Hi,
I'm just about checking the traditional ranking lists and two newer ones for the purpose of a comparative study and for the comparison with the rankings of the GGT. I've read the sites and the test conditions, but I've missed some comments about the theoretical or practical background for the start values.
Based on which considerations, goals, comparisons or testing results the rankings had been calibrated resp. the start values had been fixed ?. Thank you in advance for any clarifying note.
Here is a first table for orientation.
Code: Select all
List Since Start/ Last Rating Time Clock CPU Ponder Book
Elo Rybka3/32Bit move/ GHz
1 CPU min
----------------------------------------------- -------------------------
SSDF 1984 ? / 40/120 2,4 4** yes ?
CCRL 2005 ? 3098 40/40* 2,4 1,2,4 no several
CEGT 2006 2761 3048 40/20* 2.0 1,2,4 no several
IPON 2009/Dec 2800 2848 5'+3'' 3.0 1,2 yes 50 pos.
SWCR 2009/Dec 2655 2851 40/10 2.8 1 yes Shr12
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
* several time controls available
** listed old programs and chess computers,too. 4 CPU since 2008
- 10 years ago, SSDF had started some attempts calibrating computer tournament results to human rankings. Tony Hedlund: ..in 2000 we took 115 suitable games from Chris Carson's collection of Man vs Machine games and made a new calibration. We had to lower the list with 100 points.Question: What is the current state of the SSDF-calibration?
http://ssdf.bosjo.net/list.htm
- CCRL, I couldn't find any hints about calibration
http://computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/4040/about.html
- CEGT, gives a StartElo of 2761 without reference to an engine or to a calibration method? I don't assume the StartElo is drawn by lot : )
http://www.husvankempen.de/nunn/rating.htm
- SWCR and IPON are very new. Both were released at about the same time. The authors apparently attach importance to comparability. The StartElo for both lists were fixed for Shredder 12 = 2800 Elo. The SWCR value had been changed now to Sjeng WC-2008= 2655 Elo.
http://www.inwoba.de/
http://www.amateurschach.de/
Best
Rainer