Page 3 of 5
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sat Sep 23, 2017 2:19 pm
by Hugo
Setup Komodo with contempt 0
beram wrote:beram wrote:beram wrote:After second run and 100 games +8 -10 =82 so a tiny small win for Stockfish170917
A new match against Komodo 11.2.2 is now underway
In previously played match Komodo11.2.2 scored -17 +8 =75 against Stockfish 170917
I will share a pgn link with all the games afterwards
Completely different story here for Houdini 6 with same testbook +16 -7 =27 after the first run of 50 games
(previous match first run was +4 -4 =42 against SF170917)
Code: Select all
Houdini 6 - Komodo 11.2.2, Blitz 3m+2s 2017
1 Houdini 6 Pro x64-popc +63 +16/=27/-7 59.00% 29.5/50
2 Komodo 11.2.2 64-bit -63 +7/=27/-16 41.00% 20.5/50
Second run against Komodo11.2.2 has finished with 13+ 5- 32 for Houdini 6
So after 100 games a clear win +29 -12 =59 is 58,5% for Houdini 6
Overall winner over 300 games in these three matches combined is Houdini 6
Houdini 6 +37 -22 =141 -> 107,5 out of 200 games
SF 170917 +27 -16 =157 -> 105,5 out of 200 games
Komodo 11.2.2 +20 -46 =134 -> 87 out of 200 games
I have yet started a new match Houdini 6 vs Stockfish 170917 with TC 15m10s
(games link will follow later)
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sat Sep 23, 2017 3:01 pm
by Nordlandia
Considering H6 is stronger than K11.2.2, maybe it's advisable to set contempt at -3, which encourage Komodo to seek draw.
For Komodo ->
Positive contempt is good against weaker engines and negative contempt against stronger engines.
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sat Sep 23, 2017 5:21 pm
by stavros
APassionForCriminalJustic wrote:shrapnel wrote: I am happy for Robert he beats a whole team of Stockfish developers
How has he beaten them if the score is equal ??
Anyway, thanks for the Results.
It shows that SDV will be ahead in a month or 2, while Houdini 7 will be released next year.
So......draw your own conclusions if one should buy H 6 or not .
Latest stockfish is still stronger. And well... it's only a matter of time before the team goes on another roll.
not to mention asmfish
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sat Sep 23, 2017 5:41 pm
by beram
after 38 games at TC 15m10s still equality +5 -5 =28 (but although 5x longer TC two more wins yet)
avg game lenght 50-55minutes so will take take about two more days for full 100 games
I doubt there will be much difference in outcome with first match at TC3m2s
where Stockfish won +10 -8 =82, but lets see what happens
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sat Sep 23, 2017 5:57 pm
by beram
Hugo wrote:Setup Komodo with contempt 0
beram wrote:beram wrote:beram wrote:After second run and 100 games +8 -10 =82 so a tiny small win for Stockfish170917
...
Second run against Komodo11.2.2 has finished with 13+ 5- 32 for Houdini 6
So after 100 games a clear win +29 -12 =59 is 58,5% for Houdini 6
Overall winner over 300 games in these three matches combined is Houdini 6
Houdini 6 +37 -22 =141 -> 107,5 out of 200 games
SF 170917 +27 -16 =157 -> 105,5 out of 200 games
Komodo 11.2.2 +20 -46 =134 -> 87 out of 200 games
..
Hi Clemens, doesnt matter that much I think
Hurnavich plays a match with TC 5m4s 8cores HERT openings between Komodo 11.2.2
with contempt 0 and Houdini 6 now
http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybkaforu ... 32286;pg=2
After about 50 games +13-5 is (also) 58% for Houdini 6
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sat Sep 23, 2017 6:25 pm
by Nordlandia
K11.2.2 contempt of 0 is probable incorrect against H6.
Modest value of -2 or -3 can alter final score with more drawn games.
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sat Sep 23, 2017 6:43 pm
by Houdini
It would be nice if engines received an estimate of the opponent's Elo at the start of the game so that they could adjust parameters accordingly
.
It would add an extra dimension to the competition.
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sun Sep 24, 2017 1:56 pm
by fauzi
can you please share the pgn?
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sun Sep 24, 2017 2:15 pm
by Jeroen
Isn't it possible to estimate the quality of the opponent by evaluating its moves during the game?
An example: if the opponent makes a few inaccurate moves in the first 20 moves of the game, adjust the contempt factor etc.
Re: Houdini 6 vs Stockfish dev 170917 on AMD Ryzen 1800x
Posted: Sun Sep 24, 2017 2:31 pm
by Nordlandia
Jeroen wrote:Isn't it possible to estimate the quality of the opponent by evaluating its moves during the game?
An example: if the opponent makes a few inaccurate moves in the first 20 moves of the game, adjust the contempt factor etc.
Good idea!