The grand unified rating list 2013-07-23

Discussion of computer chess matches and engine tournaments.

Moderators: hgm, Rebel, chrisw

Vinvin
Posts: 5228
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

The grand unified rating list 2013-07-23

Post by Vinvin »

Games (rapid) from CEGT, CCRL, CountryChess downloaded recently.
Games (rapid) from WBEC, SWCR, Chess War, Mega FREEWARE (this 4 projects stopped long time ago).

Generated with Bayeselo and Ordo 0.6.

- If there's no "n-CPU" info, it's 1 CPU.
- If there's no "n-bit" info, it's 32 bit.

Code: Select all

Total games        1'503'360
White wins           554'365
Draws                530'264
Black wins           418'731
No result                  0
Unique head to head    14.99%
Reference rating      2810.0 (set to "Spike 1.2")
Bayeselo : http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 130723.txt

Ordo 0.6 : http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 130723.txt
Norm Pollock
Posts: 1056
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 4:15 pm
Location: Long Island, NY, USA

Re: The grand unified rating list 2013-07-23

Post by Norm Pollock »

Thanks

Which is more common in statistical lists: Wins-Draws-Losses (W-D-L) or Wins-Losses-Draws (W-L-D)? I've been using (W-D-L) but I see some lists using (W-L-T).
countrychess
Posts: 295
Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2011 7:56 pm
Location: Belgium

Re: The grand unified rating list 2013-07-23

Post by countrychess »

Simply great, this list.

However, I still see the same "mistakes" that I found when I was correcting my own database:

Zeta Dva and ZetaDva

There is Cyberpagno 2.1 and 2.10 (not sure if these versions are different)

Bearded: there is Neural 44, N-44 and N44

With your tool you delete the word popcount, but I have found at place 2111: Ifrit m1.8pcnt 64-bit

Why Gothmog 1.0 beta 10, but 1.0 b2 and b7 (beta and b)

Dirty 05Sep and Dirty05SEP
And Dirty 11Aug and 25.08

Greetings,
Geert
User avatar
Ajedrecista
Posts: 1968
Joined: Wed Jul 13, 2011 9:04 pm
Location: Madrid, Spain.

More candidates to be duplicates.

Post by Ajedrecista »

Hello Vincent:
Vinvin wrote:Games (rapid) from CEGT, CCRL, CountryChess downloaded recently.
Games (rapid) from WBEC, SWCR, Chess War, Mega FREEWARE (this 4 projects stopped long time ago).

Generated with Bayeselo and Ordo 0.6.

- If there's no "n-CPU" info, it's 1 CPU.
- If there's no "n-bit" info, it's 32 bit.

Code: Select all

Total games        1'503'360
White wins           554'365
Draws                530'264
Black wins           418'731
No result                  0
Unique head to head    14.99%
Reference rating      2810.0 (set to "Spike 1.2")
Bayeselo : http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 130723.txt

Ordo 0.6 : http://home.scarlet.be/vincentlejeune/r ... 130723.txt
Geert has reported some duplicates. I want to contribute with more candidates. I took Ordo list as reference:

Code: Select all

3715 Alex 1.4-r4                           : 2010.9      14.0      25   56.0%
4194 Alex 1.40.04                          : 1710.2       6.0      15   40.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2388 Amy 0.8.7                             : 2427.7     312.0     654   47.7%
2390 Amy 0.8.7b                            : 2427.4      60.5     127   47.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2704 Ant 2006-F                            : 2346.2    1024.5    2207   46.4%
3109 Ant 6.06                              : 2226.3     240.0     521   46.1%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1744 BBChess 1.3b 64-bit                   : 2570.9     356.5     704   50.6%
1957 BBChess 1.3b                          : 2526.5     268.0     525   51.0%
1994 BBChess 1.3b Win_i686                 : 2519.4      15.0      30   50.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3303 Bearded 06.29                         : 2173.2     285.0     560   50.9%
3343 Bearded 06.29.02                      : 2160.0     289.5     607   47.7%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1701 Booot 4.13.0                          : 2581.1     122.0     253   48.2%
1751 Booot 4.13b                           : 2568.6      18.0      26   69.2%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 605 Booot 5.0                             : 2910.3     580.0    1310   44.3%
 673 Booot 5.0.0                           : 2885.1     952.5    1804   52.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4448 Braincrack                            : 1425.9      36.5      74   49.3%
4470 Braincrack Alpha                      : 1389.7      28.0      53   52.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2230 Bruja 1.9b                            : 2469.5      12.0      20   60.0%
2372 Bruja 1.9                             : 2430.6     869.5    1858   46.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4501 CmcChess 2.27                         : 1332.9      10.0      14   71.4%
4555 CMCChess 2.27-uci                     : 1217.2       3.0      46    6.5%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1704 Crafty 19.19 BH                       : 2580.4      10.0      22   45.5%
2169 Crafty 19.19                          : 2481.8       7.5      14   53.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1552 Crafty 22.10                          : 2615.0     131.5     288   45.7%
1617 Crafty 22.1                           : 2598.2     450.5     941   47.9%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 851 Crafty 23.3 64-bit                    : 2826.7    1037.0    2487   41.7%
 987 Crafty 23.3 64-bit, no ponder         : 2767.6     262.0    1000   26.2%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 801 Critter 0.52b                         : 2842.9     551.5    1355   40.7%
 865 Critter 0.52                          : 2818.0     130.5     272   48.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2024 Delfi 4.4                             : 2513.3      34.0      64   53.1%
2052 DelfiT 4.4                            : 2505.7       4.0      10   40.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1323 DelfiT 4.5                            : 2673.2      17.0      31   54.8%
1656 Delfi 4.5                             : 2591.8     890.5    1994   44.7%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1487 Delfi 4.6                             : 2634.0     825.0    1917   43.0%
1675 DelfiT 4.6                            : 2586.9       4.5      11   40.9%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 677 Dirty 20Apr2013 64-bit                : 2884.0     180.5     338   53.4%
 722 Dirty Apr2013 64-bit                  : 2869.2     505.5     928   54.5%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 899 DiscoCheck 4.0.3 64-bit               : 2803.4     350.5     698   50.2%
 984 Discocheck 4.0.3 64-bit               : 2768.1      15.0      42   35.7%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 959 ExChess 6.71b 64-bit                  : 2779.7      99.0     208   47.6%
 989 ExChess v6.71b 64-bit                 : 2766.7     352.5     700   50.4%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 825 ExChess v7.11b 64-bit                 : 2833.9     306.5     600   51.1%
 834 ExChess 7.11b 64-bit                  : 2832.0      30.0      59   50.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3083 FireFly 2.5.7b4 64-bit                : 2234.2       6.0      11   54.5%
3182 FireFly 2.57b4 64-bit                 : 2207.3      41.5      54   76.9%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3107 FireFly 2.5.7b7 64-bit                : 2227.4       5.5      10   55.0%
3261 FireFly 2.57b7 64-bit                 : 2183.8      45.0      62   72.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 477 Fruit 2.3.4n 64-bit                   : 2955.5      67.0      92   72.8%
 569 Fruit 2.34n 64-bit                    : 2920.7      46.5      92   50.5%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3605 Hector for Chess 2006.03.01b          : 2060.9      41.5      98   42.3%
3816 Hector for Chess 2006.03.01           : 1957.9      31.5      63   50.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1511 Jonny 2.82-2.83                       : 2624.8    1401.5    3010   46.6%
1618 Jonny 2.82                            : 2598.1       5.0      11   45.5%
2001 Jonny 2.83                            : 2518.2       4.0      11   36.4%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4567 Marquis 0.1.5                         : 1180.5      16.5      57   28.9%
4577 Marquis 1.5                           : 1124.5       8.0      53   15.1%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3784 Micro-Max 4.8 (DM-PII)                : 1977.7     345.0     776   44.5%
3881 Micro-Max 4.8                         : 1920.9     183.0     562   32.6%
3927 Micro-Max 4.8m                        : 1892.4     124.5     301   41.4%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2026 N2 0.1 64-bit                         : 2513.0     212.0     429   49.4%
2115 N2 0.1b 64-bit                        : 2492.7      13.0      19   68.4%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2612 NOW 0.3abeta                          : 2369.6      13.5      22   61.4%
3078 NOW 0.3a beta                         : 2235.8       6.0      10   60.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 858 Naum 2.1b 64-bit                      : 2821.2      56.5      92   61.4%
 962 Naum 2.1 64-bit                       : 2777.8     138.0     263   52.5%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3670 Neurosis 1.7                          : 2029.8       5.5      10   55.0%
3688 Neurosis 1.7b                         : 2021.6      23.0      42   54.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4582 O'Chess                               : 1117.7      10.5      21   50.0%
4600 O'Chess 1.0                           : 1041.2      25.0      64   39.1%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2186 PatzerUCI/FRC                         : 2477.6      16.5      30   55.0%
Is it the same than other Patzer version?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2324 Phalanx XXII                          : 2444.5     950.5    1906   49.9%
2488 Phalanx XXII Reborn                   : 2404.9     264.0     532   49.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3923 Predateur 2.1b 64-bit                 : 1894.5      15.5      70   22.1%
4017 Predateur 2.1 64-bit                  : 1825.8      12.0      58   20.7%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3919 Predateur 2.2.1 64-bit                : 1896.7      57.5     134   42.9%
4221 Predateur 2.21b 64-bit                : 1685.8      16.5      54   30.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1321 Pro Deo 1.2                           : 2673.9    1255.0    2608   48.1%
1566 Pro Deo 1.2 Mx4                       : 2611.1     129.5     277   46.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 472 Protector 1.3.6 64-bit                : 2956.8     569.0    1234   46.1%
 512 Protector 1.3.6.r370 64-bit           : 2942.5     557.5    1249   44.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2463 Quark                                 : 2411.6       7.0      22   31.8%
Is it the same than other Quark version?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1969 Quark 2.55                            : 2524.7      13.5      29   46.6%
2023 Quark 2.55a                           : 2513.5     105.5     227   46.5%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1803 Quark 2.70                            : 2559.9     134.5     213   63.1%
1829 Quark 2.70 Alpha                      : 2555.4     135.0     276   48.9%
2227 Quark 2.70b                           : 2469.6      41.5      88   47.2%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1437 Quazar 0.3 64-bit                     : 2646.0     400.0     804   49.8%
1468 Quazar 0.3b                           : 2638.6     385.0     718   53.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2449 Queen 2.42a                           : 2415.8      51.5      77   66.9%
2785 Queen 2.42                            : 2324.6      32.5      76   42.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2071 Queen 4.03a                           : 2501.4      40.5      73   55.5%
2294 Queen 4.03                            : 2451.9    1332.0    2731   48.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2723 Rattatechess 1.0                      : 2341.1      88.0     186   47.3%
2886 RattateChess 1.0 Nosferatu            : 2293.4     349.5     734   47.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3922 Rinko 1.15b                           : 1894.8      57.5     103   55.8%
3980 Rinko 1.15                            : 1851.9     142.0     263   54.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4477 Roce 0.0344                           : 1367.9      14.0      40   35.0%
4588 Roce 0.0344a                          : 1105.7       2.0      23    8.7%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2335 RomiChess Proto 2i                    : 2441.3      11.0      12   91.7%
2920 RomiChess P2i                         : 2284.8      42.5      62   68.5%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2797 RomiChess P3i                         : 2321.9      62.5     131   47.7%
2802 RomiChess Proto 3i                    : 2319.9      35.0      64   54.7%
3329 RomiChess Proto 3                     : 2163.6      40.0      96   41.7%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2930 Rotor 0.1a                            : 2281.8     334.0     803   41.6%
3848 Rotor 0.1                             : 1940.2       7.0      14   50.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1311 Rotor 0.7a                            : 2676.5     226.5     454   49.9%
1316 Rotor 0.7                             : 2675.6     495.5    1042   47.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 540 Rybka 1.01 Beta 13d                   : 2932.8       8.5      10   85.0%
 632 Rybka 1.01 Beta 13-13d                : 2900.1     382.0     518   73.7%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1499 Scorpio 1.6                           : 2628.4     410.5     891   46.1%
1580 Scorpio 1.6a                          : 2607.5      38.5      92   41.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 978 Scorpio 1.7X1                         : 2770.1      22.5      32   70.3%
1336 Scorpio 1.7                           : 2670.8     527.5    1081   48.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1151 Scorpio 2.0                           : 2718.1     536.5    1166   46.0%
1250 Scorpio 2.0.280907                    : 2693.9      17.0      20   85.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3751 Simontacchi 1.8                       : 1992.5       6.5      11   59.1%
3912 Simontacchi 1.8a                      : 1902.3      35.5     127   28.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1242 Sjeng 1.6 defk150 2CPU                : 2696.0      68.5     189   36.2%
1274 Sjeng 1.6 2CPU                        : 2688.2     245.5     576   42.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1345 Sjeng 1.6a                            : 2667.9     104.5     184   56.8%
1467 Sjeng 1.6                             : 2638.7     744.5    1617   46.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1928 SpiderChess 3.90b                     : 2533.2      43.5      92   47.3%
2035 SpiderChess 3.90 mua2                 : 2510.0      77.0     148   52.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2088 Spike                                 : 2498.6      11.5      22   52.3%
Is it the same than other Spike version?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1419 Spike 0.9a                            : 2648.9     873.5    1691   51.7%
1620 Spike 0.9                             : 2598.0      26.0      40   65.0%
1885 Spike 0.9 X2                          : 2542.4      12.0      19   63.2%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1155 Spike 1.0a                            : 2717.6     396.0     889   44.5%
1226 Spike 1.0                             : 2700.8    1388.5    2831   49.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 744 Spike 1.3x4                           : 2861.1     150.0     236   63.6%
 778 Spike 1.3X6                           : 2851.4     103.0     149   69.1%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2484 The Butcher 1.42c                     : 2405.9       7.0      10   70.0%
2980 Butcher 1.42c                         : 2263.2      66.0     165   40.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2188 Thinker                               : 2477.1       9.0      22   40.9%
Is it the same than other Thinker version?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 764 Toga II 1.3.4                         : 2855.8     933.0    1978   47.2%
 814 Toga II 1.3x4                         : 2837.4     347.5     817   42.5%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4461 Toledo Nanochess                      : 1404.7       7.5      50   15.0%
Is it the same than other Toledo Nanochess version?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 976 Tornado 4.87a 64-bit 2CPU             : 2770.4      17.5      22   79.5%
1141 Tornado 4.87 64-bit 2CPU              : 2720.4      16.5      22   75.0%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2211 Typhoon 1.00-358                      : 2472.6     826.0    1720   48.0%
2212 Typhoon 1.00-358b1                    : 2472.6       7.5      21   35.7%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 714 Umko 1.0 64-bit                       : 2871.9     630.0    1348   46.7%
 837 Umko 1.0 64-bit, no ponder            : 2831.6     398.5    1160   34.4%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1802 WBNimzo 2000b                         : 2559.9     538.0    1116   48.2%
1850 Nimzo 2000b                           : 2549.6       6.0      11   54.5%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2298 XiniX                                 : 2450.0      19.5      35   55.7%
Is it the same than other XiniX version?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1834 Yace                                  : 2554.7      31.5      66   47.7%
Is it the same than other Yace version?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1164 Zappa 0.80b                           : 2715.6       8.0       9   88.9%
1586 Zappa 0.80b2                          : 2606.6      19.5      28   69.6%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1059 Zappa 1.0 Opt                         : 2743.9      12.5      17   73.5%
1573 Zappa 1.0                             : 2609.5     716.5    1530   46.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 463 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit                : 2961.1    5013.0   10562   47.5%
 486 Zappa Mexico II WD 64-bit             : 2953.6     157.5     360   43.8%
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Some comments:

My list will contain false positives while true duplicates are not included in it.

I have doubts with versions ended in a or in b. I choosed the most probable duplicates (a totally arbitrary decission). OTOH, some of my reported duplicates are evident.

DelfiT stands for Delfi Trainer, of the same company than Delphi.

Joana and Joanna are from different authors: link here.

Marquis has a double scheme naming (please see 0.1.5 and 1.5).

I am not sure about Protector: his author made public several revisions.

Only difference between Quazar 0.3 and Quazar 0.3b should be that the last one can run in Windows XP: link here.

-----------------------

Just curious: how much time BayesElo and Ordo take to handle all the info of the grand unified rating list?

Thank you very much for your effort! Please keep up your good work.

Regards from Spain.

Ajedrecista.
countrychess
Posts: 295
Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2011 7:56 pm
Location: Belgium

And 1 more candidate

Post by countrychess »

676: Fruit 2.3.3f Beta
828: Fruit 2.3.3f
Vinvin
Posts: 5228
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2006 9:40 am
Full name: Vincent Lejeune

Re: The grand unified rating list 2013-07-23

Post by Vinvin »

Sorry to not responded fast.
All your remarks will be take in count.

Some points :
When a version have a "a" or "b" in their name, I won't merge with other versions.
Same for "beta" and "not beta" version.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3715 Alex 1.4-r4 : 2010.9 14.0 25 56.0%
4194 Alex 1.40.04 : 1710.2 6.0 15 40.0%
Same version ?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2704 Ant 2006-F : 2346.2 1024.5 2207 46.4%
3109 Ant 6.06 : 2226.3 240.0 521 46.1%
Same version ?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1744 BBChess 1.3b 64-bit : 2570.9 356.5 704 50.6%
1957 BBChess 1.3b : 2526.5 268.0 525 51.0%
1994 BBChess 1.3b Win_i686 : 2519.4 15.0 30 50.0%
I've not enough informations to merge.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3303 Bearded 06.29 : 2173.2 285.0 560 50.9%
3343 Bearded 06.29.02 : 2160.0 289.5 607 47.7%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
605 Booot 5.0 : 2910.3 580.0 1310 44.3%
673 Booot 5.0.0 : 2885.1 952.5 1804 52.8%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4448 Braincrack : 1425.9 36.5 74 49.3%
4470 Braincrack Alpha : 1389.7 28.0 53 52.8%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4501 CmcChess 2.27 : 1332.9 10.0 14 71.4%
4555 CMCChess 2.27-uci : 1217.2 3.0 46 6.5%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1704 Crafty 19.19 BH : 2580.4 10.0 22 45.5%
2169 Crafty 19.19 : 2481.8 7.5 14 53.6%
I've not enough informations to merge.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1552 Crafty 22.10 : 2615.0 131.5 288 45.7%
1617 Crafty 22.1 : 2598.2 450.5 941 47.9%
Different versions (10 is next to 9)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
851 Crafty 23.3 64-bit : 2826.7 1037.0 2487 41.7%
987 Crafty 23.3 64-bit, no ponder : 2767.6 262.0 1000 26.2%
Different versions ("no ponder"<> "ponder").

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2024 Delfi 4.4 : 2513.3 34.0 64 53.1%
2052 DelfiT 4.4 : 2505.7 4.0 10 40.0%

1323 DelfiT 4.5 : 2673.2 17.0 31 54.8%
1656 Delfi 4.5 : 2591.8 890.5 1994 44.7%

1487 Delfi 4.6 : 2634.0 825.0 1917 43.0%
1675 DelfiT 4.6 : 2586.9 4.5 11 40.9%

Can I merge "Delfi" and "DelfiT" ???

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
677 Dirty 20Apr2013 64-bit : 2884.0 180.5 338 53.4%
722 Dirty Apr2013 64-bit : 2869.2 505.5 928 54.5%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
899 DiscoCheck 4.0.3 64-bit : 2803.4 350.5 698 50.2%
984 Discocheck 4.0.3 64-bit : 2768.1 15.0 42 35.7%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
959 ExChess 6.71b 64-bit : 2779.7 99.0 208 47.6%
989 ExChess v6.71b 64-bit : 2766.7 352.5 700 50.4%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
825 ExChess v7.11b 64-bit : 2833.9 306.5 600 51.1%
834 ExChess 7.11b 64-bit : 2832.0 30.0 59 50.8%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3083 FireFly 2.5.7b4 64-bit : 2234.2 6.0 11 54.5%
3182 FireFly 2.57b4 64-bit : 2207.3 41.5 54 76.9%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3107 FireFly 2.5.7b7 64-bit : 2227.4 5.5 10 55.0%
3261 FireFly 2.57b7 64-bit : 2183.8 45.0 62 72.6%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
477 Fruit 2.3.4n 64-bit : 2955.5 67.0 92 72.8%
569 Fruit 2.34n 64-bit : 2920.7 46.5 92 50.5%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1511 Jonny 2.82-2.83 : 2624.8 1401.5 3010 46.6%
1618 Jonny 2.82 : 2598.1 5.0 11 45.5%
2001 Jonny 2.83 : 2518.2 4.0 11 36.4%
I will merge to "2.82-2.83".

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4567 Marquis 0.1.5 : 1180.5 16.5 57 28.9%
4577 Marquis 1.5 : 1124.5 8.0 53 15.1%
Same version ?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
3784 Micro-Max 4.8 (DM-PII) : 1977.7 345.0 776 44.5%
3881 Micro-Max 4.8 : 1920.9 183.0 562 32.6%
3927 Micro-Max 4.8m : 1892.4 124.5 301 41.4%
I've not enough informations to merge.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2612 NOW 0.3abeta : 2369.6 13.5 22 61.4%
3078 NOW 0.3a beta : 2235.8 6.0 10 60.0%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4582 O'Chess : 1117.7 10.5 21 50.0%
4600 O'Chess 1.0 : 1041.2 25.0 64 39.1%
I've not enough informations to merge.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2186 PatzerUCI/FRC : 2477.6 16.5 30 55.0%
Is it the same than other Patzer version?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2324 Phalanx XXII : 2444.5 950.5 1906 49.9%
2488 Phalanx XXII Reborn : 2404.9 264.0 532 49.6%
I've not enough informations to merge.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1321 Pro Deo 1.2 : 2673.9 1255.0 2608 48.1%
1566 Pro Deo 1.2 Mx4 : 2611.1 129.5 277 46.8%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
472 Protector 1.3.6 64-bit : 2956.8 569.0 1234 46.1%
512 Protector 1.3.6.r370 64-bit : 2942.5 557.5 1249 44.6%
I've not enough informations to merge.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2463 Quark : 2411.6 7.0 22 31.8%
Is it the same than other Quark version?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2723 Rattatechess 1.0 : 2341.1 88.0 186 47.3%
2886 RattateChess 1.0 Nosferatu : 2293.4 349.5 734 47.6%
Same version ?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2335 RomiChess Proto 2i : 2441.3 11.0 12 91.7%
2920 RomiChess P2i : 2284.8 42.5 62 68.5%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2797 RomiChess P3i : 2321.9 62.5 131 47.7%
2802 RomiChess Proto 3i : 2319.9 35.0 64 54.7%
3329 RomiChess Proto 3 : 2163.6 40.0 96 41.7%
What does "i" mean ?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
540 Rybka 1.01 Beta 13d : 2932.8 8.5 10 85.0%
632 Rybka 1.01 Beta 13-13d : 2900.1 382.0 518 73.7%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
978 Scorpio 1.7X1 : 2770.1 22.5 32 70.3%
1336 Scorpio 1.7 : 2670.8 527.5 1081 48.8%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1151 Scorpio 2.0 : 2718.1 536.5 1166 46.0%
1250 Scorpio 2.0.280907 : 2693.9 17.0 20 85.0%
I've not enough informations to merge.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1242 Sjeng 1.6 defk150 2CPU : 2696.0 68.5 189 36.2%
1274 Sjeng 1.6 2CPU : 2688.2 245.5 576 42.6%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1928 SpiderChess 3.90b : 2533.2 43.5 92 47.3%
2035 SpiderChess 3.90 mua2 : 2510.0 77.0 148 52.0%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2088 Spike : 2498.6 11.5 22 52.3%
Is it the same than other Spike version?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1419 Spike 0.9a : 2648.9 873.5 1691 51.7%
1620 Spike 0.9 : 2598.0 26.0 40 65.0%
1885 Spike 0.9 X2 : 2542.4 12.0 19 63.2%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
744 Spike 1.3x4 : 2861.1 150.0 236 63.6%
778 Spike 1.3X6 : 2851.4 103.0 149 69.1%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2484 The Butcher 1.42c : 2405.9 7.0 10 70.0%
2980 Butcher 1.42c : 2263.2 66.0 165 40.0%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2188 Thinker : 2477.1 9.0 22 40.9%
Is it the same than other Thinker version?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
764 Toga II 1.3.4 : 2855.8 933.0 1978 47.2%
814 Toga II 1.3x4 : 2837.4 347.5 817 42.5%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
4461 Toledo Nanochess : 1404.7 7.5 50 15.0%
Is it the same than other Toledo Nanochess version?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
714 Umko 1.0 64-bit : 2871.9 630.0 1348 46.7%
837 Umko 1.0 64-bit, no ponder : 2831.6 398.5 1160 34.4%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1802 WBNimzo 2000b : 2559.9 538.0 1116 48.2%
1850 Nimzo 2000b : 2549.6 6.0 11 54.5%
I will merge this one.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
2298 XiniX : 2450.0 19.5 35 55.7%
Is it the same than other XiniX version?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1834 Yace : 2554.7 31.5 66 47.7%
Is it the same than other Yace version?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
1059 Zappa 1.0 Opt : 2743.9 12.5 17 73.5%
1573 Zappa 1.0 : 2609.5 716.5 1530 46.8%
Different versions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
463 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit : 2961.1 5013.0 10562 47.5%
486 Zappa Mexico II WD 64-bit : 2953.6 157.5 360 43.8%
Different versions.