Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.
Moderators: hgm , Rebel , chrisw
pedrox
Posts: 1056 Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 6:07 am
Location: Basque Country (Spain)
Post
by pedrox » Wed Jul 03, 2013 8:53 am
Code: Select all
==============================================================================
Rank Name Elo + - Games Score Oppo. Draws
==============================================================================
1 Cerebro 3.03d 2636 549 236 8 100% 2207 0%
2 Simplex 0.9.8 x64 2636 549 236 8 100% 2207 0%
3 Atlas 3.25 x64 2516 331 202 8 94% 2207 13%
4 Godel 2.3.7 x64 2513 331 203 8 94% 2207 13%
5 DanaSah 5.04 2513 331 203 8 94% 2207 13%
6 Caligula 0.7b 2513 331 203 8 94% 2207 13%
7 Averno 0.81 2513 331 203 8 94% 2207 13%
8 EveAnn 1.71a 2494 332 209 8 88% 2207 0%
9 Amyan 1.72 2435 257 187 8 88% 2207 25%
10 Pepito 1.59.2 x64 2418 258 193 8 81% 2207 13%
11 KMTChess 1.2.1 x64 2415 258 191 8 81% 2207 13%
12 Alfil 13.1 x64 2415 258 191 8 81% 2207 13%
13 Rodin 6.0 2415 258 191 8 81% 2207 13%
14 Bruja 1.9.1 x64 2391 261 202 8 75% 2207 0%
15 BetsabeII 1.30 x64 2385 260 199 8 75% 2207 0%
16 Rhetoric 1.0 x64 2297 228 203 8 63% 2207 0%
17 Sungorus 1.4 x64 2243 186 179 8 56% 2207 38%
18 Ayito 0.2.994 2207 209 209 8 50% 2207 0%
19 Carballo 0.8 2207 40 40 232 40% 2283 14%
20 Popochin 3.2 2180 179 186 8 44% 2207 38%
21 Clarabit 1.00 x64 2141 170 182 8 38% 2207 50%
22 Chispa 4.0.3 2133 185 201 8 38% 2207 25%
23 ChessKISS 1.7 x64 2129 184 201 8 38% 2207 25%
24 KDLChess 0.7.1 2055 181 220 8 25% 2207 25%
25 Roque 2.1 2000 194 258 8 19% 2207 13%
26 IACH 0.57a 1973 185 256 8 13% 2207 25%
27 RataAero 0.2.1 1924 207 332 8 13% 2207 0%
28 HeavyChess 0.13 1901 203 331 8 6% 2207 13%
29 AjedrezTactico 2.73b 1901 203 331 8 6% 2207 13%
30 Cecir 3.5 1899 202 331 8 6% 2207 13%
==============================================================================
ELO: +3
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
38 Carballo 0.8 2209 45 46 242 39% 2302 15%
39 Carballo 0.7 2206 35 35 374 44% 2229 14%
44 Carballo 0.5 2018 48 49 304 32% 2236 6%
mloftus955
Posts: 92 Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2010 5:36 pm
Location: Westfield, IN
Full name: mark loftus
Post
by mloftus955 » Fri Jul 05, 2013 4:37 pm
Very interesting results.
Good showing for Simplex and KMT Chess, I was a little surprised and expected better from Alfil.
Mark
pedrox
Posts: 1056 Joined: Fri Mar 10, 2006 6:07 am
Location: Basque Country (Spain)
Post
by pedrox » Fri Jul 05, 2013 7:07 pm
This is the result of Carballo against other 29 engines and playing 8 games against each.
The Elo shown only accounts for 8 games, maybe better to call this column "performance".
Here is the complete list of Elo and in it you can see that Alfil scored much higher.
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Gaviota 0.86 x64 2848 46 43 264 83% 2554 17%
2 Chronos 1.99b x64 2767 30 29 612 82% 2389 19%
3 Gaviota 0.85.1 x64 2761 46 43 349 87% 2262 15%
4 Dirty 20APR2013 x64 2750 39 38 250 69% 2608 24%
5 Dirty 5Sep2012 x64 2748 32 31 554 81% 2382 18%
6 Dirty 23Mar2012 x64 2700 55 51 288 87% 2182 10%
7 Alfil 13.1 x64 2645 29 28 499 65% 2516 21%
8 Alfil 12 2634 43 42 330 77% 2262 14%
9 Dirty 23Mar2012 w32 2630 52 49 262 82% 2208 11%
10 Godel 2.3.7 x64 2626 27 27 552 64% 2502 22%
11 Rodin 6.0 2615 39 38 268 64% 2498 22%
12 Atlas 3.25 x64 2613 29 29 562 66% 2411 16%
13 Rodin 5.1 2592 29 29 460 59% 2517 23%
14 Amyan 1.72 2585 27 27 619 64% 2393 17%
15 DanaSah 5.00 w32 2583 29 29 464 61% 2493 27%
16 DanaSah 5.04 2583 37 36 298 63% 2466 25%
17 DanaSah 5.06 2569 41 40 230 61% 2484 25%
18 DanaSah 4.99 x64 2552 44 43 288 73% 2241 20%
19 DanaSah 4.88 2542 43 43 312 72% 2230 14%
20 Pepito 1.59.2 x64 2536 27 27 632 60% 2391 18%
21 Rodin 4.0 2519 43 43 310 71% 2222 14%
22 Cerebro 3.03d 2516 27 27 624 57% 2393 18%
23 Bruja 1.9.1 x64 2496 27 27 632 56% 2393 17%
24 Caligula 0.7b 2485 27 27 632 54% 2393 17%
25 BetsabeII 1.28 x64 2424 38 38 365 59% 2270 15%
26 BetsabeII 1.30 x64 2423 33 34 348 44% 2473 21%
27 Rhetoric 1.0 x64 2403 40 40 258 40% 2490 16%
28 Simplex 0.9.8 x64 2390 25 26 718 48% 2368 17%
29 Sungorus 1.4 x64 2387 26 26 717 48% 2369 15%
30 Averno 0.81 2372 25 25 708 46% 2371 18%
31 EveAnn 1.71a 2365 34 34 348 36% 2477 22%
32 EveAnn 1.67 2350 41 42 305 53% 2276 18%
33 Ayito 0.2.994 2322 35 35 385 49% 2299 14%
34 KMTChess 1.2.1 x64 2272 31 31 510 44% 2294 16%
35 Popochin 3.2 2268 31 31 514 44% 2294 15%
36 Rhetoric Lite 2254 35 35 366 50% 2244 12%
37 Chispa 4.0.3 2250 31 32 519 43% 2288 15%
38 Carballo 0.8 2209 45 46 242 39% 2302 15%
39 Carballo 0.7 2206 35 35 374 44% 2229 14%
40 Clarabit 1.00 x64 2130 30 30 630 49% 2134 13%
41 ChessKISS 1.7 x64 2119 32 32 581 49% 2125 11%
42 Rhetoric 0.10.d 2107 40 40 415 44% 2161 8%
43 Clarabit 1.00 w32 2089 54 56 217 36% 2227 12%
44 Carballo 0.5 2018 48 49 304 32% 2236 6%
45 IACH 0.57a 1938 33 33 540 42% 2057 13%
46 KDLChess 0.7.1 1930 33 33 531 42% 2061 12%
47 HeavyChess 0.13 1863 30 30 601 41% 2007 22%
48 RataAero 0.2.1 1857 34 34 535 35% 2061 10%
49 Roque 2.1 1842 36 35 377 63% 1701 15%
50 Cecir 3.5 1825 31 31 613 38% 2003 11%
51 Roque 2.0 1788 54 57 300 17% 2249 5%
52 AjedrezTactico 2.73b 1783 28 28 749 42% 1922 13%
53 Rocinante 2.0 x64 1767 29 29 678 38% 1940 12%
54 Rocinante 2.0 w32 1765 38 38 468 30% 2042 11%
55 Mephisto MM5 1742 52 54 170 41% 1793 18%
56 Kitteneitor_master1 1727 35 35 276 51% 1717 35%
57 Zoidberg 0.1 1682 26 26 860 41% 1835 11%
58 Kitteneitor 0.7.2 1654 35 35 339 49% 1643 32%
59 Darky 0.5e 1635 30 31 467 47% 1638 18%
60 Darky 0.5b 1613 63 65 118 42% 1655 14%
61 Darky 0.5a 1584 47 47 230 62% 1427 16%
62 GFC 2 1525 40 39 327 60% 1405 13%
63 MiniRoque 1.2 1475 33 34 452 44% 1515 16%
64 Cheoss 0.649 1425 37 37 384 42% 1498 16%
65 Roque 1.1 1417 89 106 267 4% 2261 1%
66 Joana 1369 41 41 262 54% 1337 23%
67 Toledo 11Ene2010 1290 31 31 781 24% 1747 16%
68 SecondChess 1128 33 34 467 23% 1413 28%
69 Aretar 1.0 1079 47 49 204 27% 1302 21%
70 Omar 3.2 910 43 46 539 6% 1478 11%
mloftus955
Posts: 92 Joined: Tue Jun 08, 2010 5:36 pm
Location: Westfield, IN
Full name: mark loftus
Post
by mloftus955 » Sat Jul 06, 2013 9:56 pm
Ok, that puts it in perspective.
I see that improving an an engine is not so easy.
Maybe the newer version is better at longer time controls.
Dirty is definitely improving.