ 16,= 79,- 41), 40.8 %
Komodo51r1-64bit : 135 (+ 21,= 56,- 58), 36.3 %
Komodo51r2-64bit : 133 (+ 27,= 59,- 47), 42.5 %
Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 135 (+ 14,= 72,- 49), 37.0 %
Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 58 (+ 2,= 25,- 31), 25.0 %
Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 11 (+ 1,= 5,- 5), 31.8 %
-
RJN
- Posts: 303
- Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 5:18 am
- Location: Orion Spiral Arm
Re: Komodo: My humble tournament
A quick update:
4380 games played
9/19/2013 1:01:24 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 3047 36 36 155 56.5 % 3002 56.1 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3047 20 20 485 57.0 % 2998 58.4 %
3 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 16 16 1017 57.6 % 2994 46.1 %
4 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3023 14 14 1016 53.8 % 2996 57.1 %
5 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3008 14 14 1016 51.3 % 2999 56.4 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 15 15 1021 51.3 % 2999 53.2 %
7 Komodo51-64bit : 3006 14 14 1014 51.0 % 2999 56.6 %
8 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2980 15 15 1005 46.8 % 3003 52.4 %
9 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2977 15 15 1014 46.4 % 3003 50.4 %
10 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2921 16 16 1017 37.4 % 3010 46.7 %
4380 games played
9/19/2013 1:01:24 PM :
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Houdini_3_PRO-Contempt-0 : 3047 36 36 155 56.5 % 3002 56.1 %
2 Stockfish_13090815_x64_sse42 : 3047 20 20 485 57.0 % 2998 58.4 %
3 Houdini_3_PRO-NONE : 3047 16 16 1017 57.6 % 2994 46.1 %
4 Stockfish_4_64bit_sse42 : 3023 14 14 1016 53.8 % 2996 57.1 %
5 Komodo51r1-64bit : 3008 14 14 1016 51.3 % 2999 56.4 %
6 Komodo51r2-64bit : 3008 15 15 1021 51.3 % 2999 53.2 %
7 Komodo51-64bit : 3006 14 14 1014 51.0 % 2999 56.6 %
8 Stockfish-3-64-pop-ja : 2980 15 15 1005 46.8 % 3003 52.4 %
9 Critter_1.6a_64bit : 2977 15 15 1014 46.4 % 3003 50.4 %
10 Deep Rybka 4.1 SSE42 x64 : 2921 16 16 1017 37.4 % 3010 46.7 %