what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Discussion of anything and everything relating to chess playing software and machines.

Moderator: Ras

Uri Blass
Posts: 10783
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by Uri Blass »

I guess that you are going to see bigger rating improvement for the top engines if you measure in this way and it is possible to define a game that say that there are no draws because if you get a draw the game is not finished and you play another game at the same time control.
lkaufman
Posts: 6217
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 am
Location: Maryland USA
Full name: Larry Kaufman

Re: what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by lkaufman »

Uri Blass wrote: Wed Jun 23, 2021 6:26 pm I guess that you are going to see bigger rating improvement for the top engines if you measure in this way and it is possible to define a game that say that there are no draws because if you get a draw the game is not finished and you play another game at the same time control.
Rating games that way is called "WILO" (wins/losses) instead of "Elo", and it does offer advantages, notably no contraction of elo gains with greater time (expansion I think). If you use openings near the win/draw line (for example from S. Pohl) and rate them normally, then double the elo gain, you get a good estimate of WILO.
Komodo rules!
User avatar
Rebel
Posts: 7296
Joined: Thu Aug 18, 2011 12:04 pm
Full name: Ed Schröder

Re: what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by Rebel »

This is a raw ORDO list of the GRL 40/2 without draws.

Code: Select all

   # PLAYER                :  RATING  ERROR  POINTS  PLAYED   (%)  CFS(%)     W    D     L  D(%)  OppAvg
   1 Stockfish 13          :  4098.1   50.7  1157.0    1203    96      89  1157    0    46     0  3413.5
   2 Stockfish 21-05-18    :  4058.9   82.7   610.0     630    97      99   610    0    20     0  3335.1
   3 Stockfish 12          :  3934.3   69.2   817.0     873    94     100   817    0    56     0  3350.6
   4 Komodo-Dragon 2       :  3842.2   36.8  1276.0    1409    91      82  1276    0   133     0  3348.4
   5 Komodo-Dragon 1       :  3821.2   48.6   680.0     818    83     100   680    0   138     0  3436.3
   6 Lc0 v27               :  3680.9   53.1   307.0     412    75      85   307    0   105     0  3463.2
   7 Stockfish 11          :  3648.7   50.5   436.0     577    76      98   436    0   141     0  3408.7
   8 Stockfish 10          :  3601.3   56.8   561.0     754    74     100   561    0   193     0  3390.9
   9 Komodo 14             :  3470.9   50.6   235.0     483    49      60   235    0   248     0  3527.8
  10 SlowChess 2.6         :  3462.0   43.5   143.0     318    45      99   143    0   175     0  3575.3
  11 Anchor Engine         :  3400.0   13.0   550.0     846    65      90   550    0   296     0  3358.7
  12 RubiChess 2.1         :  3372.9   36.7   463.0    1281    36      51   463    0   818     0  3552.7
  13 Komodo 12             :  3372.6   35.9   284.0     490    58      71   284    0   206     0  3318.3
  14 Pedone 3.1            :  3359.9   41.6   723.0    1379    52      93   723    0   656     0  3376.5
  15 SlowChess 2.5         :  3335.5   34.5   429.0    1247    34      58   429    0   818     0  3535.2
  16 Komodo 11             :  3330.2   46.1   259.0     503    51      58   259    0   244     0  3326.2
  17 Igel 3.0.5            :  3325.1   36.3   434.0    1288    34      76   434    0   854     0  3532.5
  18 Ethereal 12.75        :  3313.1   36.1   367.0    1211    30      72   367    0   844     0  3560.2
  19 Ethereal 12.25        :  3301.2   41.2   213.0     617    35      72   213    0   404     0  3533.0
  20 Ethereal 12.50        :  3290.4   42.5   208.0     544    38      73   208    0   336     0  3447.1
  21 Igel 3.0.0            :  3275.9   21.5   111.0     465    24      52   111    0   354     0  3584.6
  22 SlowChess 2.4         :  3274.7   46.8   192.0     532    36      58   192    0   340     0  3475.7
  23 Ethereal 12.00        :  3269.0   55.1   204.0     656    31      58   204    0   452     0  3537.9
  24 Nemorino 6.00         :  3264.4   16.7   588.0    1406    42      97   588    0   818     0  3387.7
  25 Halogen 10            :  3240.0   14.2   955.0    1484    64      76   955    0   529     0  3132.4
  26 Beef 0.3.6            :  3233.7   15.1   627.0     952    66      59   627    0   325     0  3112.5
  27 Pedone 3.0            :  3231.3   20.0   265.0     490    54      68   265    0   225     0  3200.5
  28 Arasan 22.3           :  3224.6   25.3   668.0    1047    64      70   668    0   379     0  3119.7
  29 Berserk 4.2.0         :  3216.8   16.9   765.0    1156    66      69   765    0   391     0  3091.9
  30 Komodo 10             :  3204.7   39.0   188.0     534    35      56   188    0   346     0  3331.0
  31 Seer 2.0.1            :  3201.3   17.5   936.0    1493    63      89   936    0   557     0  3102.1
  32 Combusken 1.4.0       :  3187.1   16.8   589.0    1027    57      53   589    0   438     0  3132.2
  33 Booot 6.5             :  3185.8   23.4   413.0    1347    31      59   413    0   934     0  3432.5
  34 Clover 2.3.1          :  3182.6   18.7   698.0    1151    61      84   698    0   453     0  3102.4
  35 Lzero v27             :  3174.0   29.4   591.0     938    63      57   591    0   347     0  3075.9
  36 Winter 0.9            :  3171.4   31.9   497.0     839    59      64   497    0   342     0  3101.0
  37 Invictus r382         :  3161.1   36.3   272.0     390    70      51   272    0   118     0  3012.9
  38 rofChade 2.3          :  3160.5   30.8   413.0    1434    29      63   413    0  1021     0  3428.5
  39 Clover 2.2            :  3152.7   25.6   419.0     704    60      58   419    0   285     0  3082.4
  40 Anchor Engine         :  3150.0   13.0   907.0    1523    60      52   907    0   616     0  3090.2
  41 Danasah 8.8           :  3149.4   16.2   805.0    1496    54      57   805    0   691     0  3118.8
  42 Minic 3.04            :  3146.3   32.7   272.0     482    56      62   272    0   210     0  3098.6
  43 Stash 30.0            :  3140.7   16.2   579.0    1129    51      52   579    0   550     0  3130.3
  44 Wasp 4.50             :  3140.1   26.0   353.0     835    42      56   353    0   482     0  3201.2
  45 Berserk 4.1.0         :  3137.6   14.8   621.0    1064    58      77   621    0   443     0  3075.6
  46 Minic 3.08            :  3125.5   24.5   432.0     870    50      79   432    0   438     0  3127.4
  47 Minic 3.07            :  3110.1   29.1   403.0     732    55      73   403    0   329     0  3073.0
  48 Seer 2.0.0            :  3100.9   28.4   425.0     646    66      60   425    0   221     0  2980.2
  49 Weiss 1.3             :  3095.8   27.6   650.0    1120    58      50   650    0   470     0  3034.7
  50 Marvin 5.0            :  3095.7   11.0   579.0    1326    44      52   579    0   747     0  3141.7
  51 Orion 0.8             :  3095.2   24.2   623.0    1421    44      56   623    0   798     0  3139.4
  52 Stash 29.0            :  3093.3   30.9   407.0     889    46      72   407    0   482     0  3123.7
  53 Minic 3.06            :  3082.6   17.1   439.0     905    49      94   439    0   466     0  3094.1
  54 Berserk 4.0.0         :  3066.3   10.1   430.0     831    52      52   430    0   401     0  3054.2
  55 Vajolet2 2.8          :  3065.5   41.6   214.0     488    44      56   214    0   274     0  3110.5
  56 Monolith 2            :  3060.8   49.2   306.0     525    58      64   306    0   219     0  3002.2
  57 Berserk 3.3.0         :  3051.5   29.8   407.0     531    77      86   407    0   124     0  2824.5
  58 Koivisto 4.0          :  3025.1   26.0   256.0     691    37      61   256    0   435     0  3123.4
  59 Pirarucu 3.5.5        :  3018.5   38.4   310.0     622    50      63   310    0   312     0  3021.0
  60 Invictus r340         :  3010.6   28.2   560.0     843    66      52   560    0   283     0  2884.7
  61 Arasan 22.2           :  3009.2   36.3   156.0     637    24      67   156    0   481     0  3225.8
  62 Rodent 4.022          :  2999.7   37.7   302.0     631    48      51   302    0   329     0  3015.9
  63 Counter 3.8           :  2999.1   18.5   427.0    1077    40      72   427    0   650     0  3078.3
  64 Tucano 9.0            :  2993.0   23.5   742.0    1615    46      71   742    0   873     0  3020.1
  65 Topple 0.8.0          :  2985.7   12.0   743.0    2080    36      52   743    0  1337     0  3095.6
  66 Cheng 4.41            :  2984.9   23.9   652.0    1391    47      69   652    0   739     0  3008.8
  67 Mr Bob 1.0.0          :  2976.9   18.4   893.0    1944    46      52   893    0  1051     0  3007.7
  68 RubiChess 2.0         :  2975.7   44.7    75.0     633    12      63    75    0   558     0  3471.4
  69 FabChess 1.16         :  2967.5   21.3   635.0    1431    44      54   635    0   796     0  3012.2
  70 Seer 1.2.1            :  2965.5   26.1   280.0     700    40      56   280    0   420     0  3040.4
  71 Amoeba 3.3            :  2962.1   41.4   472.0    1124    42      55   472    0   652     0  3024.1
  72 Counter 3.7           :  2959.4   13.9   470.0    1332    35      99   470    0   862     0  3073.0
  73 Cheng 4.40            :  2906.7   38.5   365.0     950    38      98   365    0   585     0  2998.4
  74 Drofa 3.0.0           :  2868.0   30.4   460.0     765    60      85   460    0   305     0  2792.8
  75 Asymptote 0.8         :  2850.4   36.0   191.0     500    38      51   191    0   309     0  2935.9
  76 Nemo 1.01             :  2850.0   13.0   466.0    1322    35      97   466    0   856     0  2924.4
  77 Olithink 5.9.8        :  2820.5   24.5   210.0     584    36      61   210    0   374     0  2925.6
  78 Velvet 1.2.0          :  2815.1   32.6   407.0     625    65      55   407    0   218     0  2692.1
  79 Arasan 16.0           :  2813.5   25.4   453.0     765    59      58   453    0   312     0  2746.0
  80 Olithink 5.9.5        :  2810.1   31.5   199.0     497    40      66   199    0   298     0  2885.5
  81 Olithink 5.9.9        :  2800.5   33.7   205.0     615    33      55   205    0   410     0  2926.9
  82 ProDeo 3.1            :  2798.3   21.5   373.0     829    45      63   373    0   456     0  2839.2
  83 Cheese 2.2            :  2792.3   30.4   372.0     895    42      65   372    0   523     0  2859.7
  84 Olithink 5.9.3        :  2783.1   31.8   230.0     519    44      72   230    0   289     0  2828.2
  85 Orion 07              :  2769.9   21.7   383.0     732    52      53   383    0   349     0  2751.0
  86 Benjamin              :  2769.1   13.0   672.0    1138    59      92   672    0   466     0  2691.5
  87 k2 099                :  2749.1   25.6   408.0     769    53      77   408    0   361     0  2717.9
  88 ProDeo 2.2            :  2736.8   36.6   289.0     617    47      90   289    0   328     0  2758.3
  89 Dumb 1.8              :  2716.3   26.6   407.0     851    48      66   407    0   444     0  2724.5
  90 Supernova 2.3         :  2710.5   24.4   591.0    1190    50      63   591    0   599     0  2705.9
  91 Fridolin 3.10         :  2707.0   21.7   495.0     960    52      52   495    0   465     0  2687.0
  92 ProDeo 3.0            :  2706.4   31.5   245.0     782    31      67   245    0   537     0  2858.0
  93 Fruit 2.1             :  2700.0   13.0   657.0    1498    44      69   657    0   841     0  2753.7
  94 BitGenie 6.h64        :  2689.8   37.2   557.0     735    76      51   557    0   178     0  2476.1
  95 Monolith 0.4          :  2689.1   38.1   216.0     389    56      77   216    0   173     0  2647.1
  96 Orion 06              :  2675.4   27.5   196.0     366    54      67   196    0   170     0  2649.7
  97 Jumbo 0.7.0           :  2666.7   30.3   278.0     471    59      70   278    0   193     0  2596.9
  98 Arasan 14.1           :  2649.9   44.4   138.0     289    48      78   138    0   151     0  2665.8
  99 Galjoen 0.41.2        :  2628.2   36.0   297.0     562    53      71   297    0   265     0  2603.0
 100 Arasan 12.2           :  2619.7   33.9   392.0     668    59      59   392    0   276     0  2551.1
 101 Galjoen 0.41.1        :  2615.6   25.3   738.0    1372    54      82   738    0   634     0  2583.2
 102 Orion 05              :  2601.9   29.7   422.0     759    56      73   422    0   337     0  2556.4
 103 Arasan 13.0           :  2588.8   37.1   114.0     308    37      69   114    0   194     0  2680.2
 104 Monolith 0.3          :  2576.2   32.4   661.0    1144    58      69   661    0   483     0  2509.1
 105 Nalwald 1.8.1         :  2569.5   30.2   324.0     546    59      80   324    0   222     0  2494.7
 106 Jumbo 0.6.10          :  2556.5   24.8   678.0    1270    53      60   678    0   592     0  2522.5
 107 Marvin 2.0            :  2553.9   25.0   170.0     413    41      95   170    0   243     0  2613.0
 108 Orion 04              :  2518.0   30.7   385.0     754    51      57   385    0   369     0  2502.9
 109 Loki 3.5.0            :  2514.4   29.8   287.0     651    44      52   287    0   364     0  2552.3
 110 Foxsee 7.20.1         :  2513.8   18.0   582.0    1201    48     100   582    0   619     0  2517.7
 111 BitGenie 5.h64        :  2475.8   30.6   340.0     691    49      56   340    0   351     0  2477.0
 112 CT800 1.42            :  2474.1   26.3   605.0    1636    37      83   605    0  1031     0  2572.9
 113 Jumbo 0.5.3           :  2459.8   19.5   480.0    1148    42     100   480    0   668     0  2515.3
 114 Foxsee 7.8            :  2408.5   19.9   235.0     920    26      56   235    0   685     0  2618.2
 115 Zahak 3.0             :  2406.3   30.2   341.0     858    40      97   341    0   517     0  2479.7
 116 Orion 03              :  2380.6   28.1   293.0     884    33     100   293    0   591     0  2507.7
 117 BitGenie 5            :  2242.9   35.4   150.0     720    21     ---   150    0   570     0  2477.2
90% of coding is debugging, the other 10% is writing bugs.
lkaufman
Posts: 6217
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 6:15 am
Location: Maryland USA
Full name: Larry Kaufman

Re: what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by lkaufman »

Rebel wrote: Wed Jun 23, 2021 10:38 pm This is a raw ORDO list of the GRL 40/2 without draws.

Code: Select all

   # PLAYER                :  RATING  ERROR  POINTS  PLAYED   (%)  CFS(%)     W    D     L  D(%)  OppAvg
   1 Stockfish 13          :  4098.1   50.7  1157.0    1203    96      89  1157    0    46     0  3413.5
   2 Stockfish 21-05-18    :  4058.9   82.7   610.0     630    97      99   610    0    20     0  3335.1
   3 Stockfish 12          :  3934.3   69.2   817.0     873    94     100   817    0    56     0  3350.6
   4 Komodo-Dragon 2       :  3842.2   36.8  1276.0    1409    91      82  1276    0   133     0  3348.4
   5 Komodo-Dragon 1       :  3821.2   48.6   680.0     818    83     100   680    0   138     0  3436.3
   6 Lc0 v27               :  3680.9   53.1   307.0     412    75      85   307    0   105     0  3463.2
   7 Stockfish 11          :  3648.7   50.5   436.0     577    76      98   436    0   141     0  3408.7
   8 Stockfish 10          :  3601.3   56.8   561.0     754    74     100   561    0   193     0  3390.9
   9 Komodo 14             :  3470.9   50.6   235.0     483    49      60   235    0   248     0  3527.8
  10 SlowChess 2.6         :  3462.0   43.5   143.0     318    45      99   143    0   175     0  3575.3
  11 Anchor Engine         :  3400.0   13.0   550.0     846    65      90   550    0   296     0  3358.7
  12 RubiChess 2.1         :  3372.9   36.7   463.0    1281    36      51   463    0   818     0  3552.7
  13 Komodo 12             :  3372.6   35.9   284.0     490    58      71   284    0   206     0  3318.3
  14 Pedone 3.1            :  3359.9   41.6   723.0    1379    52      93   723    0   656     0  3376.5
  15 SlowChess 2.5         :  3335.5   34.5   429.0    1247    34      58   429    0   818     0  3535.2
  16 Komodo 11             :  3330.2   46.1   259.0     503    51      58   259    0   244     0  3326.2
  17 Igel 3.0.5            :  3325.1   36.3   434.0    1288    34      76   434    0   854     0  3532.5
  18 Ethereal 12.75        :  3313.1   36.1   367.0    1211    30      72   367    0   844     0  3560.2
  19 Ethereal 12.25        :  3301.2   41.2   213.0     617    35      72   213    0   404     0  3533.0
  20 Ethereal 12.50        :  3290.4   42.5   208.0     544    38      73   208    0   336     0  3447.1
  21 Igel 3.0.0            :  3275.9   21.5   111.0     465    24      52   111    0   354     0  3584.6
  22 SlowChess 2.4         :  3274.7   46.8   192.0     532    36      58   192    0   340     0  3475.7
  23 Ethereal 12.00        :  3269.0   55.1   204.0     656    31      58   204    0   452     0  3537.9
  24 Nemorino 6.00         :  3264.4   16.7   588.0    1406    42      97   588    0   818     0  3387.7
  25 Halogen 10            :  3240.0   14.2   955.0    1484    64      76   955    0   529     0  3132.4
  26 Beef 0.3.6            :  3233.7   15.1   627.0     952    66      59   627    0   325     0  3112.5
  27 Pedone 3.0            :  3231.3   20.0   265.0     490    54      68   265    0   225     0  3200.5
  28 Arasan 22.3           :  3224.6   25.3   668.0    1047    64      70   668    0   379     0  3119.7
  29 Berserk 4.2.0         :  3216.8   16.9   765.0    1156    66      69   765    0   391     0  3091.9
  30 Komodo 10             :  3204.7   39.0   188.0     534    35      56   188    0   346     0  3331.0
  31 Seer 2.0.1            :  3201.3   17.5   936.0    1493    63      89   936    0   557     0  3102.1
  32 Combusken 1.4.0       :  3187.1   16.8   589.0    1027    57      53   589    0   438     0  3132.2
  33 Booot 6.5             :  3185.8   23.4   413.0    1347    31      59   413    0   934     0  3432.5
  34 Clover 2.3.1          :  3182.6   18.7   698.0    1151    61      84   698    0   453     0  3102.4
  35 Lzero v27             :  3174.0   29.4   591.0     938    63      57   591    0   347     0  3075.9
  36 Winter 0.9            :  3171.4   31.9   497.0     839    59      64   497    0   342     0  3101.0
  37 Invictus r382         :  3161.1   36.3   272.0     390    70      51   272    0   118     0  3012.9
  38 rofChade 2.3          :  3160.5   30.8   413.0    1434    29      63   413    0  1021     0  3428.5
  39 Clover 2.2            :  3152.7   25.6   419.0     704    60      58   419    0   285     0  3082.4
  40 Anchor Engine         :  3150.0   13.0   907.0    1523    60      52   907    0   616     0  3090.2
  41 Danasah 8.8           :  3149.4   16.2   805.0    1496    54      57   805    0   691     0  3118.8
  42 Minic 3.04            :  3146.3   32.7   272.0     482    56      62   272    0   210     0  3098.6
  43 Stash 30.0            :  3140.7   16.2   579.0    1129    51      52   579    0   550     0  3130.3
  44 Wasp 4.50             :  3140.1   26.0   353.0     835    42      56   353    0   482     0  3201.2
  45 Berserk 4.1.0         :  3137.6   14.8   621.0    1064    58      77   621    0   443     0  3075.6
  46 Minic 3.08            :  3125.5   24.5   432.0     870    50      79   432    0   438     0  3127.4
  47 Minic 3.07            :  3110.1   29.1   403.0     732    55      73   403    0   329     0  3073.0
  48 Seer 2.0.0            :  3100.9   28.4   425.0     646    66      60   425    0   221     0  2980.2
  49 Weiss 1.3             :  3095.8   27.6   650.0    1120    58      50   650    0   470     0  3034.7
  50 Marvin 5.0            :  3095.7   11.0   579.0    1326    44      52   579    0   747     0  3141.7
  51 Orion 0.8             :  3095.2   24.2   623.0    1421    44      56   623    0   798     0  3139.4
  52 Stash 29.0            :  3093.3   30.9   407.0     889    46      72   407    0   482     0  3123.7
  53 Minic 3.06            :  3082.6   17.1   439.0     905    49      94   439    0   466     0  3094.1
  54 Berserk 4.0.0         :  3066.3   10.1   430.0     831    52      52   430    0   401     0  3054.2
  55 Vajolet2 2.8          :  3065.5   41.6   214.0     488    44      56   214    0   274     0  3110.5
  56 Monolith 2            :  3060.8   49.2   306.0     525    58      64   306    0   219     0  3002.2
  57 Berserk 3.3.0         :  3051.5   29.8   407.0     531    77      86   407    0   124     0  2824.5
  58 Koivisto 4.0          :  3025.1   26.0   256.0     691    37      61   256    0   435     0  3123.4
  59 Pirarucu 3.5.5        :  3018.5   38.4   310.0     622    50      63   310    0   312     0  3021.0
  60 Invictus r340         :  3010.6   28.2   560.0     843    66      52   560    0   283     0  2884.7
  61 Arasan 22.2           :  3009.2   36.3   156.0     637    24      67   156    0   481     0  3225.8
  62 Rodent 4.022          :  2999.7   37.7   302.0     631    48      51   302    0   329     0  3015.9
  63 Counter 3.8           :  2999.1   18.5   427.0    1077    40      72   427    0   650     0  3078.3
  64 Tucano 9.0            :  2993.0   23.5   742.0    1615    46      71   742    0   873     0  3020.1
  65 Topple 0.8.0          :  2985.7   12.0   743.0    2080    36      52   743    0  1337     0  3095.6
  66 Cheng 4.41            :  2984.9   23.9   652.0    1391    47      69   652    0   739     0  3008.8
  67 Mr Bob 1.0.0          :  2976.9   18.4   893.0    1944    46      52   893    0  1051     0  3007.7
  68 RubiChess 2.0         :  2975.7   44.7    75.0     633    12      63    75    0   558     0  3471.4
  69 FabChess 1.16         :  2967.5   21.3   635.0    1431    44      54   635    0   796     0  3012.2
  70 Seer 1.2.1            :  2965.5   26.1   280.0     700    40      56   280    0   420     0  3040.4
  71 Amoeba 3.3            :  2962.1   41.4   472.0    1124    42      55   472    0   652     0  3024.1
  72 Counter 3.7           :  2959.4   13.9   470.0    1332    35      99   470    0   862     0  3073.0
  73 Cheng 4.40            :  2906.7   38.5   365.0     950    38      98   365    0   585     0  2998.4
  74 Drofa 3.0.0           :  2868.0   30.4   460.0     765    60      85   460    0   305     0  2792.8
  75 Asymptote 0.8         :  2850.4   36.0   191.0     500    38      51   191    0   309     0  2935.9
  76 Nemo 1.01             :  2850.0   13.0   466.0    1322    35      97   466    0   856     0  2924.4
  77 Olithink 5.9.8        :  2820.5   24.5   210.0     584    36      61   210    0   374     0  2925.6
  78 Velvet 1.2.0          :  2815.1   32.6   407.0     625    65      55   407    0   218     0  2692.1
  79 Arasan 16.0           :  2813.5   25.4   453.0     765    59      58   453    0   312     0  2746.0
  80 Olithink 5.9.5        :  2810.1   31.5   199.0     497    40      66   199    0   298     0  2885.5
  81 Olithink 5.9.9        :  2800.5   33.7   205.0     615    33      55   205    0   410     0  2926.9
  82 ProDeo 3.1            :  2798.3   21.5   373.0     829    45      63   373    0   456     0  2839.2
  83 Cheese 2.2            :  2792.3   30.4   372.0     895    42      65   372    0   523     0  2859.7
  84 Olithink 5.9.3        :  2783.1   31.8   230.0     519    44      72   230    0   289     0  2828.2
  85 Orion 07              :  2769.9   21.7   383.0     732    52      53   383    0   349     0  2751.0
  86 Benjamin              :  2769.1   13.0   672.0    1138    59      92   672    0   466     0  2691.5
  87 k2 099                :  2749.1   25.6   408.0     769    53      77   408    0   361     0  2717.9
  88 ProDeo 2.2            :  2736.8   36.6   289.0     617    47      90   289    0   328     0  2758.3
  89 Dumb 1.8              :  2716.3   26.6   407.0     851    48      66   407    0   444     0  2724.5
  90 Supernova 2.3         :  2710.5   24.4   591.0    1190    50      63   591    0   599     0  2705.9
  91 Fridolin 3.10         :  2707.0   21.7   495.0     960    52      52   495    0   465     0  2687.0
  92 ProDeo 3.0            :  2706.4   31.5   245.0     782    31      67   245    0   537     0  2858.0
  93 Fruit 2.1             :  2700.0   13.0   657.0    1498    44      69   657    0   841     0  2753.7
  94 BitGenie 6.h64        :  2689.8   37.2   557.0     735    76      51   557    0   178     0  2476.1
  95 Monolith 0.4          :  2689.1   38.1   216.0     389    56      77   216    0   173     0  2647.1
  96 Orion 06              :  2675.4   27.5   196.0     366    54      67   196    0   170     0  2649.7
  97 Jumbo 0.7.0           :  2666.7   30.3   278.0     471    59      70   278    0   193     0  2596.9
  98 Arasan 14.1           :  2649.9   44.4   138.0     289    48      78   138    0   151     0  2665.8
  99 Galjoen 0.41.2        :  2628.2   36.0   297.0     562    53      71   297    0   265     0  2603.0
 100 Arasan 12.2           :  2619.7   33.9   392.0     668    59      59   392    0   276     0  2551.1
 101 Galjoen 0.41.1        :  2615.6   25.3   738.0    1372    54      82   738    0   634     0  2583.2
 102 Orion 05              :  2601.9   29.7   422.0     759    56      73   422    0   337     0  2556.4
 103 Arasan 13.0           :  2588.8   37.1   114.0     308    37      69   114    0   194     0  2680.2
 104 Monolith 0.3          :  2576.2   32.4   661.0    1144    58      69   661    0   483     0  2509.1
 105 Nalwald 1.8.1         :  2569.5   30.2   324.0     546    59      80   324    0   222     0  2494.7
 106 Jumbo 0.6.10          :  2556.5   24.8   678.0    1270    53      60   678    0   592     0  2522.5
 107 Marvin 2.0            :  2553.9   25.0   170.0     413    41      95   170    0   243     0  2613.0
 108 Orion 04              :  2518.0   30.7   385.0     754    51      57   385    0   369     0  2502.9
 109 Loki 3.5.0            :  2514.4   29.8   287.0     651    44      52   287    0   364     0  2552.3
 110 Foxsee 7.20.1         :  2513.8   18.0   582.0    1201    48     100   582    0   619     0  2517.7
 111 BitGenie 5.h64        :  2475.8   30.6   340.0     691    49      56   340    0   351     0  2477.0
 112 CT800 1.42            :  2474.1   26.3   605.0    1636    37      83   605    0  1031     0  2572.9
 113 Jumbo 0.5.3           :  2459.8   19.5   480.0    1148    42     100   480    0   668     0  2515.3
 114 Foxsee 7.8            :  2408.5   19.9   235.0     920    26      56   235    0   685     0  2618.2
 115 Zahak 3.0             :  2406.3   30.2   341.0     858    40      97   341    0   517     0  2479.7
 116 Orion 03              :  2380.6   28.1   293.0     884    33     100   293    0   591     0  2507.7
 117 BitGenie 5            :  2242.9   35.4   150.0     720    21     ---   150    0   570     0  2477.2
Not rating draws sure makes progress seem more dramatic, especially at longer time controls. NNUE added about 350 elo to Komodo per your "WILO" ratings. Eliminating draws from engine vs engine games would accomplish this, but how to do it? Simplest balanced solution is to start the game with c2 off but Armageddon rule, White wins draws, roughly fair. Or use an opening set like from S. Pohl which is on the win/draw line again with the Armageddon rule. If we just play multi-hour games on many cores with "good" openings and toss the draws, too few games remain.
Komodo rules!
Uri Blass
Posts: 10783
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 12:37 am
Location: Tel-Aviv Israel

Re: what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by Uri Blass »

In FRC CCRL rating list I still see many wins with no special opening books.
I agree that multi-hour games on many cores with longer time control may take a lot of time but it is the fair way.

Having Armageddon rule in unbalanced positions is not exactly chess and it may be possible to improve engines if the programmers know they play with Armageddon rules.
User avatar
pohl4711
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Sep 03, 2011 7:25 am
Location: Berlin, Germany
Full name: Stefan Pohl

Re: what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by pohl4711 »

lkaufman wrote: Wed Jun 23, 2021 8:47 pm
Uri Blass wrote: Wed Jun 23, 2021 6:26 pm I guess that you are going to see bigger rating improvement for the top engines if you measure in this way and it is possible to define a game that say that there are no draws because if you get a draw the game is not finished and you play another game at the same time control.
Rating games that way is called "WILO" (wins/losses) instead of "Elo", and it does offer advantages, notably no contraction of elo gains with greater time (expansion I think). If you use openings near the win/draw line (for example from S. Pohl) and rate them normally, then double the elo gain, you get a good estimate of WILO.
Correct. Additionally: In my AntiDraw Openings download, I included tools for rescoring pgn-games files with Armageddon scoring and Advanced Armageddon scoring (rare wins for Black count 2 points), that doubles the elo gain once more. But that makes only sense, when playing openings, which give white a clear advantage, like in my AntiDraw Openings.

Read more (and download the AntiDraw openings) here: https://www.sp-cc.de/anti-draw-openings.htm
User avatar
Rebel
Posts: 7296
Joined: Thu Aug 18, 2011 12:04 pm
Full name: Ed Schröder

Re: what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by Rebel »

lkaufman wrote: Wed Jun 23, 2021 11:58 pm
Rebel wrote: Wed Jun 23, 2021 10:38 pm This is a raw ORDO list of the GRL 40/2 without draws.

Code: Select all

   # PLAYER                :  RATING  ERROR  POINTS  PLAYED   (%)  CFS(%)     W    D     L  D(%)  OppAvg
   1 Stockfish 13          :  4098.1   50.7  1157.0    1203    96      89  1157    0    46     0  3413.5
   2 Stockfish 21-05-18    :  4058.9   82.7   610.0     630    97      99   610    0    20     0  3335.1
   3 Stockfish 12          :  3934.3   69.2   817.0     873    94     100   817    0    56     0  3350.6
   4 Komodo-Dragon 2       :  3842.2   36.8  1276.0    1409    91      82  1276    0   133     0  3348.4
   5 Komodo-Dragon 1       :  3821.2   48.6   680.0     818    83     100   680    0   138     0  3436.3
   6 Lc0 v27               :  3680.9   53.1   307.0     412    75      85   307    0   105     0  3463.2
   7 Stockfish 11          :  3648.7   50.5   436.0     577    76      98   436    0   141     0  3408.7
   8 Stockfish 10          :  3601.3   56.8   561.0     754    74     100   561    0   193     0  3390.9
   9 Komodo 14             :  3470.9   50.6   235.0     483    49      60   235    0   248     0  3527.8
  10 SlowChess 2.6         :  3462.0   43.5   143.0     318    45      99   143    0   175     0  3575.3
  11 Anchor Engine         :  3400.0   13.0   550.0     846    65      90   550    0   296     0  3358.7
  12 RubiChess 2.1         :  3372.9   36.7   463.0    1281    36      51   463    0   818     0  3552.7
  13 Komodo 12             :  3372.6   35.9   284.0     490    58      71   284    0   206     0  3318.3
  14 Pedone 3.1            :  3359.9   41.6   723.0    1379    52      93   723    0   656     0  3376.5
  15 SlowChess 2.5         :  3335.5   34.5   429.0    1247    34      58   429    0   818     0  3535.2
  16 Komodo 11             :  3330.2   46.1   259.0     503    51      58   259    0   244     0  3326.2
  17 Igel 3.0.5            :  3325.1   36.3   434.0    1288    34      76   434    0   854     0  3532.5
  18 Ethereal 12.75        :  3313.1   36.1   367.0    1211    30      72   367    0   844     0  3560.2
  19 Ethereal 12.25        :  3301.2   41.2   213.0     617    35      72   213    0   404     0  3533.0
  20 Ethereal 12.50        :  3290.4   42.5   208.0     544    38      73   208    0   336     0  3447.1
  21 Igel 3.0.0            :  3275.9   21.5   111.0     465    24      52   111    0   354     0  3584.6
  22 SlowChess 2.4         :  3274.7   46.8   192.0     532    36      58   192    0   340     0  3475.7
  23 Ethereal 12.00        :  3269.0   55.1   204.0     656    31      58   204    0   452     0  3537.9
  24 Nemorino 6.00         :  3264.4   16.7   588.0    1406    42      97   588    0   818     0  3387.7
  25 Halogen 10            :  3240.0   14.2   955.0    1484    64      76   955    0   529     0  3132.4
  26 Beef 0.3.6            :  3233.7   15.1   627.0     952    66      59   627    0   325     0  3112.5
  27 Pedone 3.0            :  3231.3   20.0   265.0     490    54      68   265    0   225     0  3200.5
  28 Arasan 22.3           :  3224.6   25.3   668.0    1047    64      70   668    0   379     0  3119.7
  29 Berserk 4.2.0         :  3216.8   16.9   765.0    1156    66      69   765    0   391     0  3091.9
  30 Komodo 10             :  3204.7   39.0   188.0     534    35      56   188    0   346     0  3331.0
  31 Seer 2.0.1            :  3201.3   17.5   936.0    1493    63      89   936    0   557     0  3102.1
  32 Combusken 1.4.0       :  3187.1   16.8   589.0    1027    57      53   589    0   438     0  3132.2
  33 Booot 6.5             :  3185.8   23.4   413.0    1347    31      59   413    0   934     0  3432.5
  34 Clover 2.3.1          :  3182.6   18.7   698.0    1151    61      84   698    0   453     0  3102.4
  35 Lzero v27             :  3174.0   29.4   591.0     938    63      57   591    0   347     0  3075.9
  36 Winter 0.9            :  3171.4   31.9   497.0     839    59      64   497    0   342     0  3101.0
  37 Invictus r382         :  3161.1   36.3   272.0     390    70      51   272    0   118     0  3012.9
  38 rofChade 2.3          :  3160.5   30.8   413.0    1434    29      63   413    0  1021     0  3428.5
  39 Clover 2.2            :  3152.7   25.6   419.0     704    60      58   419    0   285     0  3082.4
  40 Anchor Engine         :  3150.0   13.0   907.0    1523    60      52   907    0   616     0  3090.2
  41 Danasah 8.8           :  3149.4   16.2   805.0    1496    54      57   805    0   691     0  3118.8
  42 Minic 3.04            :  3146.3   32.7   272.0     482    56      62   272    0   210     0  3098.6
  43 Stash 30.0            :  3140.7   16.2   579.0    1129    51      52   579    0   550     0  3130.3
  44 Wasp 4.50             :  3140.1   26.0   353.0     835    42      56   353    0   482     0  3201.2
  45 Berserk 4.1.0         :  3137.6   14.8   621.0    1064    58      77   621    0   443     0  3075.6
  46 Minic 3.08            :  3125.5   24.5   432.0     870    50      79   432    0   438     0  3127.4
  47 Minic 3.07            :  3110.1   29.1   403.0     732    55      73   403    0   329     0  3073.0
  48 Seer 2.0.0            :  3100.9   28.4   425.0     646    66      60   425    0   221     0  2980.2
  49 Weiss 1.3             :  3095.8   27.6   650.0    1120    58      50   650    0   470     0  3034.7
  50 Marvin 5.0            :  3095.7   11.0   579.0    1326    44      52   579    0   747     0  3141.7
  51 Orion 0.8             :  3095.2   24.2   623.0    1421    44      56   623    0   798     0  3139.4
  52 Stash 29.0            :  3093.3   30.9   407.0     889    46      72   407    0   482     0  3123.7
  53 Minic 3.06            :  3082.6   17.1   439.0     905    49      94   439    0   466     0  3094.1
  54 Berserk 4.0.0         :  3066.3   10.1   430.0     831    52      52   430    0   401     0  3054.2
  55 Vajolet2 2.8          :  3065.5   41.6   214.0     488    44      56   214    0   274     0  3110.5
  56 Monolith 2            :  3060.8   49.2   306.0     525    58      64   306    0   219     0  3002.2
  57 Berserk 3.3.0         :  3051.5   29.8   407.0     531    77      86   407    0   124     0  2824.5
  58 Koivisto 4.0          :  3025.1   26.0   256.0     691    37      61   256    0   435     0  3123.4
  59 Pirarucu 3.5.5        :  3018.5   38.4   310.0     622    50      63   310    0   312     0  3021.0
  60 Invictus r340         :  3010.6   28.2   560.0     843    66      52   560    0   283     0  2884.7
  61 Arasan 22.2           :  3009.2   36.3   156.0     637    24      67   156    0   481     0  3225.8
  62 Rodent 4.022          :  2999.7   37.7   302.0     631    48      51   302    0   329     0  3015.9
  63 Counter 3.8           :  2999.1   18.5   427.0    1077    40      72   427    0   650     0  3078.3
  64 Tucano 9.0            :  2993.0   23.5   742.0    1615    46      71   742    0   873     0  3020.1
  65 Topple 0.8.0          :  2985.7   12.0   743.0    2080    36      52   743    0  1337     0  3095.6
  66 Cheng 4.41            :  2984.9   23.9   652.0    1391    47      69   652    0   739     0  3008.8
  67 Mr Bob 1.0.0          :  2976.9   18.4   893.0    1944    46      52   893    0  1051     0  3007.7
  68 RubiChess 2.0         :  2975.7   44.7    75.0     633    12      63    75    0   558     0  3471.4
  69 FabChess 1.16         :  2967.5   21.3   635.0    1431    44      54   635    0   796     0  3012.2
  70 Seer 1.2.1            :  2965.5   26.1   280.0     700    40      56   280    0   420     0  3040.4
  71 Amoeba 3.3            :  2962.1   41.4   472.0    1124    42      55   472    0   652     0  3024.1
  72 Counter 3.7           :  2959.4   13.9   470.0    1332    35      99   470    0   862     0  3073.0
  73 Cheng 4.40            :  2906.7   38.5   365.0     950    38      98   365    0   585     0  2998.4
  74 Drofa 3.0.0           :  2868.0   30.4   460.0     765    60      85   460    0   305     0  2792.8
  75 Asymptote 0.8         :  2850.4   36.0   191.0     500    38      51   191    0   309     0  2935.9
  76 Nemo 1.01             :  2850.0   13.0   466.0    1322    35      97   466    0   856     0  2924.4
  77 Olithink 5.9.8        :  2820.5   24.5   210.0     584    36      61   210    0   374     0  2925.6
  78 Velvet 1.2.0          :  2815.1   32.6   407.0     625    65      55   407    0   218     0  2692.1
  79 Arasan 16.0           :  2813.5   25.4   453.0     765    59      58   453    0   312     0  2746.0
  80 Olithink 5.9.5        :  2810.1   31.5   199.0     497    40      66   199    0   298     0  2885.5
  81 Olithink 5.9.9        :  2800.5   33.7   205.0     615    33      55   205    0   410     0  2926.9
  82 ProDeo 3.1            :  2798.3   21.5   373.0     829    45      63   373    0   456     0  2839.2
  83 Cheese 2.2            :  2792.3   30.4   372.0     895    42      65   372    0   523     0  2859.7
  84 Olithink 5.9.3        :  2783.1   31.8   230.0     519    44      72   230    0   289     0  2828.2
  85 Orion 07              :  2769.9   21.7   383.0     732    52      53   383    0   349     0  2751.0
  86 Benjamin              :  2769.1   13.0   672.0    1138    59      92   672    0   466     0  2691.5
  87 k2 099                :  2749.1   25.6   408.0     769    53      77   408    0   361     0  2717.9
  88 ProDeo 2.2            :  2736.8   36.6   289.0     617    47      90   289    0   328     0  2758.3
  89 Dumb 1.8              :  2716.3   26.6   407.0     851    48      66   407    0   444     0  2724.5
  90 Supernova 2.3         :  2710.5   24.4   591.0    1190    50      63   591    0   599     0  2705.9
  91 Fridolin 3.10         :  2707.0   21.7   495.0     960    52      52   495    0   465     0  2687.0
  92 ProDeo 3.0            :  2706.4   31.5   245.0     782    31      67   245    0   537     0  2858.0
  93 Fruit 2.1             :  2700.0   13.0   657.0    1498    44      69   657    0   841     0  2753.7
  94 BitGenie 6.h64        :  2689.8   37.2   557.0     735    76      51   557    0   178     0  2476.1
  95 Monolith 0.4          :  2689.1   38.1   216.0     389    56      77   216    0   173     0  2647.1
  96 Orion 06              :  2675.4   27.5   196.0     366    54      67   196    0   170     0  2649.7
  97 Jumbo 0.7.0           :  2666.7   30.3   278.0     471    59      70   278    0   193     0  2596.9
  98 Arasan 14.1           :  2649.9   44.4   138.0     289    48      78   138    0   151     0  2665.8
  99 Galjoen 0.41.2        :  2628.2   36.0   297.0     562    53      71   297    0   265     0  2603.0
 100 Arasan 12.2           :  2619.7   33.9   392.0     668    59      59   392    0   276     0  2551.1
 101 Galjoen 0.41.1        :  2615.6   25.3   738.0    1372    54      82   738    0   634     0  2583.2
 102 Orion 05              :  2601.9   29.7   422.0     759    56      73   422    0   337     0  2556.4
 103 Arasan 13.0           :  2588.8   37.1   114.0     308    37      69   114    0   194     0  2680.2
 104 Monolith 0.3          :  2576.2   32.4   661.0    1144    58      69   661    0   483     0  2509.1
 105 Nalwald 1.8.1         :  2569.5   30.2   324.0     546    59      80   324    0   222     0  2494.7
 106 Jumbo 0.6.10          :  2556.5   24.8   678.0    1270    53      60   678    0   592     0  2522.5
 107 Marvin 2.0            :  2553.9   25.0   170.0     413    41      95   170    0   243     0  2613.0
 108 Orion 04              :  2518.0   30.7   385.0     754    51      57   385    0   369     0  2502.9
 109 Loki 3.5.0            :  2514.4   29.8   287.0     651    44      52   287    0   364     0  2552.3
 110 Foxsee 7.20.1         :  2513.8   18.0   582.0    1201    48     100   582    0   619     0  2517.7
 111 BitGenie 5.h64        :  2475.8   30.6   340.0     691    49      56   340    0   351     0  2477.0
 112 CT800 1.42            :  2474.1   26.3   605.0    1636    37      83   605    0  1031     0  2572.9
 113 Jumbo 0.5.3           :  2459.8   19.5   480.0    1148    42     100   480    0   668     0  2515.3
 114 Foxsee 7.8            :  2408.5   19.9   235.0     920    26      56   235    0   685     0  2618.2
 115 Zahak 3.0             :  2406.3   30.2   341.0     858    40      97   341    0   517     0  2479.7
 116 Orion 03              :  2380.6   28.1   293.0     884    33     100   293    0   591     0  2507.7
 117 BitGenie 5            :  2242.9   35.4   150.0     720    21     ---   150    0   570     0  2477.2
Not rating draws sure makes progress seem more dramatic, especially at longer time controls. NNUE added about 350 elo to Komodo per your "WILO" ratings. Eliminating draws from engine vs engine games would accomplish this, but how to do it? Simplest balanced solution is to start the game with c2 off but Armageddon rule, White wins draws, roughly fair. Or use an opening set like from S. Pohl which is on the win/draw line again with the Armageddon rule. If we just play multi-hour games on many cores with "good" openings and toss the draws, too few games remain.
Another interesting statistic would be to measure the average game length of won games for each engine, best killer engine :)
90% of coding is debugging, the other 10% is writing bugs.
User avatar
Rebel
Posts: 7296
Joined: Thu Aug 18, 2011 12:04 pm
Full name: Ed Schröder

Re: what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by Rebel »

From the GRL 40/2 - Best Killer Engines. Based on the shortest average game length of won games for each engine.

Code: Select all

Best Killer Engines

 No. Engine               Games  Moves
  1. Marvin 5.0             559   48.6
  2. Benjamin               672   50.3
  3. Lzero v27              591   50.7
  4. Monolith 0.3           469   50.9
  5. Seer 2.0.1             880   51.1
  6. Berserk 3.3.0          407   51.4
  7. Seer 2.0.0             425   51.6
  8. Arasan 12.2            392   51.8
  9. Cheng 4.41             486   52.3
 10. Danasah 8.8            742   52.7
 11. RubiChess 2.0           75   52.9
 12. Jumbo 0.7.0            231   53.0
 13. Loki 3.5.0             268   53.0
 14. Vajolet2 2.8           214   53.1
 15. Pedone 3.0             265   53.1
 16. Stockfish 21-05-18     610   53.2
 17. Berserk 4.0.0          430   53.5
 18. Wasp 4.50              279   53.6
 19. SlowChess 2.4          192   54.2
 20. Critter 1.6            907   54.4
 21. Stockfish 11           436   54.4
 22. Komodo-Dragon 2       1233   54.4
 23. Weiss 1.3              559   54.6
 24. Komodo-Dragon          680   54.7
 25. Beef 0.3.6             627   54.9
 26. Seer 1.2.1             280   55.0
 27. Counter 3.7            470   55.1
 28. Cheese 2.2             313   55.2
 29. Marvin 2.0             170   55.2
 30. Nalwald 1.8.1          295   55.2
 31. Berserk 4.2.0          695   55.2
 32. ProDeo 3.1             373   55.2
 33. Stash 29.0             407   55.2
 34. Rodent 4.022           268   55.4
 35. Cheng 4.40             365   55.7
 36. Ethereal 12.00         204   55.8
 37. Komodo 12              284   55.9
 38. Nemo 1.01              391   55.9
 39. Koivisto 4.0           256   55.9
 40. Minic 3.04             272   56.0
 41. Combusken 1.4.0        518   56.0
 42. Berserk 4.1.0          621   56.3
 43. Clover 2.2             419   56.4
 44. Galjoen 0.41.1         738   56.4
 45. Mr Bob_1.0.0           751   56.4
 46. h6                     550   56.4
 47. Stash 30.0             524   56.5
 48. Fruit 2.1              657   56.5
 49. Orion 05               389   56.5
 50. Monolith 0.4           155   56.5
 51. Orion 03               166   56.6
 52. Arasan 2.22            156   56.7
 53. Clover 2.3.1           637   56.7
 54. Minic 3.06             439   56.7
 55. Komodo 11              259   56.8
 56. Arasan 16.0            453   56.8
 57. Jumbo 0.6.10           475   56.9
 58. FabChess 1.16          483   57.0
 59. Orion 04               216   57.0
 60. Ethereal 12.50         208   57.1
 61. Velvet 1.2.0           407   57.1
 62. Drofa 3.0.0            384   57.1
 63. Invictus r340          441   57.2
 64. Foxsee 7.20.1          360   57.3
 65. ProDeo 3.0             245   57.3
 66. Fridolin 3.10          495   57.3
 67. Arasan 13.0            114   57.4
 68. Winter 0.9             497   57.5
 69. Topple 0.8.0           652   57.7
 70. Stockfish 10           561   57.8
 71. Minic 3.07             403   57.8
 72. ProDeo 2.2             289   57.8
 73. Booot 6.5              413   58.0
 74. Komodo 14              235   58.0
 75. Counter 3.8            356   58.5
 76. Pirarucu 3.5.5         267   58.7
 77. sf13                  1094   58.9
 78. Orion 07               383   59.0
 79. Ethereal 12.25         213   59.1
 80. Dumb 1.8               407   59.3
 81. Orion 0.8              574   59.5
 82. Komodo 10              188   59.5
 83. Arasan 14.1            138   59.6
 84. Jumbo 0.5.3            313   59.6
 85. Supernova 2.3          591   59.7
 86. Amoeba 3.3             336   60.0
 87. Halogen 10             866   60.0
 88. k2 099                 408   60.2
 89. Foxsee 7.8              74   60.3
 90. Tucano 9.0             742   60.3
 91. Asymptote 0.8          191   60.3
 92. rofChade 2.3           413   60.5
 93. SlowChess 2.5          429   60.8
 94. Ethereal 12.75         351   61.1
 95. CT800 1.42             434   61.1
 96. Stockfish 12           817   62.2
 97. Pedone 3.1             705   62.6
 98. Orion 06               147   63.1
 99. RubiChess 2.1          447   63.7
100. Igel 3.0.5             415   64.5
101. Olithink 5.9.5         199   65.0
102. Igel 3.0.0             111   66.6
103. Olithink 5.9.3         230   67.1
104. Nemorino 6.00          588   68.7
105. Lc0-v27                307   87.1
Will try to the same for CCRL and CEGT.
90% of coding is debugging, the other 10% is writing bugs.
User avatar
Rebel
Posts: 7296
Joined: Thu Aug 18, 2011 12:04 pm
Full name: Ed Schröder

Re: what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by Rebel »

From the CCRL 40/15 - Best Killer Engines. Based on the shortest average game length of (a minimum of 100) won games for each engine.

Code: Select all

Best Killer Engines

 No. Engine               Games  Moves
  1. Laurifer 1.0           340   41.9
  2. Monochrome             453   48.0
  3. BACE 0.46              170   48.1
  4. Twisted Logic 0.065    224   49.1
  5. Isa 2.0.61 64-bit      138   49.2
  6. Kingfisher 1.0 64-b    101   49.7
  7. GopherCheck 0.2.2 6    185   49.8
  8. GopherCheck 0.2.3 6    337   50.0
  9. Hokus-Pokus 0.6.3      133   50.0
 10. ZCT 0.3.2500           144   50.1
 11. Apep 1.01              247   51.1
 12. K2 0.67                256   51.1
 13. Gogobello 0.10 64-b    104   51.1
 14. Alfil 11 MT            100   51.6
 15. Mint 2.3               265   51.9
 16. Sloppy 0.1.0           122   52.1
 17. Marvin 5.0.0 64-bit    195   52.1
 18. Chesley r323 64-bit    303   52.2
 19. Typhoon 1.00-358 64    123   52.2
 20. GChess IV 0.2.0        229   52.2
 21. NoC 4.20 64-bit        299   52.3
 22. Bagatur 1.8a 64-bit    112   52.4
 23. FireFly 2.5.13 64-b    108   52.4
 24. Bearded N44.2          112   52.5
 25. Glaurung 1.2.1 Crus    128   52.5
 26. Giraffe 20150828 64    137   52.5
 27. IQ23.003               148   52.5
 28. FireFly 2.5.8 32-bi    109   52.6
 29. Adam 3.3               389   52.6
 30. Chesley r323 32-bit    247   52.6
 31. FoxSEE 3.3.4 64-bit    108   52.7
 32. Wowl 1.3.8             222   52.7
 33. Franky 1.0 64-bit      270   52.7
 34. K2 0.43f               127   52.8
 35. Buzz 0.07              193   52.8
 36. Bagatur 1.8 64-bit     165   52.9
 37. Isa 2.0.83 64-bit      270   52.9
 38. Shallow 2020-09-09     219   53.0
 39. Monik 2.2.3 32-bit     122   53.1
 40. FabChess 1.11 64-bi    126   53.1
 41. Betsabe II 1.75        293   53.1
 42. FoxSEE 5.1.2 64-bit    125   53.1
 43. Atlas 2.20             121   53.2
 44. Twisted Logic 0.085    171   53.2
 45. CDrill 1800 build 4    249   53.2
 46. Kingfisher 1.1.1 64    132   53.3
 47. Monolith 0.3 64-bit    176   53.3
 48. Clever Girl r185 64    253   53.3
 49. Isa 1.9.51 64-bit      201   53.3
 50. Napoleon 1.6.0b 64-    108   53.4
 51. Mustang 4.97           156   53.4
 52. Betsabe II 1.47        336   53.4
 53. WyldChess 1.2 64-bi    158   53.4
 54. Fizbo 1.2 64-bit       118   53.5
 55. Ecce 1.0 (rev. 508)    341   53.5
 56. Atak 6.2               122   53.6
 57. NoC 19.12 64-bit       143   53.6
 58. Twisted Logic 0.080    107   53.6
 59. Betsabe II 1.30 64-    251   53.6
 60. FireFly 2.5.10         114   53.6
 61. Fizbo 1.1 64-bit       179   53.7
 62. chess22k 1.3 64-bit    247   53.7
 63. Ghost 3 64-bit         208   53.8
 64. Fizbo 1.31 64-bit 4    108   53.8
 65. Reger 0.09             273   53.9
 66. Maverick 1.0 64-bit    190   53.9
 67. Ares GB 1.1 64-bit     276   53.9
 68. Donna 3.0 64-bit       110   54.0
 69. ProDeo 1.1             111   54.0
 70. Carballo 1.6 64-bit    172   54.0
 71. Slibo 0.5.1            205   54.0
 72. Minic 0.47 64-bit      146   54.0
 73. Jabba 13032012         136   54.0
 74. Rhetoric Lite          116   54.0
 75. Napoleon 1.5.0 64-b    188   54.1
 76. Rainman 0.7.5          271   54.1
 77. Igel 1.9.0 64-bit      122   54.1
 78. Betsabe II 1.66        239   54.2
 79. Donna 1.0 64-bit       134   54.2
 80. Shield 1.2 64-bit      175   54.2
 81. Rodent IV 0.30 64-b    102   54.2
 82. Giraffe 20150908 64    395   54.3
 83. Clever Girl r160 64    304   54.4
 84. Coiled 0.4 64-bit      412   54.4
 85. Isa 2.0.45 64-bit      158   54.4
 86. PLP 1661571            262   54.4
 87. Maverick 0.60 64-bi    108   54.4
 88. K2 0.71                165   54.5
 89. Glaurung 1.2.1 Aval    113   54.6
 90. Pigeon 1.5.1 64-bit    138   54.6
 91. WyldChess 1.3 64-bi    131   54.6
 92. ProDeo 1.1 Silver      113   54.6
 93. Betsabe II 1.09c       118   54.6
 94. Bagatur 1.4e 64-bit    118   54.7
 95. ALChess 1.84           265   54.8
 96. Snitch 1.6.2 64-bit    263   54.8
 97. MORA 1.1.0             156   54.8
 98. Skiull 0.3 64-bit      216   54.8
 99. Bagatur 1.3a 64-bit    378   54.8
100. Zeus 1.29              310   54.9
101. Ares 1.005.2 64-bit    354   54.9
102. Delphil 1.9c           103   54.9
103. Mr Bob 0.9.0 64-bit    205   54.9
104. Gogobello 1.0 64-bi    241   54.9
105. Betsabe II 1.08c       116   54.9
106. Cheng 4.40 64-bit      476   54.9
107. Nemeton 1.2            165   55.0
108. Bearded 06 29_02       215   55.0
109. ProDeo 1.7             106   55.0
110. Carballo 0.5           251   55.0
111. Detroid 1.0.1 64-bi    406   55.1
112. Shield 2.0 64-bit      224   55.1
113. Dirty ACCA4 64-bit     111   55.1
114. KnightX 2.4 64-bit     151   55.1
115. Spartan 1.0            330   55.1
116. SdBC 0.5.15.1          268   55.1
117. ChessBrainVB 3.70      149   55.1
118. Dolphin 1.0 64-bit     395   55.1
119. Pedone 0.5 64-bit      148   55.2
120. Waxman 2008            272   55.2
121. FabChess 1.16 64-bi    326   55.2
122. RubiChess 2.0 64-bi    200   55.2
123. Flux 2.2.1             297   55.2
124. Maverick 1.5 64-bit    681   55.2
125. pikoSzachy 4.1         152   55.2
126. Ifrit j2.9             118   55.3
127. E.T. Chess 18.11.05    151   55.3
128. KnightX 1.97a 64-bi    201   55.3
129. iCE 0.1                140   55.3
130. FabChess 1.12.8 64-    129   55.3
131. Brutus 6.0             113   55.3
132. Sissa 2.0              258   55.3
133. Benjamin 1.0           195   55.4
134. Betsabe II 1.28 64-    119   55.4
135. Donna 2.1 64-bit       167   55.4
136. Maverick 0.51 64-bi    309   55.4
137. ChessBrainVB 3.74      351   55.4
138. Lime 62                177   55.4
139. Isa 1.9.63 64-bit      151   55.4
140. BeRoChess 1.00 64-b    197   55.4
141. Carballo 1.5 64-bit    202   55.5
142. Smash 1.0.3 64-bit     180   55.5
143. Ares 1.005.2.1 64-b    248   55.5
144. Fizbo 1.4 64-bit       117   55.5
145. Delphil 3.0 64-bit     119   55.5
146. Tigran 2.4n 64-bit     438   55.5
147. KMTChess 1.1 32-bit    108   55.6
148. Kanguruh 1.93          322   55.6
149. Defenchess 1.0 64-b    118   55.6
150. Hakkapeliitta 2.0 6    161   55.6
151. Nemeton 1.61           131   55.6
152. CM10th Warrior         155   55.6
153. Ayito 0.2.994          361   55.6
154. MadChess 1.2 64-bit    170   55.6
155. Rhetoric 0.10.d        122   55.6
156. Embla 2.0.7 64-bit     139   55.6
157. Booot 6.4 64-bit       412   55.7
158. RattateChess 1.0 No    373   55.7
159. Naum 2.2 64-bit        142   55.7
160. Adam 3.2               251   55.7
161. Jumbo 0.7.0 64-bit     348   55.7
162. Arasan 10.4            268   55.7
163. Chess Tiger 2007 Ga    117   55.7
164. Ifrit j3.8 64-bit      103   55.7
165. Seer 1.2.1 64-bit      182   55.7
166. NoraGrace 2.0 64-bi    562   55.7
167. OBender 03.2016 64-    423   55.7
168. GarboChess 3.0 32-b    206   55.7
169. Donna 3.1 64-bit       142   55.8
170. Minic 0.43 64-bit      128   55.8
171. Alex 1.96              120   55.8
172. Arasan 10.1            165   55.8
173. Carballo 1.4 64-bit    185   55.8
174. Booot 6.3.1 64-bit     196   55.8
175. RamJet 0.13            386   55.8
176. Gogobello 0.12 64-b    176   55.8
177. ShashChess 11.0 64-    451   55.8
178. Schooner 1.8 64-bit    295   55.8
179. iCE 4.0 64-bit         343   55.8
180. Isa 2.1 64-bit         178   55.9
181. FoxSEE 5.3 64-bit      168   55.9
182. nanoSzachy 3.0         104   55.9
183. Dirty 25Aug2011 64-    132   55.9
184. Toga II 1.3.4          131   55.9
185. Storm 0.6              285   56.0
186. K2 0.57                107   56.0
187. ChessKISS 1.3a 32-b    102   56.0
188. Dorky 4.8 64-bit       623   56.0
189. Cheese 1.4 32-bit      117   56.0
190. Delphil 2.7            147   56.0
191. Cupcake 1.1a 64-bit    340   56.0
192. Philou 3.5.1           204   56.0
193. Homer 2.01             263   56.0
194. Schooner 2.1 64-bit    347   56.1
195. Shallow Blue 2.0.0     332   56.1
196. LittleThought 1.00     115   56.1
197. Ethereal 8.02 64-bi    141   56.1
198. Hakkapeliitta 3.0 6    719   56.1
199. pikoSzachy 3.4         108   56.1
200. Barbarossa 0.6.0 64    228   56.1
201. ChessBrainVB 3.66      147   56.1
202. Jumbo 0.4.0 64-bit     121   56.2
203. Frenzee 3.5.19 32-b    109   56.2
204. Bagatur 2.0 64-bit     146   56.2
205. Waxman 2013            199   56.2
206. MadChess 2.0 64-bit    288   56.2
207. Wasp 4.50 64-bit       189   56.2
208. NoraGrace 1.0 64-bi    148   56.2
209. Counter 2.0.2 64-bi    172   56.2
210. EXchess 6.10b 32-bi    104   56.2
211. Jumbo 0.6.31 64-bit    188   56.2
212. Micah 1.0 64-bit       177   56.2
213. BlackBishop 0.47       112   56.2
214. Isa 2.0.48 64-bit      126   56.2
215. ChessBrainVB 3.50      161   56.3
216. Ares 1.005 64-bit      296   56.3
217. Kurt 271009            108   56.3
218. Minic 2.0 64-bit       160   56.3
219. Cheng3 1.02b           109   56.3
220. KnightDreamer 3.3      171   56.3
221. Francesca MAD 0.29     191   56.3
222. Ghost 3.1 64-bit       583   56.3
223. GarboChess 3.0 64-b    455   56.4
224. CT800 1.20 64-bit      154   56.4
225. Typhoon 1.00-348       148   56.4
226. CM10th Magic II        336   56.4
227. Dabbaba 6.52           299   56.4
228. Quark 2.35             391   56.4
229. Bagatur 1.9a 64-bit    136   56.4
230. Bagatur 2.2 64-bit     245   56.4
231. DoubleCheck 3.1 32-    118   56.4
232. CuckooChess 1.11 32    128   56.4
233. Napoleon 1.4.0 64-b    143   56.4
234. RamJet 0.12            117   56.4
235. Zevra 2.1.2 r248 64    346   56.4
236. Arasan 11.4 32-bit     106   56.4
237. Betsabe II 1.96        313   56.5
238. Mephisto Gideon Pro    208   56.5
239. Drofa 2.2.0 64-bit     113   56.5
240. Isa 1.9.68 64-bit      135   56.5
241. MORA 1.0.0             190   56.5
242. FireFly 2.5.13 32-b    121   56.5
243. Chessmaster 11 Conq    332   56.5
244. Needle 0.531           499   56.5
245. Stockfish+NNUE 1507    326   56.5
246. Scorpio 2.2 32-bit     123   56.5
247. Schooner 1.5 64-bit    197   56.5
248. Jumbo 0.6.10 64-bit    226   56.5
249. Laser 0.2.1 64-bit     163   56.5
250. TJchess 1.3 64-bit     400   56.5
251. ChessBrainVB 3.31      151   56.5
252. Gaia 3.5 64-bit        320   56.6
253. Drofa 2.1.0 64-bit     154   56.6
254. FireFly 2.5.6 32-bi    251   56.6
255. Igel 2.3.0 64-bit      118   56.6
256. Quazar 0.2 64-bit      139   56.6
257. Francesca MAD 0.25     160   56.6
258. ChessBrainVB 3.61      107   56.6
259. Pedone 3.0 64-bit      214   56.6
260. Sage 2.2a              113   56.6
261. Waxman 2016            197   56.6
262. Francesca MAD 0.21     273   56.6
263. Hedgehog 1.81 64-bi    212   56.6
264. ChessKISS 1.7c 64-b    354   56.6
265. Bearded N44.5 64-bi    311   56.6
266. ChessBrainVB 3.66 4    113   56.7
267. Abbess 2016.12.11      175   56.7
268. Chaturanga 2.4.3       371   56.7
269. Francesca MAD 0.28     174   56.7
270. Drosophila 1.6 64-b    242   56.7
271. Chiron 1.5 64-bit      312   56.7
272. MSCP 1.6h              229   56.7
273. Hedgehog 2.0 64-bit    172   56.7
274. Houdini 6 Tactical     440   56.7
275. Cupcake 1.0            137   56.7
276. Cheese 1.7 64-bit      222   56.8
277. AliChess 4.18          113   56.8
278. Booot 4.12.1           112   56.8
279. Glaurung 1.0.2 32-b    380   56.8
280. Neurosis 2.3           216   56.8
281. Dirty 0.99n            153   56.8
282. Barbarossa 0.3.0 64    110   56.8
283. Donna 4.0 64-bit       464   56.8
284. Shield 1.1 64-bit      157   56.8
285. Wasp 3.75 64-bit       240   56.8
286. Cerebro 3.03d          427   56.8
287. EXchess 5.01b 32-bi    124   56.8
288. Saruman 2017.08.10     213   56.8
289. Matilde 2008 64-bit    272   56.8
290. Pupsi2 0.06            111   56.8
291. Xiphos 0.4 64-bit      516   56.8
292. Pawny 0.2 64-bit       153   56.8
293. Alfil 12 MT            199   56.9
294. Quazar 0.3b 32-bit     368   56.9
295. GreKo 5.9              203   56.9
296. Glaurung 1.1 32-bit    106   56.9
297. Fischerle 0.9.65 64    132   56.9
298. TJchess 1.01           244   56.9
299. Soldat III 0.187 64    283   56.9
300. Arasan 18.0 64-bit     100   56.9
301. RataAeroespacial 0.    893   56.9
302. Dirty 14M-22           102   56.9
303. MadChess 2.1 64-bit    194   56.9
304. Fizbo 1.5 64-bit       179   56.9
305. Phalanx XXIII          119   57.0
306. Little Wing 0.6.0 6    107   57.0
307. OBender 3.10.1         120   57.0
308. RattateChess Bologn    228   57.0
309. Minic 0.65 64-bit      137   57.0
310. Eeyore 1.52 64-bit     422   57.0
311. nanoSzachy 3.4         258   57.0
312. EXchess 5.04b 64-bi    153   57.0
313. Minic 2.46 64-bit      186   57.0
314. Waxman 2014            274   57.0
315. Sloppy 0.2.2 64-bit    430   57.0
316. SugaR XPrO 1.2 64-b    803   57.0
317. Schooner 2.2 64-bit    589   57.1
318. Ghost 2.0.1            335   57.1
319. MinkoChess 1.1 32-b    115   57.1
320. Rhetoric 1.4.1 64-b    326   57.1
321. CeeChess 1.3.2 64-b    200   57.1
322. Ceibo 0.5 64-bit       196   57.1
323. Atak 6.0               120   57.1
324. Bagatur 1.4c 64-bit    109   57.1
325. The Baron 1.7.0        105   57.1
326. Tigran 2.3 64-bit      108   57.1
327. MatMoi 7.15.0-cct 3    173   57.2
328. Wowl 1.3.7             258   57.2
329. GreKo 2018.02 64-bi    196   57.2
330. Marvin 2.0.0 64-bit    275   57.2
331. Phalanx XXIV           311   57.2
332. Sjakk 1.1.9            159   57.2
333. Feuerstein 0.4.6       107   57.2
334. JSBam 0.52             464   57.2
335. Sting SF 19 64-bit     111   57.2
336. Typhoon 1.00-314       118   57.2
337. Hakkapeliitta 1.0 6    157   57.2
338. Deuterium 2019.2.37    311   57.2
339. Igel 2.0.0 64-bit      148   57.3
340. Francesca MAD 0.19     494   57.3
341. Kurt 0.9.2 32-bit      235   57.3
342. Raven 1.10 64-bit      230   57.3
343. OliThink 5.1.9         150   57.3
344. Nemeton 1.51           259   57.3
345. Hedgehog 1.99 64-bi    112   57.3
346. Jazz 444 32-bit        133   57.3
347. Joker 1.1.14           364   57.3
348. Gibbon 2.60a 64-bit    279   57.3
349. Wasp 4.0 64-bit        174   57.3
350. Nemo 1.0.1 32-bit      119   57.3
351. Berserk 3.2.1 64-bi    122   57.3
352. Waxman 2020            169   57.3
353. Jazz 501 32-bit        160   57.3
354. Minic 3.03 64-bit      101   57.3
355. RubiChess 1.6 64-bi    449   57.3
356. FireFly 2.6.0 64-bi    136   57.4
357. Napoleon 1.7 64-bit    309   57.4
358. Scorpio 2.8.5 MCTS     373   57.4
359. Nemorino 1.02 64-bi    201   57.4
360. KnightX 1.92           362   57.4
361. FrankWalter 2.3.5 6    220   57.4
362. Squared-chess 1.2.0    332   57.4
363. Gibbon 2.69a 64-bit    372   57.4
364. Delphil 2.8            206   57.4
365. Dabbaba 7.49          1195   57.4
366. Ethereal 8.28 64-bi    106   57.4
367. Kiwi 0.6d 32-bit       344   57.4
368. CM10th Paralyse        447   57.4
369. MadChess 1.4 64-bit    263   57.4
370. Marvin 4.0.0 64-bit    143   57.4
371. Phalanx XXII           228   57.4
372. Exacto 0.e 64-bit      346   57.4
373. SugaR XPrO 1.5.3 64    818   57.4
374. Wasp 2.01 64-bit       190   57.4
375. ProDeo 3.1             120   57.4
376. Abrok 5.0              379   57.4
377. Cheese 1.3b 32-bit     110   57.4
378. Soldat III 0.172 32    125   57.4
379. Zevra 1.8.5 r664 64    212   57.5
380. nanoSzachy 2.9         101   57.5
381. Dorky 4.3 32-bit       201   57.5
382. Devel 3.8.4            172   57.5
383. Xiphos 0.3 64-bit      199   57.5
384. Xiphos 0.3 64-bit 4    146   57.5
385. Strelka 1.0b 32-bit    134   57.5
386. Fizbo 1.5 64-bit 4C    116   57.5
387. SugaR XPro NN 1.0 6    639   57.5
388. Wasp 1.25 64-bit       167   57.5
389. Crafty 21.5 32-bit     117   57.5
390. Lodocase 240208        251   57.5
391. Loop 12.32             190   57.5
392. Protej 0.5.7           196   57.5
393. Shield 1.3.1 64-bit    294   57.5
394. Critter 1.4 32-bit     687   57.5
395. Sting SF 4.7           133   57.5
396. Godel 6.0 64-bit       247   57.6
397. Shallow 1.0 64-bit     134   57.6
398. WyldChess 1.51 64-b    460   57.6
399. Carballo 0.8           225   57.6
400. Jumbo 0.6.51 64-bit    145   57.6
401. Bagatur 1.9 64-bit     195   57.6
402. Philemon C             321   57.6
403. Grizzly 1.40.1b        301   57.6
404. Gaia 3.5 32-bit        268   57.6
405. Muse 0.899b            271   57.6
406. Sjakk 2.1 64-bit       137   57.6
407. Komodo 10.4 64-bit     918   57.6
408. Komodo 11.2 64-bit     842   57.7
409. SlowChess Blitz Cla    921   57.7
410. Smash 1.0.3            183   57.7
411. SugaR AI 1.00 64-bi    802   57.7
412. Mediocre 0.334         130   57.7
413. Counter 1.2            329   57.7
414. Dorky 4.5 64-bit       308   57.7
415. Hannibal 1.0a 32-bi    630   57.7
416. Gunborg 1.35 64-bit    308   57.7
417. Texel 1.01 32-bit      150   57.7
418. Orion 0.4 64-bit       291   57.7
419. Lozza 1.14a 64-bit     142   57.7
420. DoubleCheck 2.5.4 3    115   57.7
421. K2 0.83                166   57.7
422. Schola 1.1.0 32-bit    170   57.7
423. CuckooChess 1.10       113   57.7
424. Philou 3.7.1 32-bit    101   57.7
425. FabChess 1.14 64-bi    151   57.7
426. Neurosis 2.4           145   57.7
427. Schooner 1.7.0 64-b    215   57.7
428. Winter 0.1.1 64-bit    270   57.8
429. CM10th Lazarus         207   57.8
430. Bearded N44.2 64-bi    177   57.8
431. Ifrit m1.5 32-bit      145   57.8
432. Hiarcs 11.2            263   57.8
433. Deep Fritz 10.1 4CP    339   57.8
434. WyldChess 1.4 64-bi    208   57.8
435. Stash 21.2 64-bit      143   57.8
436. Combusken 1.4.0 64-    189   57.8
437. Godel 7.0 64-bit       319   57.8
438. Raven 0.90 64-bit      151   57.8
439. GarboChess 0.21        122   57.8
440. CM10th Guardian        143   57.8
441. Anatoli 0.35k          459   57.8
442. Marvin 3.6.0 64-bit    160   57.8
443. ECE 20.1 64-bit        303   57.8
444. ShashChess 15.0 64-   1200   57.8
445. Diablo 0.5.1           353   57.8
446. ECE 19.6.6.3 64-bit    286   57.8
447. Crafty 20.11 32-bit    107   57.8
448. Typhoon 1.00-285       124   57.8
449. Scorpio 2.9 MCTS 64    132   57.8
450. Tom Thumb 0.2 64-bi    412   57.9
451. Isa 2.0.64 64-bit      551   57.9
452. MadChess 1.3 64-bit    119   57.9
453. Micro-Max 4.8          120   57.9
454. Nawito 2103            132   57.9
455. Nemeton 1.81           316   57.9
456. Nemeton 1.6            184   57.9
457. Orion 0.2 64-bit       278   57.9
458. RedQueen 0.6           151   57.9
459. Scorpio 2.7 32-bit     255   57.9
460. Sting SF 15 64-bit     127   57.9
461. Fritz 8 Bilbao         127   57.9
462. Marvin 2.2.0 64-bit    180   57.9
463. Mr Bob 0.8.0 64-bit    184   57.9
464. NG-Play 9.86 64-bit    234   57.9
465. Ares 1.004             502   57.9
466. GreKo 12.9 64-bit      126   57.9
467. Velvet 1.1.0 64-bit    180   58.0
468. Pawny 1.1 64-bit       217   58.0
469. Wasp 2.00 64-bit       104   58.0
470. Bubble 1.5             367   58.0
471. Pupsi 0.19             109   58.0
472. Rybka 1.1 32-bit       574   58.0
473. Weiss 1.2 64-bit       412   58.0
474. Neurosis 2.5           425   58.0
475. iCE 0.2                383   58.0
476. Arasan 20.1 64-bit     159   58.0
477. ShashChess 8.0 64-b   1184   58.0
478. Nemeton 1.41           158   58.0
479. Jumbo 0.5.3 64-bit     158   58.0
480. Sting SF 3 64-bit 4    119   58.0
481. RedQueen 1.0.0 32-b    194   58.0
482. GreKo 2018.01 64-bi    160   58.0
483. Tunguska 1.1 64-bit    375   58.0
484. Sting SF 4.7 64-bit    120   58.0
485. Ethereal 8.12 64-bi    184   58.0
486. Toga II 1.4 beta5c     169   58.0
487. ProDeo 1.74            206   58.0
488. Deepov 0.4.1 64-bit    240   58.0
489. CuckooChess 1.12 32    185   58.0
490. Cheese 1.8 64-bit      287   58.0
491. Fischerle 0.9.30b 6    153   58.1
492. Bright 0.5c 4CPU       159   58.1
493. tomitankChess 1.4 6    224   58.1
494. AliChess 4.08          115   58.1
495. Tornado 4.4 32-bit     218   58.1
496. Waxman 2011            176   58.1
497. Cheese 2.2 64-bit      217   58.1
498. Gogobello 1.2 64-bi    161   58.1
499. Stash 18.0 64-bit      177   58.1
500. Deep Junior 12.5 32    358   58.1
501. EXchess 7.03b 64-bi    103   58.1
502. FireFly 2.5.12 64-b    108   58.1
503. Booot 6.3 64-bit       272   58.1
504. Ifrit j3.6 64-bit      128   58.1
505. Chronos 1.9.9 32-bi    339   58.1
506. SlowChess Blitz 2.3    243   58.1
507. Scorpio 2.7.8 64-bi    130   58.1
508. Igel 1.2 64-bit        325   58.1
509. Petir 4.999999         423   58.1
510. RomiChess P3L 64-bi    221   58.1
511. Chiron 1.5 32-bit      288   58.1
512. CyberPagno 3.0 64-b    636   58.1
513. Minic 2.33 64-bit      103   58.1
514. Counter 1.1            202   58.1
515. Delphil 2.6a           142   58.1
516. Asymptote 0.5 64-bi    279   58.1
517. Pedone 2.1 64-bit      133   58.1
518. Myrddin 0.83 32-bit    126   58.1
519. Deuterium 11.01.28.    268   58.2
520. DiscoCheck 3.7.1 64    119   58.2
521. ProDeo 1.85            128   58.2
522. RofChade 2.0 64-bit    306   58.2
523. MateFinder 9 64-bit    336   58.2
524. Scorpio 2.7.7 64-bi    422   58.2
525. Googleplex Starthin    960   58.2
526. Casper rev4 64-bit     239   58.2
527. Delphil 2.6b           100   58.2
528. Latista (Sinobyl) 1    265   58.2
529. Toga III 0.2 64-bit    173   58.2
530. Absolute Zero 2.4.4    112   58.2
531. Adam 3.1               254   58.2
532. Dabbaba 5.67           180   58.2
533. ChessBrainVB 3.03      151   58.2
534. CM9000 Default         114   58.2
535. Francesca MAD 0.30a    129   58.2
536. Carballo 1.7 64-bit    502   58.2
537. Rodent IV 022 64-bi    151   58.3
538. AdaChess 3.4 64-bit    273   58.3
539. Simplex 0.9.3 32-bi    115   58.3
540. tomitankChess 1.5 6    203   58.3
541. Enigma 1.1.4           612   58.3
542. Axolotl 1.9 64-bit     347   58.3
543. Cheng3 1.03 32-bit     112   58.3
544. Pupsi2 0.08            374   58.3
545. Prophet 2.0 64-bit     179   58.3
546. Matacz 1.1             117   58.3
547. ProDeo 1.2             393   58.3
548. Dragon by Komodo 2     262   58.3
549. Zeta Dva 0220 64-bi    181   58.3
550. Myrddin 0.85 32-bit    203   58.3
551. DanaSah 8.3            277   58.3
552. Blitzkrieg rev337 6    342   58.3
553. DisasterArea 1.54 6    282   58.3
554. LoopList 6.00          186   58.3
555. RubiChess 1.9 64-bi    280   58.3
556. BlackMamba 1.4 64-b    273   58.3
557. Stockfish 8 64-bit    1149   58.3
558. Glaurung 2 epsilon/    133   58.3
559. Matilde 2008 32-bit    107   58.4
560. Rodent II 0.9.64 64    184   58.4
561. Lozza 1.18 64-bit      471   58.4
562. Monolith 2 64-bit      283   58.4
563. Waxman 2010            284   58.4
564. Absolute Zero 2.4.0    244   58.4
565. Cheese 2.1 64-bit      257   58.4
566. AliChess 4.16          109   58.4
567. Snitch 1.6.2 32-bit    243   58.4
568. SugaR XPrO 1.4 64-b   1141   58.4
569. Pupsi2 0.09            441   58.4
570. Alfil 13.1 64-bit      410   58.4
571. Lozza 1.17a 64-bit     348   58.4
572. Pulsar 2009-9b         268   58.4
573. Squared-chess 1.3.0    305   58.4
574. Scorpio 2.02b          102   58.4
575. pikoSzachy 3.3         118   58.4
576. Stockfish 12 64-bit   1174   58.4
577. Atak 6.8               571   58.4
578. Chronos 1.9.4          100   58.4
579. Nemeton 1.1            125   58.4
580. Delphil 3.1 64-bit     136   58.4
581. Naum 2.2 64-bit 4CP    335   58.4
582. Gibbon 2.52a           487   58.4
583. Sloppy 0.2.2 32-bit    518   58.4
584. Dirty 24Apr2011 32-    113   58.5
585. Rodin 4.0              367   58.5
586. RamJet 0.14            496   58.5
587. SugaR XPrO 1.3 64-b    832   58.5
588. Philou 2.7.0           108   58.5
589. NG-Play 9.85 64-bit    133   58.5
590. DoubleCheck 2.3.1 6    119   58.5
591. Betsabe II 2020        195   58.5
592. Monarch 1.7            527   58.5
593. Chronos 1.9.6          150   58.5
594. Gandalf 7 64-bit       352   58.5
595. FrankWalter 2.2.3 6    162   58.5
596. Komodo 10.3 64-bit     582   58.5
597. Alfil 13.1 64-bit 4    109   58.5
598. NirvanaChess 2.0a 6    242   58.5
599. Hannibal 1.2 32-bit    387   58.5
600. Scorpio 1.84           114   58.5
601. Counter 3.7 64-bit     132   58.5
602. SugaR NN 1.1 64-bit   1092   58.5
603. Waxman 2015            175   58.5
604. Igel 2.4.0 64-bit      171   58.5
605. Dorpsgek Eve's Temp    720   58.5
606. Ethereal 8.37 64-bi    140   58.5
607. Arion 1.7              387   58.5
608. Asymptote 0.6.3 64-    158   58.6
609. DoubleCheck 2.1 32-    128   58.6
610. Counter 2.1.0 64-bi    160   58.6
611. Texel 1.02 64-bit      102   58.6
612. Arasan 15.6 64-bit     122   58.6
613. Arasan 18.0 64-bit     146   58.6
614. Arasan 9.5             103   58.6
615. Delphil 3.2 64-bit     541   58.6
616. Sage 3.53              411   58.6
617. FireFly 2.5.4          124   58.6
618. Weiss 0.9 64-bit       173   58.6
619. Marvin 2.1.0 64-bit    152   58.6
620. Demolito 2019-07-15    161   58.6
621. Arasan 12.3 32-bit     190   58.6
622. GarboChess 2.20 32-    380   58.6
623. Galjoen 0.40 64-bit    307   58.6
624. FrankWalter 2.4.0 6    477   58.6
625. Rhetoric 1.4.3 64-b    674   58.6
626. Ethereal 8.05 64-bi    135   58.6
627. BSC 3.9++ 64-bit       297   58.6
628. EXchess 7.18b 64-bi    267   58.6
629. Marvin 3.4.0 64-bit    267   58.6
630. WyldChess 1.1 64-bi    119   58.7
631. MadChess 2.2 64-bit    548   58.7
632. Uralochka 1.1b         392   58.7
633. Counter 3.3 64-bit     174   58.7
634. pikoSzachy Extreme     139   58.7
635. Igel 1.7.0 64-bit      131   58.7
636. SugaR 1.6.1 64-bit     659   58.7
637. Orion 0.3.0 64-bit     319   58.7
638. Jumbo 0.4.17 64-bit    172   58.7
639. Freyr 1.068 64-bit     412   58.7
640. Pharaon 3.5.1 4CPU     149   58.7
641. Zevra 2.1.1 r216 64    461   58.7
642. Deuterium 06.08.25.    156   58.7
643. Betsabe II 1.84        657   58.7
644. RuyDos 1.1.11 64-bi    256   58.7
645. Amoeba 1.2 64-bit      193   58.7
646. Arasan 16.3 64-bit     112   58.7
647. ProDeo 2.2             361   58.7
648. AdroitChess 0.3        219   58.7
649. Terra 3.4              290   58.7
650. Critter 1.2 32-bit     648   58.7
651. Cheese 1.9 64-bit      404   58.7
652. Bagatur 1.5e 64-bit    237   58.7
653. Xiphos 0.6 64-bit 4    192   58.8
654. PostModernist 1016     364   58.8
655. Djinn 1.010 64-bit     122   58.8
656. Maverick 0.2 64-bit    152   58.8
657. TJchess 0.121          326   58.8
658. Cheese 1.6.1 64-bit    187   58.8
659. Shallow r694 64-bit    367   58.8
660. Glass 1.8 32-bit       161   58.8
661. Critter 1.6 32-bit     322   58.8
662. nanoSzachy 3.1         100   58.8
663. Schooner 1.83 64-bi    185   58.8
664. chess22k 1.11 64-bi    186   58.8
665. Typhoon 1.00-358       398   58.8
666. Pedone 0.4 64-bit      150   58.8
667. Topple 0.7.4 64-bit    101   58.8
668. Rodent 1.7 64-bit      254   58.8
669. Sungorus 1.2           190   58.9
670. Marvin 3.5.0 64-bit    171   58.9
671. Booot 6.1 64-bit       197   58.9
672. Rybka 2.1 32-bit       334   58.9
673. Bison 9.6              218   58.9
674. Jumbo 0.4.34 64-bit    199   58.9
675. Cheng4 0.36a 64-bit    116   58.9
676. Demolito 2017-06-18    131   58.9
677. GreKo 7.0              147   58.9
678. pikoSzachy Extreme     121   58.9
679. RofChade 2.202 64-b    433   58.9
680. Tornado 1.0            145   58.9
681. Bruja 1.9.1 64-bit     414   58.9
682. Sting SF 3 64-bit      256   58.9
683. BBChess 1.3b           181   58.9
684. Komodo 9.1 64-bit      359   58.9
685. Weiss 1.3 64-bit       153   58.9
686. Invictus r305 64-bi    312   59.0
687. Komodo 11.3.1 64-bi   1073   59.0
688. Rodent 1.4 64-bit      187   59.0
689. Brutus 6.1             112   59.0
690. Fizbo 2 64-bit 4CPU    337   59.0
691. GreKo 2020.01 64-bi    213   59.0
692. Bestia 0.90            184   59.0
693. CM10th Default         452   59.0
694. Supernova 2.2.1 64-    151   59.0
695. Hiarcs 11              163   59.0
696. Houdini 6 64-bit      1789   59.0
697. K2 0.95                413   59.0
698. ProDeo 1.6             264   59.0
699. Pirarucu 3.3.5 64-b    315   59.0
700. Cmcchess 2.6 64-bit    346   59.0
701. Critter 1.6a 32-bit    394   59.0
702. Winter 0.5 64-bit 4    147   59.0
703. Igel 1.4.1 64-bit      157   59.0
704. Natwarlal 0.14         376   59.0
705. Fischerle 0.9.60 64    147   59.0
706. Gogobello 2.1 64-bi    253   59.0
707. Arasan 20.2 64-bit     135   59.0
708. CyberPagno 2.3 64-b    164   59.0
709. Houdini 5.01 64-bit   1155   59.0
710. Chiron 2 64-bit        402   59.0
711. Hakkapeliitta TCEC     567   59.0
712. chess22k 1.7 64-bit    164   59.0
713. Ifrit m1.8 64-bit      397   59.1
714. Atak 6.7               146   59.1
715. Capivara LK 0.09b02   1226   59.1
716. Ares GB 64-bit         610   59.1
717. Komodo 11.01 64-bit    556   59.1
718. Shallow Blue 1.1.0     450   59.1
719. ChessKISS 1.7 64-bi    293   59.1
720. Laser 1.2 64-bit       149   59.1
721. Feuerstein 0.4.6.1     329   59.1
722. Gogobello 1.3 64-bi    144   59.1
723. Atlas 3.60 64-bit      195   59.1
724. Komodo 12.3 64-bit     389   59.1
725. Orion 0.7 64-bit       160   59.1
726. KnightX 2.3 64-bit     168   59.1
727. Glass 1.6              299   59.1
728. Stockfish 2.2.2 32-    602   59.1
729. Nemeton 1.3            120   59.1
730. Fizbo 1.8 64-bit 4C    139   59.1
731. Fruit Reloaded 15th    194   59.1
732. Petir 3.95             101   59.1
733. Robocide 20170718 6    448   59.2
734. Cheese 1.5 64-bit      148   59.2
735. SugaR 1.6.1 64-bit     193   59.2
736. Twisted Logic 0.099    104   59.2
737. Hannibal 1.0a 64-bi    151   59.2
738. Francesca MAD 0.26     150   59.2
739. Philou 3.60            303   59.2
740. Alex 2.13              113   59.2
741. Cheng4 0.38 64-bit     182   59.2
742. Francesca MAD 0.20     132   59.2
743. Sting SF 4.8.4 64-b    174   59.2
744. Rhetoric 1.2 64-bit    128   59.2
745. Movei 00.8.438         348   59.2
746. SOS 5.1                653   59.2
747. Scorpio 2.9 MCTS+NN    298   59.2
748. Rybka 2.1 64-bit 4C    166   59.2
749. Ares 1.0               123   59.3
750. Pawny 0.2.2 32-bit     104   59.3
751. Bagatur 1.4d 64-bit    192   59.3
752. Movei 00.8.403         104   59.3
753. Dirty 23Mar2012 32-    102   59.3
754. Jazz 501 64-bit        117   59.3
755. GreKo 2015 64-bit      220   59.3
756. Xiphos 0.1 64-bit      196   59.3
757. Ranita 2.4             265   59.3
758. Aice 0.99.2            436   59.3
759. Dirty 11D-27           143   59.3
760. Crafty 25.3 64-bit     134   59.3
761. Arasan 22.0 64-bit     183   59.3
762. Cheese 1.1b            112   59.3
763. EXchess 7.51b 64-bi    210   59.3
764. Fischerle 0.9.50 64    128   59.3
765. Dirty 10Apr2015 64-    162   59.3
766. chess22k 1.14 64-bi    261   59.3
767. JikChess 0.01 64-bi    225   59.3
768. GreKo 7.2 64-bit       140   59.3
769. Hamsters 0.5           116   59.3
770. Dreamer 0.3.0 64-bi    163   59.3
771. GreKo 12.1 64-bit      131   59.3
772. KnightX 1.98 64-bit    163   59.3
773. MatMoi 7.15.0-cct 6    198   59.3
774. Winter 0.2 64-bit      599   59.4
775. Cheng3 1.04 32-bit     108   59.4
776. Phalanx XXV            502   59.4
777. Trace 1.37a            368   59.4
778. Delphil 1.6c           104   59.4
779. Galjoen 0.38 64-bit    270   59.4
780. Rybka 1.1 64-bit       417   59.4
781. Gibbon 2.57a 64-bit    241   59.4
782. Zeta Dva 0301 64-bi    153   59.4
783. Arasan 21.1 64-bit     171   59.4
784. Minic 0.92 64-bit      142   59.4
785. Cyrano 0.6b17 32-bi    473   59.4
786. Arasan 13.4 32-bit     121   59.4
787. Arasan 20.0 64-bit     136   59.4
788. LittleThought 1.052    848   59.4
789. Stockfish 8 64-bit     560   59.4
790. Deep Junior 11.1a 3    256   59.4
791. Fritz 10               489   59.4
792. Dirty CUCUMBER 64-b    649   59.4
793. SugaR NN 310719 64-    563   59.4
794. Rhetoric 1.0 64-bit    108   59.4
795. Fritz 17 64-bit        208   59.4
796. Deuterium 11.02.29.    161   59.4
797. Houdini 6 64-bit 4C    852   59.4
798. Cheng3 1.07 32-bit     159   59.4
799. Ethereal 8.19 64-bi    199   59.4
800. Rodent III 0.172 64    169   59.4
801. EveAnn 1.71a           251   59.5
802. Dirty 30Apr2017 64-    400   59.5
803. SlowChess Blitz 2.4    259   59.5
804. ECE 12.01              280   59.5
805. PolarChess 1.3         257   59.5
806. Andscacs 0.70 64-bi    146   59.5
807. Lozza 1.15 64-bit      187   59.5
808. Hiarcs 11.1            478   59.5
809. Fizbo 1.7 64-bit 4C    123   59.5
810. CM10th Ogre            190   59.5
811. Zeta Dva 0306 64-bi    321   59.5
812. Andscacs 0.89 64-bi    321   59.5
813. Monik 2.2.3 64-bit     251   59.5
814. nanoSzachy 4.1 64-b    417   59.5
815. Junior 10              619   59.5
816. Booot 6.2 64-bit       502   59.5
817. Combusken 1.0.0 64-    135   59.5
818. Godel 4.0.7 64-bit     331   59.5
819. Komodo 14 MCTS 64-b    235   59.5
820. Prophet3 20180811 6    507   59.5
821. Sting SF 9.99 64-bi    125   59.5
822. Prophet 2.0 32-bit     382   59.5
823. Soldat III 0.178 64    270   59.5
824. WChess 1.06            610   59.5
825. Protector 1.4.0 32-    725   59.5
826. Demolito 2020-05-14    211   59.5
827. EveAnn 1.72            504   59.5
828. Hiarcs 9               232   59.5
829. Counter 2.6 64-bit     188   59.6
830. Jazz 444 64-bit        126   59.6
831. Hiarcs 11.1 4CPU       329   59.6
832. GreKo 12.8 64-bit      118   59.6
833. Wasp 3.60 64-bit       176   59.6
834. Gogobello 1.1 64-bi    158   59.6
835. Counter 2.7 64-bit     145   59.6
836. OBender 2.11.5         101   59.6
837. Patzer 3.80            367   59.6
838. Counter 2.9 64-bit     183   59.6
839. Komodo 9.3 64-bit      474   59.6
840. K2 0.87                349   59.6
841. Marvin 3.1.0 64-bit    180   59.6
842. Komodo 12.3 64-bit     210   59.6
843. Fizbo 1.9 64-bit       472   59.6
844. Jazz 721 64-bit        339   59.6
845. FabChess 1.13 64-bi    234   59.6
846. Warrior 1.0.3          357   59.6
847. Minic 0.82 64-bit      173   59.6
848. Small Potato 0.7.0     375   59.6
849. Chessmaster 11         629   59.6
850. Andscacs 0.81 64-bi    232   59.6
851. Tytan 9.32 64-bit      253   59.6
852. Fizbo 1.8 64-bit       308   59.6
853. Rodin 2.1h             142   59.6
854. Chiron 1.5 64-bit 4    140   59.6
855. Fritz 15 64-bit        696   59.6
856. Sorgenkind 0.4         639   59.6
857. Dirty 25Aug2011 32-    182   59.7
858. nanoSzachy 4.0 64-b    380   59.7
859. Parrot 07.07.22        375   59.7
860. Komodo 12 64-bit       600   59.7
861. ChessBrainVB 3.72      419   59.7
862. Cheese 1.2             110   59.7
863. Weiss 1.0 64-bit       171   59.7
864. ProChess 1.02AD        389   59.7
865. Stockfish 1.4 32-bi    339   59.7
866. SpiderChess 070603     233   59.7
867. Achillees 1.0 64-bi    173   59.7
868. tomitankChess 4.0 6    180   59.7
869. Counter 1.0            102   59.7
870. Arminius 2013-08-10    123   59.7
871. Beowulf 2.4a 64-bit    391   59.7
872. Arasan 17.5 64-bit     105   59.7
873. Goldfish 1.13.0 64-    317   59.7
874. Brutus 8.05 32-bit     351   59.7
875. Komodo 10.1 64-bit     536   59.7
876. Sjakk 1.1.8            244   59.7
877. Zeus 1.27              214   59.7
878. Velvet 1.0.0 64-bit    210   59.7
879. Toga II 3.0 4CPU       125   59.7
880. Hiarcs X54 32-bit      109   59.7
881. Der Bringer 1.9        302   59.7
882. OBender 3.2.4.2        337   59.8
883. Roce 0.0390            179   59.8
884. Chessmaster 11 Aigl    251   59.8
885. Dorky 4.0 64-bit       109   59.8
886. KMTChess 1.2.1 32-b    283   59.8
887. Prophet3 20170909 6    143   59.8
888. Rhetoric 1.4 64-bit    130   59.8
889. BlackBishop 1.0        366   59.8
890. Stash 27.0 64-bit      104   59.8
891. Simplex 0.9.8 64-bi    473   59.8
892. Glass 1.9 64-bit       116   59.8
893. Dirty 23Mar2012 64-    119   59.8
894. RofChade 2.1 64-bit    257   59.8
895. CyberPagno 2.2 64-b    244   59.8
896. Nawito 1906            281   59.8
897. Brutus 5.4             109   59.8
898. Igel 1.1 64-bit        157   59.8
899. Combusken 1.3.0 64-    147   59.8
900. Crafty 22.1 32-bit     146   59.8
901. Thor's Hammer 2.28     253   59.8
902. Jumbo 0.6.35 64-bit    320   59.8
903. NagaSkaki 5.12         480   59.8
904. Delfi 5.2              248   59.8
905. DanaSah 7.0            155   59.8
906. Bumblebee 1.0.36898    304   59.9
907. Rodent II 0.8.7 64-    115   59.9
908. Rybka 1.2 64-bit       538   59.9
909. GreKo 10.2 64-bit      111   59.9
910. SpaceDog 0.97.7 64-    247   59.9
911. Alex 2.14a 32-bit      170   59.9
912. Napoleon 1.8 64-bit    444   59.9
913. Dorky 4.3 64-bit       147   59.9
914. ChessBrainVB 2.05      192   59.9
915. Komodo 10.2 64-bit     663   59.9
916. Komodo 10.4 64-bit     376   59.9
917. SmarThink 1.80 64-b    132   59.9
918. Defenchess 2.2 64-b    730   59.9
919. Fizbo 1.31 64-bit      161   59.9
920. Critter 1.4 64-bit     226   59.9
921. Delfi 5.1              153   59.9
922. Arasan 16.1 64-bit     103   59.9
923. Monolith 0.4 64-bit    276   59.9
924. Komodo 10 64-bit 4C    382   59.9
925. Sayuri 2018.03.06 6    209   59.9
926. Joker 1.1.06           108   59.9
927. Xiphos 0.5 64-bit      268   59.9
928. Thinker 5.2e Passiv    125   59.9
929. Parrot 07.01.16        142   59.9
930. Robin 0.983            251   59.9
931. LittleThought 1.03     289   59.9
932. Dimitri 4.99           316   59.9
933. Jumbo 0.6.96 64-bit    381   59.9
934. Fritz 9                625   59.9
935. RomiChess P3m 64-bi    156   60.0
936. Amoeba 2.6 64-bit      180   60.0
937. GreKo 2020.03 64-bi    222   60.0
938. ChessBrainVB 3.68      150   60.0
939. Averno 0.81            362   60.0
940. Booot 6.3.1 64-bit     596   60.0
941. GreKo 6.5              164   60.0
942. Atlas 3.50 64-bit      111   60.0
943. nanoSzachy 2.8         102   60.0
944. Bearded 06 29          134   60.0
945. Mediocre 0.4           179   60.0
946. Zurichess Glarus 64    136   60.0
947. Deep Junior 12 32-b    232   60.0
948. Dragon by Komodo 64   1226   60.0
949. GreKo 12.5 64-bit      108   60.0
950. Myrddin 0.83k 64-bi    108   60.0
951. Hermann 1.9            106   60.0
952. Igel 2.3.1 64-bit      161   60.0
953. Delphil 2.9a           121   60.0
954. Hamsters 0.6           273   60.0
955. Asymptote 0.1.8 64-    386   60.0
956. Stockfish 7 64-bit     738   60.0
957. KnightX 1.93 64-bit    385   60.0
958. Tornado 4.87a 32-bi    107   60.0
959. Rybka 2.2 64-bit 4C    371   60.0
960. Delphil 1.8            149   60.0
961. Xiphos 0.4 64-bit 4    110   60.0
962. Kurt 0.9.2.2 64-bit    295   60.1
963. tomitankChess 4.2 6    133   60.1
964. Raven 0.80 64-bit      149   60.1
965. RomiChess P3k 32-bi    296   60.1
966. Minic 1.09 64-bit      106   60.1
967. Halogen 9 64-bit       131   60.1
968. Bagatur 1.5f 64-bit    328   60.1
969. Amyan 1.72             822   60.1
970. Mr Bob 0.7.1 64-bit    138   60.1
971. Plisk 0.2.6 32-bit     115   60.1
972. Fizbo 1.9 64-bit 4C    180   60.1
973. Sting SF 5 64-bit      190   60.1
974. GreKo 2015-ML 64-bi    152   60.1
975. Gandalf 6              863   60.1
976. Gogobello 2.2 64-bi    217   60.1
977. Xiphos 0.6 64-bit      463   60.1
978. Shallow r688 64-bit    354   60.1
979. ShashChess Pro 1.0     416   60.1
980. Vajolet2 1.28 64-bi    206   60.1
981. Cheese 1.3             424   60.1
982. MinkoChess 1.2 32-b    448   60.1
983. Matacz 1.4             429   60.1
984. Hamsters 0.7           223   60.1
985. Stockfish 1.5.1 32-    510   60.1
986. Strelka 5.5 32-bit     533   60.1
987. Detroid 0.9.0 64-bi    542   60.1
988. Andscacs 0.62u 64-b    106   60.1
989. Combusken 1.2.0 64-    116   60.1
990. Orion 0.6 64-bit       269   60.1
991. Alfil 6.10             100   60.2
992. Cheng 4.39 64-bit      786   60.2
993. Spike 1.0a             250   60.2
994. Carballo 1.2           260   60.2
995. Protector 1.3.6 64-    189   60.2
996. Bitfoot 1.0.d9aeb43    208   60.2
997. GreKo 8.0 32-bit       147   60.2
998. Tornado 4.4 64-bit     118   60.2
999. Loop 10.32f            277   60.2
1000. FireFly 2.7.0 64-bi    442   60.2
1001. Stockfish 2.1.1 32-    586   60.2
1002. NagaSkaki 4.00         108   60.2
1003. Komodo 12.2.2 64-bi    511   60.2
1004. Betsabe II 1.05        104   60.2
1005. GreKo 5.5              104   60.2
1006. RedQueen 1.1.4 64-b    133   60.2
1007. Naraku 1.31            132   60.2
1008. OliThink 5.3.0 32-b    304   60.2
1009. Jumbo 0.6.107 64-bi    390   60.2
1010. Deep Fritz 10 4CPU     231   60.2
1011. Toga II 1.1a 32-bit    425   60.2
1012. Marvin 3.0.0 64-bit    228   60.2
1013. Amoeba 2.5 64-bit      155   60.2
1014. Daydreamer 1.5         252   60.2
1015. BugChess2 1.4.1        110   60.2
1016. Floyd 0.7 64-bit       139   60.3
1017. ECE X2                 181   60.3
1018. Glaurung 1.2.1 64-b    383   60.3
1019. Pawny 0.1.9 64-bit     103   60.3
1020. chess22k 1.4 64-bit    231   60.3
1021. KnockOut 0.7.1         595   60.3
1022. Shredder 10            794   60.3
1023. TheMadPrune 1.1.25     138   60.3
1024. Booot 4.13.1           119   60.3
1025. Igel 2.7.0 64-bit      153   60.3
1026. Devel 1.8090           172   60.3
1027. Winter 0.7 64-bit 4    100   60.3
1028. Topple 0.4.0 64-bit    176   60.3
1029. Asymptote 0.2.0 64-    203   60.3
1030. Fischerle 0.9.70 SE    188   60.3
1031. DanaSah 6.50           219   60.3
1032. Winter 0.6 64-bit 4    116   60.3
1033. Sting SF 8.1 64-bit    117   60.3
1034. Pirarucu 3.2.4 64-b    189   60.3
1035. Brutus 8.05 64-bit     255   60.3
1036. Ares 1.003a            108   60.3
1037. Komodo 13.3 64-bit     191   60.3
1038. Armageddon 2.308       315   60.4
1039. Devel 3.2.9            175   60.4
1040. RuyDos 1.0.27 64-bi    166   60.4
1041. Arasan 10.2 32-bit     219   60.4
1042. Cyclone xTreme Rage    119   60.4
1043. Octochess r4984 64-    101   60.4
1044. Schooner 2.0.34 64-    575   60.4
1045. Tytan 9.32 32-bit      169   60.4
1046. Scorpio 1.81           102   60.4
1047. Cheng3 1.05 32-bit     101   60.4
1048. K2 0.79                129   60.4
1049. Gibbon 2.01b           170   60.4
1050. RobboLito 0.21Q 32-    199   60.4
1051. chess22k 1.5 64-bit    140   60.4
1052. AliChess 4.20          116   60.4
1053. Baislicka 1.0 64-bi    333   60.4
1054. Komodo 9.2 64-bit      442   60.4
1055. EveAnn 1.62            110   60.4
1056. Hussar 0.2             113   60.4
1057. Cheng4 0.38 64-bit     132   60.4
1058. Stockfish 10 64-bit   3059   60.4
1059. Jabba 1.0 64-bit       255   60.4
1060. Deuterium 12.01.30.    152   60.4
1061. nanoSzachy 3.9         219   60.4
1062. Atlas 3.70em 64-bit    206   60.4
1063. Floyd 0.8 64-bit       260   60.4
1064. Movei 00.8.438 (10     836   60.4
1065. nanoSzachy 3.8         453   60.4
1066. GreKo 9.2 32-bit       101   60.5
1067. Beowulf 2.4a 32-bit    411   60.5
1068. RubiChess 0.8 64-bi    176   60.5
1069. Zeus 1.28              145   60.5
1070. Colossus 2007d         202   60.5
1071. Alf 1.09               215   60.5
1072. Arasan 22.1 64-bit     175   60.5
1073. Asymptote 0.8 64-bi    284   60.5
1074. Amoeba 2.1 64-bit      109   60.5
1075. Andscacs 0.62w 64-b    105   60.5
1076. Chiron 1.1a 32-bit     358   60.5
1077. BugChess2 1.9 32-bi    229   60.5
1078. Alarm 0.93.1           313   60.5
1079. Arasan 21.3 64-bit     313   60.5
1080. Rotor 0.1a             122   60.5
1081. Gull 2.2 64-bit        175   60.5
1082. Spark 1.0 32-bit       648   60.5
1083. Vajolet2 2.6.1 64-b    125   60.5
1084. Bison 8.2.4r           191   60.5
1085. Komodo 9 64-bit        414   60.5
1086. Andscacs 0.80 64-bi    210   60.5
1087. La Dame Blanche 2.0    720   60.5
1088. KnightX 1.94 64-bit    272   60.5
1089. Trace 1.35             133   60.5
1090. Donna 4.1 64-bit       545   60.5
1091. BigLion 2.23w          290   60.5
1092. Bagatur 1.5g 64-bit    198   60.5
1093. Fizbo 2 64-bit        1033   60.5
1094. Tornado 8.0 64-bit     556   60.5
1095. Vajolet2 2.8 64-bit    398   60.5
1096. Zeta Dva 0310 64-bi    350   60.5
1097. ECE 11.01              248   60.5
1098. Deuterium 10.01.27.    245   60.5
1099. RedQueen 1.1.1 32-b    101   60.5
1100. Hiarcs X50 Hypermod    120   60.5
1101. Amoeba 3.3 64-bit      109   60.6
1102. Horizon 4.3            158   60.6
1103. Tucano 8.00 64-bit     271   60.6
1104. Counter 2.8 64-bit     178   60.6
1105. Hiarcs 14              784   60.6
1106. Dirty 20Apr2013 64-    374   60.6
1107. ProDeo 1.87            153   60.6
1108. Stockfish 9 64-bit    1204   60.6
1109. Stockfish 5 64-bit     515   60.6
1110. Xpdnt 091007           519   60.6
1111. Laser 1.7 64-bit       786   60.6
1112. Booot 6.4 64-bit 4C    111   60.6
1113. Raven 1.0 64-bit       218   60.6
1114. Schola 1.1.0 64-bit    295   60.6
1115. chess22k 1.13 64-bi    236   60.6
1116. CT800 1.41 64-bit      149   60.6
1117. Arasan 11.3 32-bit     100   60.6
1118. AliChess 4.06          133   60.6
1119. Supernova 2.3 64-bi    168   60.6
1120. Wasp 3.50 64-bit 4C    185   60.6
1121. Fischerle 0.9.80 SE    320   60.6
1122. Sloppy 0.1.1           109   60.6
1123. Hiarcs 13.2            802   60.6
1124. Hiarcs 10 Hypermode    246   60.6
1125. FrankWalter 2.2.8 6    325   60.6
1126. Booot 6.0.2 64-bit     109   60.6
1127. Pedone 2.0 64-bit      229   60.6
1128. Loop 13.6 (Loop 200   1418   60.6
1129. Pupsi2 0.07            260   60.6
1130. Pepito 1.59.2 64-bi    374   60.6
1131. GreKo 12.0 64-bit      178   60.7
1132. Rodin 5.1              138   60.7
1133. Bagatur 1.7 64-bit     271   60.7
1134. Raven 0.50 64-bit      146   60.7
1135. Arminius 2017-01-01    419   60.7
1136. Zevra 1.8.6 r672 64    327   60.7
1137. Toga II 3.1.2SE        328   60.7
1138. Waxman 2009            296   60.7
1139. Counter 3.2 64-bit     276   60.7
1140. Hermann 2.0            135   60.7
1141. Komodo 13.3 64-bit     399   60.7
1142. Bobcat 3.25 32-bit     108   60.7
1143. Philou 3.1.4.1         245   60.7
1144. Chiron 3.01 64-bit     149   60.7
1145. Minic 0.40 64-bit      331   60.7
1146. RedQueen 1.1.98 64-    550   60.7
1147. Stockfish 1.2 Defau    162   60.7
1148. Fritz 12               755   60.7
1149. Booot 4.14.0           233   60.7
1150. ShashChess 4.0 64-b    356   60.7
1151. Scorpio 2.0 32-bit     374   60.7
1152. Protej 0.5.8c          380   60.7
1153. Pirarucu 3.0.7 64-b    197   60.7
1154. Texel 1.01 64-bit      221   60.7
1155. Clueless 1.4           436   60.7
1156. Fruit 2.3.1            487   60.7
1157. Nemeton 1.0            149   60.7
1158. Bagatur 1.6c 64-bit    263   60.7
1159. Lozza 2.0 64-bit       128   60.7
1160. Absolute Zero 3.3.2    123   60.7
1161. Amundsen 0.80          437   60.7
1162. Tiny Chess 1.46 64-    357   60.7
1163. Ceibo 0.6 64-bit       133   60.7
1164. Galjoen 0.36 64-bit    150   60.7
1165. Devel 2.0000           580   60.7
1166. Arasan 16.2 64-bit     100   60.7
1167. Arasan 21.4 64-bit     227   60.7
1168. Chessmaster 11 Arch    233   60.7
1169. Octochess r5506 64-    555   60.7
1170. Strelka 5.1 32-bit     497   60.7
1171. CM10th Xperience       606   60.7
1172. Roc 1.7 64-bit         130   60.8
1173. iCE 3.0 64-bit         608   60.8
1174. Cyclone xTreme         427   60.8
1175. Amateur 2.82           363   60.8
1176. Orion 0.5 64-bit       540   60.8
1177. Komodo 10.1 64-bit     497   60.8
1178. DeepSaros 3.0 32-bi    227   60.8
1179. Amyan 1.597            238   60.8
1180. Hermann 2.6 32-bit     115   60.8
1181. Eeyore 1.52 32-bit     230   60.8
1182. Houdini 1.5a 32-bit    884   60.8
1183. Protector 1.8.0 64-    308   60.8
1184. Chiron 4 64-bit       1002   60.8
1185. Komodo 12 64-bit 4C    476   60.8
1186. Monik 2.2.6 64-bit     649   60.8
1187. Topple 0.7.3 64-bit    174   60.8
1188. Protector 1.7.0 64-    337   60.8
1189. Rotor 0.7a             263   60.8
1190. Leela Chess 0.10 w3    437   60.8
1191. Critter 0.90 32-bit    570   60.8
1192. Bumblebee 1.0 64-bi    252   60.8
1193. DanaSah 6.80           125   60.8
1194. Protector 1.4.0 64-    690   60.8
1195. Jabba 1.0 32-bit       271   60.8
1196. Vajolet2 2.6 64-bit    322   60.8
1197. Heracles 0.6.16        356   60.8
1198. Alfil 8.1.1            630   60.8
1199. Ifrit j4.3             137   60.8
1200. Abbess 2018.02.07      311   60.8
1201. Tao 5.6                503   60.8
1202. Zurichess Graubuend    170   60.8
1203. CM9000 Enforcer        244   60.8
1204. Texel 1.06 64-bit      282   60.8
1205. JikChess 0.02 64-bi    523   60.8
1206. Raven 0.70 64-bit      152   60.8
1207. Fruit 05/11/03         230   60.8
1208. N2 0.1                 189   60.8
1209. Cheng4 0.36c 64-bit    377   60.8
1210. Halogen 10 64-bit      133   60.8
1211. Cheese 1.4 64-bit      318   60.8
1212. Komodo 14 64-bit 4C    200   60.8
1213. Frenzee 3.0 32-bit     242   60.8
1214. OliThink 5.3.2 64-b    408   60.8
1215. Rodent 1.2 64-bit      101   60.9
1216. Sting SF 4 64-bit      218   60.9
1217. Deep Sjeng c't 2010    803   60.9
1218. CM9000 Assassin        182   60.9
1219. Snowy 0.2 64-bit       233   60.9
1220. Sjakk 2.2 64-bit       427   60.9
1221. Myrddin 0.87 64-bit    859   60.9
1222. Movei 00.8.295         127   60.9
1223. Zeta Dva 0305 64-bi    246   60.9
1224. FireFly 2.7.2 64-bi    459   60.9
1225. Igel 1.8.3 64-bit      125   60.9
1226. Texel 1.05 64-bit 4    220   60.9
1227. AnMon 5.75             516   60.9
1228. Defenchess 2.1 64-b    123   60.9
1229. SmarThink 1.50 64-b    153   60.9
1230. Hiarcs X50             292   60.9
1231. Andscacs 0.92 64-bi    365   60.9
1232. Waxman 2017            466   60.9
1233. Scorpio 2.7.6 64-bi    491   60.9
1234. Chessmaster 11 Leon    215   60.9
1235. Pharaon 3.3            101   60.9
1236. Hamsters 0.0.6         222   60.9
1237. Alaric 704             100   60.9
1238. Hiarcs X54 Hypermod    137   60.9
1239. Dumb 1.3 64-bit        300   60.9
1240. Minic 0.98 64-bit      174   60.9
1241. Bison 9.11 64-bit      652   60.9
1242. Anechka 0.08           373   60.9
1243. Twisted Logic 20100    698   60.9
1244. Rodent 0.10            110   61.0
1245. ChessAlex 2.0r4        290   61.0
1246. K2 0.75                228   61.0
1247. Hedgehog 1.9 64-bit    399   61.0
1248. Pedone 1.5 64-bit      165   61.0
1249. NirvanaChess 2.1c 6    261   61.0
1250. Rybka 4.1 32-bit       720   61.0
1251. Rival 1.18             234   61.0
1252. KnightX 2.7 64-bit     105   61.0
1253. GreKo 2018 64-bit      653   61.0
1254. AliChess 4.25          364   61.0
1255. GreKo 10.3.1 64-bit    108   61.0
1256. Arasan 12.1 32-bit     123   61.0
1257. Scorpio 1.9            120   61.0
1258. Rybka 1.0 32-bit       606   61.0
1259. Stockfish 1.9.1 32-    532   61.0
1260. Godel 3.4.9 64-bit     563   61.0
1261. Pedone 1.0 64-bit      157   61.0
1262. Muse 0.953 64-bit      416   61.0
1263. RubiChess 1.7.1 64-    126   61.0
1264. Pawny 1.0 64-bit       329   61.0
1265. CM10th Pestilence      173   61.0
1266. Topple 0.3.5 64-bit    113   61.0
1267. Damas 9                244   61.0
1268. Apollo 1.2.1 64-bit    373   61.0
1269. Buzz 0.08 64-bit       333   61.0
1270. RuyDos 1.0.2 64-bit    111   61.0
1271. ECE X3 64-bit          502   61.0
1272. Mr Bob 1.0.0 64-bit    108   61.1
1273. Naraku 1.4             518   61.1
1274. Hannibal 1.3 32-bit    256   61.1
1275. Dirty 24Apr2011 64-    238   61.1
1276. MinkoChess 1.3 64-b    616   61.1
1277. Simplex 0.9.7 32-bi    133   61.1
1278. Rybka 1.2 32-bit       571   61.1
1279. TJchess 1.1 32-bit     110   61.1
1280. Fruit 2.2.1            638   61.1
1281. Mediocre 0.34          197   61.1
1282. Mediocre 0.5           229   61.1
1283. Arasan 22.2 64-bit     170   61.1
1284. BugChess2 1.5.1        110   61.1
1285. Gull 0.11a 32-bit      169   61.1
1286. Scorpio 1.91           528   61.1
1287. Ghost 2.0.2 64-bit     384   61.1
1288. Petir 4.39             278   61.1
1289. DisasterArea 1.65 6    645   61.1
1290. NirvanaChess 1.6 64    111   61.1
1291. EnkoChess 290818       300   61.1
1292. Deep Junior Yokoham    639   61.1
1293. Houdini 3 32-bit       405   61.1
1294. Pawny 1.2 64-bit       524   61.1
1295. Bouquet 1.8 64-bit     785   61.1
1296. Igel 2.9.0 64-bit      142   61.2
1297. Toga II 3.0            350   61.2
1298. Xpdnt 080927           166   61.2
1299. Fizbo 1.7 64-bit       186   61.2
1300. NG-Play 9.87 64-bit    323   61.2
1301. Chispa 4.0.3           424   61.2
1302. Dorpsgek Dillinger     413   61.2
1303. Hannibal 1.2 64-bit    166   61.2
1304. Combusken 1.3.1 64-    145   61.2
1305. Chenard 2018.03.06     467   61.2
1306. Sungorus 1.4 32-bit    287   61.2
1307. Chiron 4 64-bit 4CP    380   61.2
1308. Embla 1.0.2 64-bit     163   61.2
1309. EXchess 7.31b 64-bi    101   61.2
1310. Pawny 0.3 64-bit       109   61.2
1311. Rotor 0.2              114   61.2
1312. BeLL 0.0.41 64-bit     273   61.2
1313. Cyrano 0.6b17 64-bi    236   61.2
1314. Atlas 3.80 64-bit      463   61.2
1315. Arasan 19.1 64-bit     179   61.2
1316. Naum 3 32-bit          333   61.2
1317. RuyDos 1.0.22 64-bi    123   61.2
1318. Rodent III 0.281 64    162   61.2
1319. Rodin 8.0              445   61.2
1320. tomitankChess 2.1 6    216   61.2
1321. Thinker 4.7a           122   61.3
1322. Fridolin 2.00 64-bi    558   61.3
1323. OliThink 5.9.2 64-b    170   61.3
1324. Pawny 0.2 32-bit       134   61.3
1325. Hussar 0.4             430   61.3
1326. Jonny 4.00             797   61.3
1327. Spike 1.1              431   61.3
1328. Scorpio 1.8            256   61.3
1329. Philou 3.0.0           126   61.3
1330. ECE X                  135   61.3
1331. Cheng3 1.06 32-bit     105   61.3
1332. Tornado 6.0 64-bit     212   61.3
1333. RomiChess P3n 64-bi    632   61.3
1334. Deep Junior 11.2 64    162   61.3
1335. Equinox 3.20 64-bit   1117   61.3
1336. Onno 1.0 32-bit        207   61.3
1337. Amoeba 2.3 64-bit      141   61.3
1338. tomitankChess 2.0 6    393   61.3
1339. RubiChess 1.3 64-bi    451   61.3
1340. NirvanaChess 2.5 64    235   61.3
1341. Winter 0.4a 64-bit     145   61.3
1342. Murka 2 32-bit         137   61.3
1343. Arasan 10.3            203   61.3
1344. Laser 1.3 64-bit       115   61.3
1345. Houdini 2.0c 32-bit   1033   61.3
1346. Booot 4.11.1           105   61.4
1347. Pedone 0.3 64-bit      101   61.4
1348. ChessBrainVB 3.68 4    100   61.4
1349. GreKo 2018.08 64-bi    235   61.4
1350. Hamsters 0.4           120   61.4
1351. Counter 3.4 64-bit     185   61.4
1352. Komodo 13.1 64-bit     184   61.4
1353. RedQueen 0.9.8 32-b    261   61.4
1354. Junior 10.1            152   61.4
1355. Philou 3.7.1 64-bit    580   61.4
1356. TJchess 1.1 64-bit     308   61.4
1357. TSCP 1.81              417   61.4
1358. Ethereal 11.00 64-b    402   61.4
1359. Protector 1.3.2 32-    135   61.4
1360. Dragon 4.6             369   61.4
1361. Pedone 1.8 64-bit      271   61.4
1362. ChessMind 0.82         271   61.4
1363. Quazar 0.4 32-bit      596   61.4
1364. Koivisto 4.0 64-bit    271   61.4
1365. Hannibal 1.3 64-bit    382   61.4
1366. Andscacs 0.95 64-bi    934   61.4
1367. N2 0.4 32-bit          283   61.4
1368. Delocto 0.61n 64-bi    198   61.4
1369. Pedone 1.9 64-bit      231   61.5
1370. Bobcat 6.4b 64-bit     104   61.5
1371. Gibbon 2.42c           169   61.5
1372. GnuCheese 1.00 64-b    382   61.5
1373. BlackMamba 2.0 64-b    899   61.5
1374. Protector 1.3.4 32-    310   61.5
1375. Plisk 0.2.7d 64-bit    360   61.5
1376. Zevra 1.8.4 r650 64    171   61.5
1377. Bruja 1.9.1 32-bit     198   61.5
1378. Queen 4.03             340   61.5
1379. Octochess r5190 64-    566   61.5
1380. Komodo 10 64-bit      1033   61.5
1381. Twisted Logic 20080    497   61.5
1382. Winter 0.3 64-bit      164   61.5
1383. Naum 4 32-bit          628   61.5
1384. Minic 3.04 64-bit      101   61.5
1385. tomitankChess 3.0 6    393   61.5
1386. Deuterium 2019.1.36    282   61.5
1387. Rodin 6.0              166   61.6
1388. Pirarucu 2.9.5 64-b    280   61.6
1389. Dirty 0.99z            107   61.6
1390. GreKo 8.2 32-bit       163   61.6
1391. Ktulu 9                617   61.6
1392. Myrddin 0.84 32-bit    139   61.6
1393. Komodo 9.42 64-bit     346   61.6
1394. Stockfish 5 64-bit     557   61.6
1395. ProDeo 2.0             210   61.6
1396. Texel 1.04 64-bit 4    139   61.6
1397. Alfil 15.8 64-bit      307   61.6
1398. Lozza 1.16 64-bit      170   61.6
1399. Philou 2.8.0           102   61.6
1400. Stockfish 1.8 32-bi    482   61.6
1401. Caligula 0.8           337   61.6
1402. RubiChess 1.7.3 64-    380   61.6
1403. Demolito 2018-10-29    531   61.6
1404. Equinox 3.30 64-bit    439   61.6
1405. ZCT 0.3.2451           175   61.6
1406. MOBMAT 0.903d 64-bi    197   61.6
1407. Sjakk 2.0 64-bit       188   61.6
1408. Glaurung 2.0.1 32-b    321   61.6
1409. Stockfish 7 64-bit     500   61.6
1410. Elektro 1.2 64-bit     228   61.6
1411. Chronos 1.9.9 64-bi    695   61.6
1412. Twisted Logic 20071    179   61.6
1413. Deep Junior 13 32-b    268   61.6
1414. Deuterium 14.2.33.2    138   61.6
1415. Hermann 2.8 64-bit     478   61.6
1416. Zap!Chess Paderborn    475   61.6
1417. Gogobello 1.4 64-bi    384   61.6
1418. iCE 2.0 64-bit         320   61.6
1419. Murka 3 64-bit         563   61.6
1420. Rotor 0.3              112   61.6
1421. RedQueen 1.1.3 64-b    256   61.6
1422. Deep Junior 13.3 32    377   61.6
1423. ShashChess 6.0 64-b    326   61.6
1424. Stockfish 2019-10-0    305   61.7
1425. Orion 0.8 64-bit       164   61.7
1426. Andscacs 0.88 64-bi    319   61.7
1427. Drosophila 1.5.1 64    560   61.7
1428. Nemorino 5.00 64-bi    644   61.7
1429. Tornado 6.0 64-bit     112   61.7
1430. Myrddin 0.85 64-bit    212   61.7
1431. RofChade 2.3 64-bit    546   61.7
1432. Zevra 1.8.2 r612 64    137   61.7
1433. Arasan 13.0 64-bit     145   61.7
1434. Gosu 0.16              402   61.7
1435. Minic 1.39 64-bit      110   61.7
1436. Topple 0.7.2 64-bit    247   61.7
1437. Hannibal 1.1 32-bit    460   61.7
1438. Topple 0.7.5 64-bit    403   61.7
1439. DanaSah 5.06           102   61.7
1440. Naum 1.91 32-bit       396   61.7
1441. Fritz 17 64-bit 4CP    107   61.7
1442. Delfi 5.4              737   61.7
1443. Zurichess Geneva 64    143   61.7
1444. RubiChess 0.7 64-bi    283   61.7
1445. Fridolin 3.10 64-bi    609   61.7
1446. Andscacs 0.93 64-bi    550   61.7
1447. Critter 1.6a 64-bit   2309   61.7
1448. Tucano 9.00 64-bit     182   61.7
1449. Arminius 2014-01-18    210   61.7
1450. Onno 1.1.1 32-bit      242   61.7
1451. Nemorino 4.00 64-bi    439   61.7
1452. Aristarch 4.50         848   61.7
1453. Arasan 11.6 32-bit     108   61.7
1454. Comet B68              374   61.7
1455. Gaviota 0.84 32-bit    161   61.7
1456. Andscacs 0.921 64-b    776   61.7
1457. Hermann 2.8 32-bit     175   61.7
1458. Naum 3 64-bit 4CPU     354   61.7
1459. Rotor 0.8              404   61.8
1460. CuckooChess 1.09       121   61.8
1461. DanaSah 5.07           373   61.8
1462. Amoeba 2.4 64-bit      112   61.8
1463. Francesca MAD 0.24     299   61.8
1464. Ufim 8.00              100   61.8
1465. Ethereal 11.75 64-b    303   61.8
1466. Gull II b2 32-bit      197   61.8
1467. Tornado 7.0 64-bit     129   61.8
1468. iCE 0.3                149   61.8
1469. DeepSaros 4.1.6 64-    282   61.8
1470. Cyclone xTreme Fury    192   61.8
1471. Dirty ACCA4 32-bit     103   61.8
1472. Protector 1.5.0 64-    572   61.8
1473. Ethereal 7.78 64-bi    206   61.8
1474. Vice 1.0 64-bit        239   61.8
1475. Winter 0.7 64-bit      321   61.8
1476. ProDeo 1.86            113   61.8
1477. Laser 1.6 64-bit       587   61.8
1478. Critter 0.38           110   61.8
1479. Gaviota 0.84 64-bit    110   61.8
1480. BibiChess 0.5          197   61.8
1481. Butcher 1.61 32-bit    177   61.8
1482. Djinn 0.987 64-bit     129   61.8
1483. Chess Tiger 2004       113   61.8
1484. Asymptote 0.7 64-bi    218   61.8
1485. Barbarossa 0.4.0 64    449   61.8
1486. Crafty 25.6 64-bit     175   61.8
1487. Chessmaster 11 Toxi    214   61.8
1488. Deep Junior 13.3 64    503   61.8
1489. Cyclone 3.4            191   61.8
1490. Rodent 1.3 64-bit      110   61.8
1491. BugChess2 1.6.4 32-    174   61.9
1492. Asymptote 0.4.2 64-    394   61.9
1493. Glaurung 2.2 32-bit    143   61.9
1494. Toga II 1.2.1a 32-b    728   61.9
1495. Matant 5.04            406   61.9
1496. Absolute Zero 2.4.7    689   61.9
1497. Counter 3.5 64-bit     298   61.9
1498. Pooky 2.7              144   61.9
1499. Vajolet 2.48           111   61.9
1500. Brutus 7.02b           341   61.9
Cut at 1500 engines because of the char limit of a post.

Code: Select all

2350. Nemorino 6.05 64-bi    168   71.4
2351. Komodo TCEC 64-bit     327   71.9
2352. Komodo 5 64-bit        902   72.3
2353. Topple 0.1.1 64-bit    365   72.5
2354. Crafty 25.0 64-bit     113   73.3
2355. Fire 8 64-bit 4CPU     146   74.7
2356. Arasan 21.0 64-bit     323   75.7
2357. Pedone 1.6 64-bit 4    105   78.0
90% of coding is debugging, the other 10% is writing bugs.
Terje
Posts: 347
Joined: Tue Nov 19, 2019 4:34 am
Location: https://github.com/TerjeKir/weiss
Full name: Terje Kirstihagen

Re: what is the rating of engines when you do not count draws?

Post by Terje »

Rebel wrote: Thu Jun 24, 2021 12:12 pm

Code: Select all

 21. Stockfish 11           436   54.4
 22. Komodo-Dragon 2       1233   54.4
 23. Weiss 1.3              559   54.6
 24. Komodo-Dragon          680   54.7
In good company 8-)