Here is the link from Ed's website:
http://rebel13.nl/download/books.html
Noomen.ctg: UPDATE
Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw
-
- Posts: 501
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:49 pm
Re: Noomen.ctg: UPDATE
Thanks. I am running a test against Cerebellum as well, same result: 3-2 to Cerebellum, with many draws.
In any case, this looks like a very good test candidate. So I am going to forward it to my testers and take a good look at it. I like new challenges .
In any case, this looks like a very good test candidate. So I am going to forward it to my testers and take a good look at it. I like new challenges .
-
- Posts: 501
- Joined: Wed Mar 08, 2006 9:49 pm
Re: Noomen.ctg: UPDATE
Hi Harvey,
It is funny that people like Shrapnel evaluate a book after just two games . In any case, I am happy he showed me a good idea! IMO it would be a good test candidate for your book as well.
Wishing you well,
Jeroen
It is funny that people like Shrapnel evaluate a book after just two games . In any case, I am happy he showed me a good idea! IMO it would be a good test candidate for your book as well.
Wishing you well,
Jeroen
-
- Posts: 3187
- Joined: Sat Feb 16, 2008 7:38 am
- Full name: Peter Martan
Re: Noomen.ctg: UPDATE
Sounds great, thanks againJeroen wrote: In any case, this looks like a very good test candidate. So I am going to forward it to my testers and take a good look at it. I like new challenges .
Peter.
-
- Posts: 732
- Joined: Wed Jun 19, 2013 8:14 pm
-
- Posts: 2011
- Joined: Sun May 25, 2008 11:12 pm
- Location: Whitchurch. Shropshire, UK.
- Full name: Harvey Williamson
Re: Noomen.ctg: UPDATE
Sounds like a good 3-way book test if I get the time to run it.Jeroen wrote:Hi Harvey,
It is funny that people like Shrapnel evaluate a book after just two games . In any case, I am happy he showed me a good idea! IMO it would be a good test candidate for your book as well.
Wishing you well,
Jeroen
-
- Posts: 1476
- Joined: Mon Jan 28, 2013 2:51 pm
Re: Noomen.ctg: UPDATE
Try the newest AsmFish with Noomen against BrainFish with Cerebellum.
Jeroen wrote:Thanks. I am running a test against Cerebellum as well, same result: 3-2 to Cerebellum, with many draws.
In any case, this looks like a very good test candidate. So I am going to forward it to my testers and take a good look at it. I like new challenges .
-
- Posts: 4833
- Joined: Sun Aug 10, 2008 3:15 pm
- Location: Philippines
Re: Noomen.ctg: UPDATE
I continue to run some tests, in the match-1, it was 50 games, but later matches I use just 20 games.
In Match-1, noomen is using up to move 60, but from match-2 to 4, increase it to 100.
Before running the match-2, I let noomen book to learn the wins and loses from match-1 games.
Before running the match-3, I let noomen book to learn the wins and loses from match-2 games.
Before running the match-4, I let noomen book to learn the wins and loses from match-3 games.
Cerebellum release 12 is used for match-1 to 3, and cerebellum release 13 is used in match-4.
The learn from games features in Fritz has an effect in Match-3, when noomen won by one game.
In match-4 the new cerebellum (release 13) regains the advantage again.
Before running match-5, I will first let noomen learn the wins and loses from match-4 games.
Here are the results of matches.
In Match-1, noomen is using up to move 60, but from match-2 to 4, increase it to 100.
Before running the match-2, I let noomen book to learn the wins and loses from match-1 games.
Before running the match-3, I let noomen book to learn the wins and loses from match-2 games.
Before running the match-4, I let noomen book to learn the wins and loses from match-3 games.
Cerebellum release 12 is used for match-1 to 3, and cerebellum release 13 is used in match-4.
The learn from games features in Fritz has an effect in Match-3, when noomen won by one game.
In match-4 the new cerebellum (release 13) regains the advantage again.
Before running match-5, I will first let noomen learn the wins and loses from match-4 games.
Here are the results of matches.
Code: Select all
Blitz 3m+2s, Match-1
1 Brainfish 190816 64 POPCNT +7 +3/=45/-2 51.00% 25.5/50
2 Stockfish 190816 64 POPCNT -7 +2/=45/-3 49.00% 24.5/50
Blitz 3m+2s, Match-2
1 Brainfish 190816 64 POPCNT +53 +4/=15/-1 57.50% 11.5/20
2 Stockfish 190816 64 POPCNT -53 +1/=15/-4 42.50% 8.5/20
Blitz 3m+2s, Match-3
1 Stockfish 190816 64 POPCNT +17 +1/=19/-0 52.50% 10.5/20
2 Brainfish 190816 64 POPCNT -17 +0/=19/-1 47.50% 9.5/20
Blitz 3m+2s, Match-4
1 Brainfish 190816 64 POPCNT +35 +2/=18/-0 55.00% 11.0/20
2 Stockfish 190816 64 POPCNT -35 +0/=18/-2 45.00% 9.0/20
-
- Posts: 4833
- Joined: Sun Aug 10, 2008 3:15 pm
- Location: Philippines
Re: Noomen.ctg: UPDATE
Match continues, Match-5.
Sf book: noomen with learn from win and loss games from match-4.
Bf book: cerebellum release 13.
Match-5 start thinking data comparison, only wins are shown.
Cerebellum dominates here with advantage to book exit especially on game 20.
Head to head:
Download games for m2 to m5.
http://www.mediafire.com/download/cmi46 ... 5-games.7z
Sf book: noomen with learn from win and loss games from match-4.
Bf book: cerebellum release 13.
Match-5 start thinking data comparison, only wins are shown.
Code: Select all
rd 6, black Stockfish, thinkStartsFmvn 11, lastFmvn 72, eco B18, res 1-0
rd 6, white Brainfish, thinkStartsFmvn 14, lastFmvn 72, eco B18, res 1-0
rd 12, white Brainfish, thinkStartsFmvn 13, lastFmvn 56, eco B80, res 1-0
rd 12, black Stockfish, thinkStartsFmvn 15, lastFmvn 56, eco B80, res 1-0
rd 18, black Stockfish, thinkStartsFmvn 9, lastFmvn 56, eco C54, res 1-0
rd 18, white Brainfish, thinkStartsFmvn 13, lastFmvn 56, eco C54, res 1-0
rd 20, black Stockfish, thinkStartsFmvn 11, lastFmvn 53, eco C54, res 1-0
rd 20, white Brainfish, thinkStartsFmvn 22, lastFmvn 53, eco C54, res 1-0
Head to head:
Code: Select all
Blitz 3m+2s, Match-5
1 Brainfish 190816 64 POPCNT +70 +4/=16/-0 60.00% 12.0/20
2 Stockfish 190816 64 POPCNT -70 +0/=16/-4 40.00% 8.0/20
http://www.mediafire.com/download/cmi46 ... 5-games.7z
-
- Posts: 112
- Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 7:36 pm
Re: Noomen.ctg: UPDATE
Buenas alguien podria aclarar por favor esta duda referente a la optimización del libro, aquí en el post el señor Jeroen Noomen , pone optimización de 3 a 100 movidas. Y en la pagina REBEL 13, se muestra en la gráfica otra cosa(3 a 60), CUAL ES LA CORRECTA. Muchas gracias. Good someone could please clarify this doubt concerning the optimization of the book, here in the post Mr. Jeroen Noomen, puts optimization 3-100 moved. And in the REBEL 13 page, it is shown in the graph otherwise (3-60), which one is correct. Thank you very much.