Re: ICGA - Rybka<>Fruit, Shredder, Komodo, Chiron
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 6:29 pm
Ah, it must only be the contents of the postings that are hidden from Google, then.
Computer Chess Club
https://talkchess.com/
Did you see my post where I demonstrate how you can find postings in this forum section on Google?
Well hgm has managed to derail this thread with nonsense he could have determined with a brief search request to google with some text from inside a post here more than say one day old which will show the post at the head of google search list.
Right.chrisw wrote: ↑Sat Oct 12, 2019 8:32 pmWell hgm has managed to derail this thread with nonsense he could have determined with a brief search request to google with some text from inside a post here more than say one day old which will show the post at the head of google search list.
Deliberate derail with trivial nonsense, imo.
Please get back on topic.
it doesn’t indicate acceptance or it wasn’t acceptable?smatovic wrote: ↑Sat Oct 12, 2019 4:07 pmNo, it doesn't.chrisw wrote: ↑Sat Oct 12, 2019 3:45 pmYour comment “what Vas has done” indicates an acceptance it was ok to have dragged him as a witch into the town square and burnt him at the stake.smatovic wrote: ↑Sat Oct 12, 2019 2:04 pmHmm, imo this belongs to the EO subforum.Rebel wrote: ↑Sat Oct 12, 2019 1:03 pm viewtopic.php?f=10&t=72066
I think this post belongs in the main forum, certainly the ICGA part.
Obviously you try to rehabilitate Vas resp. try to indict other chess
programmers of what Vas has done.
My POV is immaterial, the data says he is just another programmer.
I didn’t come with any intentions. Ed’s Simex tester produced some unexpected results. We’ld recently been working on some entirely different stuff. He asked my opinion on the results. I set about trying to find the flaws, but there were none. I generated another 100,000 new test positions, other than the Don Dailey ones. Same pattern. I generated test suites split by game phase, 80,000 new test positions, same patterns.Ok, you made your and Eds intention clear. Fine.chrisw wrote: ↑Sat Oct 12, 2019 3:45 pm In the alternative, we are not witch hunters, we come from another level that says what happened in 2011 or whenever was not okay, the sorcery of which Vas was accused is more general, look, here is what we found.
What happened was not okay. We do not want to allow the contradiction to remain.
Well, no less than an esteemed and distinguished jurist and professor of International Law acting for the body which has responsibility for oversight of ICGA Ethical behaviour, produced a report censuring the ICGA process as out of order and its punishment as out of order. The ICGA under Mr Levy ignored it. It has not removed the penalty on Vas not atoned in any way for process failure. What makes you think it will do that now or that any reliance could be placed on it to investigate itself?
But I wish to point out that here on CCC you won't find a fair trial.
Here you can only rehabilitate Vas by 'another witch hunt'.
The fair and more effective way for rehabilitation would be to address this with
the ICGA, cos the ICGA was the institution that sentenced Vas.
--
Srdja