Test Carballo 0.8 JA

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

User avatar
pedrox
Posts: 1056
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 6:07 am
Location: Basque Country (Spain)

Test Carballo 0.8 JA

Post by pedrox »

Code: Select all

==============================================================================
  Rank  Name                  Elo   +    -    Games  Score  Oppo.  Draws  
==============================================================================
  1     Cerebro 3.03d         2636  549  236  8      100%   2207   0%     
  2     Simplex 0.9.8 x64     2636  549  236  8      100%   2207   0%     
  3     Atlas 3.25 x64        2516  331  202  8      94%    2207   13%    
  4     Godel 2.3.7 x64       2513  331  203  8      94%    2207   13%    
  5     DanaSah 5.04          2513  331  203  8      94%    2207   13%    
  6     Caligula 0.7b         2513  331  203  8      94%    2207   13%    
  7     Averno 0.81           2513  331  203  8      94%    2207   13%    
  8     EveAnn 1.71a          2494  332  209  8      88%    2207   0%     
  9     Amyan 1.72            2435  257  187  8      88%    2207   25%    
  10    Pepito 1.59.2 x64     2418  258  193  8      81%    2207   13%    
  11    KMTChess 1.2.1 x64    2415  258  191  8      81%    2207   13%    
  12    Alfil 13.1 x64        2415  258  191  8      81%    2207   13%    
  13    Rodin 6.0             2415  258  191  8      81%    2207   13%    
  14    Bruja 1.9.1 x64       2391  261  202  8      75%    2207   0%     
  15    BetsabeII 1.30 x64    2385  260  199  8      75%    2207   0%     
  16    Rhetoric 1.0 x64      2297  228  203  8      63%    2207   0%     
  17    Sungorus 1.4 x64      2243  186  179  8      56%    2207   38%    
  18    Ayito 0.2.994         2207  209  209  8      50%    2207   0%     
  19    Carballo 0.8          2207  40   40   232    40%    2283   14%    
  20    Popochin 3.2          2180  179  186  8      44%    2207   38%    
  21    Clarabit 1.00 x64     2141  170  182  8      38%    2207   50%    
  22    Chispa 4.0.3          2133  185  201  8      38%    2207   25%    
  23    ChessKISS 1.7 x64     2129  184  201  8      38%    2207   25%    
  24    KDLChess 0.7.1        2055  181  220  8      25%    2207   25%    
  25    Roque 2.1             2000  194  258  8      19%    2207   13%    
  26    IACH 0.57a            1973  185  256  8      13%    2207   25%    
  27    RataAero 0.2.1        1924  207  332  8      13%    2207   0%     
  28    HeavyChess 0.13       1901  203  331  8      6%     2207   13%    
  29    AjedrezTactico 2.73b  1901  203  331  8      6%     2207   13%    
  30    Cecir 3.5             1899  202  331  8      6%     2207   13%    
==============================================================================
ELO: +3

Code: Select all

Rank Name                   Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
  38 Carballo 0.8          2209   45   46   242   39%  2302   15% 
  39 Carballo 0.7          2206   35   35   374   44%  2229   14% 
  44 Carballo 0.5          2018   48   49   304   32%  2236    6% 
mloftus955
Posts: 92
Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2010 5:36 pm
Location: Westfield, IN
Full name: mark loftus

Re: Test Carballo 0.8 JA

Post by mloftus955 »

Very interesting results.
Good showing for Simplex and KMT Chess, I was a little surprised and expected better from Alfil.


Mark
User avatar
pedrox
Posts: 1056
Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 6:07 am
Location: Basque Country (Spain)

Re: Test Carballo 0.8 JA

Post by pedrox »

This is the result of Carballo against other 29 engines and playing 8 games against each.

The Elo shown only accounts for 8 games, maybe better to call this column "performance".

Here is the complete list of Elo and in it you can see that Alfil scored much higher.

Code: Select all

Rank Name                   Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Gaviota 0.86 x64      2848   46   43   264   83%  2554   17% 
   2 Chronos 1.99b x64     2767   30   29   612   82%  2389   19% 
   3 Gaviota 0.85.1 x64    2761   46   43   349   87%  2262   15% 
   4 Dirty 20APR2013 x64   2750   39   38   250   69%  2608   24% 
   5 Dirty 5Sep2012 x64    2748   32   31   554   81%  2382   18% 
   6 Dirty 23Mar2012 x64   2700   55   51   288   87%  2182   10% 
   7 Alfil 13.1 x64        2645   29   28   499   65%  2516   21% 
   8 Alfil 12              2634   43   42   330   77%  2262   14% 
   9 Dirty 23Mar2012 w32   2630   52   49   262   82%  2208   11% 
  10 Godel 2.3.7 x64       2626   27   27   552   64%  2502   22% 
  11 Rodin 6.0             2615   39   38   268   64%  2498   22% 
  12 Atlas 3.25 x64        2613   29   29   562   66%  2411   16% 
  13 Rodin 5.1             2592   29   29   460   59%  2517   23% 
  14 Amyan 1.72            2585   27   27   619   64%  2393   17% 
  15 DanaSah 5.00 w32      2583   29   29   464   61%  2493   27% 
  16 DanaSah 5.04          2583   37   36   298   63%  2466   25% 
  17 DanaSah 5.06          2569   41   40   230   61%  2484   25% 
  18 DanaSah 4.99 x64      2552   44   43   288   73%  2241   20% 
  19 DanaSah 4.88          2542   43   43   312   72%  2230   14% 
  20 Pepito 1.59.2 x64     2536   27   27   632   60%  2391   18% 
  21 Rodin 4.0             2519   43   43   310   71%  2222   14% 
  22 Cerebro 3.03d         2516   27   27   624   57%  2393   18% 
  23 Bruja 1.9.1 x64       2496   27   27   632   56%  2393   17% 
  24 Caligula 0.7b         2485   27   27   632   54%  2393   17% 
  25 BetsabeII 1.28 x64    2424   38   38   365   59%  2270   15% 
  26 BetsabeII 1.30 x64    2423   33   34   348   44%  2473   21% 
  27 Rhetoric 1.0 x64      2403   40   40   258   40%  2490   16% 
  28 Simplex 0.9.8 x64     2390   25   26   718   48%  2368   17% 
  29 Sungorus 1.4 x64      2387   26   26   717   48%  2369   15% 
  30 Averno 0.81           2372   25   25   708   46%  2371   18% 
  31 EveAnn 1.71a          2365   34   34   348   36%  2477   22% 
  32 EveAnn 1.67           2350   41   42   305   53%  2276   18% 
  33 Ayito 0.2.994         2322   35   35   385   49%  2299   14% 
  34 KMTChess 1.2.1 x64    2272   31   31   510   44%  2294   16% 
  35 Popochin 3.2          2268   31   31   514   44%  2294   15% 
  36 Rhetoric Lite         2254   35   35   366   50%  2244   12% 
  37 Chispa 4.0.3          2250   31   32   519   43%  2288   15% 
  38 Carballo 0.8          2209   45   46   242   39%  2302   15% 
  39 Carballo 0.7          2206   35   35   374   44%  2229   14% 
  40 Clarabit 1.00 x64     2130   30   30   630   49%  2134   13% 
  41 ChessKISS 1.7 x64     2119   32   32   581   49%  2125   11% 
  42 Rhetoric 0.10.d       2107   40   40   415   44%  2161    8% 
  43 Clarabit 1.00 w32     2089   54   56   217   36%  2227   12% 
  44 Carballo 0.5          2018   48   49   304   32%  2236    6% 
  45 IACH 0.57a            1938   33   33   540   42%  2057   13% 
  46 KDLChess 0.7.1        1930   33   33   531   42%  2061   12% 
  47 HeavyChess 0.13       1863   30   30   601   41%  2007   22% 
  48 RataAero 0.2.1        1857   34   34   535   35%  2061   10% 
  49 Roque 2.1             1842   36   35   377   63%  1701   15% 
  50 Cecir 3.5             1825   31   31   613   38%  2003   11% 
  51 Roque 2.0             1788   54   57   300   17%  2249    5% 
  52 AjedrezTactico 2.73b  1783   28   28   749   42%  1922   13% 
  53 Rocinante 2.0 x64     1767   29   29   678   38%  1940   12% 
  54 Rocinante 2.0 w32     1765   38   38   468   30%  2042   11% 
  55 Mephisto MM5          1742   52   54   170   41%  1793   18% 
  56 Kitteneitor_master1   1727   35   35   276   51%  1717   35% 
  57 Zoidberg 0.1          1682   26   26   860   41%  1835   11% 
  58 Kitteneitor 0.7.2     1654   35   35   339   49%  1643   32% 
  59 Darky 0.5e            1635   30   31   467   47%  1638   18% 
  60 Darky 0.5b            1613   63   65   118   42%  1655   14% 
  61 Darky 0.5a            1584   47   47   230   62%  1427   16% 
  62 GFC 2                 1525   40   39   327   60%  1405   13% 
  63 MiniRoque 1.2         1475   33   34   452   44%  1515   16% 
  64 Cheoss 0.649          1425   37   37   384   42%  1498   16% 
  65 Roque 1.1             1417   89  106   267    4%  2261    1% 
  66 Joana                 1369   41   41   262   54%  1337   23% 
  67 Toledo 11Ene2010      1290   31   31   781   24%  1747   16% 
  68 SecondChess           1128   33   34   467   23%  1413   28% 
  69 Aretar 1.0            1079   47   49   204   27%  1302   21% 
  70 Omar 3.2               910   43   46   539    6%  1478   11% 
mloftus955
Posts: 92
Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2010 5:36 pm
Location: Westfield, IN
Full name: mark loftus

Re: Test Carballo 0.8 JA

Post by mloftus955 »

Ok, that puts it in perspective.
I see that improving an an engine is not so easy.
Maybe the newer version is better at longer time controls.
Dirty is definitely improving.