So I was convinced by Mark to put my name on the letter even though I have little to do with computer chess any more. After some thinking (and some browsing the forums, where people are making absolutely ridiculous claims) I decided I was going to have to write a little better explanation. It seems that computer chess has once again figured out how to waste my time.
www.acoz.net/zappa/rybka-cloning
The key points: why Rybka has been so dominant for so long, why copying an engine is totally different than reading source code, and why we almost certainly would never have heard the name Rajlich if he hadn't copied Fruit wholesale, which is why the guy talking about the confederacy of dunces should take a good look in the mirror (after all, if we are judging people entirely by the ELO of their engine, then his worth is 0).
I don't plan on replying to this since I've said just about everything I want to say in the article. I very much doubt I will convince the Rybka supporters of anything, but hopefully it will make a few things more clear to the rest of us (there is a great quote by Lichtenberg about this).
cheers,
Anthony
Longer Article
Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw
-
PK
- Posts: 893
- Joined: Mon Jan 15, 2007 11:23 am
- Location: Warsza
Re: Longer Article
Q: What's the new marketing name for Rybka Cluster?
A: Fish and chips.
A: Fish and chips.
Pawel Koziol
http://www.pkoziol.cal24.pl/rodent/rodent.htm
http://www.pkoziol.cal24.pl/rodent/rodent.htm
-
Jouni
- Posts: 3285
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 8:15 pm
Re: Longer Article
Really interesting article. BTW: if Rybka is declared as derivate/clone do
we get all money invested for Rybka 1-4 as refund
Or are they sent to Fabian?
Jouni
we get all money invested for Rybka 1-4 as refund
Or are they sent to Fabian?Jouni
-
Michael Diosi
- Posts: 672
- Joined: Mon Jun 22, 2009 1:37 pm
-
tomgdrums
- Posts: 736
- Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2009 9:48 am
Re: Longer Article
Why do you single out chessbase? Rybka was also sold by ChessOK and by the Rybka team as well.
-
Sylwy
- Posts: 4466
- Joined: Fri Apr 21, 2006 4:19 pm
- Location: IASI - the historical capital of MOLDOVA
- Full name: SilvianR
Re: Degeaba...:)))
Salut Carol !
Te chinui degeaba ! Nu ti-e clar inca cine trage sforile pe aicea ? Daca nu esti lamurit - uite un post interesant (si instructiv
):
http://talkchess.com/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 27&t=38190
Se pare ca autorul textului e un fost daco-roman.Si nu e unicul pe aici !
Crezi ca au intervenit moderatorii ? Sponsorii ? Asa ca nu te minuna .
Despre Rybka -povestea e veche. Se pare ca nu e scrisa de cine trebuia !
Pa !
S
Te chinui degeaba ! Nu ti-e clar inca cine trage sforile pe aicea ? Daca nu esti lamurit - uite un post interesant (si instructiv
):http://talkchess.com/forum/viewtopic.ph ... 27&t=38190
Se pare ca autorul textului e un fost daco-roman.Si nu e unicul pe aici !
Crezi ca au intervenit moderatorii ? Sponsorii ? Asa ca nu te minuna .
Despre Rybka -povestea e veche. Se pare ca nu e scrisa de cine trebuia !
Pa !
S -
Romy
- Posts: 72
- Joined: Thu Mar 10, 2011 10:39 pm
- Location: Bucharest (Romania)
Re: Degeaba...:)))
Salut!Sylwy wrote:Salut Carol !
SKANDALOV!
-
Osipov Jury
- Posts: 186
- Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2008 2:07 pm
- Location: Russia
Re: Longer Article
I also tested Strelka in the games at 4 ply. Each game finish in less than 1 second. Per hour was played 5000 games. At 100000 games take 20 hours.I had a discussion with Vasik in Mexico about his tuning. His procedure was to play games at 3-4 ply which would finish in 10 seconds or so. At that speed the context switching and parsing of UCI would be much to slow, so he had written a special tester to link two versions of Rybka. To accurately measure 2-3 elo changes requires about 100,000 games; at 10 seconds per game that equates to about 10 days of computer time.
If you disable the interface UCI and switching, the speed increases by about half.
Besides, my computer is slow (Core Duo). At a more powerful computer the entire test can be carried out for 1-2 hours.
I went through the Rybka code forwards and backwards and took many things.
-
Sylwy
- Posts: 4466
- Joined: Fri Apr 21, 2006 4:19 pm
- Location: IASI - the historical capital of MOLDOVA
- Full name: SilvianR
Re: Degeaba...:)))
ÜBER SKANDALOV !Romy wrote:Salut!Sylwy wrote:Salut Carol !
SKANDALOV!
Auf Wiedersehen !
Silvian -
tomgdrums
- Posts: 736
- Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2009 9:48 am
Re: Longer Article
As you can see below, Hiarcs has gained 132 ELO over the course of 4 years. This information is based on release dates and CCRL testing.Romy wrote:Reference is to Mr HIARCS Uniacke. Can he appear to be Chief of the confed?acozzie wrote:So I was convinced by Mark to put my name on the letter
If case is so clear on technicals, why his persuasion was necessary?
Yes. This is 90% of point.Rybka has been so dominant for so long
I am good-looking. I see skeptic chessplayer.the guy talking about the confederacy of dunces should take a good look in the mirror
I play Zappa, I have not a bad record. But without the permission of its true author/s, I am polite not to publish it.
But I play RYBKA, I get most painful crush if I play for win, else some draws also.
But was not able to resist?I don't plan on replying
When replying, can you please report decompilation investigation in to how HIARCS gain 200 ELO in very short period? Better, demand source code.
Or is it there is not an investigation to this? Why? Because Mr "Osipov" not bother to reverse engineer weakie, when he has RYBKA for target?
So your point of 200 elo in a "short time" is not even remotely valid. Sorry.
Hiarcs 11-released December 6th, 2006-ELO=2879
Hiarcs 12.1-released December 14th, 2008-ELO=2921
Hiarcs 13.2-released December 24th, 2010-ELO=3011
Hiarcs is a great engine and the their customer service is amazing.