Latest SFdev vs Komodo 8

[ernest]

Also based in 200 games just above that match.

You are right!
But still, error bars are too large to conclude...

Anyway, we'll see with SF6

[beram]

first results for the SF 6RC1 are not that good as earlier recent SF dev results
200 games on i5 4200M and 50 games on the AMD1090T, 57,25% and 56%

Code: Select all

SF 6RC1  - K8, Blitz 3m+2s  i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu Fritzmark 5,1 
                                   
1   Stockfish 6 RC1 64 BMI2   +51  +63/=103/-34 57.25%  114.5/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit           -51  +34/=103/-63 42.75%   85.5/200


SF6 RC1 - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s, AMD 1090T @3200Mhz, 4cpu Fritzm. 15,6                                                             
1   Stockfish 6 RC1 64  +14/=28/-8 56.00%   28.0/50
2   Komodo 8 64-bit     +8/=28/-14 44.00%   22.0/50

First match result (with same book) for the official SF6 release gives SF a nice 60%
also on the I5 4200M after first 60 games SF scored 60% sofar
I will run both matches till 200 games results will follow later

Code: Select all

SF 6 - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s            AMD 1090T @3200Mhz , 4cpu Fritzmark 15,6                                                                      
1   Stockfish 6 64   +16/=28/-6 60.00%   30.0/50
2   Komodo 8 64-bit  +6/=28/-16 40.00%   20.0/50

[beram]

And here are the end results after 2x 200 games
59,5 % with SF 6 x64BMI on the i5 4200M and 53,5 % fo SF 6 x64 on the AMD 1090T

Code: Select all

SF 6  - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s         i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu (Fritzmark 5,1)
1   Stockfish 6 64 BMI2   +67  +64/=110/-26 59.50%  119.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit       -67  +26/=110/-64 40.50%   81.0/200


SF 6 - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s  AMD 1090T @3200Mhz , 4cpu (Fritzmark 15,6)
1   Stockfish 6 64   +44/=126/-30 53.50%  107.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit  +30/=126/-44 46.50%   93.0/200

[beram]

And here are the end results after 2x 200 games
59,5 % with SF 6 x64BMI on the i5 4200M and 53,5 % fo SF 6 x64 on the AMD 1090T

Code: Select all

SF 6  - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s         i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu (Fritzmark 5,1)
1   Stockfish 6 64 BMI2   +67  +64/=110/-26 59.50%  119.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit       -67  +26/=110/-64 40.50%   81.0/200


SF 6 - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s  AMD 1090T @3200Mhz , 4cpu (Fritzmark 15,6)
1   Stockfish 6 64   +44/=126/-30 53.50%  107.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit  +30/=126/-44 46.50%   93.0/200

[JJJ]

Last Komodo is probably 20 elo below Stockfish 6. At least, the one who played TCEC. But I m sure Komodo 9 will catch up Stockfish 6. I really want Komodo 9 to be stronger than Stockfish 6.

[beram]

And here are the end results after 2x 200 games
59,5 % with SF 6 x64BMI on the i5 4200M and 53,5 % fo SF 6 x64 on the AMD 1090T

Code: Select all

SF 6  - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s         i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu (Fritzmark 5,1)
1   Stockfish 6 64 BMI2   +67  +64/=110/-26 59.50%  119.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit       -67  +26/=110/-64 40.50%   81.0/200


SF 6 - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s  AMD 1090T @3200Mhz , 4cpu (Fritzmark 15,6)
1   Stockfish 6 64   +44/=126/-30 53.50%  107.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit  +30/=126/-44 46.50%   93.0/200

After a rerun with the ‘official’ SF 6 from the official downloadsite -http://stockfishchess.org/download/ I get a much better result for SF 6 on the AMD where SF 6 now scores 58,5 %

Code: Select all

SF 6 (official binary) - K8, Blitz 3m+2s                         i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu (Fritzmark 5,1)
1   Stockfish 6 64 BMI2   +70  +68/=104/-28 60.00%  120.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit       -70  +28/=104/-68 40.00%   80.0/200

SF 6(official binary)- Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s                   AMD 1090T @3200Mhz , 4cpu (Fritzmark 15,6)
1   Stockfish 6 64   +62/=110/-28 58.50%  117.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit  +28/=110/-62 41.50%   83.0/200

[beram]

And here are the end results after 2x 200 games
59,5 % with SF 6 x64BMI on the i5 4200M and 53,5 % fo SF 6 x64 on the AMD 1090T

Code: Select all

SF 6  - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s         i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu (Fritzmark 5,1)
1   Stockfish 6 64 BMI2   +67  +64/=110/-26 59.50%  119.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit       -67  +26/=110/-64 40.50%   81.0/200


SF 6 - Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s  AMD 1090T @3200Mhz , 4cpu (Fritzmark 15,6)
1   Stockfish 6 64   +44/=126/-30 53.50%  107.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit  +30/=126/-44 46.50%   93.0/200

After a rerun with the ‘official’ SF 6 from the official downloadsite -http://stockfishchess.org/download/ I get a much better result for SF 6 on the AMD where SF 6 now scores 58,5 %

Code: Select all

SF 6 (official binary) - K8, Blitz 3m+2s                         i5 4200M @2500Mhz, 2 cpu (Fritzmark 5,1)
1   Stockfish 6 64 BMI2   +70  +68/=104/-28 60.00%  120.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit       -70  +28/=104/-68 40.00%   80.0/200

SF 6(official binary)- Komodo 8, Blitz 3m+2s                   AMD 1090T @3200Mhz , 4cpu (Fritzmark 15,6)
1   Stockfish 6 64   +62/=110/-28 58.50%  117.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit  +28/=110/-62 41.50%   83.0/200

And here my results for one of the latest SFdev 160315
Same set up as in my other matches
Instead of 60% with the official SF6 binary SF160315 scores 61,5%

Code: Select all

SF 160315  - K8, Blitz 3m+2s                                   
1   Stockfish 160315 64 BMI2   +81  +69/=108/-23 61.50%  123.0/200
2   Komodo 8 64-bit            -81  +23/=108/-69 38.50%   77.0/200