the Naum 4.2 test was horrible.
Better the statistics, the engine is great ... runs without any problem, very nice games, very strong endgame.
Naum lost from game number 135 to 760 51 ELO points.
Better, from game number 300 up to 410 32 ELO points.
Never I saw such a statistic and I made it now a long time.
OK, here are the actual SWCR:
- each one vs. each one 40 games
- 40 moves in 10 minutes up to mate, remis. One game need around 40 minutes.
- only 32-Bit, only 1 Core, all with ponder = on
- 4-pieces table-bases.
This is the main ratinglist list.
Normaly it isn't a rating list, more or less a big tournament.
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Rybka 3 2852 22 21 760 75% 2673 29%
2 Naum 4.2 2822 21 21 760 71% 2675 34%
3 Stockfish 1.6.3 JA 2820 21 21 760 71% 2675 35%
4 Shredder 12 2800 21 20 760 68% 2676 34%
5 Deep Fritz 12 2773 20 20 760 64% 2677 41%
6 Komodo 1.0 JA 2710 20 19 760 55% 2681 41%
7 Thinker 5.4d Inert 2706 20 20 760 54% 2681 39%
8 Protector 1.3.2 2675 20 20 760 49% 2682 41%
9 Hiarcs 12.1 Sharpen PV 2662 20 20 760 47% 2683 38%
10 Sjeng WC-2008 2660 20 20 760 47% 2683 38%
11 Spark 0.3a 2655 19 20 760 46% 2683 42%
12 Zappa Mexico II 2651 19 19 760 45% 2684 43%
13 Junior 11.1a 2649 20 20 760 45% 2684 38%
14 Onno 1.1.1 2628 20 20 760 42% 2685 41%
15 Critter 0.52b 2611 20 20 760 39% 2686 38%
15 Fruit 05/11/03 2611 20 20 760 39% 2686 41%
17 Ktulu 9.03 2605 20 21 760 39% 2686 30%
18 Loop 13.6 2601 20 20 760 38% 2686 39%
19 SmarThink 1.20 2583 20 20 760 35% 2687 39%
20 Twisted Logic 20100131x 2567 21 21 760 33% 2688 32%And here the list after all played games (17.640 so far):
Code: Select all
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Rybka 3 2858 17 17 1320 74% 2687 31%
2 Naum 4.2 2826 21 21 760 71% 2679 34%
3 Stockfish 1.6.3 JA 2824 19 19 960 70% 2684 36%
- Naum 4.1 2810 19 19 920 68% 2684 35%
- Stockfish 1.6.0 JA 2801 18 18 960 68% 2686 39%
4 Shredder 12 2800 16 16 1320 66% 2689 36%
- Naum 4.0 2784 18 18 960 65% 2681 38%
5 Deep Fritz 12 2779 19 19 840 64% 2687 41%
- Fritz 12 2745 16 16 1160 59% 2687 44%
- Stockfish 1.5.1 JA 2730 21 21 680 57% 2684 43%
6 Komodo 1.0 JA 2715 18 17 1000 54% 2693 40%
7 Thinker 5.4d Inert 2711 15 15 1320 53% 2691 43%
- Doch 1.3.4 JA 2689 19 19 840 51% 2685 44%
- Cyclone xTreme Wrath 2675 17 17 1080 47% 2696 41%
8 Protector 1.3.2 2673 16 16 1160 47% 2694 41%
9 Junior 2010 2668 16 16 1240 47% 2690 36%
- Doch 1.2 JA 2667 20 21 720 47% 2689 40%
10 Hiarcs 12.1 2666 19 18 880 47% 2688 41%
- Protector 1.3.1b 2666 19 19 840 47% 2689 42%
- Hiarcs 12.1 Sharpen PV 2665 17 17 1080 45% 2698 40%
11 Sjeng WC-2008 2657 15 15 1320 45% 2693 37%
11 Zappa Mexico II 2657 15 15 1320 45% 2693 44%
- Doch 09.980 JA 2655 21 21 680 45% 2689 43%
13 Spark 0.3a 2655 17 17 1080 44% 2698 41%
- Junior 11.1a 2653 20 20 760 45% 2688 38%
- Spark 0.3 2642 19 19 880 43% 2689 42%
14 Onno 1.1.1 2631 15 15 1320 41% 2694 43%
15 Fruit 05/11/03 2616 16 16 1240 38% 2694 41%
16 Loop 13.6 2615 15 16 1320 38% 2694 40%
17 Critter 0.52b 2613 19 19 880 38% 2697 37%
- Glaurung 2.2 JA 2609 17 17 1080 37% 2699 36%
18 Ktulu 9.03 2607 20 20 840 38% 2695 29%
19 SmarThink 1.20 2597 16 16 1320 36% 2695 38%
20 Twisted Logic 20100131x 2570 20 20 880 32% 2699 31%Code: Select all
2 Naum 4.2 : 2826 760 (+411,=257,- 92), 71.0 %
Onno 1.1.1 : 40 (+ 21,= 15,- 4), 71.2 %
Rybka 3 : 40 (+ 12,= 16,- 12), 50.0 %
Zappa Mexico II : 40 (+ 26,= 13,- 1), 81.2 %
Thinker 5.4d Inert : 40 (+ 21,= 15,- 4), 71.2 %
SmarThink 1.20 : 40 (+ 24,= 15,- 1), 78.8 %
Shredder 12 : 40 (+ 16,= 17,- 7), 61.3 %
Sjeng WC-2008 : 40 (+ 22,= 12,- 6), 70.0 %
Loop 13.6 : 40 (+ 26,= 11,- 3), 78.8 %
Deep Fritz 12 : 40 (+ 13,= 23,- 4), 61.3 %
Critter 0.52b : 40 (+ 28,= 12,- 0), 85.0 %
Ktulu 9.03 : 40 (+ 29,= 8,- 3), 82.5 %
Spark 0.3a : 40 (+ 23,= 14,- 3), 75.0 %
Twisted Logic 20100131x : 40 (+ 32,= 7,- 1), 88.8 %
Protector 1.3.2 : 40 (+ 18,= 16,- 6), 65.0 %
Fruit 05/11/03 : 40 (+ 26,= 11,- 3), 78.8 %
Hiarcs 12.1 Sharpen PV : 40 (+ 22,= 13,- 5), 71.2 %
Komodo 1.0 JA : 40 (+ 18,= 14,- 8), 62.5 %
Stockfish 1.6.3 JA : 40 (+ 9,= 16,- 15), 42.5 %
Junior 11.1a : 40 (+ 25,= 9,- 6), 73.8 %
1. Protector 1.3.4 JA
2. Engine 21: Spike 1.2 Turin
Best
Frank