Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.
Moderator: Ras
Vinvin
Posts: 5312Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Sun May 12, 2013 9:14 pm
Games from CEGT, CCRL downloaded today.
Games from WBEC, SWCR, Chess War, Mega FREEWARE (this 4 projects stopped long ago).
Names was corrected as suggested in the previous thread (but not all yet).
No games from CountryChess because the names mixed 32 and 64-bit but good news, Geert write he will correct this soon !
Generated with Bayeselo and Ordo 0.6.
- If there's no "n-CPU" info, it's 1 CPU.
- If there's no "n-bit" info, it's 32 bit.
Code: Select all
Total games 1'471'841
White wins 543'235
Draws 517'941
Black wins 410'665
No result 0
Unique head to head 14.86%
Reference rating 2810.0 (set to "Spike 1.2")
Now enough games for some top engines :
Code: Select all
5 Stockfish 3.0 64-bit 4CPU 3275.97 26.90 26.90
14 Houdini 3.0 Tactical 64-bit 3250.80 30.96 30.96
26 Komodo CCT 64-bit 3221.32 17.46 17.46
Bayeselo :
http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 130512.txt
Ordo 0.6 :
http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 130512.txt
Vinvin
Posts: 5312Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Sun May 12, 2013 9:31 pm
Top 20 1-CPU and 4-CPU
1-CPU
Code: Select all
Rnk Name Elo +/- Games Score Oppo. Draws
9 Houdini 3.0 64-bit 3255.17 10.83 2735 66.12% 3147.63 42.89%
14 Houdini 3.0 Tactical 64-bit 3250.80 30.96 311 65.11% 3157.56 49.20%
26 Komodo CCT 64-bit 3221.32 17.46 1000 61.80% 3147.00 46.20%
27 Houdini 3.0 3221.11 19.60 838 70.35% 3090.51 44.03%
28 Houdini 2.0 64-bit 3219.16 7.89 5681 69.72% 3074.19 36.26%
29 Houdini 1.5 64-bit 3219.16 7.84 5817 70.29% 3067.86 36.19%
40 Komodo 5 64-bit 3201.35 8.15 4509 58.68% 3145.24 49.15%
54 Rybka 4 64-bit Exp. 42 3189.99 16.78 1450 74.93% 2991.05 30.14%
55 Houdini 2.0 3186.07 13.06 2011 70.86% 3043.10 38.99%
56 Critter 1.6a 64-bit 3185.80 15.79 1148 58.23% 3134.08 54.79%
57 Komodo 4 64-bit 3185.77 6.73 7220 62.47% 3094.91 42.84%
59 Rybka 4.1 64-bit Exp. 79TD v.1 3185.58 19.18 1200 78.50% 2958.33 25.67%
61 Equinox 1.90 64-bit 3184.58 29.91 300 47.67% 3198.02 60.00%
62 Houdini 1.5 3183.84 8.55 4660 67.80% 3057.57 38.48%
63 Critter 1.4 64-bit 3183.13 8.37 4777 66.82% 3059.90 42.58%
66 Stockfish 3.0 64-bit 3181.00 16.77 1000 51.95% 3169.13 54.50%
67 IvanHoe 999946f 64-bit 3179.60 16.06 1480 73.01% 3001.70 34.39%
69 Critter 1.2 64-bit 3177.11 8.50 4537 63.14% 3078.61 43.31%
70 IvanHoe B46fB 64-bit 3176.73 16.57 1400 74.29% 2991.25 35.00%
72 Komodo 3 64-bit 3175.12 8.09 5069 61.92% 3086.74 40.82%
4-CPU
Code: Select all
Rnk Name Elo +/- Games Score Oppo. Draws
1 Houdini 3.0 64-bit 4CPU 3346.97 9.50 4164 76.45% 3155.40 34.99%
3 Houdini 2.0 64-bit 4CPU 3297.44 9.80 3840 72.86% 3125.73 35.78%
4 Houdini 1.5 64-bit 4CPU 3290.21 9.74 3648 70.34% 3145.65 38.10%
5 Stockfish 3.0 64-bit 4CPU 3275.97 26.90 411 59.85% 3210.84 50.61%
6 Critter 1.6 64-bit 4CPU 3261.69 17.97 873 57.96% 3212.17 56.36%
7 Equinox 1.70 64-bit 4CPU 3260.80 13.36 1914 71.53% 3111.40 42.11%
10 Critter 1.2 64-bit 4CPU 3253.03 8.78 4546 70.27% 3103.76 40.45%
11 Stockfish 2.3 64-bit 4CPU 3252.30 17.70 898 55.79% 3217.87 55.46%
12 Critter 1.6a 64-bit 4CPU 3251.31 13.60 1519 59.02% 3196.57 58.13%
16 Rybka 4.1 64-bit 4CPU 3244.98 9.42 3306 58.14% 3193.92 51.97%
17 Critter 1.4 64-bit 4CPU 3243.12 12.78 1788 58.67% 3188.82 52.80%
18 Rybka 4 64-bit 4CPU 3240.95 7.53 6116 69.12% 3100.56 40.50%
19 Stockfish 2.2.2 64-bit 4CPU 3239.80 12.31 1921 59.03% 3184.69 52.89%
20 Stockfish 2.3.1 64-bit 4CPU 3236.20 18.45 851 55.23% 3204.08 52.64%
22 Bouquet 1.5 64-bit 4CPU 3223.39 27.55 352 48.15% 3234.87 62.22%
24 Stockfish 2.1.1 64-bit 4CPU 3222.36 14.76 1399 57.83% 3172.10 46.89%
30 Stockfish 3 64-bit 4CPU 3214.72 72.98 51 51.96% 3198.34 56.86%
31 Stockfish 2.2.1 64-bit 4CPU 3213.47 28.62 350 53.86% 3188.81 53.43%
32 Stockfish 2.0.1 64-bit 4CPU 3213.42 8.42 5231 70.77% 3053.95 37.16%
37 IvanHoe 9.46h 64-bit 4CPU 3202.05 14.70 1296 54.24% 3176.12 58.49%
lkaufman
Posts: 6284Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 amLocation: Maryland USAFull name: Larry Kaufman
Post by lkaufman Sun May 12, 2013 10:02 pm
I note that although Komodo CCT is 34 elo behind Houdini 3 (both 1 cpu) on your Bayeselo list, it is a mere 3 elo points behind on the Ordo list. This is a huge disparity, I wonder what is the cause? It's hard to say which method is really superior, but we switched to Ordo some time ago in our internal testing, as it it based on the rating systems actually used in the chess world, unlike Bayeselo.
Vinvin
Posts: 5312Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Sun May 12, 2013 10:51 pm
lkaufman wrote: I note that although Komodo CCT is 34 elo behind Houdini 3 (both 1 cpu) on your Bayeselo list, it is a mere 3 elo points behind on the Ordo list. This is a huge disparity, I wonder what is the cause? It's hard to say which method is really superior, but we switched to Ordo some time ago in our internal testing, as it it based on the rating systems actually used in the chess world, unlike Bayeselo.
May be you mismatch "Houdini 3.0 64-bit" and "Houdini 3.0 (32-bit)" ?
Gusev
Posts: 1476Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2013 2:51 pm
Post by Gusev Sun May 12, 2013 11:04 pm
Vinvin wrote: Top 20 1-CPU and 4-CPU
1-CPU
Code: Select all
Rnk Name Elo +/- Games Score Oppo. Draws
9 Houdini 3.0 64-bit 3255.17 10.83 2735 66.12% 3147.63 42.89%
14 Houdini 3.0 Tactical 64-bit 3250.80 30.96 311 65.11% 3157.56 49.20%
26 Komodo CCT 64-bit 3221.32 17.46 1000 61.80% 3147.00 46.20%
27 Houdini 3.0 3221.11 19.60 838 70.35% 3090.51 44.03%
28 Houdini 2.0 64-bit 3219.16 7.89 5681 69.72% 3074.19 36.26%
29 Houdini 1.5 64-bit 3219.16 7.84 5817 70.29% 3067.86 36.19%
40 Komodo 5 64-bit 3201.35 8.15 4509 58.68% 3145.24 49.15%
54 Rybka 4 64-bit Exp. 42 3189.99 16.78 1450 74.93% 2991.05 30.14%
55 Houdini 2.0 3186.07 13.06 2011 70.86% 3043.10 38.99%
56 Critter 1.6a 64-bit 3185.80 15.79 1148 58.23% 3134.08 54.79%
57 Komodo 4 64-bit 3185.77 6.73 7220 62.47% 3094.91 42.84%
59 Rybka 4.1 64-bit Exp. 79TD v.1 3185.58 19.18 1200 78.50% 2958.33 25.67%
61 Equinox 1.90 64-bit 3184.58 29.91 300 47.67% 3198.02 60.00%
62 Houdini 1.5 3183.84 8.55 4660 67.80% 3057.57 38.48%
63 Critter 1.4 64-bit 3183.13 8.37 4777 66.82% 3059.90 42.58%
66 Stockfish 3.0 64-bit 3181.00 16.77 1000 51.95% 3169.13 54.50%
67 IvanHoe 999946f 64-bit 3179.60 16.06 1480 73.01% 3001.70 34.39%
69 Critter 1.2 64-bit 3177.11 8.50 4537 63.14% 3078.61 43.31%
70 IvanHoe B46fB 64-bit 3176.73 16.57 1400 74.29% 2991.25 35.00%
72 Komodo 3 64-bit 3175.12 8.09 5069 61.92% 3086.74 40.82%
4-CPU
Code: Select all
Rnk Name Elo +/- Games Score Oppo. Draws
1 Houdini 3.0 64-bit 4CPU 3346.97 9.50 4164 76.45% 3155.40 34.99%
3 Houdini 2.0 64-bit 4CPU 3297.44 9.80 3840 72.86% 3125.73 35.78%
4 Houdini 1.5 64-bit 4CPU 3290.21 9.74 3648 70.34% 3145.65 38.10%
5 Stockfish 3.0 64-bit 4CPU 3275.97 26.90 411 59.85% 3210.84 50.61%
6 Critter 1.6 64-bit 4CPU 3261.69 17.97 873 57.96% 3212.17 56.36%
7 Equinox 1.70 64-bit 4CPU 3260.80 13.36 1914 71.53% 3111.40 42.11%
10 Critter 1.2 64-bit 4CPU 3253.03 8.78 4546 70.27% 3103.76 40.45%
11 Stockfish 2.3 64-bit 4CPU 3252.30 17.70 898 55.79% 3217.87 55.46%
12 Critter 1.6a 64-bit 4CPU 3251.31 13.60 1519 59.02% 3196.57 58.13%
16 Rybka 4.1 64-bit 4CPU 3244.98 9.42 3306 58.14% 3193.92 51.97%
17 Critter 1.4 64-bit 4CPU 3243.12 12.78 1788 58.67% 3188.82 52.80%
18 Rybka 4 64-bit 4CPU 3240.95 7.53 6116 69.12% 3100.56 40.50%
19 Stockfish 2.2.2 64-bit 4CPU 3239.80 12.31 1921 59.03% 3184.69 52.89%
20 Stockfish 2.3.1 64-bit 4CPU 3236.20 18.45 851 55.23% 3204.08 52.64%
22 Bouquet 1.5 64-bit 4CPU 3223.39 27.55 352 48.15% 3234.87 62.22%
24 Stockfish 2.1.1 64-bit 4CPU 3222.36 14.76 1399 57.83% 3172.10 46.89%
30 Stockfish 3 64-bit 4CPU 3214.72 72.98 51 51.96% 3198.34 56.86%
31 Stockfish 2.2.1 64-bit 4CPU 3213.47 28.62 350 53.86% 3188.81 53.43%
32 Stockfish 2.0.1 64-bit 4CPU 3213.42 8.42 5231 70.77% 3053.95 37.16%
37 IvanHoe 9.46h 64-bit 4CPU 3202.05 14.70 1296 54.24% 3176.12 58.49%
Congratulations to the Stockfish team on passing Critter on 4CPU!
lkaufman
Posts: 6284Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 amLocation: Maryland USAFull name: Larry Kaufman
Post by lkaufman Mon May 13, 2013 12:00 am
Vinvin wrote: lkaufman wrote: I note that although Komodo CCT is 34 elo behind Houdini 3 (both 1 cpu) on your Bayeselo list, it is a mere 3 elo points behind on the Ordo list. This is a huge disparity, I wonder what is the cause? It's hard to say which method is really superior, but we switched to Ordo some time ago in our internal testing, as it it based on the rating systems actually used in the chess world, unlike Bayeselo.
May be you mismatch "Houdini 3.0 64-bit" and "Houdini 3.0 (32-bit)" ?
Oh, I see; if you don't specify, it means 32 bit. I forget that 32 bit even exists anymore. So there is no big discrepancy, my bad!
Mark Mason_2
Posts: 13Joined: Sat May 19, 2012 12:56 pmLocation: United Kingdom
Post by Mark Mason_2 Mon May 13, 2013 9:08 am
Thank you Vincent. Very useful list as always.
mloftus955
Posts: 98Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2010 5:36 pmLocation: Westfield, INFull name: mark loftus
Post by mloftus955 Mon May 13, 2013 7:27 pm
I never heard of Mega Freeware, were they testing programs a long time? It seems that their site no longer exists.
Vinvin
Posts: 5312Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Mon May 13, 2013 10:45 pm
mloftus955 wrote: I never heard of Mega Freeware, were they testing programs a long time? It seems that their site no longer exists.
It's a big tournament run by George Speight :
http://www.talkchess.com/forum/viewtopi ... =&start=60
Vinvin
Posts: 5312Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 amFull name: Vincent Lejeune
Post by Vinvin Wed May 15, 2013 12:07 pm
I manually edited the list and so made some mistake, here's the corrected top lists :
Top 100 1-CPU
Code: Select all
Rnk Name Elo +/- Games Score Oppo. Draws
9 Houdini 3.0 64-bit 3255.17 10.83 2735 66.12% 3147.63 42.89%
14 Houdini 3.0 Tactical 64-bit 3250.80 30.96 311 65.11% 3157.56 49.20%
26 Komodo CCT 64-bit 3221.32 17.46 1000 61.80% 3147.00 46.20%
27 Houdini 3.0 3221.11 19.60 838 70.35% 3090.51 44.03%
28 Houdini 2.0 64-bit 3219.16 7.89 5681 69.72% 3074.19 36.26%
29 Houdini 1.5 64-bit 3219.16 7.84 5817 70.29% 3067.86 36.19%
40 Komodo 5 64-bit 3201.35 8.15 4509 58.68% 3145.24 49.15%
51 Stockfish 3 64-bit 3192.46 32.04 281 51.60% 3183.42 49.82%
52 Strelka 5.5 64-bit 3191.91 12.76 1750 57.03% 3148.27 55.77%
53 Critter 1.6 64-bit 3191.75 10.83 2671 62.35% 3108.67 45.86%
54 Rybka 4 64-bit Exp. 42 3189.99 16.78 1450 74.93% 2991.05 30.14%
55 Houdini 2.0 3186.07 13.06 2011 70.86% 3043.10 38.99%
56 Critter 1.6a 64-bit 3185.80 15.79 1148 58.23% 3134.08 54.79%
57 Komodo 4 64-bit 3185.77 6.73 7220 62.47% 3094.91 42.84%
59 Rybka 4.1 64-bit Exp. 79TD v.1 3185.58 19.18 1200 78.50% 2958.33 25.67%
61 Equinox 1.90 64-bit 3184.58 29.91 300 47.67% 3198.02 60.00%
62 Houdini 1.5 3183.84 8.55 4660 67.80% 3057.57 38.48%
63 Critter 1.4 64-bit 3183.13 8.37 4777 66.82% 3059.90 42.58%
66 Stockfish 3.0 64-bit 3181.00 16.77 1000 51.95% 3169.13 54.50%
67 IvanHoe 999946f 64-bit 3179.60 16.06 1480 73.01% 3001.70 34.39%
69 Critter 1.2 64-bit 3177.11 8.50 4537 63.14% 3078.61 43.31%
70 IvanHoe B46fB 64-bit 3176.73 16.57 1400 74.29% 2991.25 35.00%
72 Komodo 3 64-bit 3175.12 8.09 5069 61.92% 3086.74 40.82%
75 Strelka 5.5 3174.02 15.97 1200 66.00% 3072.26 48.83%
77 Stockfish 2.1.1 64-bit PHQ 3171.06 15.68 1530 71.90% 3001.84 35.95%
78 Rybka 4 Exp.61 64-bit 3170.16 11.47 2685 64.12% 3063.09 34.53%
79 Strelka 5.1 3168.75 16.21 1154 65.55% 3068.59 49.83%
80 Rybka 4.1 64-bit 3168.53 6.36 7720 60.84% 3092.19 46.30%
81 Houdini 1.03a 64-bit 3165.69 20.74 1000 79.55% 2933.30 29.50%
82 Stockfish 2.3.1 64-bit 3164.77 11.31 2250 54.93% 3134.50 52.36%
83 Equinox 1.70 64-bit 3164.40 15.37 1190 53.57% 3141.95 55.21%
85 Fire 2.2 xTreme 64-bit 3162.54 14.34 1840 72.53% 2987.91 36.58%
86 IvanHoe B47cB 64-bit 3162.08 14.14 1800 70.67% 3006.30 38.67%
87 Stockfish 2.2.2 64-bit 3161.39 10.35 2879 60.58% 3091.72 47.52%
90 Critter 1.4 3160.94 10.75 2656 63.20% 3074.09 48.16%
91 Rybka 4 64-bit 3159.60 9.50 3939 70.32% 3009.68 38.13%
92 Sting SF 3 64-bit 3157.90 74.19 51 45.10% 3183.57 50.98%
93 Fire 1.5 xTreme 64-bit 3157.65 16.37 1400 72.89% 2984.10 35.79%
94 Stockfish 2.2 64-bit 3157.02 37.93 202 57.92% 3108.37 53.47%
95 Stockfish 2.2.1 64-bit 3155.03 21.19 663 53.54% 3130.01 46.76%
96 RobboLito 0.10 64-bit 3154.81 54.75 90 47.78% 3166.24 57.78%
97 IvanHoe B49jA 64-bit 3154.64 18.41 1160 75.82% 2961.10 33.53%
98 Critter 1.6a 3153.08 16.03 1123 62.38% 3075.99 54.94%
99 IvanHoe 999946hm 64-bit 3152.54 56.01 90 47.78% 3166.50 51.11%
100 Stockfish 2.3 64-bit 3152.43 18.05 897 52.51% 3136.54 50.39%
102 Critter 1.6 3151.31 19.82 765 65.62% 3052.00 52.03%
103 IvanHoe 9.46h 64-bit 3150.73 14.76 1278 54.62% 3121.53 58.06%
104 Equinox 1.65 64-bit 3150.24 15.50 1239 59.08% 3091.25 49.72%
107 Bouquet 1.5 64-bit 3149.71 22.29 561 51.60% 3139.33 57.58%
108 Critter 1.2 3149.65 10.20 3285 69.62% 3012.74 40.06%
112 Stockfish 2.1.1 64-bit 3146.27 8.31 4665 60.60% 3067.90 43.64%
113 Komodo 2.03 64-bit 3143.96 9.95 3392 61.38% 3057.82 38.97%
114 RobboLito 0.09 64-bit 3143.45 15.25 1640 71.46% 2974.34 35.73%
117 Vitruvius 1.11C 64-bit 3142.06 18.41 846 52.60% 3126.16 52.25%
118 RobboLito 0.21Q 64-bit 3141.54 20.50 663 51.73% 3129.55 56.11%
119 Stockfish 2.2.2 3141.37 10.68 2679 61.29% 3067.29 47.18%
122 IvanHoe B52aC 64-bit 3140.35 19.63 1000 76.40% 2948.83 33.80%
125 DeepSaros 3.3b 64-bit 3136.85 28.15 346 47.98% 3148.99 58.38%
126 Bouquet 1.6 64-bit 3135.22 19.96 692 50.51% 3131.41 58.24%
127 Gull II 64-bit 3133.95 14.83 1322 52.91% 3113.04 51.21%
128 Komodo 2.01 64-bit 3133.71 12.97 1799 52.61% 3115.43 44.97%
129 DeepSaros 3.0 64-bit 3133.46 26.03 420 48.33% 3140.27 53.81%
131 Komodo 5 3132.04 16.06 1126 58.39% 3080.05 52.13%
132 Stockfish 2.0.1 64-bit 3131.50 10.34 2959 61.30% 3052.95 44.74%
137 Fire 1.31 64-bit 3125.61 18.92 1040 73.32% 2955.32 36.63%
139 Gull II b2 64-bit 3125.14 13.79 1503 49.70% 3124.82 53.23%
140 Fire 2.2 xTreme 3124.84 16.70 1240 70.32% 2980.75 40.48%
141 Stockfish 2.3.1 3124.47 16.37 1091 57.10% 3080.44 50.60%
142 Critter 1.01 64-bit 3124.07 13.28 1895 62.85% 3029.55 40.53%
143 Rybka 3 64-bit 3123.57 7.34 6373 67.53% 2998.31 38.51%
144 Stockfish 1.9.1 64-bit 3121.94 9.92 3324 62.85% 3030.67 41.16%
146 Critter 1.0 64-bit 3118.68 13.80 1533 53.72% 3095.32 50.03%
147 Rybka 4.1 3117.29 9.73 3343 62.67% 3029.92 44.63%
148 Stockfish 1.8 64-bit 3117.17 11.15 2773 68.81% 2982.14 38.80%
149 Stockfish 2.1.1 3116.22 11.32 2602 66.89% 2999.90 41.39%
150 Vitruvius 1.11C 3116.19 14.75 1309 57.26% 3070.80 55.39%
151 BlackMamba 1.4 64-bit 3115.54 36.75 207 46.62% 3136.96 54.59%
152 Equinox 1.60 64-bit 3115.48 16.79 1034 51.16% 3107.89 50.29%
154 Komodo 4 3114.98 16.26 1147 59.07% 3055.85 47.69%
156 IvanHoe B47cB 3114.48 16.62 1240 68.67% 2981.08 40.08%
158 Critter 1.0 3113.37 20.34 751 60.45% 3044.65 42.88%
159 Rybka 4 3113.00 8.33 4732 62.95% 3022.51 43.03%
161 Equinox 1.50 64-bit 3112.05 19.80 750 50.33% 3109.22 48.67%
162 Sting SF 2 64-bit 3111.78 17.46 927 50.22% 3109.20 54.69%
164 Komodo 3 3110.65 9.07 3996 61.82% 3026.08 40.42%
165 IvanHoe 9.46h 3110.50 13.63 1550 56.94% 3065.50 54.13%
167 Critter 1.01 3108.82 13.03 2077 69.79% 2965.55 36.74%
168 Stockfish 2.0.1 3108.50 10.81 2912 68.20% 2981.40 40.80%
169 DeepSaros 2.3j 3106.99 14.74 1299 53.58% 3083.49 55.58%
171 Stockfish 1.7.1 64-bit 3104.47 10.48 3023 66.24% 2991.83 40.85%
172 Bouquet 1.6 3103.39 17.44 907 52.81% 3086.60 58.21%
173 Komodo 4.402 64-bit 3101.62 156.17 14 67.86% 2978.84 21.43%
174 Critter 0.90 64-bit 3101.21 10.43 2989 61.14% 3023.45 41.39%
175 Rybka 3 Dynamic 64-bit 3100.26 32.85 332 74.85% 2929.79 36.45%
176 RobboLito 0.21Q 3099.90 18.00 848 52.77% 3082.77 58.84%
179 Rybka 3 Human 64-bit 3099.16 28.52 432 73.84% 2937.04 37.04%
180 Bouquet 1.5 3096.42 17.19 958 51.67% 3085.98 54.70%
181 Stockfish 1.9.1 3095.15 13.09 2044 72.87% 2937.10 38.89%
186 Rick48-v4 3091.15 62.14 88 70.45% 2946.86 43.18%
187 Komodo 2.03 3090.41 10.72 2924 63.12% 2998.39 37.18%
Top 100 4-CPU
Code: Select all
Rnk Name Elo +/- Games Score Oppo. Draws
1 Houdini 3.0 64-bit 4CPU 3346.97 9.50 4164 76.45% 3155.40 34.99%
3 Houdini 2.0 64-bit 4CPU 3297.44 9.80 3840 72.86% 3125.73 35.78%
4 Houdini 1.5 64-bit 4CPU 3290.21 9.74 3648 70.34% 3145.65 38.10%
5 Stockfish 3.0 64-bit 4CPU 3275.97 26.90 411 59.85% 3210.84 50.61%
6 Critter 1.6 64-bit 4CPU 3261.69 17.97 873 57.96% 3212.17 56.36%
7 Equinox 1.70 64-bit 4CPU 3260.80 13.36 1914 71.53% 3111.40 42.11%
10 Critter 1.2 64-bit 4CPU 3253.03 8.78 4546 70.27% 3103.76 40.45%
11 Stockfish 2.3 64-bit 4CPU 3252.30 17.70 898 55.79% 3217.87 55.46%
12 Critter 1.6a 64-bit 4CPU 3251.31 13.60 1519 59.02% 3196.57 58.13%
16 Rybka 4.1 64-bit 4CPU 3244.98 9.42 3306 58.14% 3193.92 51.97%
17 Critter 1.4 64-bit 4CPU 3243.12 12.78 1788 58.67% 3188.82 52.80%
18 Rybka 4 64-bit 4CPU 3240.95 7.53 6116 69.12% 3100.56 40.50%
19 Stockfish 2.2.2 64-bit 4CPU 3239.80 12.31 1921 59.03% 3184.69 52.89%
20 Stockfish 2.3.1 64-bit 4CPU 3236.20 18.45 851 55.23% 3204.08 52.64%
22 Bouquet 1.5 64-bit 4CPU 3223.39 27.55 352 48.15% 3234.87 62.22%
24 Stockfish 2.1.1 64-bit 4CPU 3222.36 14.76 1399 57.83% 3172.10 46.89%
30 Stockfish 3 64-bit 4CPU 3214.72 72.98 51 51.96% 3198.34 56.86%
31 Stockfish 2.2.1 64-bit 4CPU 3213.47 28.62 350 53.86% 3188.81 53.43%
32 Stockfish 2.0.1 64-bit 4CPU 3213.42 8.42 5231 70.77% 3053.95 37.16%
37 IvanHoe 9.46h 64-bit 4CPU 3202.05 14.70 1296 54.24% 3176.12 58.49%
39 Vitruvius 1.11C 64-bit 4CPU 3201.49 16.68 984 53.66% 3180.38 60.57%
41 Stockfish 1.9.1 64-bit 4CPU 3200.34 9.33 4094 69.54% 3058.09 37.96%
42 Sting SF 2 64-bit 4CPU 3198.76 28.41 345 50.14% 3199.79 57.97%
44 Equinox 1.65 64-bit 4CPU 3198.00 11.97 2122 59.19% 3134.65 49.58%
45 Rybka 3 64-bit 4CPU 3197.71 6.72 7378 64.94% 3091.55 41.24%
46 Bouquet 1.6 64-bit 4CPU 3197.13 23.33 497 50.20% 3195.52 60.97%
47 Stockfish 1.8 64-bit 4CPU 3195.92 9.81 3485 66.11% 3082.13 41.55%
48 RobboLito 0.21Q 64-bit 4CPU 3194.05 31.92 263 53.61% 3173.60 62.36%
49 Equinox 1.50 64-bit 4CPU 3193.56 12.30 2020 56.61% 3149.36 46.19%
50 Rybka 3 Human 64-bit 4CPU 3192.80 38.19 213 63.85% 3099.74 45.07%
64 Critter 1.0 64-bit 4CPU 3182.91 15.09 1302 55.30% 3148.30 48.54%
65 Stockfish 1.7.1 64-bit 4CPU 3182.88 9.77 3380 64.63% 3081.99 44.41%
71 Critter 0.90 64-bit 4CPU 3175.20 11.57 2357 57.47% 3121.60 44.51%
73 Critter 1.01 64-bit 4CPU 3174.70 34.79 229 49.78% 3175.20 58.52%
84 Equinox 1.40 64-bit 4CPU 3163.38 18.74 874 48.05% 3176.67 43.94%
101 Naum 4.2 64-bit 4CPU 3152.21 6.59 6895 47.86% 3164.25 48.01%
106 Chiron 1.1a 64-bit 4CPU 3149.73 24.65 482 43.98% 3187.48 50.62%
110 Hiarcs 14 4CPU 3146.58 12.48 1878 46.14% 3170.40 49.57%
115 Protector 1.5.0 64-bit 4CPU 3143.19 19.14 772 48.38% 3152.83 52.46%
116 Chiron 1.5 64-bit 4CPU 3142.30 17.22 984 45.88% 3167.73 49.29%
120 Equinox 1.35 64-bit 4CPU 3140.73 11.32 2404 54.55% 3110.42 44.13%
121 Chiron 1.1 64-bit 4CPU 3140.66 17.68 953 48.27% 3151.12 46.17%
124 Stockfish 1.6 64-bit 4CPU 3136.94 10.58 2914 64.82% 3036.67 41.73%
130 Naum 4.1 64-bit 4CPU 3132.79 28.49 376 61.04% 3061.50 45.48%
133 Gull R375 64-bit 4CPU 3130.78 24.29 473 39.75% 3190.23 58.35%
138 Deep Fritz 13 4CPU 3125.16 14.44 1398 43.13% 3165.89 50.64%
145 Critter 0.80 64-bit 4CPU 3120.36 13.51 1611 48.63% 3128.59 49.35%
153 Junior 13.3 64-bit 4CPU 3115.11 21.31 681 40.01% 3181.16 44.49%
155 Naum 4 64-bit 4CPU 3114.97 9.66 3286 55.11% 3081.63 46.26%
163 Stockfish 1.6.3 64-bit 4CPU 3110.95 23.99 542 60.89% 3039.92 43.54%
170 Junior 13 64-bit 4CPU 3105.24 10.26 2982 47.60% 3119.73 43.96%
178 Hannibal 1.3 64-bit 4CPU 3099.46 10.86 2651 44.29% 3134.70 43.38%
182 Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit 4CPU 3094.24 7.51 5752 58.28% 3039.04 43.32%
183 Spike 1.4 4CPU 3093.40 9.17 3746 39.10% 3164.79 43.01%
185 Shredder 12 4CPU 3092.78 6.20 8159 48.79% 3100.35 43.65%
190 Junior 12.5 4CPU 3085.54 14.60 1444 45.36% 3115.51 43.91%
194 Critter 0.70 64-bit 4CPU 3083.27 18.14 906 44.15% 3119.85 47.68%
197 Protector 1.4.0 64-bit 4CPU 3081.17 13.77 1638 43.32% 3124.26 42.31%
200 Deep Fritz 12 4CPU 3078.51 9.85 3178 44.51% 3112.51 45.59%
204 Hiarcs 13.2 4CPU 3073.24 11.20 2478 40.54% 3134.65 44.03%
221 Spark 1.0 64-bit 4CPU 3054.16 11.03 2530 41.28% 3110.59 44.39%
222 Rybka 2.1 64-bit 4CPU 3052.86 37.24 258 73.06% 2890.16 36.82%
223 Deep Fritz 11 4CPU 3052.29 10.46 2805 52.16% 3037.35 45.78%
226 Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit 4CPU 3047.79 20.01 815 66.07% 2938.70 41.10%
227 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit 4CPU 3047.01 6.09 8484 44.39% 3084.64 44.46%
232 Stockfish 1.5.1 64-bit 4CPU 3044.89 16.86 1045 51.63% 3034.51 45.26%
235 Hiarcs 13.1 4CPU 3044.10 14.95 1418 39.70% 3113.81 41.33%
242 Junior 12 4CPU 3038.52 14.90 1410 45.21% 3069.97 39.79%
243 Spark 0.4 64-bit 4CPU 3035.79 13.71 1625 42.22% 3086.09 46.03%
246 Protector 1.3.6 64-bit 4CPU 3033.23 17.82 973 46.71% 3053.78 42.03%
251 Shredder WM Edition Bonn 4CPU 3031.27 12.66 1999 48.45% 3039.79 39.17%
260 Naum 3 64-bit 4CPU 3026.81 11.37 2379 58.01% 2972.67 44.64%
261 Naum 3.1 64-bit 4CPU 3026.52 8.44 4577 43.81% 3071.97 39.98%
263 Zappa Mexico 64-bit 4CPU 3026.30 8.74 4210 50.13% 3027.81 42.83%
266 Stockfish 1.4 64-bit 4CPU 3024.99 9.61 3403 56.42% 2982.23 41.79%
268 Crafty 23.5 64-bit 4CPU 3024.01 71.28 68 63.24% 2934.16 32.35%
279 Fruit 090705 64-bit 4CPU 3013.91 18.46 916 42.30% 3063.61 41.38%
284 Zap!Chess Zanzibar 64-bit 4CPU 3010.88 13.49 1685 56.38% 2970.89 46.29%
286 Spark 0.3 64-bit 4CPU 3007.46 14.37 1441 47.15% 3024.82 46.43%
287 Onno 1.2.70 64-bit 4CPU 3007.43 15.76 1193 46.86% 3027.32 46.94%
294 Toga II 3.0 4CPU 3004.78 29.56 342 50.00% 3005.90 44.44%
295 Thinker 5.4d Inert 64-bit 4CPU 3003.77 10.98 2544 50.63% 2998.06 43.16%
302 Junior 11.1a 4CPU 3000.19 18.61 892 48.71% 3009.79 40.47%
306 Thinker 5.4c Inert 64-bit 4CPU 2999.04 14.50 1552 49.07% 3005.07 38.98%
308 Junior 11.2 4CPU 2997.55 17.04 1099 42.58% 3046.37 37.85%
315 Shredder 11 4CPU 2991.59 7.04 6517 45.72% 3021.71 39.82%
316 Hiarcs 12.1 4CPU 2991.19 8.53 4425 41.02% 3053.42 40.86%
317 Critter 0.60 64-bit 4CPU 2991.14 23.22 552 45.74% 3016.75 45.47%
320 Sjeng WC 2008 64-bit 4CPU 2990.07 8.13 4893 43.09% 3037.44 40.65%
326 Stockfish 1.2def 64-bit 4CPU 2987.83 20.88 684 48.76% 2995.82 44.88%
341 Bright 0.5c 4CPU 2980.08 34.41 273 48.72% 2989.72 38.83%
348 Thinker 5.4a Inert 64-bit 4CPU 2977.97 17.85 930 48.60% 2988.83 47.31%
351 Sjeng 3.0 64-bit 4CPU 2977.89 12.44 1985 47.78% 2993.83 42.67%
352 Hiarcs 12 4CPU 2977.61 10.53 2766 49.84% 2979.63 44.58%
354 Toga II 1.4.1SE 4CPU 2977.20 12.26 2092 49.00% 2984.33 41.59%
357 Fruit 2.4 Beta A 4CPU 2974.51 12.48 2190 35.82% 3078.19 37.31%
363 Tornado 4.88 64-bit 4CPU 2971.29 35.42 243 53.91% 2944.21 42.80%
372 Stockfish 1.3 64-bit 4CPU 2967.74 22.26 598 49.67% 2969.21 45.15%
373 Deep Fritz 10.1 4CPU 2967.62 10.82 2754 49.07% 2973.45 37.44%
374 Glaurung 2.2 64-bit 4CPU 2967.61 10.64 2820 46.12% 2995.83 40.53%