What a move 11.a3!! Aronian-Carlsen_Norway Chess 2017

[jhellis3]

This is beyond blatant trolling, and the user should be banned...

[fastgm]

this is indeed my last one, not going to asnwer to anyone here, just to do justice to the very simple single-piece endgame, which is a DEMONSTRABLE, obvious draw. (and Carlsen certainly will evaluate it like that after 1 sec., and will certainly have not the least effort in the world achieving the draw)

indeed, engines are scoring well here with white, even with a bit longer TC, but again, this is only because they fully misunderstand fortresses.

and, black can save the game ONLY through a fortress.

Top engines prefer some line like: Ba5 Na6 f4 (both Sf and Komodo seem to like that) f5 Kf2 Nb8!(engines do not see that, insetad they are moving the king) Kf3 Nd7 Bd8 Ke8 Bc7 Nf6 Be5 and now, of course, Ne4! (again, no engine sees that) Bg7 h5:

[d]4k3/6B1/2p1p3/2P2p1p/3PnP2/4PK2/6PP/8 w - - 0 10

well, that is a simple fortress DRAW, you might want to check with your engines for as long as you want.

This position is neither a fortress nor a draw.

Stockfish in combination with tablebases is incredible strong in endgames. Beyond our imagination.
I'm sorry, Lyudmil, but here you are wrong again with your claim, that this position is a simple fortress DRAW.
I would like to show you improvements for black, but there are none!

This time I took the latest Stockfish/McBrain 2.5 for analysis.

[d]4k3/6B1/2p1p3/2P2p1p/3PnP2/4PK2/6PP/8 w - - 0 10

Here the engine output:

McBrain 2.5 64 BMI2:

54/63 00:03 235.604k 62.996k +2,29 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.Bg5 Nc3 3.h3 Kg6 4.Bd8 Nd5 5.Bh4 Kf7 6.Be1 Nf6 7.Bg3 Nd5 8.Ke2 Nf6 9.Bh4 Nd5 10.Be1 Nf6 11.Kf3 Nd5 12.Bf2 Nf6 13.Ke2 Nd5 14.Bg1 Nc3+ 15.Kd2 Ne4+ 16.Ke1 Kf6 17.Bf2 Kg7 18.Bh4 Nc3 19.Bd8 Kf7 20.Kd2 Nd5 21.Ke2 Nc3+ 22.Kd3 Nd5 23.Bh4 Kg6 24.Bf2 Kf6 25.Kd2 Kf7 26.Ke2 Kf6 27.Kf3 Kg6 28.e4 Nf6 29.exf5+ exf5
55/63 00:06 388.282k 64.681k +2,29 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.Bg5 Nc3 3.h3 Nd5 4.Bd8 Kg6 5.Bh4 Kf7 6.Bg5 Kg6 7.Bd8 Kf7 8.Ke2 Kg6 9.Ba5 Kf7 10.Be1 Nf6 11.Bf2 Nd5 12.Kd3 Kg6 13.Kc2 Kf7 14.Kd2 Kf6 15.Bg3 Kf7 16.Kd3 Nf6 17.Ke2 Ne4 18.Bf2 Nf6 19.Be1 Nd5 20.Kf3 Nf6 21.Bg3 Kg6 22.Bf2 Nd5 23.Be1 Kf7 24.Ba5 Kg6 25.e4 Nf6 26.exf5+ exf5 27.Bd8 Nd5 28.g4 hxg4+ 29.hxg4 fxg4+ 30.Kxg4
56/98 07:14 31.898.089k 73.397k +5,16 1.Bh6 Ke7 2.Bg5+ Kf7 3.h3 Nc3 4.Bd8 Nd5 5.Bh4 Kg7 6.e4 Nc3 7.exf5 exf5 8.g4 Kg6 9.g5 Nd5 10.Be1 Kf7 11.Ba5 Ke7 12.Bb6 Ke6 13.Bd8 Kf7 14.Kg3 Nc3 15.Bf6 Kg6 16.Kf3 Kf7 17.Kg2 Nd5 18.Kg3 Nb4 19.Kf2 Nd5 20.Be5 Nb4 21.Kg3 Nd5 22.Bd6 Kg7 23.Kf2 Nb4 24.Ke2 Kh7 25.Be5 Nd5 26.Kd2 Kg6 27.Bb8 Kh7 28.Ke2 Kg7 29.Bd6 Nc3+ 30.Ke3 Nd5+ 31.Kd3 Kh7 32.Bb8 Nb4+ 33.Kc3 Na6 34.Be5
57/98 07:42 34.024.784k 73.580k +5,16 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.h3 Nc3 3.Bg5 Nd5 4.Bh4 Kg7 5.e4 Nc3 6.exf5 exf5 7.g4 Kg6 8.Be1 Nd5 9.g5 Kf7 10.Ba5 Ke7 11.Kg3 Kf7 12.Bd8 Nc3 13.Bf6 Nd5 14.Be5 Ne3 15.Bc7 Kg6 16.Ba5 Nd5 17.Kf3 Kh7 18.Bd8 Kg8 19.Kg3 Kh7 20.Bf6 Nc3 21.Kg2 Kg8 22.Be5 Kf7 23.Kf3 Kg6 24.Bc7 Kh7 25.Bd8 h4 26.Ba5 Nd5 27.Be1 Nc7 28.Bxh4 Kg6 29.Be1 Kh5 30.Ba5 Ne6 31.Ke3 Kh4 32.d5 cxd5 33.c6 Kxh3
58/98 11:57 53.377.191k 74.434k +5,58 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.h3 Nc3 3.Bg5 Nd5 4.Bd8 Kg6 5.Ba5 Kf7 6.Bb6 Ke8 7.Ba7 Kf8 8.Bb8 Nf6 9.Be5 Ne4 10.g4 Nc3 11.g5 Ne4 12.Bc7 Nd2+ 13.Ke2 Nc4 14.Bb8 Kf7 15.Bd6 Nb2 16.Be5 Nc4 17.Kd3 Nb2+ 18.Kd2 Ke7 19.e4 fxe4 20.Ke3 Nc4+ 21.Kxe4 Kf7 22.Bc7 Nd2+ 23.Ke3 Nb3 24.Be5 Kg6 25.Kd3 Kh7 26.Kc2 Nxc5 27.g6+ Kxg6 28.dxc5 Kf7 29.Kd3 Kf8 30.Bd6+ Kf7 31.Kd4 Kg7 32.Be5+ Kg6 33.Ke4 Kf7 34.Bd6 Kg7 35.Kd4 Kg6
59/98 12:18 55.072.619k 74.592k +5,58 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.h3 Nc3 3.Bg5 Nd5 4.Bd8 Kg6 5.Ba5 Kf7 6.Bb6 Ke8 7.Ba7 Kf8 8.Bb8 Nf6 9.Be5 Ne4 10.g4 Nd2+ 11.Ke2 Ne4 12.g5 Ke8 13.Bc7 Nc3+ 14.Kf3 Nd5 15.Bd6 Kf7 16.Bb8 Kg7 17.e4 Nc3 18.exf5 exf5 19.Bc7 Kg6 20.Be5 Nd5 21.Bf6 Nc3 22.Ke3 Kf7 23.Be5 Nd5+ 24.Kd3 Ke8 25.Kc4 Ne3+ 26.Kc3 Nd5+ 27.Kd3 Ne7 28.Bd6 Nd5 29.Ke2 Kd7 30.Kf3 Ke6 31.Kf2 Nc3 32.Kg3 Kf7 33.Be5 Nd5 34.Kf2 Ne7 35.Bd6 Nc8 36.Kf3 Kg8 37.Ke2 Kf7 38.Kd3 Ke6 39.Kc4
60/98 25:29 116.975.366k 76.492k +5,96 1.Bh6 Nc3 2.Bg5 Kf8 3.Bh4 Kf7 4.h3 Nd5 5.e4 Nc3 6.exf5 exf5 7.g4 Kg6 8.Be1 Nd5 9.g5 Ne7 10.Ba5 Kf7 11.Kg3 Kg6 12.Bc7 Nd5 13.Be5 Kf7 14.Kf3 Ne7 15.Bd6 Nd5 16.Kf2 Kg6 17.Be5 Kf7 18.Ke2 Ne7 19.Bd6 Nd5 20.Kd2 Ke6 21.Kc2 Kd7 22.Kb3 Ke6 23.Kb2 Nb4 24.Be5 Kf7 25.Kc3 Nd5+ 26.Kc2 Ke6 27.g6 Ke7 28.Kb3 Ne3 29.Kb4 Nd5+ 30.Kc4 Ke8 31.Kb3 Ne7 32.g7 Kf7 33.Kb4 Kg8 34.Ka4 Nd5 35.Ka5 Kh7 36.Ka6 Nb4+ 37.Kb7 Kg8 38.d5 Nxd5 39.Kxc6 Ne3

....

75/101 1:14:25 335.098.716k 75.036k +6,21 1.h3 Nd2+ 2.Ke2 Ne4 3.Bh6 Nc3+ 4.Kf3 Kf7 5.Bg5 Nd5 6.Bh4 Kg6 7.e4 Nc3 8.exf5+ exf5 9.g4 Nb5 10.Bf2 Nc3 11.g5 Nd5 12.Be1 Kf7 13.Ba5 Ke7 14.Kg3 Kf7 15.Bd8 Nc3 16.Bc7 Nd5 17.Be5 Ne7 18.Bd6 Nd5 19.Kf2 Nc3 20.Be5 h4 21.Ke3 Kg8 22.Kd3 Nd5 23.Ke2 Kh7 24.Kd2 Nb4 25.Kc3 Nd5+ 26.Kc4 Kg6 27.Bd6 Ne3+ 28.Kb4 Nd5+ 29.Kb3 Ne3 30.Be5 Kf7 31.Kc3 Nd5+ 32.Kd2 Ne7 33.Bd6 Nd5 34.Ke2 Ke6 35.Bb8 Ne7 36.Kd3 Kd7 37.Bd6 Ng6 38.d5 cxd5 39.Kd4 Kc6 40.Ke3 Nh8 41.Kd3 Kb7 42.Kd4 Kc6 43.Ke5 d4 44.Kxd4 Ng6 45.Kc4 Nh8 46.Kc3

[IQ]

i think lyudmil has a very keen eye, but i get the impression analysis bores him.

By his own admission he studied the position for a couple of hours and presented his analysis in dozens of posts. It does not seem to bore him, he is just - let's find a polite word - very inefficient at it.

my hesitant conclusion is that it is NEARLY a fortress; but black is a crucial tempo off. rather than stupidity, the machines here display their obstinance,

I see it the other way around. The position is a technical win for an experienced tournament player - only a miracle computeresque defense with a great number of only moves would save this position, if it would be saveable, which according to my analysis it isn't.

the stubborn tenacity with which they cling to what even very strong humans insist are ridiculous evaluations, & relentlessly maneuver until a breakthrough is created.

The engine evals are spot on in this position, close to winning. Only on very shallow depths they very rarely go astray for a brief moment - maybe that's what deluding Lyudmil. Which is kind of sad, because it shows that he is just an engine monkey with no human chess understanding at all. If he sees a score that doesn't improve for a couple of iterations he mechanically shouts: Fortress.

a near-fortress, & a true fortress -- so close in nature, so many shared traits, but the final outcome is as far apart as the strength of a chess expert, & a chess machine.

Sometimes yes, in this case no.

[Arpad Rusz]

Thanks for your analysis! It seems like this was a breakable fortress.
My guess is that the reason why the engines have to think over depth 50 to make some progress is a long king journey through a5.

The following position should be much harder to crack:
[D]4k3/1p4B1/1Pp1p3/2P2p1p/3PnP2/4PK2/6PP/8 w - - 0 1

[beram]

I do not know why Andreas suggested it is better to trade rooks: maybe because black performs much better in the rook endgame?

redid the test with SF from the position with rooks on after Kd8, and, this time, the score was 8 DRAWS, 2 white wins.

the TC was quick, but, that is how engines are tested.
you do not believe in fortresses, and I do not believe in LTC.

so that, 80% draws.
more than convincing.

only conclusion could be made is

1) the endgame is drawn
2) my assessment was 4 times better than your cumulative one
3) it would be better, instead of trying to prove the unprovable, to learn something

obviously, you have been posting only winning games, quite pitiful.

forum members, wishing to know who says the truth and who lies, might want to do some games themsleves.

below the games:

[pgn][Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.02/24 4 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
0.89/22 1} Ke8 {0.94/24 3} 14. Rc7 {0.87/23 3} Nxf2 {0.57/23 4} 15. Ke5 {0.58/
22 1} Re2 {0.56/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.68/23 1} Rxf2 {0.28/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.27/24 2
} Kd7 {0.30/27 3} 18. Rd6+ {0.29/28 1} Kc7 {0.29/30 2} 19. Rd3 {0.26/26 1} Kc6
{0.25/28 2} 20. Kd4 {0.25/28 2} Rf1 {0.25/29 3} 21. Ra3 {0.39/29 6} Rd1+ {0.31/
27 6} 22. Ke3 {0.35/26 2} Re1+ {0.23/26 2} 23. Kf3 {0.22/26 1} g6 {0.22/28 2}
24. Ra5 {0.18/29 8} Rc1 {0.22/28 2} 25. Kf2 {0.16/27 2} Kb7 {0.09/27 3} 26. Ke3
{0.10/26 1} Rc3+ {0.08/27 1} 27. Kd4 {0.10/28 3 (Kf4)} Rxg3 {0.12/27 2} 28.
Rb5+ {0.08/28 2} Kc7 {0.13/29 1} 29. Rb6 {0.08/28 1} Rf3 {0.08/29 1} 30. Kd5 {
0.06/29 13 (Ke5)} Rd3+ {0.06/29 1} 31. Ke5 {0.06/30 2} Rc3 {0.06/30 1} 32. Ra6
{0.06/30 1} Kb7 {0.06/29 1} 33. Rd6 {0.06/29 5} Kc7 {0.06/29 1} 34. Kd4 {0.06/
29 2} Rf3 {0.06/30 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1-0"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "99"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.11/22 3} 3. Kf3
{1.02/22 1} Ra3+ {1.21/22 4} 4. Be3 {0.88/21 2} Kc8 {1.14/23 3} 5. Rb1 {1.23/
22 2} e5 {0.99/23 4 (Kc7)} 6. d5 {1.19/23 1} Kc7 {1.16/23 4 (cxd5)} 7. Ke2 {1.
15/23 5 (d6+)} Ra5 {1.18/24 8 (h5)} 8. d6+ {1.08/25 2} Kc8 {1.02/28 5} 9. Rc1 {
1.13/25 2} Nf6 {1.13/28 3} 10. Rc4 {1.13/28 1} Ng4 {1.20/29 11} 11. Rc2 {1.20/
27 1} Nxe3 {1.23/30 3} 12. Kxe3 {1.19/28 2} g6 {1.11/26 3 (Kd7)} 13. f3 {1.11/
28 3 (Ke2)} Kd7 {1.10/32 4} 14. Kd3 {1.10/29 2 (Kd2)} f6 {1.10/31 3} 15. g3 {
1.23/28 5 (Ke3)} h5 {1.39/24 4} 16. Rc1 {1.48/26 4} f5 {1.50/25 4} 17. Rc3 {1.
60/23 2} Ra1 {1.59/24 4} 18. Rb3 {1.61/24 2} fxe4+ {1.75/24 2} 19. Kxe4 {1.55/
24 1} Re1+ {1.79/23 1} 20. Kd3 {1.79/27 2} Rc1 {1.79/27 1} 21. Rc3 {1.79/28 1}
Rh1 {1.81/27 1} 22. h4 {1.79/28 3} Re1 {1.81/27 1} 23. Rc4 {1.86/27 1} Rg1 {1.
86/27 1} 24. Ke3 {1.93/28 2} Ke6 {1.95/28 1} 25. Kf2 {1.89/29 2} Rd1 {1.82/26 1
} 26. Rc3 {2.07/28 3} Kd7 {2.18/25 1} 27. Ke3 {2.18/25 1} Re1+ {2.31/25 2} 28.
Kd3 {2.39/26 2} Ra1 {2.43/25 1 (Ke6)} 29. Ke4 {2.50/28 2} Ke6 {2.44/26 1} 30.
Ke3 {2.46/26 2} Re1+ {2.66/26 1 (Rg1)} 31. Kd2 {2.66/26 2} Ra1 {2.76/26 1} 32.
Rd3 {2.64/27 1} Ra2+ {2.83/26 1} 33. Ke3 {2.94/27 2} Kd7 {2.88/25 1} 34. Rb3 {
2.76/26 2} Rc2 {2.98/23 1} 35. Rb7+ {2.71/23 1} Kd8 {2.76/25 1} 36. Rg7 {3.24/
24 3 (Ke4)} Rxc5 {3.05/23 1} 37. Ke4 {3.21/24 2} Rc1 {3.29/22 1 (Rc2)} 38. Kxe5
{3.34/23 2} Re1+ {3.45/24 2 (Rc3)} 39. Kf6 {3.58/24 1} c5 {3.81/23 1} 40. Kxg6
{3.88/23 1} Re6+ {4.03/22 1} 41. Kxh5 {3.91/23 1} Rxd6 {4.20/23 1} 42. Rg4 {4.
29/21 1} Rd4 {4.14/21 1 (Kd7)} 43. Kg5 {4.47/21 1} Rd5+ {4.57/22 1} 44. Kg6 {
4.57/22 1} Rd6+ {4.72/22 1} 45. Kf5 {4.80/19 1} Ke7 {4.72/23 1} 46. Rg7+ {5.19/
22 2} Kf8 {5.27/21 1 (Kd8)} 47. Rc7 {5.47/20 1} Rd5+ {5.62/22 1} 48. Kg4 {5.97/
21 1} c4 {6.12/22 1 (Kg8)} 49. Rxc4 {7.36/26 3} Kf7 {7.54/22 1 (Rd6)} 50. f4 {
9.57/22 2 (Rc7+)} 1-0

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.12/22 5 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.10/21 1} Ra2 {1.26/21 3} 10. Kg5 {1.07/21 2} Nf6 {1.11/23 4} 11. g3 {1.23/22
2} Kd7 {0.99/22 3} 12. Kf4 {1.09/20 1} Ng4 {1.13/23 2} 13. Rb7+ {1.07/23 4} Ke8
{1.04/24 2} 14. Rc7 {0.99/24 1} Nxf2 {0.89/25 3} 15. Ke5 {0.71/25 9 (Rxc6)} Re2
{0.91/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.83/25 1} Rxf2 {1.05/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.33/23 4} Kd7 {0.
39/25 2} 18. Rd6+ {0.25/25 2} Kc7 {0.22/29 4} 19. Rd3 {0.24/29 3} Kc6 {0.29/28
2} 20. Kd4 {0.29/28 2} Rf1 {0.27/28 2} 21. Ke3 {0.24/26 1} Re1+ {0.54/26 4} 22.
Kf4 {0.22/26 2} g6 {0.22/28 2} 23. Kg5 {0.22/27 1} Kxc5 {0.20/30 2} 24. Kf6 {
0.30/31 1} Rxe4 {0.20/34 2} 25. Kxf7 {0.20/34 1} Rg4 {0.20/37 2} 26. Rf3 {0.17/
35 1} Kb5 {0.12/36 3} 27. Kf6 {0.10/33 1 (Kg7)} Kc5 {0.08/35 1} 28. Kg7 {0.08/
36 2} Kb5 {0.08/37 1} 29. Rd3 {0.08/37 1 (Kh6)} Kc5 {0.08/37 1 (Kc4)} 30. Rc3+
{0.08/36 1} Kb4 {0.08/38 2} 31. Re3 {0.08/38 1} Kc4 {0.08/39 1} 32. Kh6 {0.08/
38 1} Kd5 {0.08/36 1} 33. Rd3+ {0.08/32 2 (Ra3)} Ke5 {0.08/34 1} 34. Rf3 {0.08/
36 2} Ke6 {0.08/36 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "170"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.11/22 3} 3. Kf3
{1.02/22 1} Ra3+ {1.21/22 4} 4. Be3 {0.88/21 1} Kc8 {1.14/23 3} 5. Rb1 {1.23/
22 2} e5 {0.99/23 4 (Kc7)} 6. d5 {1.19/23 1} Kc7 {1.16/23 4 (cxd5)} 7. Ke2 {1.
15/23 5 (d6+)} Ra5 {1.18/24 8 (h5)} 8. d6+ {1.08/25 2} Kc8 {1.02/28 5} 9. Rc1 {
1.13/25 2} Nf6 {1.13/28 3} 10. Rc4 {1.13/28 1} Ng4 {1.20/29 11} 11. Rc2 {1.22/
28 2} Nxe3 {1.18/29 2} 12. Kxe3 {1.14/30 1} f6 {1.12/30 2} 13. f3 {1.12/31 3}
Kd7 {1.44/31 7} 14. Kf2 {1.43/30 1} g6 {1.37/34 2} 15. g4 {1.37/35 2} Ke6 {1.
37/35 2} 16. h4 {1.37/36 2} Kd7 {1.62/37 6} 17. h5 {1.61/29 1} g5 {1.49/32 2}
18. Rc1 {1.37/35 1} Ra2+ {1.37/35 2} 19. Ke3 {1.37/37 1 (Kg3)} Ra3+ {1.37/37 1}
20. Ke2 {1.37/39 2} Ra2+ {1.37/39 1} 21. Kd3 {1.37/40 2} Ra5 {1.37/40 2 (Ra3+)}
22. Kc4 {1.37/40 3 (Rc3)} Ra4+ {1.37/41 1} 23. Kb3 {1.37/42 2} Ra5 {1.37/43 2}
24. Kb4 {1.37/44 3} Ra8 {1.37/42 1} 25. Rc2 {1.37/41 1 (Rf1)} Ra1 {1.37/40 1}
26. Kc4 {1.37/37 2 (Rb2)} Ra4+ {1.37/38 1} 27. Kc3 {1.37/38 1} Ra5 {1.37/39 1
(Ra3+)} 28. Kd3 {1.37/39 1 (Kd2)} Ra3+ {1.37/39 1 (Rb5)} 29. Ke2 {1.37/40 2}
Ra5 {1.37/41 1} 30. Rc3 {1.37/41 2} Ke6 {1.37/36 1 (Ra2+)} 31. Kd3 {1.37/35 1
(Rc4)} Kd7 {1.37/40 1} 32. Kd2 {1.37/40 1 (Kc4)} Ke6 {1.37/41 1 (Ra2+)} 33. Rc4
{1.37/42 1} Kd7 {1.37/43 2} 34. Rc1 {1.37/44 2} Ke6 {1.37/35 1 (Ra2+)} 35. Ke2
{1.37/39 2} Ra2+ {1.37/40 1} 36. Kd3 {1.37/40 4} Ra3+ {1.37/40 1} 37. Kc4 {1.
37/37 2 (Rc3)} Ra4+ {1.37/39 1} 38. Kc3 {1.37/40 1} Ra5 {1.37/41 1} 39. Kb4 {
1.37/41 2} Ra7 {1.37/42 1} 40. Rc2 {1.37/40 1 (Rc3)} Ra1 {1.37/40 1} 41. Kb3 {
1.37/39 1} Ra5 {1.37/39 1} 42. Kc4 {1.37/40 2} Ra4+ {1.37/40 1} 43. Kd3 {1.37/
40 4} Ra5 {1.37/43 1} 44. Ke3 {1.37/43 3} Kd7 {1.37/43 1} 45. Kf2 {1.30/34 1}
Rb5 {1.30/37 1} 46. Kg2 {1.30/38 3 (Rc1)} Ra5 {1.30/38 1} 47. Kg3 {1.30/37 1
(Rc1)} Rb5 {1.30/39 1} 48. Rc1 {1.23/32 1} Ra5 {1.23/36 2} 49. Rc3 {1.37/35 5}
Rb5 {1.18/32 1} 50. Rc2 {0.56/31 2 (Rc1)} Ra5 {0.93/34 1} 51. Rc1 {0.50/33 2}
Ke6 {0.50/36 1} 52. Kh2 {0.50/35 1 (Kf2)} Ra2+ {0.50/37 1} 53. Kg1 {0.50/36 1
(Kh3)} Ra5 {0.90/38 1} 54. Rc3 {0.50/38 1} Kd7 {0.50/40 1} 55. Kf2 {0.50/39 1}
Ke6 {0.50/30 1} 56. Ke2 {0.42/33 1 (Kg1)} Kd7 {0.50/32 1} 57. Kd3 {0.42/30 1
(Ke1)} Ke6 {0.41/32 2} 58. Kd2 {0.31/31 1 (Ke3)} Ra2+ {0.31/32 1 (Kd7)} 59. Rc2
{0.31/32 1 (Kc1)} Ra5 {0.31/34 1} 60. Kc1 {0.27/28 1 (Rb2)} Ra3 {0.27/30 1} 61.
Rd2 {0.26/29 2 (Kb1)} Kd7 {0.26/30 1} 62. Rb2 {0.25/31 3} Rc3+ {0.25/31 1} 63.
Kd2 {0.25/30 1} Rxc5 {0.25/33 1} 64. Rb7+ {0.24/31 1} Kxd6 {0.24/33 1} 65. Rh7
{0.24/33 1} Rb5 {0.24/33 1} 66. Rxh6 {0.24/33 1} Ke6 {0.24/34 1} 67. Kc3 {0.24/
30 1 (Rh8)} Rb1 {0.24/33 1} 68. Kd3 {0.24/33 1} Rb3+ {0.24/34 1} 69. Ke2 {0.24/
36 2} c5 {0.24/35 2 (Rb2+)} 70. Rh7 {0.24/35 2} Rb2+ {0.24/36 1} 71. Ke3 {0.24/
33 1} Rb3+ {0.24/34 1} 72. Kf2 {0.24/32 1} Rc3 {0.24/33 1} 73. Ra7 {0.24/30 1
(Rc7)} c4 {0.24/31 1 (Rc2+)} 74. Ra2 {0.24/31 1} Rb3 {0.24/31 1} 75. Rc2 {0.24/
31 1} Rb4 {0.24/33 1} 76. Ke3 {0.16/31 2} Ra4 {0.16/32 1} 77. Rd2 {0.16/32 1
(Kd2)} Ra3+ {0.24/33 1} 78. Kf2 {0.08/33 6} Ra1 {0.00/29 1} 79. Rc2 {0.00/28 1}
Ra4 {0.00/30 1} 80. Rd2 {0.00/32 1 (Rb2)} Ra1 {0.00/42 1} 81. Ke2 {0.08/32 2
(Rc2)} Ra4 {0.07/31 2} 82. Rb2 {0.04/30 1} Ra6 {0.04/31 1} 83. Rc2 {0.04/31 1}
Ra4 {0.00/33 1} 84. Ke3 {0.00/30 1 (Kd2)} Ra3+ {0.00/47 1 (Kd6)} 85. Ke2 {0.00/
52 1 (Kf2)} Ra4 {0.00/54 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1-0"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "77"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.11/22 3} 3. Kf3
{1.02/22 1} Ra3+ {1.21/22 4} 4. Be3 {0.88/21 2} Kc8 {1.14/23 3} 5. Rb1 {1.23/
22 2} e5 {0.99/23 4 (Kc7)} 6. d5 {1.19/23 1} Kc7 {1.16/23 4 (cxd5)} 7. Ke2 {1.
15/23 5 (d6+)} Ra5 {1.18/24 8 (h5)} 8. d6+ {1.08/25 2} Kc8 {1.02/28 5} 9. Rc1 {
1.13/25 2} Nf6 {1.13/28 3} 10. Rc4 {1.13/28 1} Ng4 {1.20/29 11} 11. Rc2 {1.20/
28 1} Nxe3 {1.18/29 5} 12. Kxe3 {1.17/28 1} f6 {1.12/31 2} 13. f3 {1.12/29 2}
Kd7 {1.12/34 3} 14. Kd3 {1.12/30 1 (Kf2)} g6 {1.12/31 2} 15. Ke3 {1.11/30 1}
Ke6 {1.25/31 8} 16. Kf2 {1.37/27 1 (Ke2)} Kd7 {1.41/26 3} 17. Kg3 {1.38/26 2}
Kc8 {1.28/27 2} 18. Rc3 {1.17/25 4} Ra4 {1.47/24 1} 19. Kh3 {1.52/26 2} Ra5 {
1.52/27 2} 20. f4 {1.41/28 6} exf4 {1.40/27 2 (Ra4)} 21. Kg4 {1.45/28 3} Kd7 {
1.56/23 1} 22. Kxf4 {1.58/27 2} h5 {1.51/26 1 (Rb5)} 23. h4 {1.78/25 2} Ke6 {
1.93/24 2 (Rb5)} 24. Rd3 {2.02/26 2} Kd7 {2.18/24 1} 25. Rg3 {2.03/25 2} Ke6 {
2.03/25 1} 26. Rxg6 {2.20/23 1} Rxc5 {2.22/24 1} 27. d7 {2.29/23 1} Kxd7 {1.89/
22 1} 28. Rxf6 {2.27/23 2} Rc2 {2.18/22 1} 29. g3 {2.34/24 2} c5 {2.12/23 1}
30. Rh6 {2.50/23 2} c4 {2.55/22 1} 31. Rxh5 {2.61/22 2} Kc6 {2.89/21 1} 32.
Rh6+ {2.87/21 1} Kd7 {2.56/23 1} 33. e5 {3.39/23 4} Rf2+ {3.51/21 1} 34. Ke3 {
3.65/22 1} Rc2 {3.69/23 1} 35. Rg6 {3.79/22 1} Ke8 {3.89/22 1 (Kd8)} 36. g4 {
4.25/22 1} c3 {4.69/22 2} 37. h5 {5.33/21 2} Rg2 {5.45/21 1 (Ra2)} 38. Kf3 {6.
74/23 3} Rg1 {6.78/20 1 (c2)} 39. Rc6 {7.48/21 1} 1-0

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "75"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.17/23 2 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
1.17/21 1} Ke8 {0.74/23 3} 14. Rc7 {0.47/20 1} Nxf2 {0.54/23 3} 15. Ke5 {0.76/
23 2} Re2 {0.66/25 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.95/25 2} Rxf2 {0.68/24 3} 17. Rxc6 {0.38/24 3
} Kd7 {0.27/27 2} 18. Rd6+ {0.22/26 1} Kc7 {0.25/30 4} 19. Rd3 {0.28/30 1} Kc6
{0.27/31 9} 20. Kd4 {0.34/28 4} Rf1 {0.34/30 4} 21. Rc3 {0.21/29 6} Rd1+ {0.23/
27 4} 22. Ke3 {0.30/29 6} Re1+ {0.25/25 1} 23. Kf4 {0.19/26 3} Rf1+ {0.37/26 2}
24. Kg5 {0.17/26 1} Re1 {0.18/25 1} 25. Kxh5 {0.12/25 3} Rxe4 {0.12/26 1} 26.
Ra3 {0.23/28 12} Re7 {0.14/26 1} 27. Ra5 {0.13/25 1 (Ra8)} Rc7 {0.12/26 1} 28.
Ra4 {0.16/25 2 (g4)} Re7 {0.27/27 2} 29. Ra8 {0.36/24 1} Kxc5 {0.21/27 1} 30.
Rg8 {0.21/28 1} Re5+ {0.21/30 1} 31. Kg4 {0.21/1 0} g6 {0.21/32 1} 32. Rf8 {0.
29/32 2} Rf5 {0.40/31 1} 33. h5 {0.22/32 1} Rxh5 {0.22/34 1} 34. Rxf7 {0.22/35
1} Kd6 {0.22/36 1} 35. Rg7 {0.22/34 1} Ra5 {0.22/36 1} 36. Rxg6+ {0.22/36 1}
Ke7 {0.22/38 1} 37. Rg5 {0.22/38 1} Ra4+ {0.22/38 1} 38. Kh5 {0.22/39 1}
1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.02/24 4 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
0.89/22 1} Ke8 {0.94/24 3} 14. Rc7 {0.87/23 3} Nxf2 {0.57/23 4} 15. Ke5 {0.58/
22 1} Re2 {0.56/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.68/23 1} Rxf2 {0.28/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.27/24 2
} Kd7 {0.30/27 3} 18. Rd6+ {0.29/28 1} Kc7 {0.29/30 2} 19. Rd3 {0.26/26 1} Kc6
{0.25/28 2} 20. Kd4 {0.25/28 2} Rf1 {0.25/29 3} 21. Ra3 {0.39/29 6} Rd1+ {0.31/
27 5} 22. Ke3 {0.35/26 2} Re1+ {0.23/26 2} 23. Kf3 {0.22/26 1} g6 {0.22/28 2}
24. Ra5 {0.18/29 8} Rc1 {0.22/28 3} 25. Kf2 {0.16/27 2} Kb7 {0.16/26 1} 26. Ke3
{0.10/25 1} Rc3+ {0.10/26 2} 27. Kf4 {0.08/24 1} f6 {0.08/26 2} 28. g4 {0.19/
27 3} hxg4 {0.14/26 2} 29. Kxg4 {0.14/28 2} Rc4 {0.14/27 1} 30. Kf3 {0.14/28 2}
Rc1 {0.14/28 1} 31. Ra2 {0.14/28 6} Rxc5 {0.14/29 1} 32. Rg2 {0.14/30 2} Rc3+ {
0.14/31 1} 33. Kf4 {0.13/32 1} Rh3 {0.13/34 1} 34. Rxg6 {0.13/34 2} Rxh4+ {0.
13/35 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "218"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.17/23 2 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
1.17/21 1} Ke8 {0.74/23 3} 14. Rc7 {0.47/20 1} Nxf2 {0.54/23 3} 15. Ke5 {0.76/
23 2} Re2 {0.66/25 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.95/25 2} Rxf2 {0.68/24 3} 17. Rxc6 {0.38/24 3
} Kd7 {0.27/27 2} 18. Rd6+ {0.22/26 1} Kc7 {0.25/30 4} 19. Rd3 {0.28/30 1} Kc6
{0.27/31 9} 20. Kd4 {0.34/28 4} Rf1 {0.34/30 4} 21. Rc3 {0.21/29 6} Rd1+ {0.23/
27 4} 22. Ke3 {0.22/27 1} Ra1 {0.22/28 2} 23. Kf4 {0.38/26 1} Re1 {0.43/24 1
(Rf1+)} 24. Rc4 {0.47/23 2 (Ra3)} Rf1+ {0.51/23 1} 25. Ke3 {0.50/25 1} Re1+ {
0.50/26 2 (Rd1)} 26. Kf2 {0.49/25 1} Rd1 {0.49/25 1} 27. Ra4 {0.63/26 3} Rd7 {
0.64/26 1} 28. Ke3 {0.64/27 2} Rb7 {0.64/26 1} 29. Rd4 {0.63/26 2} Rb3+ {0.56/
25 1} 30. Kf4 {0.54/26 4} Rb1 {0.54/28 1} 31. Rd6+ {0.57/26 1} Kxc5 {0.57/27 1}
32. Rd5+ {0.62/26 2} Kc6 {0.64/27 1} 33. Rxh5 {0.63/28 2} Kd6 {0.63/29 1} 34.
Rd5+ {0.52/25 2} Ke7 {0.60/25 1} 35. Rd3 {0.51/23 3 (h5)} Kf6 {0.39/25 1} 36.
Rd6+ {0.39/25 2} Ke7 {0.39/1 0} 37. Rc6 {0.39/27 2 (Ra6)} Rf1+ {0.44/27 1} 38.
Kg4 {0.39/29 2} Re1 {0.39/30 2} 39. Kf3 {0.39/30 1} Rf1+ {0.39/29 1} 40. Ke2 {
0.42/29 2} Rh1 {0.42/30 1} 41. Rc5 {0.39/29 1} g6 {0.39/27 1} 42. Rc6 {0.37/28
1} Rb1 {0.37/30 1} 43. Kf3 {0.37/29 1 (Ke3)} Kf8 {0.37/29 1} 44. Kg4 {0.37/27
2 (Rc5)} Re1 {0.37/29 1} 45. Kf4 {0.37/29 2} Rf1+ {0.37/30 1} 46. Kg5 {0.37/31
1} Re1 {0.37/31 1} 47. Rc4 {0.36/31 4} Kg7 {0.35/30 1} 48. Rb4 {0.35/26 1 (Ra4)
} Rg1 {0.35/28 1} 49. Kg4 {0.31/27 1 (Kf4)} Re1 {0.31/29 1} 50. Kf3 {0.29/28 3}
Rf1+ {0.29/29 1} 51. Ke2 {0.29/30 2} Ra1 {0.29/30 1} 52. Ke3 {0.29/30 1} Re1+ {
0.29/30 1} 53. Kf2 {0.29/28 1} Ra1 {0.29/29 1} 54. Rb6 {0.29/27 1 (Rb3)} Ra5 {
0.29/30 2} 55. Kf3 {0.29/31 2} f5 {0.29/31 1} 56. g4 {0.29/28 1 (Kf4)} fxe4+ {
0.29/30 1} 57. Kf4 {0.29/32 1} e3 {0.29/32 1 (Ra4)} 58. Rb7+ {0.29/33 2} Kf6 {
0.29/35 1} 59. g5+ {0.29/35 1} Ke6 {0.29/37 1} 60. Rb6+ {0.29/38 2} Kf7 {0.29/
40 1} 61. Rf6+ {0.29/40 1} Kg7 {0.29/42 1} 62. Kxe3 {0.29/43 1} Ra4 {0.29/44 1}
63. Rf4 {0.29/45 2} Ra3+ {0.29/46 1} 64. Kf2 {0.29/46 1} Ra2+ {0.29/47 1} 65.
Kg3 {0.29/47 2} Ra3+ {0.29/46 1} 66. Kg4 {0.29/47 1} Ra1 {0.29/47 1} 67. Re4 {
0.29/45 1} Rg1+ {0.29/45 1} 68. Kf3 {0.29/44 1 (Kf4)} Rf1+ {0.29/45 2} 69. Kg2
{0.29/46 2} Rc1 {0.29/46 1} 70. Re6 {0.29/43 1 (Re7+)} Rc4 {0.29/43 1} 71. Kg3
{0.29/44 1} Rc1 {0.29/40 1 (Ra4)} 72. Rf6 {0.29/40 1 (Re7+)} Rg1+ {0.29/44 1}
73. Kh2 {0.29/45 1} Ra1 {0.29/39 1 (Rc1)} 74. Rd6 {0.29/41 1} Rb1 {0.29/41 1
(Ra3)} 75. Rd7+ {0.29/39 1 (Rd4)} Kg8 {0.29/41 1} 76. Kg3 {0.29/41 1} Rg1+ {0.
29/40 1} 77. Kf3 {0.29/40 1 (Kf4)} Rf1+ {0.29/42 1} 78. Kg4 {0.29/44 2} Ra1 {
0.29/45 1} 79. Re7 {0.29/39 1 (Rd8+)} Ra4+ {0.29/42 1} 80. Kg3 {0.29/44 1} Ra3+
{0.29/45 1} 81. Kf4 {0.29/45 1} Ra1 {0.29/39 1 (Ra5)} 82. Rd7 {0.29/41 1 (Kf3)}
Rf1+ {0.29/43 1 (Ra4+)} 83. Ke5 {0.29/44 1} Rf8 {0.29/42 1 (Rf5+)} 84. Rd6 {0.
29/38 1 (Rc7)} Kg7 {0.29/38 1 (Rf5+)} 85. Rd4 {0.29/38 1 (Ke6)} Rf1 {0.29/43 1}
86. Ke4 {0.29/40 1 (Rd7+)} Re1+ {0.29/42 1} 87. Kd5 {0.29/44 1} Rh1 {0.29/46 1}
88. Kd6 {0.29/38 1 (Rc4)} Re1 {0.29/41 1} 89. Rb4 {0.29/40 1} Rd1+ {0.29/42 1}
90. Ke5 {0.29/38 1 (Kc7)} Re1+ {0.29/39 1} 91. Kf4 {0.29/41 1} Rf1+ {0.29/41 2}
92. Kg3 {0.29/41 1} Rg1+ {0.29/42 1} 93. Kf2 {0.29/36 1} Rc1 {0.29/37 1} 94.
Rb7+ {0.29/35 1 (Rf4)} Kg8 {0.29/37 1} 95. Rb6 {0.29/37 1} Rc2+ {0.29/38 1} 96.
Kg3 {0.29/33 2 (Ke3)} Rc3+ {0.29/31 1} 97. Kg4 {0.29/27 1} Rc4+ {0.29/32 1} 98.
Kh3 {0.29/28 1} Rc3+ {0.29/31 1} 99. Kg2 {0.29/26 1} Rc2+ {0.29/27 1} 100. Kf3
{0.29/24 1} Kh7 {0.29/25 1 (Kg7)} 101. Rb7+ {0.29/25 3 (Rd6)} Kg8 {0.29/25 1}
102. Rd7 {0.29/29 1 (Rb8+)} Rc3+ {0.29/30 1 (Ra2)} 103. Ke4 {0.29/27 1} Rc4+ {
0.29/28 1} 104. Rd4 {0.29/28 1} Rc3 {0.29/27 1} 105. Rb4 {0.29/22 1 (Rd6)} Rc1
{0.29/25 1} 106. Kd5 {0.29/21 1 (Ra4)} Rd1+ {0.29/24 1 (Rh1)} 107. Rd4 {0.22/
26 6 (Ke6)} Rf1 {0.14/22 1} 108. Kd6 {0.00/21 1 (Ke6)} Rf2 {0.00/37 1} 109. Ra4
{0.00/42 3 (Ke7)} Kh7 {0.00/45 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.02/24 4 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
0.89/22 1} Ke8 {0.94/24 3} 14. Rc7 {0.87/23 3} Nxf2 {0.57/23 4} 15. Ke5 {0.58/
22 1} Re2 {0.56/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.68/23 1} Rxf2 {0.28/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.27/24 2
} Kd7 {0.30/27 3} 18. Rd6+ {0.29/28 1} Kc7 {0.29/30 2} 19. Rd3 {0.26/26 1} Kc6
{0.25/28 2} 20. Kd4 {0.25/28 2} Rf1 {0.25/29 3} 21. Ra3 {0.39/29 6} Rd1+ {0.31/
27 5} 22. Ke3 {0.35/26 2} Re1+ {0.23/26 2} 23. Kf3 {0.22/26 1} g6 {0.22/28 2}
24. Ra5 {0.18/29 8} Rc1 {0.22/28 3} 25. Kf2 {0.16/27 2} Kb7 {0.16/26 1} 26. Ke3
{0.10/25 1} Rc3+ {0.10/26 2} 27. Kf4 {0.08/24 1} f6 {0.08/26 2} 28. g4 {0.19/
27 3} hxg4 {0.14/26 2} 29. Kxg4 {0.14/28 2} Rc4 {0.14/27 1} 30. Kf3 {0.14/28 2}
Rc1 {0.14/28 1} 31. Ra2 {0.14/28 2} Rxc5 {0.14/29 1} 32. Rg2 {0.14/29 1} Rc3+ {
0.14/30 1} 33. Kf4 {0.14/32 1} Rh3 {0.14/34 1} 34. Rxg6 {0.14/35 2} Rxh4+ {0.
14/37 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.02/24 4 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
0.89/22 1} Ke8 {0.94/24 3} 14. Rc7 {0.87/23 3} Nxf2 {0.57/23 4} 15. Ke5 {0.58/
22 1} Re2 {0.56/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.68/23 1} Rxf2 {0.28/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.27/24 2
} Kd7 {0.30/27 3} 18. Rd6+ {0.29/28 1} Kc7 {0.29/30 2} 19. Rd3 {0.26/26 1} Kc6
{0.25/28 2} 20. Kd4 {0.25/28 2} Rf1 {0.25/29 3} 21. Ra3 {0.39/29 6} Rd1+ {0.31/
27 5} 22. Ke3 {0.35/26 2} Re1+ {0.23/26 2} 23. Kf3 {0.22/26 1} g6 {0.22/28 2}
24. Ra5 {0.18/29 8} Rc1 {0.22/28 3} 25. Kf2 {0.16/27 2} Kb7 {0.16/26 1} 26. Ke3
{0.10/25 1} Rc3+ {0.10/26 2} 27. Kf4 {0.08/24 1} f6 {0.08/26 2} 28. g4 {0.19/
27 3} hxg4 {0.19/25 1} 29. Kxg4 {0.09/26 2} Rc4 {0.09/27 1} 30. Kf3 {0.09/27 1}
Rc1 {0.09/27 1} 31. Ra2 {0.09/27 2} Rxc5 {0.09/28 1} 32. Rg2 {0.09/29 2} Rc3+ {
0.09/30 1} 33. Kf4 {0.09/32 2} Rh3 {0.09/34 2} 34. Rxg6 {0.09/35 2} Rxh4+ {0.
09/36 1} 1/2-1/2

[/pgn]

the simple one-piece endgame is also drawn, I got draws in the astounding majority of variations if not all, so I have not my doubts about it at all, but will obviously never be able to prove it with such an outcry, when I have to listen to false stories instead of analysing.

Kasparov, Carlsen and Fischer in my place also would not have handled it.

all games shown by Lyudmill debugged or 'de-Lyudmillized' not Kf3 (as in his SF lines at short TC- but the winning Kd3!
White sacrifices the f-pawn but wins c-pawn and transfers white king to queenside
[d] 3k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PPB2/3K4/r4PPP/8 b - - 0 3

[Lyudmil Tsvetkov]

this is indeed my last one, not going to asnwer to anyone here, just to do justice to the very simple single-piece endgame, which is a DEMONSTRABLE, obvious draw. (and Carlsen certainly will evaluate it like that after 1 sec., and will certainly have not the least effort in the world achieving the draw)

indeed, engines are scoring well here with white, even with a bit longer TC, but again, this is only because they fully misunderstand fortresses.

and, black can save the game ONLY through a fortress.

Top engines prefer some line like: Ba5 Na6 f4 (both Sf and Komodo seem to like that) f5 Kf2 Nb8!(engines do not see that, insetad they are moving the king) Kf3 Nd7 Bd8 Ke8 Bc7 Nf6 Be5 and now, of course, Ne4! (again, no engine sees that) Bg7 h5:

[d]4k3/6B1/2p1p3/2P2p1p/3PnP2/4PK2/6PP/8 w - - 0 10

well, that is a simple fortress DRAW, you might want to check with your engines for as long as you want.

This position is neither a fortress nor a draw.

Stockfish in combination with tablebases is incredible strong in endgames. Beyond our imagination.
I'm sorry, Lyudmil, but here you are wrong again with your claim, that this position is a simple fortress DRAW.
I would like to show you improvements for black, but there are none!

This time I took the latest Stockfish/McBrain 2.5 for analysis.

[d]4k3/6B1/2p1p3/2P2p1p/3PnP2/4PK2/6PP/8 w - - 0 10

Here the engine output:

McBrain 2.5 64 BMI2:

54/63 00:03 235.604k 62.996k +2,29 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.Bg5 Nc3 3.h3 Kg6 4.Bd8 Nd5 5.Bh4 Kf7 6.Be1 Nf6 7.Bg3 Nd5 8.Ke2 Nf6 9.Bh4 Nd5 10.Be1 Nf6 11.Kf3 Nd5 12.Bf2 Nf6 13.Ke2 Nd5 14.Bg1 Nc3+ 15.Kd2 Ne4+ 16.Ke1 Kf6 17.Bf2 Kg7 18.Bh4 Nc3 19.Bd8 Kf7 20.Kd2 Nd5 21.Ke2 Nc3+ 22.Kd3 Nd5 23.Bh4 Kg6 24.Bf2 Kf6 25.Kd2 Kf7 26.Ke2 Kf6 27.Kf3 Kg6 28.e4 Nf6 29.exf5+ exf5
55/63 00:06 388.282k 64.681k +2,29 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.Bg5 Nc3 3.h3 Nd5 4.Bd8 Kg6 5.Bh4 Kf7 6.Bg5 Kg6 7.Bd8 Kf7 8.Ke2 Kg6 9.Ba5 Kf7 10.Be1 Nf6 11.Bf2 Nd5 12.Kd3 Kg6 13.Kc2 Kf7 14.Kd2 Kf6 15.Bg3 Kf7 16.Kd3 Nf6 17.Ke2 Ne4 18.Bf2 Nf6 19.Be1 Nd5 20.Kf3 Nf6 21.Bg3 Kg6 22.Bf2 Nd5 23.Be1 Kf7 24.Ba5 Kg6 25.e4 Nf6 26.exf5+ exf5 27.Bd8 Nd5 28.g4 hxg4+ 29.hxg4 fxg4+ 30.Kxg4
56/98 07:14 31.898.089k 73.397k +5,16 1.Bh6 Ke7 2.Bg5+ Kf7 3.h3 Nc3 4.Bd8 Nd5 5.Bh4 Kg7 6.e4 Nc3 7.exf5 exf5 8.g4 Kg6 9.g5 Nd5 10.Be1 Kf7 11.Ba5 Ke7 12.Bb6 Ke6 13.Bd8 Kf7 14.Kg3 Nc3 15.Bf6 Kg6 16.Kf3 Kf7 17.Kg2 Nd5 18.Kg3 Nb4 19.Kf2 Nd5 20.Be5 Nb4 21.Kg3 Nd5 22.Bd6 Kg7 23.Kf2 Nb4 24.Ke2 Kh7 25.Be5 Nd5 26.Kd2 Kg6 27.Bb8 Kh7 28.Ke2 Kg7 29.Bd6 Nc3+ 30.Ke3 Nd5+ 31.Kd3 Kh7 32.Bb8 Nb4+ 33.Kc3 Na6 34.Be5
57/98 07:42 34.024.784k 73.580k +5,16 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.h3 Nc3 3.Bg5 Nd5 4.Bh4 Kg7 5.e4 Nc3 6.exf5 exf5 7.g4 Kg6 8.Be1 Nd5 9.g5 Kf7 10.Ba5 Ke7 11.Kg3 Kf7 12.Bd8 Nc3 13.Bf6 Nd5 14.Be5 Ne3 15.Bc7 Kg6 16.Ba5 Nd5 17.Kf3 Kh7 18.Bd8 Kg8 19.Kg3 Kh7 20.Bf6 Nc3 21.Kg2 Kg8 22.Be5 Kf7 23.Kf3 Kg6 24.Bc7 Kh7 25.Bd8 h4 26.Ba5 Nd5 27.Be1 Nc7 28.Bxh4 Kg6 29.Be1 Kh5 30.Ba5 Ne6 31.Ke3 Kh4 32.d5 cxd5 33.c6 Kxh3
58/98 11:57 53.377.191k 74.434k +5,58 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.h3 Nc3 3.Bg5 Nd5 4.Bd8 Kg6 5.Ba5 Kf7 6.Bb6 Ke8 7.Ba7 Kf8 8.Bb8 Nf6 9.Be5 Ne4 10.g4 Nc3 11.g5 Ne4 12.Bc7 Nd2+ 13.Ke2 Nc4 14.Bb8 Kf7 15.Bd6 Nb2 16.Be5 Nc4 17.Kd3 Nb2+ 18.Kd2 Ke7 19.e4 fxe4 20.Ke3 Nc4+ 21.Kxe4 Kf7 22.Bc7 Nd2+ 23.Ke3 Nb3 24.Be5 Kg6 25.Kd3 Kh7 26.Kc2 Nxc5 27.g6+ Kxg6 28.dxc5 Kf7 29.Kd3 Kf8 30.Bd6+ Kf7 31.Kd4 Kg7 32.Be5+ Kg6 33.Ke4 Kf7 34.Bd6 Kg7 35.Kd4 Kg6
59/98 12:18 55.072.619k 74.592k +5,58 1.Bh6 Kf7 2.h3 Nc3 3.Bg5 Nd5 4.Bd8 Kg6 5.Ba5 Kf7 6.Bb6 Ke8 7.Ba7 Kf8 8.Bb8 Nf6 9.Be5 Ne4 10.g4 Nd2+ 11.Ke2 Ne4 12.g5 Ke8 13.Bc7 Nc3+ 14.Kf3 Nd5 15.Bd6 Kf7 16.Bb8 Kg7 17.e4 Nc3 18.exf5 exf5 19.Bc7 Kg6 20.Be5 Nd5 21.Bf6 Nc3 22.Ke3 Kf7 23.Be5 Nd5+ 24.Kd3 Ke8 25.Kc4 Ne3+ 26.Kc3 Nd5+ 27.Kd3 Ne7 28.Bd6 Nd5 29.Ke2 Kd7 30.Kf3 Ke6 31.Kf2 Nc3 32.Kg3 Kf7 33.Be5 Nd5 34.Kf2 Ne7 35.Bd6 Nc8 36.Kf3 Kg8 37.Ke2 Kf7 38.Kd3 Ke6 39.Kc4
60/98 25:29 116.975.366k 76.492k +5,96 1.Bh6 Nc3 2.Bg5 Kf8 3.Bh4 Kf7 4.h3 Nd5 5.e4 Nc3 6.exf5 exf5 7.g4 Kg6 8.Be1 Nd5 9.g5 Ne7 10.Ba5 Kf7 11.Kg3 Kg6 12.Bc7 Nd5 13.Be5 Kf7 14.Kf3 Ne7 15.Bd6 Nd5 16.Kf2 Kg6 17.Be5 Kf7 18.Ke2 Ne7 19.Bd6 Nd5 20.Kd2 Ke6 21.Kc2 Kd7 22.Kb3 Ke6 23.Kb2 Nb4 24.Be5 Kf7 25.Kc3 Nd5+ 26.Kc2 Ke6 27.g6 Ke7 28.Kb3 Ne3 29.Kb4 Nd5+ 30.Kc4 Ke8 31.Kb3 Ne7 32.g7 Kf7 33.Kb4 Kg8 34.Ka4 Nd5 35.Ka5 Kh7 36.Ka6 Nb4+ 37.Kb7 Kg8 38.d5 Nxd5 39.Kxc6 Ne3

....

75/101 1:14:25 335.098.716k 75.036k +6,21 1.h3 Nd2+ 2.Ke2 Ne4 3.Bh6 Nc3+ 4.Kf3 Kf7 5.Bg5 Nd5 6.Bh4 Kg6 7.e4 Nc3 8.exf5+ exf5 9.g4 Nb5 10.Bf2 Nc3 11.g5 Nd5 12.Be1 Kf7 13.Ba5 Ke7 14.Kg3 Kf7 15.Bd8 Nc3 16.Bc7 Nd5 17.Be5 Ne7 18.Bd6 Nd5 19.Kf2 Nc3 20.Be5 h4 21.Ke3 Kg8 22.Kd3 Nd5 23.Ke2 Kh7 24.Kd2 Nb4 25.Kc3 Nd5+ 26.Kc4 Kg6 27.Bd6 Ne3+ 28.Kb4 Nd5+ 29.Kb3 Ne3 30.Be5 Kf7 31.Kc3 Nd5+ 32.Kd2 Ne7 33.Bd6 Nd5 34.Ke2 Ke6 35.Bb8 Ne7 36.Kd3 Kd7 37.Bd6 Ng6 38.d5 cxd5 39.Kd4 Kc6 40.Ke3 Nh8 41.Kd3 Kb7 42.Kd4 Kc6 43.Ke5 d4 44.Kxd4 Ng6 45.Kc4 Nh8 46.Kc3

I really do not know, if this is a fortress or no.

you are eraching depth 80 after an hour of analysis, and the score is still not very much convincing.

there are fortresses with bigger evaluation scores.

in any case, how easily do you think Aronian would have won that position against Carlsen?

certainly, a very good drawing chance.

the alternative non-capturing Bd6 retreat leads to much more convincing scores much quicker.

but of course, you are only able to analyse simple positions, I mean your engines.

so that again, my assessment was much more correct, I do not understand why you try to prove the opposite all the time.

[Lyudmil Tsvetkov]

This is beyond blatant trolling, and the user should be banned...

you are indeed pitiful I had a bit different opinion of you, unfortunately.

[IQ]

all games shown by Lyudmill debugged or 'de-Lyudmillized' not Kf3 (as in his SF lines at short TC- but the winning Kd3!
White sacrifices the f-pawn but wins c-pawn and transfers white king to queenside
[d] 3k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PPB2/3K4/r4PPP/8 b - - 0 3

Yes, I pointed him to Kd3! in this line multiple times. It completely debunks his engine vs. engine self-play games. Good that you corroborate my analysis - there are some tricky lines, but in the end white wins.

[Lyudmil Tsvetkov]

I do not know why Andreas suggested it is better to trade rooks: maybe because black performs much better in the rook endgame?

redid the test with SF from the position with rooks on after Kd8, and, this time, the score was 8 DRAWS, 2 white wins.

the TC was quick, but, that is how engines are tested.
you do not believe in fortresses, and I do not believe in LTC.

so that, 80% draws.
more than convincing.

only conclusion could be made is

1) the endgame is drawn
2) my assessment was 4 times better than your cumulative one
3) it would be better, instead of trying to prove the unprovable, to learn something

obviously, you have been posting only winning games, quite pitiful.

forum members, wishing to know who says the truth and who lies, might want to do some games themsleves.

below the games:

[pgn][Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.02/24 4 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
0.89/22 1} Ke8 {0.94/24 3} 14. Rc7 {0.87/23 3} Nxf2 {0.57/23 4} 15. Ke5 {0.58/
22 1} Re2 {0.56/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.68/23 1} Rxf2 {0.28/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.27/24 2
} Kd7 {0.30/27 3} 18. Rd6+ {0.29/28 1} Kc7 {0.29/30 2} 19. Rd3 {0.26/26 1} Kc6
{0.25/28 2} 20. Kd4 {0.25/28 2} Rf1 {0.25/29 3} 21. Ra3 {0.39/29 6} Rd1+ {0.31/
27 6} 22. Ke3 {0.35/26 2} Re1+ {0.23/26 2} 23. Kf3 {0.22/26 1} g6 {0.22/28 2}
24. Ra5 {0.18/29 8} Rc1 {0.22/28 2} 25. Kf2 {0.16/27 2} Kb7 {0.09/27 3} 26. Ke3
{0.10/26 1} Rc3+ {0.08/27 1} 27. Kd4 {0.10/28 3 (Kf4)} Rxg3 {0.12/27 2} 28.
Rb5+ {0.08/28 2} Kc7 {0.13/29 1} 29. Rb6 {0.08/28 1} Rf3 {0.08/29 1} 30. Kd5 {
0.06/29 13 (Ke5)} Rd3+ {0.06/29 1} 31. Ke5 {0.06/30 2} Rc3 {0.06/30 1} 32. Ra6
{0.06/30 1} Kb7 {0.06/29 1} 33. Rd6 {0.06/29 5} Kc7 {0.06/29 1} 34. Kd4 {0.06/
29 2} Rf3 {0.06/30 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1-0"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "99"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.11/22 3} 3. Kf3
{1.02/22 1} Ra3+ {1.21/22 4} 4. Be3 {0.88/21 2} Kc8 {1.14/23 3} 5. Rb1 {1.23/
22 2} e5 {0.99/23 4 (Kc7)} 6. d5 {1.19/23 1} Kc7 {1.16/23 4 (cxd5)} 7. Ke2 {1.
15/23 5 (d6+)} Ra5 {1.18/24 8 (h5)} 8. d6+ {1.08/25 2} Kc8 {1.02/28 5} 9. Rc1 {
1.13/25 2} Nf6 {1.13/28 3} 10. Rc4 {1.13/28 1} Ng4 {1.20/29 11} 11. Rc2 {1.20/
27 1} Nxe3 {1.23/30 3} 12. Kxe3 {1.19/28 2} g6 {1.11/26 3 (Kd7)} 13. f3 {1.11/
28 3 (Ke2)} Kd7 {1.10/32 4} 14. Kd3 {1.10/29 2 (Kd2)} f6 {1.10/31 3} 15. g3 {
1.23/28 5 (Ke3)} h5 {1.39/24 4} 16. Rc1 {1.48/26 4} f5 {1.50/25 4} 17. Rc3 {1.
60/23 2} Ra1 {1.59/24 4} 18. Rb3 {1.61/24 2} fxe4+ {1.75/24 2} 19. Kxe4 {1.55/
24 1} Re1+ {1.79/23 1} 20. Kd3 {1.79/27 2} Rc1 {1.79/27 1} 21. Rc3 {1.79/28 1}
Rh1 {1.81/27 1} 22. h4 {1.79/28 3} Re1 {1.81/27 1} 23. Rc4 {1.86/27 1} Rg1 {1.
86/27 1} 24. Ke3 {1.93/28 2} Ke6 {1.95/28 1} 25. Kf2 {1.89/29 2} Rd1 {1.82/26 1
} 26. Rc3 {2.07/28 3} Kd7 {2.18/25 1} 27. Ke3 {2.18/25 1} Re1+ {2.31/25 2} 28.
Kd3 {2.39/26 2} Ra1 {2.43/25 1 (Ke6)} 29. Ke4 {2.50/28 2} Ke6 {2.44/26 1} 30.
Ke3 {2.46/26 2} Re1+ {2.66/26 1 (Rg1)} 31. Kd2 {2.66/26 2} Ra1 {2.76/26 1} 32.
Rd3 {2.64/27 1} Ra2+ {2.83/26 1} 33. Ke3 {2.94/27 2} Kd7 {2.88/25 1} 34. Rb3 {
2.76/26 2} Rc2 {2.98/23 1} 35. Rb7+ {2.71/23 1} Kd8 {2.76/25 1} 36. Rg7 {3.24/
24 3 (Ke4)} Rxc5 {3.05/23 1} 37. Ke4 {3.21/24 2} Rc1 {3.29/22 1 (Rc2)} 38. Kxe5
{3.34/23 2} Re1+ {3.45/24 2 (Rc3)} 39. Kf6 {3.58/24 1} c5 {3.81/23 1} 40. Kxg6
{3.88/23 1} Re6+ {4.03/22 1} 41. Kxh5 {3.91/23 1} Rxd6 {4.20/23 1} 42. Rg4 {4.
29/21 1} Rd4 {4.14/21 1 (Kd7)} 43. Kg5 {4.47/21 1} Rd5+ {4.57/22 1} 44. Kg6 {
4.57/22 1} Rd6+ {4.72/22 1} 45. Kf5 {4.80/19 1} Ke7 {4.72/23 1} 46. Rg7+ {5.19/
22 2} Kf8 {5.27/21 1 (Kd8)} 47. Rc7 {5.47/20 1} Rd5+ {5.62/22 1} 48. Kg4 {5.97/
21 1} c4 {6.12/22 1 (Kg8)} 49. Rxc4 {7.36/26 3} Kf7 {7.54/22 1 (Rd6)} 50. f4 {
9.57/22 2 (Rc7+)} 1-0

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.12/22 5 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.10/21 1} Ra2 {1.26/21 3} 10. Kg5 {1.07/21 2} Nf6 {1.11/23 4} 11. g3 {1.23/22
2} Kd7 {0.99/22 3} 12. Kf4 {1.09/20 1} Ng4 {1.13/23 2} 13. Rb7+ {1.07/23 4} Ke8
{1.04/24 2} 14. Rc7 {0.99/24 1} Nxf2 {0.89/25 3} 15. Ke5 {0.71/25 9 (Rxc6)} Re2
{0.91/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.83/25 1} Rxf2 {1.05/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.33/23 4} Kd7 {0.
39/25 2} 18. Rd6+ {0.25/25 2} Kc7 {0.22/29 4} 19. Rd3 {0.24/29 3} Kc6 {0.29/28
2} 20. Kd4 {0.29/28 2} Rf1 {0.27/28 2} 21. Ke3 {0.24/26 1} Re1+ {0.54/26 4} 22.
Kf4 {0.22/26 2} g6 {0.22/28 2} 23. Kg5 {0.22/27 1} Kxc5 {0.20/30 2} 24. Kf6 {
0.30/31 1} Rxe4 {0.20/34 2} 25. Kxf7 {0.20/34 1} Rg4 {0.20/37 2} 26. Rf3 {0.17/
35 1} Kb5 {0.12/36 3} 27. Kf6 {0.10/33 1 (Kg7)} Kc5 {0.08/35 1} 28. Kg7 {0.08/
36 2} Kb5 {0.08/37 1} 29. Rd3 {0.08/37 1 (Kh6)} Kc5 {0.08/37 1 (Kc4)} 30. Rc3+
{0.08/36 1} Kb4 {0.08/38 2} 31. Re3 {0.08/38 1} Kc4 {0.08/39 1} 32. Kh6 {0.08/
38 1} Kd5 {0.08/36 1} 33. Rd3+ {0.08/32 2 (Ra3)} Ke5 {0.08/34 1} 34. Rf3 {0.08/
36 2} Ke6 {0.08/36 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "170"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.11/22 3} 3. Kf3
{1.02/22 1} Ra3+ {1.21/22 4} 4. Be3 {0.88/21 1} Kc8 {1.14/23 3} 5. Rb1 {1.23/
22 2} e5 {0.99/23 4 (Kc7)} 6. d5 {1.19/23 1} Kc7 {1.16/23 4 (cxd5)} 7. Ke2 {1.
15/23 5 (d6+)} Ra5 {1.18/24 8 (h5)} 8. d6+ {1.08/25 2} Kc8 {1.02/28 5} 9. Rc1 {
1.13/25 2} Nf6 {1.13/28 3} 10. Rc4 {1.13/28 1} Ng4 {1.20/29 11} 11. Rc2 {1.22/
28 2} Nxe3 {1.18/29 2} 12. Kxe3 {1.14/30 1} f6 {1.12/30 2} 13. f3 {1.12/31 3}
Kd7 {1.44/31 7} 14. Kf2 {1.43/30 1} g6 {1.37/34 2} 15. g4 {1.37/35 2} Ke6 {1.
37/35 2} 16. h4 {1.37/36 2} Kd7 {1.62/37 6} 17. h5 {1.61/29 1} g5 {1.49/32 2}
18. Rc1 {1.37/35 1} Ra2+ {1.37/35 2} 19. Ke3 {1.37/37 1 (Kg3)} Ra3+ {1.37/37 1}
20. Ke2 {1.37/39 2} Ra2+ {1.37/39 1} 21. Kd3 {1.37/40 2} Ra5 {1.37/40 2 (Ra3+)}
22. Kc4 {1.37/40 3 (Rc3)} Ra4+ {1.37/41 1} 23. Kb3 {1.37/42 2} Ra5 {1.37/43 2}
24. Kb4 {1.37/44 3} Ra8 {1.37/42 1} 25. Rc2 {1.37/41 1 (Rf1)} Ra1 {1.37/40 1}
26. Kc4 {1.37/37 2 (Rb2)} Ra4+ {1.37/38 1} 27. Kc3 {1.37/38 1} Ra5 {1.37/39 1
(Ra3+)} 28. Kd3 {1.37/39 1 (Kd2)} Ra3+ {1.37/39 1 (Rb5)} 29. Ke2 {1.37/40 2}
Ra5 {1.37/41 1} 30. Rc3 {1.37/41 2} Ke6 {1.37/36 1 (Ra2+)} 31. Kd3 {1.37/35 1
(Rc4)} Kd7 {1.37/40 1} 32. Kd2 {1.37/40 1 (Kc4)} Ke6 {1.37/41 1 (Ra2+)} 33. Rc4
{1.37/42 1} Kd7 {1.37/43 2} 34. Rc1 {1.37/44 2} Ke6 {1.37/35 1 (Ra2+)} 35. Ke2
{1.37/39 2} Ra2+ {1.37/40 1} 36. Kd3 {1.37/40 4} Ra3+ {1.37/40 1} 37. Kc4 {1.
37/37 2 (Rc3)} Ra4+ {1.37/39 1} 38. Kc3 {1.37/40 1} Ra5 {1.37/41 1} 39. Kb4 {
1.37/41 2} Ra7 {1.37/42 1} 40. Rc2 {1.37/40 1 (Rc3)} Ra1 {1.37/40 1} 41. Kb3 {
1.37/39 1} Ra5 {1.37/39 1} 42. Kc4 {1.37/40 2} Ra4+ {1.37/40 1} 43. Kd3 {1.37/
40 4} Ra5 {1.37/43 1} 44. Ke3 {1.37/43 3} Kd7 {1.37/43 1} 45. Kf2 {1.30/34 1}
Rb5 {1.30/37 1} 46. Kg2 {1.30/38 3 (Rc1)} Ra5 {1.30/38 1} 47. Kg3 {1.30/37 1
(Rc1)} Rb5 {1.30/39 1} 48. Rc1 {1.23/32 1} Ra5 {1.23/36 2} 49. Rc3 {1.37/35 5}
Rb5 {1.18/32 1} 50. Rc2 {0.56/31 2 (Rc1)} Ra5 {0.93/34 1} 51. Rc1 {0.50/33 2}
Ke6 {0.50/36 1} 52. Kh2 {0.50/35 1 (Kf2)} Ra2+ {0.50/37 1} 53. Kg1 {0.50/36 1
(Kh3)} Ra5 {0.90/38 1} 54. Rc3 {0.50/38 1} Kd7 {0.50/40 1} 55. Kf2 {0.50/39 1}
Ke6 {0.50/30 1} 56. Ke2 {0.42/33 1 (Kg1)} Kd7 {0.50/32 1} 57. Kd3 {0.42/30 1
(Ke1)} Ke6 {0.41/32 2} 58. Kd2 {0.31/31 1 (Ke3)} Ra2+ {0.31/32 1 (Kd7)} 59. Rc2
{0.31/32 1 (Kc1)} Ra5 {0.31/34 1} 60. Kc1 {0.27/28 1 (Rb2)} Ra3 {0.27/30 1} 61.
Rd2 {0.26/29 2 (Kb1)} Kd7 {0.26/30 1} 62. Rb2 {0.25/31 3} Rc3+ {0.25/31 1} 63.
Kd2 {0.25/30 1} Rxc5 {0.25/33 1} 64. Rb7+ {0.24/31 1} Kxd6 {0.24/33 1} 65. Rh7
{0.24/33 1} Rb5 {0.24/33 1} 66. Rxh6 {0.24/33 1} Ke6 {0.24/34 1} 67. Kc3 {0.24/
30 1 (Rh8)} Rb1 {0.24/33 1} 68. Kd3 {0.24/33 1} Rb3+ {0.24/34 1} 69. Ke2 {0.24/
36 2} c5 {0.24/35 2 (Rb2+)} 70. Rh7 {0.24/35 2} Rb2+ {0.24/36 1} 71. Ke3 {0.24/
33 1} Rb3+ {0.24/34 1} 72. Kf2 {0.24/32 1} Rc3 {0.24/33 1} 73. Ra7 {0.24/30 1
(Rc7)} c4 {0.24/31 1 (Rc2+)} 74. Ra2 {0.24/31 1} Rb3 {0.24/31 1} 75. Rc2 {0.24/
31 1} Rb4 {0.24/33 1} 76. Ke3 {0.16/31 2} Ra4 {0.16/32 1} 77. Rd2 {0.16/32 1
(Kd2)} Ra3+ {0.24/33 1} 78. Kf2 {0.08/33 6} Ra1 {0.00/29 1} 79. Rc2 {0.00/28 1}
Ra4 {0.00/30 1} 80. Rd2 {0.00/32 1 (Rb2)} Ra1 {0.00/42 1} 81. Ke2 {0.08/32 2
(Rc2)} Ra4 {0.07/31 2} 82. Rb2 {0.04/30 1} Ra6 {0.04/31 1} 83. Rc2 {0.04/31 1}
Ra4 {0.00/33 1} 84. Ke3 {0.00/30 1 (Kd2)} Ra3+ {0.00/47 1 (Kd6)} 85. Ke2 {0.00/
52 1 (Kf2)} Ra4 {0.00/54 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1-0"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "77"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.11/22 3} 3. Kf3
{1.02/22 1} Ra3+ {1.21/22 4} 4. Be3 {0.88/21 2} Kc8 {1.14/23 3} 5. Rb1 {1.23/
22 2} e5 {0.99/23 4 (Kc7)} 6. d5 {1.19/23 1} Kc7 {1.16/23 4 (cxd5)} 7. Ke2 {1.
15/23 5 (d6+)} Ra5 {1.18/24 8 (h5)} 8. d6+ {1.08/25 2} Kc8 {1.02/28 5} 9. Rc1 {
1.13/25 2} Nf6 {1.13/28 3} 10. Rc4 {1.13/28 1} Ng4 {1.20/29 11} 11. Rc2 {1.20/
28 1} Nxe3 {1.18/29 5} 12. Kxe3 {1.17/28 1} f6 {1.12/31 2} 13. f3 {1.12/29 2}
Kd7 {1.12/34 3} 14. Kd3 {1.12/30 1 (Kf2)} g6 {1.12/31 2} 15. Ke3 {1.11/30 1}
Ke6 {1.25/31 8} 16. Kf2 {1.37/27 1 (Ke2)} Kd7 {1.41/26 3} 17. Kg3 {1.38/26 2}
Kc8 {1.28/27 2} 18. Rc3 {1.17/25 4} Ra4 {1.47/24 1} 19. Kh3 {1.52/26 2} Ra5 {
1.52/27 2} 20. f4 {1.41/28 6} exf4 {1.40/27 2 (Ra4)} 21. Kg4 {1.45/28 3} Kd7 {
1.56/23 1} 22. Kxf4 {1.58/27 2} h5 {1.51/26 1 (Rb5)} 23. h4 {1.78/25 2} Ke6 {
1.93/24 2 (Rb5)} 24. Rd3 {2.02/26 2} Kd7 {2.18/24 1} 25. Rg3 {2.03/25 2} Ke6 {
2.03/25 1} 26. Rxg6 {2.20/23 1} Rxc5 {2.22/24 1} 27. d7 {2.29/23 1} Kxd7 {1.89/
22 1} 28. Rxf6 {2.27/23 2} Rc2 {2.18/22 1} 29. g3 {2.34/24 2} c5 {2.12/23 1}
30. Rh6 {2.50/23 2} c4 {2.55/22 1} 31. Rxh5 {2.61/22 2} Kc6 {2.89/21 1} 32.
Rh6+ {2.87/21 1} Kd7 {2.56/23 1} 33. e5 {3.39/23 4} Rf2+ {3.51/21 1} 34. Ke3 {
3.65/22 1} Rc2 {3.69/23 1} 35. Rg6 {3.79/22 1} Ke8 {3.89/22 1 (Kd8)} 36. g4 {
4.25/22 1} c3 {4.69/22 2} 37. h5 {5.33/21 2} Rg2 {5.45/21 1 (Ra2)} 38. Kf3 {6.
74/23 3} Rg1 {6.78/20 1 (c2)} 39. Rc6 {7.48/21 1} 1-0

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "75"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.17/23 2 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
1.17/21 1} Ke8 {0.74/23 3} 14. Rc7 {0.47/20 1} Nxf2 {0.54/23 3} 15. Ke5 {0.76/
23 2} Re2 {0.66/25 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.95/25 2} Rxf2 {0.68/24 3} 17. Rxc6 {0.38/24 3
} Kd7 {0.27/27 2} 18. Rd6+ {0.22/26 1} Kc7 {0.25/30 4} 19. Rd3 {0.28/30 1} Kc6
{0.27/31 9} 20. Kd4 {0.34/28 4} Rf1 {0.34/30 4} 21. Rc3 {0.21/29 6} Rd1+ {0.23/
27 4} 22. Ke3 {0.30/29 6} Re1+ {0.25/25 1} 23. Kf4 {0.19/26 3} Rf1+ {0.37/26 2}
24. Kg5 {0.17/26 1} Re1 {0.18/25 1} 25. Kxh5 {0.12/25 3} Rxe4 {0.12/26 1} 26.
Ra3 {0.23/28 12} Re7 {0.14/26 1} 27. Ra5 {0.13/25 1 (Ra8)} Rc7 {0.12/26 1} 28.
Ra4 {0.16/25 2 (g4)} Re7 {0.27/27 2} 29. Ra8 {0.36/24 1} Kxc5 {0.21/27 1} 30.
Rg8 {0.21/28 1} Re5+ {0.21/30 1} 31. Kg4 {0.21/1 0} g6 {0.21/32 1} 32. Rf8 {0.
29/32 2} Rf5 {0.40/31 1} 33. h5 {0.22/32 1} Rxh5 {0.22/34 1} 34. Rxf7 {0.22/35
1} Kd6 {0.22/36 1} 35. Rg7 {0.22/34 1} Ra5 {0.22/36 1} 36. Rxg6+ {0.22/36 1}
Ke7 {0.22/38 1} 37. Rg5 {0.22/38 1} Ra4+ {0.22/38 1} 38. Kh5 {0.22/39 1}
1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.02/24 4 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
0.89/22 1} Ke8 {0.94/24 3} 14. Rc7 {0.87/23 3} Nxf2 {0.57/23 4} 15. Ke5 {0.58/
22 1} Re2 {0.56/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.68/23 1} Rxf2 {0.28/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.27/24 2
} Kd7 {0.30/27 3} 18. Rd6+ {0.29/28 1} Kc7 {0.29/30 2} 19. Rd3 {0.26/26 1} Kc6
{0.25/28 2} 20. Kd4 {0.25/28 2} Rf1 {0.25/29 3} 21. Ra3 {0.39/29 6} Rd1+ {0.31/
27 5} 22. Ke3 {0.35/26 2} Re1+ {0.23/26 2} 23. Kf3 {0.22/26 1} g6 {0.22/28 2}
24. Ra5 {0.18/29 8} Rc1 {0.22/28 3} 25. Kf2 {0.16/27 2} Kb7 {0.16/26 1} 26. Ke3
{0.10/25 1} Rc3+ {0.10/26 2} 27. Kf4 {0.08/24 1} f6 {0.08/26 2} 28. g4 {0.19/
27 3} hxg4 {0.14/26 2} 29. Kxg4 {0.14/28 2} Rc4 {0.14/27 1} 30. Kf3 {0.14/28 2}
Rc1 {0.14/28 1} 31. Ra2 {0.14/28 6} Rxc5 {0.14/29 1} 32. Rg2 {0.14/30 2} Rc3+ {
0.14/31 1} 33. Kf4 {0.13/32 1} Rh3 {0.13/34 1} 34. Rxg6 {0.13/34 2} Rxh4+ {0.
13/35 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "218"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.17/23 2 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
1.17/21 1} Ke8 {0.74/23 3} 14. Rc7 {0.47/20 1} Nxf2 {0.54/23 3} 15. Ke5 {0.76/
23 2} Re2 {0.66/25 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.95/25 2} Rxf2 {0.68/24 3} 17. Rxc6 {0.38/24 3
} Kd7 {0.27/27 2} 18. Rd6+ {0.22/26 1} Kc7 {0.25/30 4} 19. Rd3 {0.28/30 1} Kc6
{0.27/31 9} 20. Kd4 {0.34/28 4} Rf1 {0.34/30 4} 21. Rc3 {0.21/29 6} Rd1+ {0.23/
27 4} 22. Ke3 {0.22/27 1} Ra1 {0.22/28 2} 23. Kf4 {0.38/26 1} Re1 {0.43/24 1
(Rf1+)} 24. Rc4 {0.47/23 2 (Ra3)} Rf1+ {0.51/23 1} 25. Ke3 {0.50/25 1} Re1+ {
0.50/26 2 (Rd1)} 26. Kf2 {0.49/25 1} Rd1 {0.49/25 1} 27. Ra4 {0.63/26 3} Rd7 {
0.64/26 1} 28. Ke3 {0.64/27 2} Rb7 {0.64/26 1} 29. Rd4 {0.63/26 2} Rb3+ {0.56/
25 1} 30. Kf4 {0.54/26 4} Rb1 {0.54/28 1} 31. Rd6+ {0.57/26 1} Kxc5 {0.57/27 1}
32. Rd5+ {0.62/26 2} Kc6 {0.64/27 1} 33. Rxh5 {0.63/28 2} Kd6 {0.63/29 1} 34.
Rd5+ {0.52/25 2} Ke7 {0.60/25 1} 35. Rd3 {0.51/23 3 (h5)} Kf6 {0.39/25 1} 36.
Rd6+ {0.39/25 2} Ke7 {0.39/1 0} 37. Rc6 {0.39/27 2 (Ra6)} Rf1+ {0.44/27 1} 38.
Kg4 {0.39/29 2} Re1 {0.39/30 2} 39. Kf3 {0.39/30 1} Rf1+ {0.39/29 1} 40. Ke2 {
0.42/29 2} Rh1 {0.42/30 1} 41. Rc5 {0.39/29 1} g6 {0.39/27 1} 42. Rc6 {0.37/28
1} Rb1 {0.37/30 1} 43. Kf3 {0.37/29 1 (Ke3)} Kf8 {0.37/29 1} 44. Kg4 {0.37/27
2 (Rc5)} Re1 {0.37/29 1} 45. Kf4 {0.37/29 2} Rf1+ {0.37/30 1} 46. Kg5 {0.37/31
1} Re1 {0.37/31 1} 47. Rc4 {0.36/31 4} Kg7 {0.35/30 1} 48. Rb4 {0.35/26 1 (Ra4)
} Rg1 {0.35/28 1} 49. Kg4 {0.31/27 1 (Kf4)} Re1 {0.31/29 1} 50. Kf3 {0.29/28 3}
Rf1+ {0.29/29 1} 51. Ke2 {0.29/30 2} Ra1 {0.29/30 1} 52. Ke3 {0.29/30 1} Re1+ {
0.29/30 1} 53. Kf2 {0.29/28 1} Ra1 {0.29/29 1} 54. Rb6 {0.29/27 1 (Rb3)} Ra5 {
0.29/30 2} 55. Kf3 {0.29/31 2} f5 {0.29/31 1} 56. g4 {0.29/28 1 (Kf4)} fxe4+ {
0.29/30 1} 57. Kf4 {0.29/32 1} e3 {0.29/32 1 (Ra4)} 58. Rb7+ {0.29/33 2} Kf6 {
0.29/35 1} 59. g5+ {0.29/35 1} Ke6 {0.29/37 1} 60. Rb6+ {0.29/38 2} Kf7 {0.29/
40 1} 61. Rf6+ {0.29/40 1} Kg7 {0.29/42 1} 62. Kxe3 {0.29/43 1} Ra4 {0.29/44 1}
63. Rf4 {0.29/45 2} Ra3+ {0.29/46 1} 64. Kf2 {0.29/46 1} Ra2+ {0.29/47 1} 65.
Kg3 {0.29/47 2} Ra3+ {0.29/46 1} 66. Kg4 {0.29/47 1} Ra1 {0.29/47 1} 67. Re4 {
0.29/45 1} Rg1+ {0.29/45 1} 68. Kf3 {0.29/44 1 (Kf4)} Rf1+ {0.29/45 2} 69. Kg2
{0.29/46 2} Rc1 {0.29/46 1} 70. Re6 {0.29/43 1 (Re7+)} Rc4 {0.29/43 1} 71. Kg3
{0.29/44 1} Rc1 {0.29/40 1 (Ra4)} 72. Rf6 {0.29/40 1 (Re7+)} Rg1+ {0.29/44 1}
73. Kh2 {0.29/45 1} Ra1 {0.29/39 1 (Rc1)} 74. Rd6 {0.29/41 1} Rb1 {0.29/41 1
(Ra3)} 75. Rd7+ {0.29/39 1 (Rd4)} Kg8 {0.29/41 1} 76. Kg3 {0.29/41 1} Rg1+ {0.
29/40 1} 77. Kf3 {0.29/40 1 (Kf4)} Rf1+ {0.29/42 1} 78. Kg4 {0.29/44 2} Ra1 {
0.29/45 1} 79. Re7 {0.29/39 1 (Rd8+)} Ra4+ {0.29/42 1} 80. Kg3 {0.29/44 1} Ra3+
{0.29/45 1} 81. Kf4 {0.29/45 1} Ra1 {0.29/39 1 (Ra5)} 82. Rd7 {0.29/41 1 (Kf3)}
Rf1+ {0.29/43 1 (Ra4+)} 83. Ke5 {0.29/44 1} Rf8 {0.29/42 1 (Rf5+)} 84. Rd6 {0.
29/38 1 (Rc7)} Kg7 {0.29/38 1 (Rf5+)} 85. Rd4 {0.29/38 1 (Ke6)} Rf1 {0.29/43 1}
86. Ke4 {0.29/40 1 (Rd7+)} Re1+ {0.29/42 1} 87. Kd5 {0.29/44 1} Rh1 {0.29/46 1}
88. Kd6 {0.29/38 1 (Rc4)} Re1 {0.29/41 1} 89. Rb4 {0.29/40 1} Rd1+ {0.29/42 1}
90. Ke5 {0.29/38 1 (Kc7)} Re1+ {0.29/39 1} 91. Kf4 {0.29/41 1} Rf1+ {0.29/41 2}
92. Kg3 {0.29/41 1} Rg1+ {0.29/42 1} 93. Kf2 {0.29/36 1} Rc1 {0.29/37 1} 94.
Rb7+ {0.29/35 1 (Rf4)} Kg8 {0.29/37 1} 95. Rb6 {0.29/37 1} Rc2+ {0.29/38 1} 96.
Kg3 {0.29/33 2 (Ke3)} Rc3+ {0.29/31 1} 97. Kg4 {0.29/27 1} Rc4+ {0.29/32 1} 98.
Kh3 {0.29/28 1} Rc3+ {0.29/31 1} 99. Kg2 {0.29/26 1} Rc2+ {0.29/27 1} 100. Kf3
{0.29/24 1} Kh7 {0.29/25 1 (Kg7)} 101. Rb7+ {0.29/25 3 (Rd6)} Kg8 {0.29/25 1}
102. Rd7 {0.29/29 1 (Rb8+)} Rc3+ {0.29/30 1 (Ra2)} 103. Ke4 {0.29/27 1} Rc4+ {
0.29/28 1} 104. Rd4 {0.29/28 1} Rc3 {0.29/27 1} 105. Rb4 {0.29/22 1 (Rd6)} Rc1
{0.29/25 1} 106. Kd5 {0.29/21 1 (Ra4)} Rd1+ {0.29/24 1 (Rh1)} 107. Rd4 {0.22/
26 6 (Ke6)} Rf1 {0.14/22 1} 108. Kd6 {0.00/21 1 (Ke6)} Rf2 {0.00/37 1} 109. Ra4
{0.00/42 3 (Ke7)} Kh7 {0.00/45 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.02/24 4 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
0.89/22 1} Ke8 {0.94/24 3} 14. Rc7 {0.87/23 3} Nxf2 {0.57/23 4} 15. Ke5 {0.58/
22 1} Re2 {0.56/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.68/23 1} Rxf2 {0.28/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.27/24 2
} Kd7 {0.30/27 3} 18. Rd6+ {0.29/28 1} Kc7 {0.29/30 2} 19. Rd3 {0.26/26 1} Kc6
{0.25/28 2} 20. Kd4 {0.25/28 2} Rf1 {0.25/29 3} 21. Ra3 {0.39/29 6} Rd1+ {0.31/
27 5} 22. Ke3 {0.35/26 2} Re1+ {0.23/26 2} 23. Kf3 {0.22/26 1} g6 {0.22/28 2}
24. Ra5 {0.18/29 8} Rc1 {0.22/28 3} 25. Kf2 {0.16/27 2} Kb7 {0.16/26 1} 26. Ke3
{0.10/25 1} Rc3+ {0.10/26 2} 27. Kf4 {0.08/24 1} f6 {0.08/26 2} 28. g4 {0.19/
27 3} hxg4 {0.14/26 2} 29. Kxg4 {0.14/28 2} Rc4 {0.14/27 1} 30. Kf3 {0.14/28 2}
Rc1 {0.14/28 1} 31. Ra2 {0.14/28 2} Rxc5 {0.14/29 1} 32. Rg2 {0.14/29 1} Rc3+ {
0.14/30 1} 33. Kf4 {0.14/32 1} Rh3 {0.14/34 1} 34. Rxg6 {0.14/35 2} Rxh4+ {0.
14/37 1} 1/2-1/2

[Event "Shootout (Stockfish864POPCNT, Blitz 1m+"]
[Site "?"]
[Date "????.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "New game"]
[Black "?"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[SetUp "1"]
[FEN "r2k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PP3/8/3B1PPP/5K2 w - - 0 1"]
[PlyCount "68"]

1. Bf4 {1.00/17 2} Ra1+ {0.96/21 5} 2. Ke2 {1.11/22 4} Ra2+ {1.13/23 4} 3. Kf3
{1.19/22 1} Ra3+ {1.12/24 3} 4. Be3 {0.93/23 1} Kc8 {1.11/23 6} 5. Rb1 {1.12/
22 1} h5 {1.20/24 6 (e5)} 6. h4 {1.05/21 2 (e5)} e5 {0.90/21 3} 7. dxe5 {1.07/
22 3 (d5)} Nxe5+ {1.16/21 3} 8. Kf4 {1.14/21 1} Nd7 {1.29/23 6 (Nd3+)} 9. Rb4 {
1.12/21 2} Ra2 {1.22/22 3} 10. Kg5 {1.20/22 2} Nf6 {1.19/23 3} 11. g3 {1.28/21
1} Kd7 {1.28/23 3 (Ra5)} 12. Kf4 {1.15/20 1} Ng4 {1.02/24 4 (Ke6)} 13. Rb7+ {
0.89/22 1} Ke8 {0.94/24 3} 14. Rc7 {0.87/23 3} Nxf2 {0.57/23 4} 15. Ke5 {0.58/
22 1} Re2 {0.56/24 3} 16. Bxf2 {0.68/23 1} Rxf2 {0.28/24 2} 17. Rxc6 {0.27/24 2
} Kd7 {0.30/27 3} 18. Rd6+ {0.29/28 1} Kc7 {0.29/30 2} 19. Rd3 {0.26/26 1} Kc6
{0.25/28 2} 20. Kd4 {0.25/28 2} Rf1 {0.25/29 3} 21. Ra3 {0.39/29 6} Rd1+ {0.31/
27 5} 22. Ke3 {0.35/26 2} Re1+ {0.23/26 2} 23. Kf3 {0.22/26 1} g6 {0.22/28 2}
24. Ra5 {0.18/29 8} Rc1 {0.22/28 3} 25. Kf2 {0.16/27 2} Kb7 {0.16/26 1} 26. Ke3
{0.10/25 1} Rc3+ {0.10/26 2} 27. Kf4 {0.08/24 1} f6 {0.08/26 2} 28. g4 {0.19/
27 3} hxg4 {0.19/25 1} 29. Kxg4 {0.09/26 2} Rc4 {0.09/27 1} 30. Kf3 {0.09/27 1}
Rc1 {0.09/27 1} 31. Ra2 {0.09/27 2} Rxc5 {0.09/28 1} 32. Rg2 {0.09/29 2} Rc3+ {
0.09/30 1} 33. Kf4 {0.09/32 2} Rh3 {0.09/34 2} 34. Rxg6 {0.09/35 2} Rxh4+ {0.
09/36 1} 1/2-1/2

[/pgn]

the simple one-piece endgame is also drawn, I got draws in the astounding majority of variations if not all, so I have not my doubts about it at all, but will obviously never be able to prove it with such an outcry, when I have to listen to false stories instead of analysing.

Kasparov, Carlsen and Fischer in my place also would not have handled it.

all games shown by Lyudmill debugged or 'de-Lyudmillized' not Kf3 (as in his SF lines at short TC- but the winning Kd3!
White sacrifices the f-pawn but wins c-pawn and transfers white king to queenside
[d] 3k4/1R1n1pp1/2p1p2p/2P5/3PPB2/3K4/r4PPP/8 b - - 0 3

why then engines score differently?

we are talking of probability chances here, and this simple eg position is the much better black option for a draw, in comparison to the Bd6 c5 e4 line.

why do not you analyse that line?

I will tell you why: because you and your machines do not have a clear vision what is going on in complicated positions; all you can do is switch the computer on in some very simple position, and wait for the output.

and then, please do not forget, that there are always alternative options, in each and every position, something, of which neither humans, nor engines have thought of currently, always.

it might become evident at some later point in time.

so that, please, do not be so certain with your conclusions.

if black has been drawing in test games the much bigger portion of games, then certainly this position offers very good drawing chances.

and then, finally, why are you all offering me a challenge?

I already won the first encounter with Andreas, right, and a DRAW has been achieved?

if you want to appeal, you must first go through the relevant appeals channels.

[IQ]

Voting on the CCC Challenge is open in this thread:

http://www.talkchess.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=64340