FIDE Ethics Commission ruling on ICGA/Rybka complaint

[Graham Banks]

I see it being discussed here - http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforu ... ?tid=30118

[Graham Banks]

Not sure what you mean Terry.
All I'm doing is informing members that the FIDE Ethics Commission report is being discussed there.
I guess that once the full report is published on the FIDE site, we'll be even better informed.

[Adam Hair]

I see it being discussed here - http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforu ... ?tid=30118

Would you care to elaborate {SNIP}?

[Graham Banks]

I see it being discussed here - http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforu ... ?tid=30118

Would you care to elaborate {SNIP}?

I understand that the report is available for interested parties to view in private, but it can't be posted in full until it appears on the FIDE website. It seems that it can be quoted from until then.
Therefore you can see some of the content in that thread.

[Roger Brown]

I see it being discussed here - http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforu ... ?tid=30118

Would you care to elaborate {SNIP}?

Hello Adam,

You are asking Terry to elaborate but this is not the animal excrement forum or indeed, the amateur psychological forum, so I had to take his post out.

Then it snowballed.

I hate editing but this started before I saw it. In my judgement this may contain useful information so the potential value of the thread outweighed my abhorrence of intervening.

Barely.

Let us keep it civil.

No Adam, that is not intended for you.

Later.

Sigh.

[Adam Hair]

I see it being discussed here - http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforu ... ?tid=30118

Would you care to elaborate {SNIP}?

I understand that the report is available for interested parties to view in private, but it can't be posted in full until it appears on the FIDE website. It seems that it can be quoted from until then.
Therefore you can see some of the content in that thread.

Hi Graham,

I was responding to Terry's crude and uninformed response to your post. I have had the opportunity to view the full report and felt the need to call Terry out for his reaction.

[Harvey Williamson]

I see it being discussed here - http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforu ... ?tid=30118

As they are being selective in that thread and you are not able to read the full report I will post this snip from the report

"There are no violations of any FIDE rules."

"There is no evidence that the members of the ICGA Executive Committee - the only ICGA organ responsible for the decision - did not act in an impartial way."

" For these reasons, under this profile, the complaint has to be dismissed."

I think everyone should wait till FIDE allow us to publish it in full and then discuss it.

[Terry McCracken]

I see it being discussed here - http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforu ... ?tid=30118

As they are being selective in that thread and you are not able to read the full report I will post this snip from the report

"There are no violations of any FIDE rules."

"There is no evidence that the members of the ICGA Executive Committee - the only ICGA organ responsible for the decision - did not act in an impartial way."

" For these reasons, under this profile, the complaint has to be dismissed."

I think everyone should wait till FIDE allow us to publish it in full and then discuss it.

How the devil did the FIDE get involved? This is absurd in the extreme.

[Graham Banks]

I see it being discussed here - http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforu ... ?tid=30118

Would you care to elaborate {SNIP}?

I understand that the report is available for interested parties to view in private, but it can't be posted in full until it appears on the FIDE website. It seems that it can be quoted from until then.
Therefore you can see some of the content in that thread.

Hi Graham,

I was responding to Terry's crude and uninformed response to your post. I have had the opportunity to view the full report and felt the need to call Terry out for his reaction.

The crude and uniformed is you, Graham and Roger.
You have no such need unless you're trolling.

The FIDE has nothing to say in this matter, nor should they, it's not their jurisdiction. I see legal suits yet to be filed.

This is a troll thread initiated by Graham and followed up by you and interrupted by a misinformed moderator.

The FIDE and Ethics is an Oxymoron.

ICGA are a FIDE affiliate.

How is informing members that the FIDE Ethics Commission report in response to the complaint filed against ICGA is being discussed either crude, uninformed or trolling?
That is absurd!

Graham.

[Sean Evans]

Hello Graham,

To the best of my knowledge Rybka is no longer being worked on. In other words, the company is now defunct never to be resurrected.

Do you disagree?

Sean